← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-AD/62/2022dismissed

Harpreet Kaur v. Vakil Singh And ANR

2025-05-13Mr. Justice Anupinder Singh Grewal,Mr. Justice Deepak Manchanda12 pages

                             

 



  

 !" #$%&$'()''   *            !

        "  

 +! !+&,--".*/. !0

 !#!.(.)!1 22222     !

# $%&  $ /3 0 *! "* 41 0 &" !- "!  0     

         . 0 *10

.4505*/-.45-6* 70 

 41 0 !"!8 9)#:.  *!* 5 0 ;"*5-0!"!**   30!41! *'0 4<"*00!5!-*50-"*!&. =. >  . ?

 *

  0 $+  @$ '= **   A = !5!*"*!&?$++& *0 !&!  %!*"!0

"4-0! *' 04!!"1<"*.0"50."/*0*4* 41 0 !"  03 0 ! * ' 0* !41 6 0 



31.**0!*08"1"*0!70!"! 0* *  

! 0 /* * 41 0 !" ! !1.

!"!1 0-  0 !"!8"*! & ? !+  30!* 4!0!"! ? )!*

!-33-30- 3-/* 419(&:30!0*00!*/5,*3* 0-!!50*4-*300

9)#:4"3-0 5  A A =.00*0!-!-0-30"!-5 0-*0*6.A>.

B5304">5*300! )"!0!*000*" 00

0* *30 *'.303!*0!//5 04 0 - . 0 @$ 3 !5!* "*! & ? $+  + & *04"*1!.0

3!"*410! !/ !- -4 "!5 /5. ! * ' * 0 - .  ;"/. 3! !!*  * ' "!* 0 *"! -. "!"  300. 0 ** * *-!* 0 5* "!!."*50!-/!"0%!. * ' 3 -*1 8-* * 0 4* -  3 *70

3-*18-**0! !0-   C8+  )! - "*! & ? !+ 3 !!**. 30!.0*003!4163141 !30 3-"**3!!15 1 !70!!.00*4 ** * 3 6 41 ! * '  /!  * 3

8"1 "* 70 -  0 

 3 !!** "*! &!+ ? A =.  A =. A A =*  A =

C8?D - 0/5.0 "4-* 4!0!"!0! !"*!&>!+ *!*! **   =.03--*0"!&0!5 "*!&. =.>  .?

*

0$+3!!-* 5! *'$/30- 45;"/.0 3 *4!0!*,"/,"E!*!"!0! !*300 !/0,"/," !*+! 0*!. 70 !"0*8-*503 "

!  +F.3000!0

* *00.5 30  ("!; &50 * 0 &!

0  0 /5. 0* !"* 0 

*60!0-)* *003*410

 *"!5 0 /5  0 -  0! -* 8-  30*-!0  > +F?.0- 08-0.*0  A A =.!10-!5!"*?-.03..0 ! 

. 0*  30 ! * ' &0 0*  6 30 0! .A>.

B. 5 30 >   5* !- * -  0! 0)"!0!*0!00** !  4!0)50"!0 !8-G50!-!!5300 "* * ' 0! )  -* 0 0!!. 0 

 0*  04* 30 0- 0"50. 0 !" 0* 

*!*0-40*!*0-300!!-

C8+=.4"0 !"3"4!/!0!!*  @"!0!-!.0!8-.0- 0**-*00 3*! *'3!"03000!*"*  6!<"1/!0 0  A A =.00*36"

!"*

  - * !-* 0 -0! 4" 0 *

!  0 3 70!!. 0 - 0 0!3. 30 

!* 0- 4" 0  !0 430

*! *' = +F.*000*!*0!!00"0 

*! *'-01!.

B$0! 8-.0*00

0*/!-*1-  0-55000*4!4163141! *'! 003458"1"*410- A +F>. 0 5!  #- *1. $7 !. * *00

.5300"* *'0!. 0*1*00!- A == A =)"!0!*0 0 

 * ! * ' 0* 1*  !-  . 30 ("!

