← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/250/2011allowed

Jai Pal v. State Of Haryana And ANR.

2018-02-23Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia8 pages



      

 

  !"   



 

     

 #  $%#  &&&'% 

 

  !



 $"%&'%%&'(%)%*"(++* 

, -  

# -   .

  !

 ! /..

$"'01"(+%%  &&'% () *+,- 

,

  () 3 

$"

'01('+ ('0"(+%%$"%(0' %(')%(**%&'%%&'(%)%*('*+ 0%+0"(++*  '0 4 !5 !

%)106

7!

78





#

9+%%(++' %)+'(+%+  : !



;   %) !

 

 /

   !.

9')+++<" .9'++++<"#!## 4 !5 /   #

()+*(++(2 !5 # '(0)!   



/; 3 (+ # 

(+%+(+++  0  * # 

%%%+(++% #!5 .



 .

 = 

 2   

;   >3 :

 .

  !

%1&&2

!.# ,

3

#!5  

     

 .

 .

   !.

  #!  

   





 #

9++1(++' ?

3, 

   

# /    !

#  

#  ! .  !    3

!..

!    >:!

  #  ; 3 (+ 3!

#!#,

,!

5 #

 ! 3

!!   #

2 !

 

   !     ! #

  '+++<" 5

# , #!

3 *.

   !

       

*+53

.99!2 #

-

!

 #  

!

 

 5

# !..

! 

     #

  (+++<" 5 #!

3#

#



!3 .





  

 /   

  !

 

!!.

!  !!

/  ! 3 !(&!    

9+%%(++'

!  

  

 3

  @9')+++<" 

#  .  3

!!

 !.

!

!.

@9'++++<"

# %(A

   3

#.

'('))((+2

 



#!3



   B(+ 3

 .



-      

CD'

%+<"!  (++(#

  # 

(+++ 





 (+++3

!  ?

3               #  !5    

! ;  . 3 

-

   !5      .

   #    9')+++<"  4/ %'(++0 !

9+"1"(++' ! ;



! 



!3 !  

! 

  .  ,

 ;

 

 

      !     9+"1"(++'  .   !   

4/ %'(++0.

 !5    3 9')+++<"

   9'++++<"    !  

#    .      

 C

# !.

   9'++++<"  

#   %(    !

  3

#.

'('))((+ 

#

#.

!5     ! 

9')+++<" 

#  .

3



%( !



!.

 



  !.    .

   .   .3  .  !

     5

   3

 !

  3 

  

  .

     !  3   4   !5  /    

!  5

#!! 





3   !  

   

E   3 

# 

    

 ##!#  

 ! # D3

 

 .

 ! 

# 5  2

!  # 3  ?

 ! !!. !   

<

  #  ,  3. 

 .

 !.

 #   !

   !  #  #   '('))((+    !   .

.

   3 

  (9 !

2



!

!!

!!

2

 

!!

#!

   !!

  !.

#!.

 

 !!

  

/    

!#!

!

2

 3     (9

!

 

  0 3

#! .3 .



!5   ,

#!#3

. 2 #  

 

F

 !

 !

! # 5

3#!



!!

D

.

 !

$!

#   /    3!

!  #

!

3 !!

  .

   !

 !  !

   

CD "0 !

%+%+(+++  ;.  #



 3 ;."G9# 3 3

 ##  %+!    !!

 !



 .

 ?

  / 

 

.  

3, /  

 

!

 # !

%+3  0 

 

#  # 3     ;.  #     #    3

 !5    2  

!  #         .

     3  3"



 ?

 !!!.  /  . 



!

! !!

 

#! !CD "'#! )!  #!# !

((+9(++(3 !  /..

;    /

G 

/ 

 



3 # !

%  '.



 0 2   %+! )!  3 . 

3

#

( 3   !    "

. #  !

3  !3 !!. #

 !

 

!

 3

   5

/

G 

/  . ! 5

 #!.  3  

 %+! !!



.  3 



2



 



/2 ;  # !3 3 ! ! 4. #



! #

!3

D.

!

 #!# ! /

G 

/ 

#

 #,!

!5 

!

 ! 5 



 !#!!

  #!5

! 2     

"  6CD % (8#!#  3H

;.: . #  # 5 #3  #

3   ! # 3 "  ; C 

.



%0+0(+++

 !

!CD 9 ;:

# .

;. 



# $C:   

#   (+++2 #

.

;."G' 

 

%++++<"

  # 3

  G 

/  ; @9'+<" 5 #

 ! # D.

 3   #  !

!

!

 #  !! 

!

!!



   .



 !!

G") !;

 $C: 

;:

  $C: .

 9&9(+<"3

      

 

3 !CD )< )<F



 .

 ?

!.

  !"

D. ;:

##  .

;.# G'



  

#3 !3#

 #  ! . #!#    !  !

   ! / ! 3

 !

! .  ! / !  3

 !  

       

    3            !" 

  !  # !  !  . #!!

 !   .   

         #"G%  # 3  

.

#,!

!  .

!

"    #    !

  #!  #    #  . 

!5   .

# 



 ; "  .

 #



!5  3  !

   .

!5    D/ .+ *+/.0+*)-12% /3.*/ 4/%+  /  

*+3.*)-&!7#

#  ,

#!3

3



 4/ +8/. 9+1.+ +3,"):-&;:

         / # 3

 ! 3

.



!.

  "

. 3

!  !!



# !  ! #! . ;   

 # 3

!5 !

2    #!

   '(0)!

/    '+A! 

. 6CD '8# 3 #@%+!

# !

!

3  

"

# # . . !  ! /   



#3

!.

@'!



#  3

 !

   # !!

 !.

!!



 (9+((+%)  )&&'%-