Narinder Singh v. The Financial Commissioner (Appeals) Punjab And ORS
!
" #$%$ &
' '
(
)* ('
+ +
! "
# !"
! " $ %%% +
, '
& "' () *+ (*(,- . /+01& - 0 21 3 1& ! " 1& ,4 *, (*45- . /,01& (* *4 (*4+ - . /40 1& 6 $61"! 76 1 1"" "8!
61"! 76 " 61 " ! " " 3 613&!3 " 9 3 " ! " 9 3 3 ! "
-0
- $0 3 !" 1 7 " 1 "
- $0
1 61"
3"1+*&"
) 34#" "
" "!" $/
61"! ! (* *4 (*4+- . /40
!1& " 4, " 21 6 ! 1" 7! " 1 "1& ! ,4 *, (*45- . /,0
!1& " ! 45" 216! 1" 3! " 1 ! () *+ (*(, - . /+0 ! ! " : 1&3&""
6 " " &" "61
1 1" / :1 &&/;
: 1 3& !&&" 33 & 3111" : 1 3 &1! 3!!9 )+(, *5 (*4$ ,5, ,55/ ,<59 &' 9!*) 4( (*(( : 1 $
3 " & " : 1 ! & ! : " 1 "4+" 216! 3 11" "61 !3 ;1& 13& ! 3 : 1 1 ! !11& 61"
6 " $ 1 " " 61 $" "!""
1 " $ 61 " " $ " 1" : 1
& $
" 1" 1" : " 1 !"1& 3
& 1& ! 11 :
" " " "613 3 9 1 $" !"3 !"
-
1" "
$/
1 1 61 " !
/ " 1" 3 3 !1" 3 9 3 ! " 1& 1! 1 9 )+ (, *5 (*4$ ,5, ,55/ ,<59 93 " 1! !! 9 =( (+ *< (*4$ ,)) $*(9 (+" 91!1& 9 =* "(*4$ ,)$ +)5 ,$9 (+ +$ +)" 3 " & ;
" & !
3 ""1& > 9 6 9 )+(, *5 (*4$! *( 4( (*(* " " " ! 1& 1& 1 13 9+./01$&" 2 +$&40 5%'
+
!
.&1
&"
0 2% (*45-,0 -!0<(+ 3 3 ' / ?4$ 9 "
61& !!"
7 1& & 1 3 "" " & !& @
7
3 & " 11! 9 3 & " 1& 3 1 !;!3 1& "1"" " !& :;
! -!0
21 (*45-$0-!0,,+3 3 ' / ?, :! 1
""" " !
" " ! ! " "" 3 !1" &1& ! 1 @ !33;1& :A17! " !
! -!
0 21 (*4(-5=0-!0(==
!3" 3 "& 1 !"& 1&
+
' '
; C DC 1 DC