!&50 0*410 "

*!- ?$0 !8-. 0  1 * 0 0 

 0* 0! "!0* 10!*0!!*0-06)* * 00

0!-*1- 0-4"0"*! **0!1!-*"!50!100 +F . 30 3 0 *!. 30 0* *"* 0 -* 8-0

  A =.* *0 !0% ?

C8+  ! !*410!.0!31-4!"0

: 43.300"*0/4*

!8-10"! !! 0!-*8-&0"!0!*00!3!0!! !8!;"!0! !*00**003!41 0

0-08-***0-*"!5 !  +F. 0 &! & ! E51. @&%. *0"4. * +F?. 0 &! &  ' /. @&%.*0"4.* *00- 3!*!-0

!*0400

*0"* *' 0! 70 ! ! C8+?  +?= ** 0 0 ' ! 5!* !- 0 -  **  0 0  0 

 -0* 30 0 ' ! 5!* !- 0 4* -   0 "* *'0!   70 !"!8. 30 3 8-*  +F . * 0 

A A =.  4" ? -. 30 0 3 ! !5   0 60. "**1  ! 30  3 -"* * 3 !!15  5" 6 ! !* 0 60 ) * 0 0* /! 0! -"0 * 0!*60!*0!0"4*)"!0!0!*00-* 1.03"**093!5*5:*410!0! ! /50!0"4*)0!4160!"00".30!3 0!  303!-"*3!35!7016 0!  E0* 701. 0 " - */  0!  * 6 0!  0*5!0D !55".0*/!*00 !

30 0* 4*"* 0! 3 ! * ' &0 "!0! * * 0 *'0!*60!*0!-1--4!0** -!!10- 3500!.05!*-!!10-0*5!0 70!!.! *'*0;"/60!-430!01 1*0*30!! *'50!**"* 0!&"4<"1.0160!("!"5!-*6 0!0!- !3*1&03"*0!3!3*1.014!"50 0!46-4*6 0!0!!*-*!- *1. 0 3 !"* 41 0! " * 0! 5* -! * 3 4!"50460! !0-  70 "* * ' 0!.  0 - "*! &  !+. ** 0 0 0* 4 1 - * 70 

 0* 351  * 30 0- * 0 0* /*  5 5 0- "*! !"! !- 0! 0"4* * 0! ! 70*0*8-*0*/300**0 4!0 )50 "!  40  0 

 * ! * ' 65

!   * 4!1 70 /*  0 * 3 *  A   70 ! "! ! 

!5 0 /* 4! . <"*! *'00!5 ? 70 !". 0!"50 ! /*. 0 4 4  40 41* !4 *"4 0 01 ! 0* 6  430

*! *'70

0!*  4! 0 ! "! 0* * 0 0 0* 4 ** * 0 *'0*40* 01!300!50!3 

410!50!30*!<" $   * !   3 0 /  4 4* 1  0 -1  0 /-  8" " 30" 45 !!4!*4110!/*F0!0-1"0"! 0   *  0 "!. 0 -  4 !* "  ! /50"*$3* ! 3030 /44*0-10 !"!8.0"! 048!-1!"308-50-1! 4-*0;"*5-0&"

!-"!0

  !"

'## $  

# # ( ).30!0 &"

!-"!-*0354!/ H=   

  

                   

       

                     



 

       

     

          

   

           

          

        

  

 

C0"

*  70&"

!-"!



%## &'

(  )0*0*304*4 9!53:70!/8!0;"*5-! !*"*43          !  "       # 

         

   $             

 

   

    #                 

     

                    % 

   

            



           

        

 >

  $ 

 

           #  

  



                        

   &  

  

   

       

    

 

   

 



        #

'      &    



      

                

     

  



       



                        

    

   

     

 

     

 

  

   

  

 

     (       #     

   



   

 

   !  "  

 

  $ 

   

         

                                    

     

  

     

    )                

       

   $   

       

        



 > 70"*-"!"!*!0  300! 0 /* **"* 41 0 !". !"!1 0 -10 !"!8!"3!01.!*4*3!01!. 3!!0/! *'"*!&. =. >  .?

