← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1253/2014dismissed

United India Ins. Co. Ltd v. Bijanti & ORS

2023-09-22Mrs. Justice Amarjot Bhatti17 pages

  

       

 

!



 !

 "#" "# $  %"

&'# $%&  & !

 '

(())*+ ,- () * +& & !

 '

(+ " #  .! %"

&'# , -  !

.

!& .

'

&

 "

/!"

(())*+ ,- $%&  & !

 '

(+ 0 12$/3 ("

4-(,.3 04, $,,.

+  ' */ **01*+ 2+3*(())*+/ $  %* 2(++4/  .! % '5*6/01*+ 2(+* / $  % *2(+$* /  .! % '56*01*+ 2+3*(())*+/  .! % *2(+!/ $  % 77777 04, $,,.5 4"

3  *(())*+  8  /9*+/  *  3  :/  13/)  *:); (*<0/;*5-:*/0/3*5-:*/*'*/-"+3-63+3/:+3 /*(())*+=/6*+-*)6-*/*#3*2/)+3/+*+*((*)

  =*/6      $  2  %  2  :/2/1*+/  *  3*1:+  2 1:(*+/  *>*  =;  +3  /=-*)  /  /:(-6  >*  *+

% !(*=;)*'+11/+ )*/:/=-*)03*99*0 >3*0+3*(())*+83 /+/*-*1 :(*;?/:/+3* 2/)*((*)=*/6  .!2 %2++/6*/+3/:(-6 >**2*=+3+3*((*)3**/-+2+3*: >**+

% !0+320+3*((*)*+*<-(+6+32 /(*) 32*1+2+31**+3*+ /9*+/*:/*:); (*<0/;*5-:*/0/3*5-:*/*'*/-"+3-63+3/*+-*) -*/*0:+3/(+/+//9*+/#*@3*+//">3 A(/-/6+3(1;21)*/:(+/+/# 3*2/)1)*/:(+/+/ -@1+/44*% 2+3'+,3/1)1+0B

26*+2 1:(*+/2  .0

C*)6>/+3/++D %E(*-: *11-+2*+32 *93**/*'+,3/1-)**11/++/ -=:/+++3*+*++3+/:2*11/+01* *93**>*!% ;*)*>*/6+39=2F)(G/'C@-(-+/0 '0*3*-6*3**/6 .0.

C(:+3 +32*+2-)*;

2

40*+*=-+

!

*: *93***)6>/+33/=+3/ )*>/35-:*>6/62:'-+/*)*0+ 22/1 *3*-6*3++3//1+3/(1+/1;1)H3+3; *13*'*:* 3><0'*3*-6*30*))2*- *1+=*/6 6/+*+/ ! B%>/+3>*++*<>3/13 >*=/6/=;(+ @*+;***/1*:2:+3/2 3*-6*3/**306)/6+*1<):**+*;3/63( *3/++3=/1;1)2 *93**>/+36*+21-++3/:(*1+0

!

*93**2))>*/+3(+ 6*/6+3/*11/+0   B!  *+ 

4  -  @1+/  $B0  !

%  2     >* 6/+*6*/+(+ *+)/1@+*+/ /+;0*3*-6*3 10+31)*/:(+/+/ !

31)*/:(+/+/>*1++=;*))+3(++3 9/+>/+++*+:+2/)=;(+* 0()/:/*; =91+/6*/6:*/+*/*=/)/+;01*-2*1+/0+*((*13/6+3

-+>/+31)*3*>+*<+/*:/+++3*++3(+ /+3>2/13*1+2*=>0/+/-=:/+++3*+ +3*))6*11/+>*1*--++36)/61*1<)2 1*1;1)/+ *93**322/63/1)>*/->/+3 (+!0+320+3*>/6(+*+)/*=)+ (*;*;1:(*+/0**))6 :/+0*))+32*1+>/+ >*1)*/:+3*++3*:-+:+//+31)*/:(+/+//3/63); A*66*+/+3+33/1)2+3(+>*/) +3(+ >*(/=)/*;:*21*-/6*))6 *11/+10/+>*(*;+3*++31)*/:(+/+/:*;=/:/ >/+31+ % 3  -*1  :(*;  8  (+    !

