Shamsher Singh & ORS v. Bhakra Beas Management Board And ORS

  
     
 


 

 

 

 

   " #      




$% 

   %
 

     

 

          %&  '%(
 

 !

 ""# ""$ % &

 (  ! )) ( ( +





   ( 

) )) -1#2 3()









  ()  !( 

 

7 5) 8) % ()   8 

, )

! , & &  (   %(,*&

 +)) -1#2

' 

 ( :;
*"<



:;
*0< '=, ) )

 ) :;
*.<

(>  
3'

) ,



?
 



    

)     ( ' ( /" -- "/-4 -. -" "/-4 -. /2 "/-$ ! (  "" -- "/-$ :;
*$< @!  ) 3

  -2 /" "/-# , (

  
3'

 7, 



(( ',

 !

 ( ( 

  =

    

 

 



, = %(,*&  , '( )

! , & & (  =,  -1#2

+))

( 

& (  ))

,  

  3, )

-4 /" "/-2  ! ( '=, ) )


3'

& ')

)(     (  ! 

 , ; '   

', ),

    ')     (  !  * , ) 3  (( , ( (, '  ( ) (  * ( ' ' !

 

 

    ),

 !

') )  )' !

 ( ) (

( & 

  ()  , ', 

 $1
3'

+(  -1## , !

'  !  

  ') , -11" ,  


3'

 7,  :!

% < !   /- /- -12# 

 ;

,  ; 

 

 '( ), !

 &   ( 3() 


3'

)  , )     (   (

, ')   ) 

7 5) 8
 % 
)'
)

 , !(

   = ) 

3

A )   -2 /" "/-#  ( 3

@  '

 " #   @( (  ')  ' 

 )

       

)

! , & &  ( !( 

 

7 5) 8 8)  

 -1#2 +)) 

 %(,*&  





  (

, ( 

( ) 

%(,*&  ( (

(,



( )

! , & & = 

+ -./*0//

(   ) B 

9  !

 , ' (    

,  ) (





  =

= !  , 

) )$

% 

& ' 

 ( )
*+ ,
% -
+. 

 =,

 !  ( !( )  -.

-# + ; !  ! !

 "#$  !"

$ 

%#

&!  ' (

 

 '"

)  *  

(

 

 +  ,-. "(

 

! )#$  !"

$ 

%"

'

) 

) # / 0 !

 "10

#2$  !"

$ 

%"

'

 ) 

) #) $  !"

$ 

%"

 

  '  &/ ! !

3' !

 

 )  "    4 )   "    (        '       "

)  ) " !

+  " (

 

 

   !

$  '"

  $  ! 

"  + 5  

'$   " !!

 "



6  )    )!

)  !!

)    "" 1 $     "(

 

) )  ) 



  )4  "! $     " (

 

)

 "

  

%  ! )$    

 ) ' "$ 

%) $  !

 

) %

/0 & 10 %  ( ) 2
3,
%
"+ 

)     = )  =

) )'    ,) , 9 ))   ) ) ') ' !

 ?/ 4 5

& ' 

 ( )
*3,
% -6
.  '  78 '

 !!!

29

 )  )"  ! "

9

 ) )!

 

 * ")"  ! "

9

 ) )!

 ! )) 

'

 )!

)   )) 

 ! "

9

 ) )!

" 

)!

) !

  ))!



 ))

' "+  5 "(

 

 

 ) 

"!



 

  ( '  * 

 -.

  !  ( ( '( 3()

(( , '

'3   , ',

 

,

3'

)  (, '

, )(    =    ), , , 9 =  '  ' )   ') , 



   

%

 , -11"

=,  ) & !   (  ' !  =

,  

! 

 )

) 7% 89 & ' 

 ( )
*+,
% 26  ,

 ,  )

 ' ) '   *', ' & ' 

:;    "

   



!  " )     "! 

) $ 

)

'% *  !!   "  (      

      ) 3    "  !)

)!

 1   "(

 

1

) ' 

    0< "(

 

3   3

!)   )   !

"1+  -. 1   ! )  " "

! '   !  "" )  

4   3

) !

 

 "

)

  

 "

*   

"    !     1  

      ) )   $    )  

  )  $    3 "  !!

 +  ,-.    $  !"

$ 

%"

'

) 

)   

' 

  !   "4 )  "(   1  =

" 3-, :.1((5    ! 

  "" "$  3(

!!3>!% "

 (  '  -!.
?@

3 %     !

 

    &!

         

$         "

 

%   "(  !    )  "

         %       

"    (     " 

"  ( >  "(    )

 

 4 

 ! ) 

    "A 1;

 ?

0    " 3    (   '       

 



)3!



  !

)

' ""  ) "!) ' '



"" !) 

 '

,  ' , 

   = 8   ))   ) ) ') ' !

 / 4 5

)/ ,

 , , ' 

  )) ), (  '    )



3

A )

  -2 /" "/-#  ' * ( ', (, '   

A (', %(,*&   

'( 3

 (( 

& ' 

  



( ',

 

(

 3

)  ' @!  







(( , ' ,

,) 

  ) ,

 ), ' ! )  '

3()  :%0 ;/4

& %

/0
**+ ), %< --".

 '  7,+"  

 "

!

!

  "

   !



%4 

"(   + ::5 "(

 

" "

"&

"!  B  

 

' "4 )  " )! ( 3 $ 

"  

 ) 

' "





  )

!

!         )   

                  

 

"  "

 )

1 

 "

)

% ") 

) " )  + ' '!&(  9 !#- !. (      " !)  ")!!



" )

1   

')  '

"

  

"         

 )

3      (  

  '  4 "  

 !)  "  

)

!   " " !

 6  /  9!(  )

 ' 

  !

' ' !



',  (



 = ! ,  )  & &

) ' +

 

   (  !    ,

 3  3()

 %5
*-/$41*-11/ :;
*"< 3()

*..*"//1 :;
*0<

 ' ; ) )  '  ! ' 

 )

(  (

+

 "$ -/ "/-2 

   '

 %0 ;/4

)/ , 9 (,
(

  ,    '  %(

 

  8!% B

CB@

8!

'

CB@