Joga Singh & ORS. v. Union Of India And ORS




    
    

 !"!"
  $%&'$"&% 

          

 



   
 # $($"&() *+ !

"     

 



      *   ,-* ! .
/
 .! # 00000 #$ %%&'"&()*+,-& .)  % )&)('&+,-&& %  /+,-& .  0 %)&,&)+ +('&/ .  1 2 33333 /
 .! #  1!) 23+   )    )&44     .  5  5    /&6 $%&'$"&%4
  

     

&# $($"&(4
        

7/8 &-99 '(69

$ $ )  )&,/.4.*6(&- .-) -) :-4&9( -; <.)&45&8-+<=<.-(-6&, /6&&45&8>6 ?2(&&,44&6%&6&
& @&/&  &&*+  -  (& (   # $%&'$"&% & . -(-6.&,/6&&45&8>6 2A(&& ,44&6 &&5&4
&@&/& &&*+ -(& (+) 9&$ &@&/& &&*&45&8B# $($"&(& 9,)..-(4.),44&6C.&9&&/4)9 &*)&6-(4(&4D( 9&9 49)).

) 6)5&8+5)).4&(& !&9/)&4.  0)&/ .45)) )&, -.-&448(/9&(#


 

 ! "

#$% &   (  %   )      !'       

%)*!+ ,  )-%.  ) ,   " %%/)

), '

$.



#$%&  ! )! .

 ,  ( ,

  .

   )  

     ,

  

  )!

.

'  " - )"  %(/%-%

0123 -%%"4 )

'  ",

) %(/'

, , !( '%) '%   %).. '%   -%%" *"

  $ '        % ,"*(/ "

.-%%"  )   "

%  6',!   3'     & !$ 7

 7

+

%%/5( '%)

$$%

'"    ,

)  '

,0      , 7     '$!)        , 6'

.      -

! 

6' , % /!)$/& %  -

!   %%  '

!

)  %-% 

"       $

$0$ %! )  /0

) "%/7%-%

&+123 88 4 5%  $%! )0

  .

%! 

$)',

 .. ) /

%-%

"0  .. ) /

%-%

0&+12- /% (00 0003

  %  5 .%-%

"19:

%/0, % /%-%

"- "' % () / . ..   $ %! )   "  (/  ( '  "- "   /  %

 ,0

(- 7  "

)  .    %(/    ;7  %(/  , !   

)  ,   %%/    .    )    ) ))  

'  '

, %(/# ( '

,(%%$

' )(! !'!:0<! =:0<! ,0"

%!  /00

7

%%/ 

'" , "0" ) ")  "  ( (  (  - " ;(%%$,

-))%

"

(  , ")  0 $)%-% . ;(%% $$% ($)%-% .'

, )(

(%%$

-))   ;  '!'%)(  '%) "

 '

"

) $/  $

7.   '$(/ 

' )7%-%

012!/- $ % )  ( '  "- "   / 

"0  $> 

. .

!4*? 7 " )7% )/ $ ; -)% 0@A:7))AB0@09<AB0 ' %) ,/ .)% 0@A:7))AB0@09<AB7  ) (


  94& )&&4/.4>!$< 00.

A<)4,&E&-&)(#$
90      ,

  

  ,,

 )  

#$%& ( %  ) !' 

%)*!+ ,  )-%.  ) ,   "

 %%/)

), '

$.



#$%&  ! )!

 ,  ( ,

$1$   .

   )  

     ,

  

  )!

.

'  " - )"   %(/  %-% 

"  012  3  %%"  4 )

'  ",

) %(/'

, , !( '%) '%   %).. '% -%%" *"

$ ' % ,"*(/ "

.-%%"  )   "

%  6',!   3'     !$ 7

 7



%%/5( '%)

$$%

'",

)'

+,0 , 7 '$!), 6'

. -

!

6' , % /!)$/& %"

-

! %%'

!

)%-%

"  $%! ) 

/0

) "%/7%-%

0&+123-%%" 4 5    %    $  %! )0       .

%! 

$)',

 .. ) /

%-%

"0  .. ) /

%-%

0&+ 12- /% (00 0003

  % 5 .%-%

"19:

%/0, % /%-%

"- "

' % () / . ..   $%! ) " (/( '"- " /%

,0

(- 7  "

) . %(/  ;7%(/, ! 

),   %% .    )  0  ) ))  

'     '

 ,   %(/# ( '

,(%%$

' ) (  ! !'!  :0<  !  =  :0<  ! 0  0  "

% !  /  00  

7  

%%/    ,  

'"  

, "0  " ) "  )  "  .    ( 7  ( 

(  - " ;(%%$$% ($)%-% .

, )(

(%%$,

-))   ;

 '!'%)(  '%)"

'

"

)$/ $

0.'$(/



' )7%-%

"

012!/- $ % )( '"- " /

"0

$> 

  . .

!4*? 7 " )7   % )/  $  ;  -)    % 0@A:7

$2$ ))AB0<@09<AB0 ' %) ,/ .)%

0@A:7  ))  AB0<@09<AB7   )   (  


       )(  ,  )&  )  &45&8   &9  )& -)..-(4/6.&-/8) &- -(-&( &&/4&6-(4(&4D( 9 9 49 .&&/49/&*)).) &&4

6)5&8  ,5.)&.&+4&-(4&

&6/)&4.

.  )    (/9  )&      )&  /   .(-((   .&)&,6/.(-((   44) 69-44&(&

4-&+.&8+&&4  . )/
 .! #+  



 1"  % ! !)) &*6C& # FC !)) &/4 # FC