% *1+>*I-/+(//6?/1I-**;*(+ ,3/1)>03>*+(/6+3*:3*1+>/+3 >*++*<>*///)*+/2+:*1/+/2/-*1 ()/1;  320  +3  *>/6  (+  /  +  )/*=)  +  (*;  *; 1:(*+/++3(+/+/ :/+0*))+32*1+>/2 >*++<>)6>/+3+3(*;+3*++31)*/:*+C(+/+/:*;= (-+++/1+(22+3/1:21*/1+/:*6*/6+3 1)*/:21:(*+/+>*(*;+3*++31)*/:(+/+/2/)=;+3 (+/+/  :*;  </);  =  /:/  I-*  +3 *>/6  (+  8 -*1 :(*; .

:  +3  ()*/6  2  +3  (*+/0  2))>/6  /-  > 2*:=;+3/=-*)     

   

        



  

            



         !"!#$% &   '

   () * ( +      ' ,                    

    

-           

    



 

   '

 '  ,  -  - ,-) * "     ( ,       

       

    - 

'

 '

  ) *!"

%          ! 

       ) *!"

. .    

    - 



       

&'

 '  ,   ) *!"

/   +(+31)*/:(+/+/0+3(+/+/ /9*+/3)2+((/++3>/+=A*H*(+3-63 3-);>*22/*/+AHC3(+/+/2-+3A*:/ *:

/>*0(-+;@-(/++0 *)(/+*)0*3*-6*3*H *  ?*)  *=-  @/63  *  H!  3*2+0  )*  1-)  2  +3 (+/+/+1+/2/1(;2(+-@1+/$!  * A */(1+/(+222/63/1)*A!*1)+3 /1 $ +=-++31*2+3(+/+/C1)*/:*+0+3 )*1-)2(+ @*+;***/3/:)2+((/++3 >/+  =A  *  H  *  (  +3-63  3/  -);  >  *22/*/+ A HC  3  (+  2-+3  A*:/  */  5-:*0

6/+*+/ )<0 -+3/+;0*3*-6*3* H 0@*+/35-:*0

 )<0 -+3/+;03*99** H!*@-/)5-:*0 -/1/*)*1303*99* * H% 3*2+0)*1-) 2+3 (+* +/+1-:+*;/11(;2 //6)/1*A 01(;2 6/+*+/ +/2/1*+*A  01(;

2  -*1  )/1;  *  A !0  1+/2/  1(;  2  9-6:+  *+



$*A %01+/2/1(;2+*+:+2/3*A .* 1)+3/1 +3+33*0)*1-)2(+ !+1+/2/1(;2-*1)/1;*A 4*1)+3 /1 2+3*/6+3*6-:+**1=;)*1-)2

4 *))+3(*+/0+31)*/:(+/+/2/)=;+3(+/+/C1)*/:*+>* *))>  =;  (*/6  /:(-6  >*  *+  

% !  /  >3/13 1:(*+/++3+-2 40

C>/+3/++*++3*+2$.E (  *-:  2:  +3  *+  2  /+/+-+/  2  +3  (+/+/  +/))  /+  *1+-*) *)/J*+/>**>*0*+*/)+3/ )/6*66/2+3/>*0+3*((*)=*/6

$ 2 %3*=(2=;*(())*+C1)*/:*+/9*+/* +30  >3*0  +3 *((*) =*/6     .!  2  % 3* = (2=;+3*(())*+C-*1 :(*;

3*3*+3*6-:+2)*1-)(+/6 +3  (*+/  /  =+3  +3  *((*)  ?*  1-)  2  +3 *(())*+C1)*/:*+  /   $  %  *6-  +3*+  +3  )*  '+ 11/+ )*/:/=-*)03*99*(*+3>**+

% !/ >3/13+31:(*+/>*6*+++3+-2 4)*1*)6>/+3 /++  D$.E  (  *-:  2:  +3  *+  2  1)*/:  *(()/1*+/  +/)) *)/J*+/2+3*:-+0>3/13//*I-*+*+3*>*(*=;+3 /=-*)/)/*=)+=:/2/+/(/++3*++32*1+-:2*11/+ >*(1=;A*://62+3;>/+?*)*=-@/63 H! +32*+2-)*;2

40*+*=-+

!

