Bimla And ORS v. Naseem And ORS
!" #"$%&%'( )
%*+ '#!,"-& .."++ '!& /"-&0& &""* '#!,"-& "&.'#"'!&
-"&"'!( -10-"'#"-1 %'%2#3$ !" -!," .."++ '!& '" --"&.'#"'! -*%!40* -5 +2#3$ !" --"&.'#"'! 66666
.."++ '!&7$+ %* '!& , 3"
%+"# !,%& .." + &""8%'9 "', '$"*"'! !," $*."'& !%' : -#"# ! !,"* ;5 +" -'"# !- $$%#"'! + %*& -%;0' +2 1'". ! <-%;0' += - &,-! %' : -# # !"# ' $$0'! #" !, 0+ ;1%'9,%' *!-3",%$+" $$%#"'!
-%"
$!& '"$"&& -5 - #>0#%$ !%' !," $ &" -" !, !2 !," $+ %* '!& %+"# ."!%!%' 0'#"- 1"$!%' ?? !," !- /",%$+"& $! - &,-!2 !," @$!@ &""8%'9 $*."'& !%' ' $$0'! !," #" !, 0+ ; 1%'9,2 :, +&! ,%& +% " %' *!- 3",%$+" $$%#"'! :,%$, !8 .+ $" ' A
)#0"!!,"- &, '#'"9+%9"'!#-%3%'9 !,"
"'#%'93",%$+";5 %!& #-%3"-7-"&.'#"'! ," & %# 3",%$+" : & '! %'&0-"# "&.'#"'! %& !," -"9%&!"-"# :'"- !,"
"'#%'9 3",%$+" B" -'"# -%;0' + $'$+0#"#!, !0+ ;1%'9,, #+&! ,%&+% "#0"!!,"- &, '#'"9+%9"'! #-%3%'9 !," 3",%$+" %' C0"&!%' ;5 -"&.'#"'! ,"-" %& ' #%&.0!" -"9 -#%'9!," ;3"& %# %'#%'9 !,"+" -'"#-%;0' +'!,%&%&&0"2:,%$,
, & !! %'"# %' +%!59" !,"#"$" &"#0+ ;1%'9,: & 5" -& !!," !%*" ,%& #" !, " : & "*.+5"# & "' :%!, !," 10."-%'!"'#"'! +%$"2 9,. ! B" -'"# -%;0' + ' !," ; &%& !," & + -5 $"-!% %$ !" D $'$+0#"#!, !!,"#"$" &"#: &-"$"%3%'9 & + -5 &?
7E "#0$!%' 7 -#: & ..+%"# !"- ..+5%'9 *0+!%.+%"- F2!! +#"."'#"'$5: & &&"&&"# ! &)2
7E '!,"- &0* &
7E : & : -#"# -
0'"- + "D."'&"& '# +&& "&! !"2 ;"&%#"&2 &
- +&& $'&-!%0* ," $+ %* '!& :"-" ,"+# "'!%!+"# ! &)2
7E & $*."'& !%' B" -'"#-%;0' +2,:"3"-2;&"-3"#!, !!,"3",%$+"%'C0"&!%' , # ;""' &+# ;5 -"&.'#"'! ! '" 10+! ' 1%'9,2 :, : & '! %*.+" #"# & . -!5"&.'#"'!& '#:"-","+#+% ;+"!. 5!," $*."'& !%'!!,"$+ %* '!&7 .."++ '!&>%'!+5 '#&"3"- ++5!!,""D!"'! G'+599-%"3"#!,"-"
-*2!,%& .." +, &;""' %+"# B" -'"# $0'&"+ - !," .."++ '!& -90"& !, ! $*."'& !%' : -#"#!!," .."++ '!&'""#&!;""', '$"#0+!%.+%"- ?%&-"C0%-"# !;" ..+%"#%'$-" &"' $$0'! 0!0-".-&."$!&, &;""'
