High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/42269/2020dismissed

Mahalovya Gauba v. State Of Punjab And Another

2021-02-08Mr. Justice Arun Kumar Tyagi23 pages

"#$#%&'((

& )* ( +

! "

$ %&

' ! " $ (

) !'

!* !+

,,,,

, -.

*/ -)" . "" / ) " 012-(/ "03('' " !%241 -5'

5/"""

$ (%2 %% (6(6 7 !

" 89 $ 666: %1 %% (6(6 "06:0(69 '!%3:6-;9 '</ "$9

(

%2 6% (6(%! $ ( = '

"" )$ ( ' (> 6% (6(%"

" " " " &"=

* "

" "

" ' ! (> 6% (6(% ?. !

$ ( " "! *" ? "

! "" ?. (2 6% (6(%"" " ?"

"!%234

)"!*"?"

" " *"?"

" >

)' (> 6% (6(%

" @ " " "" A = "

" " "

" " A "

0 ""

= " ""A "A " " 8 ! "" " .@"

" " 9 &""" " " " ?. ?"

"!%234 " "*"?"

"" " ?. " A . " @"

" " ?.

= ""A "A "" "" ?. ! @"

" &" " "

""! "+

) !' ""

""+

) !

'! "" " @ A" !

"!*"?"

""" ?. " A . "

" " @"

""" 9"&" "! "" " " " "= 89 """ " ! @ " ! "!*"? "

"" " ?.

" A . " " " @"

""" "" " " "' = 89 "

!* !+ +

) !'

9" " (> 6% (6(%!' "&"

&"!*"?"

60 6( (6(% 6( (6(%7 "%'!

" ."

9 60 6( (6(% ' 7 " &"

&"!*"?"

"?. B" " 61 6( (6(% " " 961 6( (6(%7 "

1 % '!

$ (&""

= " " !" "" " %6

" ! " "" " $ ( 7 !

9 7 "% '!

' !""" $ ( 7 !

+ ! " (> 6% (6(% ?.

" ?. "

?. A" ) !!= @ " " ' @" "03( '

" %1

)?"

"!%234 "

" "12 ' 9 " " " ."" "

""C " " !?. "

" = %0

'9?"

"!%234 ?.

"%2 (( " &

" !# "

"# "#

"#$ "!$ % &

!# " #$ "

" $ " $ "

#'# $$ ("# " $ $ #

""!# % ) * " "# + $ " $ "

# " $, "&$ !# " #

# "

- " "

". $/ $0"#% 1 * " "#+ $ "$ "

# " $ , "&$ !# " $

# ", ")

- " "

". $/ $

% 2

! " #

! "

$ "% & '

()%

" * "

! +

! !

" $

# # "

# !# "# , $

* $

" "

$ " #

% &-

" %

" $

& # # "

# !# * $

" "

$ " #

% )* "

(!$

% 1

! #

. #

"" "

$ " $ "#

. * # "

. "

# # " $' +

$ "# " % 24 ". ## !# " "# "

# . "

" #

$ . $ " " # "# , " $ # "

' #" . .% 54 ". ## !# " "# "

# . "

# ", "& !#

# "

% 64 #$

" #"# , "2

# #

. $ .. # $

$ " "# , "%

( , ."

$ " $

"#.

!# " $

# "# , "$ "&7

,$ #"

$"# #" ""

# #"#

9676$967% &

. ## !#

$" "# "#""

"#"

" . #%

(('

' + !#

$ $ #""

" ""#

"# # $ 3 #

:792$:79 .

" " $ $

;, """# "$ "

"#" $"

. " "# *""" % #

"# # "$"

# "

% "$ # " "$$# % # + ""$"

# # "

$ # # "

$ "

$$ "#

#% & 4 '# "

$ .

" #", "

+ .

$ ." # $ #

" "$"

# " $ % )

#" $ !#

# # '# #". " ""$ " :) &:"#&&9$ 0"#"3 " # 12$957 "#

# #

$ $ ":2"#

<<=0$

# $ " 3 #

:6)&$:61% %>

9 / '

01 /

& ())2!(/%%33)-& B" ' ?.

! "" "!

= " @ "! .! ""

+ ! 4' / /

" 0 ' 1

& ()5!)/%%3)!+D ' " ' ?. " "A ?. " %4

" %2->/ ? "

"!%234 " " ?. "

" -/"

' E -/ " "

' "?.

)!"" & " ?. )"%2 ->/?"

"!%234@" " ?. "" " " 9 ?.

" "%2?"

"!%234 " " "" - 6

0/ 7 $ ' !&()3 5!'18(35/ %3

+ ! " %2 ->/ ? "

"!%234 " " ?. " " ""

' "" " "-/" "" "1(6-%/ '

' -/" " "1(6-(/'

' " "?. " &" " "!?. " " " " " "1(6-%/'

' " "1(6-(/'

' (6

)

?. " " " " "1(6-%/'

' "" "" "= A @"

'' " + !

?. " ;' < "1(6-(/'

" " " " "1(6-(/'

' (%

"? " " .DD ? ) " " ? F " "

- / 9 ' ! 0// / &9833/%:53/9 ' " " ? " " ."'

" " " " ) " )' !!"" " " ? @" 9"

' " "! ! " "

;$< 0;/ &98, /%:,(8 / 7/

0;/ "'&98,:/%:5 /) " ?. " !" " " "" ) " "C " " " " "

' " ' + !

?. " " " ' 9 " " = )! ! " ?. " "" ' " " " " ) ? " " . "" ' " A D"345%!

8# 94 :3#$$#% 5:

D% "345%!

5%!

: %;7 8D " %2->/ ? "

"! %234

'= !?.

" " "" ' ((

"(6-1/?"

"!%234

"?.

& "(6-%/?"