'+31* /1+/: *93***)6>/+3/35-:*>1:/6+3/ (**+1;1)2:'-+/*)*0*3*-6*3+>*+3/ /1*>3+3;*13*'*:* 3><0'*3*-6*30 +3  22/6  /13  *1+  =*/6  6/+*+/     ! B% *)6>/+3>*++*<1*:*+*3/63(/**3*6)/6+ :**3/+*6*/++31;1)2 *93**+3/*11/+0 *93 **-22/-/9-/0**-)+03)+3/)/2 6*/6+3/

$ *11/+0 =*/6 B!C

4>*6/+-@1+/ $BC!

%  2   0  )/1  @+*+/  /+;0  *3*-6*3  3  1(;  2 +:+: (+/A31)*/:*(()/1*+/>*2/)=;+3 (+*(())*+C1)*/:*+//9*+/8>/>*)6>/+32-:/ 13/)81)*/:*+ +.*1)*/:*+4@3*+//>3/ -/6+3(1;2+31)*/:(+/+/31* *93**>* ></6**)(>/+3'C@-(-+/0'0*3*-6*3* >*  *>/6  *)*; 2   ..

C  (  :+3  3 +/  2*:/);  >* (+  -(  3/:  >0  +3 )*  '+  11/+  )*/: /=-*)0  3*99*  >3/)  */6  +3  I-*+-:  2  1:(*+/  3* >6);+*<+3/1:21** %.

C(:+3@/:/)*);0 /*I-*+1:(*+/2 

C3*=6*+6*/6+3 A(/+-2-*)*)*+/+31:(*+/*>*2) 21+/-:*>))*)2-(//*6-/*12*2*+3 +>*3/13/)* 

C/*)/*I-*+*:*63 /++*>*=;+3)*'+11/+ )*/:/=-*)03*99*/ *)+>*+3)>/+/(*;+3*++3*(())*+C1)*/:*+* +/+)+3*1*:-+21:(*+/320+3>**+

% !(*=;+3)*'+11/+ )*/:/=-*)03*99* :*;</);=:/2/

  +3  +3  3*0  +3  )*  1-)  2  +3 *(())*+C/-*11:(*;/  .! %*6-+3*+/+31*/ 3*0+3*11/+*3*6)/6+//6+3(*+2@*+;***/ 8(+ >*+(13/1)=;+3 1)*/:*+>*++-+>+3;(+3/>/0 *93** >*+-/63:*)6>/+3/35-:*>0+31)*/:*+

  2*/)+A*://35-:*0*-+32+3 *>/+=2+3 )*'+11/+ )*/:/=-*)03*99*3)*1-)2 +3  *(())*+C/-*1  1:(*;  (/+  -+  +3*+  )* 1-)  2 /-*11:(*;3*A*:/@-/)5-:*0 50-/1/*)*130 3*99** H%>33*(1+31(;29-6:+/

/:/*) * !B2

41/ 

$01*+/+)F@+*+ ,-@*+;***/G>3@*+;***/>**1I-/++2+313*6 2*:*6*/+3/:2>*+2/1 (;29-6:+/A %* 1(;2+*+:+2/35-:*1=2+3 /:/*)+/*)

-+/A .3+*+:+2?*)*=-@/63H!>*>6); )/-(=;+3)*'+11/+ )*/:/=-*)03*99*3 /+3/61+3>+3*+3>*;>/+++3*11/+ 2*1+0@*+;***/8(+ **;*/+((/++3 >/+=A* H(+3*+()/13*1:+3/3-

4>*2*));/)/+3*11/+1*3*2/) *(()/1*+/A $6*/63/2*)/:()/1*+/*-)+/:*+);3>* *1I-/++2+313*62*:*6*/+3/:/+3*/ *+31(;2 9-6:+/A %3)*'+11/+ )*/:/=-*)03*99* 3*++*));/6+3*2*/2*1+*>6);1*:++311)-/ 6*/6  /-     +3*+  +3  *11/+  >*  1*- - +  *3  * 6)/6+//62@*+;***/0/8(+ 3  )*  1-)  2  +3  *(())*+C/-*1  1:(*; 2-+3*/+3/-+3*+@*+;***/0+3*))6/2+3*1+ =*/6     ! B%  >*  +  3)/6  +3  *)/  221+/  //6 )/1*++3+/:2*11/+>3/13/A (+3///6)/10 3>*1:(+++/)/63++*(+3/1)**+*1+);3

B 6/+*+/1+/2/1*+2+3*2*/*1+/A  *+3-)* >/63+2+3*1+/4.