-#"#2 !,09,%!%&'!%'#%&.0!"!, !!,"#"$" &"#: & 3"-'*"'!"*.+5"" *."'& !%'0'#"-!,"$'3"'!%' +," #&2%!%&&! !"#2%& +&-"C0%-"#! ;""', '$"# B" -'"# $0'&"+ - !," .."++ '!& 0-!,"- &0;*%!& !, ! !," -%;0' + , & ++"' %' "--- %' #%-"$!%'9 -"&.'#"'!& '# ! . 5 $*."'& !%'!!," .."++ '!&'+5!!,""D!"'! G'$"%!%&.-3"# ' -"$-# !, ! -"&.'#"'! %& !," -"9%&!"-"# :'"- !," 3",%$+" %'
C0"&!%'2!,"-"
-"2,"%&+% ;+"!. 5!,""'!%-" *0'! $*."'& !%'! %&!,0&.- 5"#!, !!,%& .." +;" ++:"# B" -'"# $0'&"+ - -"&.'#"'! -"
0!"# !," ;3" & %# -90*"'!& :,%+" &0;*%!!%'9 !, ! !," %*.09'"# : -# , & ;""' $--"$!+5 . &&"# "&.'#"'! , & &."$% %$ ++5 .-3"# !, ! ," , # &+# !," 3",%$+"%'C0"&!%' !!,"-"+"3 '!!%*"'"10+! '1%'9,: &%'.&&"&&%' !,"3",%$+"%'C0"&!%',"-"
-"2-"&.'#"'!$ ''!;";0-#"'"# :%!,!,""'!%-"+% ;%+%!5!%&2,:"3"-2'!%'#%&.0!"!, !' .." +, &;""'
%+"#;5-"&.'#"'! , 3" ," -# +" -'"# $0'&"+ - !," . -!%"& '# , 3" 9'" !,-09,!,"-"$-#:%!,!,"%- ;+" &&%&! '$" '=;+"10.-"*"0-!%' !" # $%&
, & ,"+# !, ! !," -"9%&!"-"# :'"- !,"
"'#%'9 3",%$+" %& +% ;+" ! . 5 $*."'& !%' "3"' !,09, !," 3",%$+" %' C0"&!%', &;""' 0-!,"-&+#-!- '& "--"#! '5."-&'"+"3 '!. - ;3">0#9*"'!%&-".-#0$"# &0'#"-(E H," $'&%&!"'! !,-" # -" &'%'9 :,%$, "*"-9"& -* !," ;3" #"$%&%'&%&!, !%'3%": !,"#"
%'%!%' !,""D.-"&&%'I:'"-=%' 1"$!%' 2%!%&!,"."-&'%':,&"' *"!,"*!-3",%$+"&! '#& -"9%&!"-"# :,2 - !,".0-.&"& !," $!2 :0+# ;"!-" !"# &!," I:'"-=:"3"-2:,"-" ."-&'%& *%'-2!,"90 -#% ' !,"*%'- :0+#;"!-" !"# &!,":'"-J,"-" *!-3",%$+"%&&0;>"$!! ' 9-""*"'! ,%-" .0-$, &"2 +" &" - ,5.!,"$ !%'2 !," ."-&' %' .&&"&&%' !," 3",%$+" 0'#"- !, ! 9-""*"'! %& !-" !"# & !," :'"-' &%!0 !%'&0$, &!,".-"&"'!:,"-"!,"-"9%&!"-"#:'"- , &.0-.-!"# !!- '& "-!," 3",%$+";0!$'!%'0"&!;"-"
+"$!"#%' !,"-"$-#& !,"-"9%&!"-%'9 0!,-%!5 &!,":'"- !,"3",%$+"2," :0+# '! &! '# ;&+3"# +% ;%+%!5 -+% *"'! , & $'&$%0&+5 %'!-#0$"# !," #"
%'%!%' !," "D.-"&&%' I:'"-= %'1"$!%'
2
* 8%'9 #". -!0-" -*!,".-3%&%'& 1"$!%'A%'!,"" -+%"- $! A A,".-%'$%.+"0'#"-+5%'9!,".-3%&%'& 1"$!%'