*

0$+ = 10-10 !"!80500 4/ -* !  * *3 41 0 &"

!- "!. -6  !1!00!!/!-!0 !" /*. !"!10-10 !"!8*0!!.0 !43 A 70

*0/45* 1!0- =

!5!0@$)!0"4*0**5*0- 50! 0 0 0*  "  0 0 0*  * 30 0 "* * '0!$0!8-.00**000!0 

0*!-*0-00

0*!30! * ' !!0-!!5

70

0!-4!0 "*!& !+ C8?.0*5!1*03 6.. *'.300*-0!0"*0*0!*8  0! !/"!0 300-0!0"4**0*0!*0! * !300-/5760-)3/!.0!-4!0 5!"*!&?!+.0 "!0*!/!* 0 !303-"**3!!15 1  !.0*!4160!31!-0!0-*0***0!$ 0!* 4!0!"!.0 "!0- !/*/!*  0  - 30  -"*  !!15  5" 6 ! 0* 0!*0!0038 0!*0!0"4*)6 0!

 "  0 0" * 3 0! ! 3! 5   ! F0 !* 30 0! !!1 -. 0 *-* -65 0 -0 0**.4"0-"300! /!70!!/!-!*.00 " !0*!/!0**!5  !/!. 30 !5!*  0! !1 4" 0! 4*". 0 *-*00-65!-0600"**!3"* 44"0!"!-"70!"!0!5!*0*4!

03"*4- "4! !"05!*!0! 0. 5* !- /G 0. 6. !!5 * 0   .

.

B"00! $/*000* *  30! *'3*/*3*-!04!/ 0!"! @"!0!-!.  0! !8-. 0 *-* 0 0 0*4<"*30! *'! !*/8-0

!!0-0!-!!530+F?&0*0 00*35140* 01!30! *'4! 0*-!!5  *-*1. 0 

 * ! * ' 0* *  !- -"  4!5 ?

 = 4! 0 "! 65 !   * 4!1. 300  /* !- 0! */ * /6- !*"*  !!*  !6  * !6 E. /170*/.300**0 0!40.3 8-*F)0**00

*! *' 0* - 50!  0   0*5!0 * 0* "!0* 0 !1*"-!50 )0***0

 040!*/**0!!*)"!0!*00 -  5 0 * . 0 

 0* -* 0 0 3 "-!!*0-.0!-!!53-*30! *' F0!*300* F.0

**-5 30 0 * */  0*5!0. 4" *-* 0! /  0 )50 "!

? $  0" 

! 0 0 

 * ! * '

!!-*-!!5300!-""*0!3!3*

05! 0  0 !5!* 3!  !*"*  !!*  !6  * !6.! /1.3003!*-*410

70

 0*  *-*  0! !8-.030 0 0* 5 30 *'.00*65300!6.0.!!5 *!5-*5** .

.

B0

$ /3  0 4/. 3 !  0 *!*/3 0 0

!"/*" 0*0!!**5 0<"! *'*0- "5*;"*5-0! "!4*"

 ! !

!0/*!!*  $!0!!

5<"3"* 43!!*130!0;"*5- !/!!-15E1 0;"*5-<".0 !"- 0"* !!*C/.0!/3 4!-

!/*. 0

"!0"*!!!-!!5!*!<" !-14-*0;"*5-0&" !-"!0 *%+,$%--%  $. '. /%/0 12 "%$+%/%3%#

> ? & ?  70 !/8!0;"*5-! !*"*"*!

         

      

 $    



    



# * +,+-, +.,/ 

 $       

#        

 0    

 

           

  

) 

      

       

    '   

    

#      

 

     

       + , 

 

        

      

           

#       

C0"

* > <"1. 3 *  * 1 - 51  0 ;"*5-0!"!<"5! *'*0

 **-*!*51 =  *5-"

 ** *          !

                  "           (44     

 F00!& 65B* IB' F00! !4 IB'