<6++3+/:2*11/+0+3*/*1+ >*1*;/6*>*++*<0+320+3++*)>/63+2+3*))6 22/6*1+3*A1+3(://=))/:/+3/>* -((  +  3*  *  //6  )/1  2  *;    ,3/1)C*; *(+  ,3/1)  320  +3  *1+  >*  =/6  //6  / 1+*+/2+3+:*1/+/2/-*11:(*;3 )*  1-)  2  *(())*+C/-*1  1:(*;  3*  )/  -(  +3 *-+3/+;2

1/+/  /1* +/+)F1  .

!& ''

&

 "

/!"

6 '

'

(& %&7 ( 8  '"G +3/1*0 

  

 

   





  

   - &



 

 &     

  

&

  

 

 ,       

 0  

 '



-       

 ,  -      

   ,    

 ,    

   +3*+1*0 +3>*/1(-11+3>+3*++3*1+>* -2*;1::1/*)(-(=;+3>2+3*/*1+*++3 +/:2*11/+320+3*2*/*-+3/+;)/-(=;)* 1-)2*(())*+C/-*11:(*;+-((++3// 3)*1-)2*(())*+C/-*11:(*;2-+3)/-( *-+3/+;2+3 

 

01/+/ 0 /1*+/+)F0&%&9  & !

 "

6 '

'

0&+' & !

'"G0>3/ +3*+1*0     - & 

       

!

& ,       

  ' '  , 



   - 



      

& +  

'   ,           

!&     

 



  ,          +3*+1*'

 ,    

   - & ,   

   & -   -+/+31*/ 3*0  +3  *2*/  *-+3/+;  )/  -(  =;  +3  *(())*+/-*1 1:(*;/+*(()/1*=)++32*1+2+3(+1* 3  )*  1-)  2  +3  *(())*+C/-*1  1:(*; 2-+3*/+3/-+3*++3*1+>*=/6-/1+*+/2 +3 +:* 1/+/2 /-*1 ()/1; (+3 6/+*+/ 1+/2/1*+2+322/6*1+A  0/+>*+=-);2 *6/1-)+-*)(-(>0*++3+/:2*11/+0+3*1+>* 1*;/6>*++*</+3'-/1/(*)?

% !  +  /  (*;  +3*+  +3  *((*)  (2  =;  +3 *(())*+C/-*11:(*;:*;</);=*11(+  3*1/+3*6-:+**1=;)*1-) 2+3*(())*+C1)*/:*+/ $  %*>))*)*1-)2 *(())*+C/-*11:(*;/  .! %*3*6+3-63 +3+/*) -+11*2-));@:+/9*+/*+32/)1)*/:(+/+/

 -@1+/442'+,3/1)1+0B

26*+21:(*+/ *11-+2*+32 *93**/*:+3/1-)**11/+0 *))6);1*-=;(+ >3/)//63/*1+=*/6 6/+*+/ ! B%*3);*6)/6+);31)*/:*(()/1*+/ 3*=2/)-@1+/442'+,3/1)1+0B

0+320 +3->*+31)*/:*+++*=)/3+3*3*6)/6+//6 +3(*+2(+ 6*/6>3/13(1/2/1/->* 2*:  =;  +3  )*  '+  11/+  )*/: /=-*)0  3*99*  3 )*1-)21)*/:*+3*A*:/?*)*=-@/63*H! 1*+6/1*));+*++3*++32*+2-)*;2

40*+*=-+

!