"!%234 "

&"(6-(/? "

"!%234!?. " " " "(6->/?"

"!%234

0 ?. "" ! " " "! """ " "

9 " A " "1(6-(/'

' !?. " " " " " "1(6-(/'

9 "(%-%/?"

"!%234 ?. " "" !" !"

"(%-(/?"

"!%234" ?. !" $ " @" ?. " A (0

G ?. "" ?"

"!%234 ' ' ' "1(6-(/'

" ' "" " '

$ 1

"%2-%/ (%-%/?"

"!%234?. ' " C"

A " "'' " "?. C 9 ?"

"!%234!

" "" " ?. " A?. !?. "= "1(6-3/'

' ' " A @"

' ' " "(%-%/?"

"!%234

! "%2->/? "

"!%234 " " " ! ?. "" "

. H+' / 0/9 '

=!&())2 (5!8%8 %

!55 (:

9=/

8 0<< &(): :!/%%((3 +D ' & >)2% 4 $

$ $$ " " "# " 1:9, $ 03 " "#

" $

""#$ "

* "

# "%

" #

$$ "#

$ "1:9,$ 03 . " # " " #"#""

+ ""

% '# . *

" * # " #

" " # " $ $ .% " # "

" # #

# #

1 "# % 0" $

+ #%0" "

"# "

+ #%0$. "

" #. "

%0" * " "

" %0$

#$ "# "$ " "# .

# # ""

. .

" "

% ?

+ "

$ $

"# "

" $"#

+ "# "" % " ""

" $ . ""

# + " # %4 . # .

! $ # "$ # "$ "

""# "

" $ "# " "$ "#"

$ # "%4

"@ A # "B" $$ #$

" # "" "

". . ."

# "" " # %C (4

) " ?.

$&" " " !"

"! A " " " " " 8@ " " &" "023& 9 '

= " ""!"

" " "%(>'

+ " "!%2>:

!" "" "0>(A1(:9 '

"AA

' "

0:49 ' = " A 9 "" "" ""

?. """" "" " "

'' "" "+' = 89 9 @"

" " = 89 +' !?. !

"!. = 89 +' = 89 +' ! "

'' "

9"= " " "= B "" " " " = " ! ""7 """ " "

" . + ' " " "" " "" . " ' 9 "= "" " " ?. ""

2 "" @"

'' "

9=-> =

"4 0%</ &()( !

8%8 %

!)(!" "%13$ 9

"!%33% ?. " ?"

"!%234 ' '

)" """ ?. " " " I @"

DD' ! @"

' ' """ ?. " +'

I+D ' " "%13$ 9

"!%33%?.

" " ?. !

""(%-%/ ?"

"!%234! ?.

" '' "" @"

'' 9"+D ' & >6% 8 #"

." " ; 0" .$ " " $ "

. #$ !#

# # # $

"# *

% & # " ! "

# " "

. " $ " #

"# "

% ) " "" .

$ !

' # ". # #"

# . "

" $ $

"# " "

D "

" D #

8 E # "

" "#

8 $ " % 1 "$

# "

"# ")9$ F 0" "

99 "#

$ # " " . # #

! # # "

## $ * "

%C 1%

9 " @"

" A """ A A . ! ?.

! " @"

' ' "! " "&" " "@"

" 1(

"1(6-%/'

" " " "%41-(/'

@ <8# 9 4 :3#$$#% 5:

89#"9 %; 4:$ "5 #% : $5"9 %"

#$ 4 %!#%=> "1(6-(/'

)= " " " " " " " " "%41-(/'

9 =

8 0 < 0/ '; /?- ;

'/$())5 !;3),

+' . " " "!"" " "& "%41-(/'

9" + ' & 4 " ""

"# # "

"# .

" "#

$$ " ."# ")&7 %3%% :6)

" $ #

" #" ! "

$$ " " " " " )&7 %3%% :6) . "#"" #" "

$ "$ %0$ $$ " . + "$

# "# #

" *" "## # . " # " "#%0$ $ "

$ "#" " # # " " ". " " $ #"#

"# " "%0$ $$ " "

"# # "# ## " + "$

"#$

$"# ". . " "

$$ " " "# #

" " "

$ "#" ""# $$ " ". " $" "%%%%

9 . +' #" A""""

! ""

" "" ""

"""" A""""

" 9I" 9 "" "& "%41-(/'

" "" " A ""A""

" )"& "%41 -(/'

! " 9 "

"""" "

" A""""

)! "

" " " " "!"" " " "%41-(/'

?. ""!" " " "" " " ' "?. C

"" " "" "

?. "& "%41-(/ '

*" ? "

A) . ? "'

?. "(6-(/ ?"

"!%234 1:

) ""

& -/

? "

"! %234! ?.

C $ ? "

A ? "

A*" ? "

A) . ? " '

' ' "

" "" " " " " -/ 9 " " ?. " " " "" ' -/ 9 " " " " " "& "%41'

-/ ' "" "" ' ' ! " " " "!

" " "

?. A?. !?.

"= ' ' " A

A " "" A A .@"

'' "

-/ 9" " " @

A" =

"! "!*" ?"

"""

?. "(6-(/? "

"! %234 " A . " " " A @"

""" -/ 9 " &" "

! "

" " " " " " " = 89 """ " ! @ " = !

"!*"?"

""" ?.

" (6-(/ ? "

"!%234"" " ""' ' ?. . "

! " " " A @"

0 """ "" " ""' = 89 "

9 "! ?.

B"!

" A @"

'' " " " " "& " %41 '

""! ?. B"!

. """

" ' +

) ! ' *"

"! !+

) !'"= " " "" (> 6% (6(%

"! ? "

! !+

) !' *"7 +

) ! ' "! *" ? "

A= " " '(( -

, / #.A J # J