Om Parkash And ANR. v. State Of Haryana And ORS
!
"
!
#$ ! ! $
!
"
#### ! $% $ %%& %%' ( ) * +
,"- , .
"
%/ %0/0
2/ %0/2 " -4" !
"
! .
,
4 5
6(
/11'
6
/17% $
.
,8 4*
,
"
4 , " -
,, "
$ (! .
, !
"
-
4,--4 , .
"
, " "
/11'
! , %/ %0/0 , -" (
, $ 4- -4 - ,
4* ,
2/ %0/2 - 4"
:-4
,
$ , -
, " ,, 4
;
-
( -*
- /2 %0/0 %& 0< %0// * - ,
3.
Contentions On behalf of Petitioners The learned counsel for the petitioners contended that the action of the respondent-department in denying them promotion while extending reservation benefits to their juniors is wholly arbitrary, illegal, and contrary to the statutory framework governing promotions in the Haryana Health Department. It is submitted that the Haryana Health Department Subordinate Offices Ministerial Staff (Group-C) Service Rules, 1997 and the Group-B Service Rules, 1982, which regulate promotions to the posts of Deputy Superintendent and Superintendent, contain no provision for reservation in promotion. In the absence of any such enabling clause, the Department could not have lawfully implemented reservation in promotion merely on the strength of judicial observations or executive instructions.
It is - " , 201 ( 4 ," - "- =" 4,
4" "
"-
, ,- .
,
4" /< /&/ ( -
*
"
"
4, ",
$
-,
!!
" #
$ %$$&
'()
!!
*+ "
, 4, , "
*
4
- -4 *
" - " , : ,, ,- -" On behalf of Respondents $ " 4"
4,- ,* ,
,8 " ,-;- -
, ( $4 $"
,(
"/&< /&< () " #
$ () 4- : 4
, -4 , "4-- -
) - .
,,", , "
4" , , , *
( - $ 4,
, - ,,"4 "
, " 4 ,-4" :-
"
$", .
, 4
,8 - 4"
,( - " 4
4 $ 4- , 4,
! 4
, -# )
- , -
,4 -
, , *
"
/&< ( , ,
,
"4 ;
*
"
4
!
,"
4 , ", $:
,
, $
,( . /$
++ ()) *
!!
01
-
"
/&<:
"
, , ,4 " $ /&< 4 ,
,
), 4-/&< 4" "6 ,," /113
4
, , (
$44 " 4 *
4 , *
/& < 4
) $
& &2 )
&
)& ! "#
$% -/&<:
",
, -* " ( $4 *
"
, , , 4" - 4 $
-
, - "
, :- " - " $, 4
- , " - "
;
$ , 4:" "- *
, " 4"
:
: &'$!
(
$!
) $*
$" # $!
# $
& $ )
&
)& !
! "$"
$
"
# # + ,#-,, ,
$*.#
$% ) +
, -
,4": 4" - ,
" ,, "
- 4 ,(
, (
- , 4
, ), 4 ,
4 ,"
- , :
> , "
"
, ,-
,4
* 4 ,4 4
- ( * * -, / 0 1
# 2 $ 4( " ! .
, ( 4* "4 , -4 , .
"
$ , " "
/11'
! - , %/ %0/0 , (
, 4-- - -" 4-
& . -* 4"
, , : " 6 , -
" 201( 9 " , ,
4 , "
:
) !
"
! .
,
4 5
6(
/11'
6
/17% "
-
, $ : 4
- , ! ( , ,
,, $" 4 - "
$
4 -
- ,
" ", ) - ,,/11' /17%
$ , ,
4" !
,, "
, ,%/ %0/0 2/ %0/2
4
,
$ 4-- - -" 4- -4 -, :
4- ,
" , $ : 4
4 : 6 "
" , 4 "
-
$, ,
- :-
" ,4"
: ?
3&
$ !$($%
, !!
+ ' (&$* # #
! $"
! $ (3$ * " 4 5 6 7 $ $ 8$6$ 6
+
3'3 !! ''1 6!
#.
, , 9 & $% >
8 - , " 4
, , 4"
,
$
4, ", 4- " - , "" , , ,
-( ,
4 ( -4 , $
- - , " , 4
- , - *
" "
$ -
, " , -
" @ 4 , , 4.
Conclusion -" ())*+,- $ 4 , " .
"
- * 4
. "
":
"- "4
, " 4
"8,
,
5 -"
Pending application(s), if any shall be disposed off, accordingly. / ! $0
4
/ -: ;
<: / # ;
<: