High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/29855/2017dismissed

The Ropar Central Cooperative Bank Ltd., Ropar v. The Permanent Lok Adalat (Pus), Rupnagar And Another

2018-01-17Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath6 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

)#*!+#'"+!,*#+!"%-# !'./"0 #"%"%'#+ 1& )##+2!'#'"/.0!,!"3456*'!7!+!'0!'")#+ #&*'0#'"& 8( 8( 8( 8(9 /8 ::8 9 /8 ::8 9 /8 ::8 9 /8 ::8 +#&#'"( 8+!7%'0#+%'7)1!&)%&"50-$!"#5

+")#*#"%"%'#+ ::8 5 ::8 5 ::8 5 ::8 5 )# *#"%"%'#+ )!& $)!,,#'7#0 ")# !;!+0 *!&&#0 <= ")# #+2!'#'" /. 0!,!" 36<,%$ "%,%"= #+-%$#&45 6*'!7!+ > + &)+" ?")# /9@0!"#0A ' <+%# 5 +#&*'0#'" %,#0 !' !**,%$!"%' 6'0#+ #$"%' ")# /#7!, #+-%$#& 6")+%"%#& $"5 > + &)+" ?")# $"9@ !,,#7%'7 ")!" )# ;!& #'7!7#0 !& !' 0-$!"# <= ")# +!2 !'$)!=!"5 )!'!6,%%'!$!&#!'0;!&*!%0)%&+#26'#+!"%'<=;!= $)#B6# !' !26'" 5

C'D #&*'0#'")!0!,,#7#0,=*+#&#'" ")#$)#B6#")+67)!E%-)!+2!50-$!"#"")# !'. +*!=2#'"5;)%$) ;!& +# 6&#0 ' ")# 7+6'0 ")!" +#&*'0#'" )%2&#, &)6,0 )!-#

$,,#$"#0")#*!=2#'""%&!,,#7#0")!"' 5+#&*'0#'"!,'7 ;%")!E%-)!+2!50-$!"#5-%&%"#0")#*#"%"%'#+C<!'.!"!<6"(F 8 !'0+#B6#&"#0")#8!'!7#+ ")#*#"%"%'#+C<!'."2!.#")#*!=2#'"!

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

%0!-%""#'0#+#0<=)%2!&''#G6+#)!&<##'"!.#'%'" $'&%0#+!"%'!7!%'&"")#*#"%"%'#+!'0!,&")# !$"")!"")#*#"%"%'#+ !%,#0 " *+06$# 1 "!7# 0#&*%"# ")# !$" ")!" ")# *#"%"%'#+C<!'.)!&")#1$!2#+!& /#!+'#0$6'&#, +")#*#"%"%'#+)!&&6<2%""#0")!"")#$)#B6# ;!&'"#'$!&)#0<#$!6&#'#$#&&!+=-#+% %$!"%';!&+#B6%+#0!&")#$)#B6# ;!&%&&6#0<=")#6<,%$ 0= )!-# )#!+0 ,#!+'#0 $6'&#, + ")# *#"%"%'#+ !'0 !

"#+ #G!2%'%'7")#!-!%,!<,#+#$+05!2 ")#$'&%0#+#0*%'%'")!"")#+#%&'

+$#%'")#&6<2%&&%'&2!0#<=$6'&#, +")#*#"%"%'#+%'-%#; ")#

%'0%'7&+#$+0#0<=")#/5;)%$)!+#+#*+06$#0!&6'0#+(

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

)!+!2 !, !& !' 0-$!"# $6,0 <# *+-#0C!&$#+"!%'#0;%")6"!'=0%

%$6,"=

A )#' ")# +#&*'0#'"& +# 6&#0 " 2!.# ")# *!=2#'" ")# $)#B6#5 ")# !**,%$!'" ' %,#0 ")# *+#&#'" !**,%$!"%' %' ;)%$)!'"%$#;!&%&&6#0"")#+#&*'0#'"&

+ )##'0+&#2#'"G!'0 G ' ")# '"%$#& &); ")!" ")# &!2# ;#+# &#+-#0 ' <") ")# +#&*'0#'"& ' '&"#!0 2!.%'7")#*!=2#'" !7!%'&" ")# $)#B6#5 ")#= #'7!7#0 ! ,!;=#+ ;) !**#!+#0 <# +# ")%& 0!,!" ' "$'"#&"")#*+#&#'"!**,%$!"%' )#=2!0#'&6$)+# #+#'$#' % ")#= ;#+# +#!0= " 2!.# ")# *!=2#'" !7!%'&" ")# &!%0 $)#B6# " 2!= <# 2#'"%'#0!7!%'")!"")#$)#B6#;!&%&&6#0 ' D

!'0 ;!& -!,%0 6* " "%,, ")#+# ;#+# 6+ 0!=& ,# "

+ ")# +#&*'0#'"& " 2!.# ")# *!=2#'" !7!%'&" ")# &!%0 $)#B6#5 <6" %'&"#!0 2!.%'7 ")# *!=2#'"5 ")#= $)&# " **&# ")# !**,%$!"%' + ;)%$) *6+*&# ")#= )!0 #'7!7#0 !' 0-$!"# +0%'!+%,= %' &6$) ! $!&#5% ")# !'.)!0' 2!,!

%0# %'"#'"%' !7!%'&" ")# !**,%$!'"5 %" ;6,0 )!-# $'"!$"#0 ")# !**,%$!'" %22#0%!"#,= !

"#+

&#+-%$# &622'&' +!"")# 2&"&)6,0)!-#$2#*+#&#'"'")#0!"#

%G#0%# !'0+#*+#&#'"#0")!"")#= ;#+# +#!0= " 2!.# ")# *!=2#'" ")# $)#B6# )# $'06$" ")# +#&*'0#'"&%' **&%'7 ")# !**,%$!"%' &);& ")!" ")#= ;#+#'";%,,%'7")'6+!-!,%0$)#B6# )#,#!+'#0$6'&#, +")#+#&*'0#'"&)!& -#)#2#'",=!+76#0")!"")#*+#&#'"0%&*6"#%& " <# &#"",#0 <= ")# #7%&"+!+5 *#+!"%-# $%#"%#& ")+67) +<%"+!"%' %' -%#; #$"%'

")#*#+!"%-#$%#"%#&$" )#';#7")+67)")#&!%0*+-%&%'5;#

%'0 ")!" %" ;6,0 <# !**,%$!<,# ',= % ")# 0%&*6"# %&5 %+&",=5 <#";##' ")# 2#2<#+& + *!&"2#2<#+&#"$ ")#*#+!"%-#$%#"= !'0 &#$'0,=5 +#,!"%'7 " ")# $'&"%"6"%'5 8!'!7#2#'" ")# <6&%'#&& ")# $%#"= '# ")#&#%'7+#0%#'"&%&&!"%& %#0%'")# *+#&#'"$!&#)#0%&*6"#%&<#";##'")# *#+!"%-# !'. !'0 ")# !**,%$!'" %' ;)&#

!-6+ %"& $$6'" ),0#+ )!& %&&6#0 ! $)#B6# %&&6#0 ";!+0& ## %' !-6+ ")# !**,%$!'" ;) %& '" ! 2#2<#+ ")# $%#"="%&!<!'.%'7"+!'&!$"%'<#";##'

D ")#!**,%$!'"!'0")#+#&*'0#'" !'.)# !+762#'" ")# /0 6'&#, + ")# +#&*'0#'"&%&")#+# +#50#-%0 2#+%"& )6&5%'-%#; ")#!

+#&!%0 !$"&50'" %'0!'=2#+%"%' ")#*+#&#'"*#"%"%'!'0)#'$#")#&!2#%&)#+#<=0%&2%&&#0 3: 3: 3: 3::8 4 :8 4 :8 4 :8 4

)#")#+&*#!.%'7C+#!&'#0 #&C )#")#++#*+"!<,# #&C