%& !, !!,"3%$!%* *!- $$%#"'!-2%'!,"$ &" #" !,2!,"+"9 + ,"%-& !,"#"$" &"#3%$!%*&,0+#'!;"+"
!%' &! !" 0'$"-! %'!5 $+ %* '! -$*."'& !%'09,!'!!;";0-#"'"#:%!, ++:%'9 !- %+ &0$$"&&%3" !- '& "-&2 :,%$, -" '! -"9%&!"-"# :%!, !," -"9%&!"-%'9 0!,-%!5,+#!,"-:%&":0+#;"!#" " !!,"& +0! -5 ;>"$! '#.0-.&" !,"$!"'$"2!,"%'!"-.-"! !%'!;".+ $"# *0&! $%+%! !" !," 0+ %+*"'! !," ;>"$! !," + : ' !," .-"&"'! $ &"2 !,"%-&!-"&.'#"'! : &!,"I:'"-= !," 3",%$+"%'3+3"#%' !," $$%#"'! :%!,%' !," *" '%'9 1"$!%'
," +% ;%+%!5 ! . 5 $*."'& !%'&! '#& &!"'"#0.',%*#*%!!"#+52!,"3",%$+": & 0'%'&0-"#,"%9,0-!, &.-$""#"#0.' *%&$'&!-0$!%' !,">0#9*"'!& !,%&0-!%'"&,* '#0-'5 4 + "3%K ,"-"
-"2 %! %& $+" - !, ! -"&.'#"'!& '# >%'!+5 '# &"3"-"+5 -"+% ;+"!. 5!,""'!%-"$*."'& !%' '#'!'+5!!,""D!"'! G &#%-"$!"#;5!,"+" -'"#-%;0' + 9" !,"#"$" &"#%" 5" -&%&'!%'#%&.0!"'$*", & ;""' $--"$!+5 &&"&&"# ! &?
7E ."- *'!, ' 3%": !," 90%#"+%'"& + %##:';5!,"'=;+"10.-"*"0-!%' !%' +'&0- '$"*. '5B!# /&- ' 51"!,% '#!,"-&2 %3%+
A2F G%'$-" &", &! ;"
-#"# ' $$0'! 0!0-" .-&."$!& + %* '!& -" "'!%!+"# ! &F2
7E" $, -+&& "&! !" '# 0'"- +"D."'&"&;"&%#"&&
!!,"$+ %* '!:%#: -+&& $'&-!%0*
"#0$!%' 7 -#' $$0'! ."-&' +"D."'&"&%&>0&!% %"# :"3"-2*0+!%.+%"- ?%'&!" # F, &!;" ..+%"# 9" #"$" &"# ;"%'9 5" -& ! !," !%*" $$%#"'! %' 3%": 1*! 1 -+ /"-* '# !,"-&/& "+,%- '&.-!-.- !%' '# '!,"-2
F .."++ '!&E$+ %* '!& -"2!,0&2"'!%!+"#!$*."'& !%':,%$,%&-"E:-8"# &0'#"-(E
'$*" ?
.* %"2 2
7E."- ''0* 2
' 2
() G L2 )2
! +%'$*" !"- ##%!%' !!,"- !" G' $$0'! 0!0-".-&."$!& 2 )2
*2 ))(7 L 2
'$*" !"-#"#0$!%' 7 -#' $$0'! ."-&' + "D."'&"&
! +#"."'#"'$5 !"- ..+5%'9 *0+!%.+%"- ? 2
(?L2F2
F B&& "&! !" F2
? B&& $'&-!%0*!:% "
0'"- +"D."'&"& F2
#$%+ &22
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
? J%!,!," ;3"& %#*#% %$ !%'%'!," : -## !"# 2 .-"&"'! .." +%&#%&.&"# ,
- . +"/01203 &,: - 4&%& 56 78 $#9: 8 $ 4&%& 5$ %;+9: 8 $