'  )*+  *93  **  *  /3  5-:*  >  +-/6    +3/ (1+/1;1)2:'-+/*)*0+ 22/1*3*-6*3 *  >3  +3;  >  *  '*:*  3><0  '  *3*-6*30  +3 22/6*1+*)6>/+3>*++*<=*/66/+*+/ !

B%1*:2:+3/2*3*-6*3*+*3/63(/**3* 6)/6+  :*  *  3/+  +3  1;1)  2  *93  **  *93  ** -22/-/9-/*11-+2>3/133)+3/)/2(*+2: +3/0+3)*1-)21)*/:*+3*()*111(;2  B!C

4-@1+/ $B0!

% )/1@+*+/ /+;0 *3*-6*3?*+0+3/+/6*+/>*1*/-+*(+  @*+;***/0/2+3*2*/*1+>/+3>*++*<>* 13*))*>0-/6+3+/*)/35-:*/+-((++3 (1-+//0**-)+0@*+;***/8(+ >* *1I-/++2+313*62*:*6*/+3/:*11-+2)*1<2/1 31(;29-6:+2*1I-/++*)*+ 

$/ /:/*) * !B*+ !

4/A %>0/+31*/3*0+3*11/+

  /(12:+3++/:;2+3;>/+?*)*=- @/630>3/A*:/*H!3*11/+06/+*+/2 *6*/+ @*+;***/8(+ *(+*+/213*))**+ /(-+ 3+*+:+ 2?*)*=-/631*H! =2 )*'+11/+ )*/:/=-*)03*99*/-22/1/++(+3 2*1+-:2*11/+*>))**3*6)/6+//6+3(*+2 (+ >3>3/)//6+3*1+>/+3>*++*<*3); *6)/6+);3/++3*:*6*/++31;1)2 *93**3/1+/:

-11-:=  +  +3  /9-/  -22  =;  3/:  /  +3  *11/+  (;  2 +:+:  (+  /  A    +3/  (/+0    *:  -((+  =;  +3 *-+3/+;1/+/  !!"

# $0 % !

&

 $ .

!&5 /1*+/+)F4& &9& !:

; <&&

= >&!

 '"

6 '

'

:("

."".""."

/&+9 !

.

'

&

 +>& /!"G0-@1+/44 2'+,3/1)1+0B

0>3/+>*A()*//(** 0>3/13 **-  12         

     



 -   



   ,  

 



    3   //   4 5

 ' $## ,

  -- &             

&    - 

    , 

   



 

     6      

  

   

  

     

   

  ,

          



 -   

         

    7   &  



8 3  *  -:= 2  +3  *-+3/+/  >3  /+  / 1)*); :+/+3*+*;1)*/:(+/+/-@1+/442'+,3/1) 1+0B

/+=1/+3=*/2/1)=2+3/=-*)

! 320+*6>/+3+3*6-:+**1=;)*1-) 2+3*(())*+C/-*11:(*;/  .! %32//6 6/=;+3)*'+11/+ )*/:/=-*)03*99*(+*//6+ /-6*/6+3*11/+1*-=;@*+;***/8(+  -+3/*3*6)/6+//6>3/)//6*1+=*/6 6/+*+/ ! B%+I-/*;/+21*+3 2//6**11/6);-(3) 3)*1-)2*(())*+C1)*/:*+/ $  % (/+-++3*+I-*+-:21:(*+/*>*=;+3)*'+ 11/+ )*/:/=-*)03*99*/>**+

% !/+>* +3)>/+/1)*/:+3*++31*/1+/: *93**>* ></6  *  *  F)(G  >/+3  '  -+/*)  *0  +  22/1 *3*-6*3*>*6++/6*)*;2 .0.

C(:+3+ (+3I-*+-:21:(*+/0+3)*1-)21)*/:*+ A*:/  /9*+/  8  1)*/:*+      *  H  *  -/6  3  1 A*:/*+/0311+3*+3+(*;(26*/6 +3:();:+*/1:23)*+3-=*3)*1-)2 1)*/:*+2*/)+A*:/*;>/+2:'-+/*)*+ +*=)/3+3:();:+**)*;2 *93**31)*/:*+ -/631A*:/*+/2-+3+*++3*+3>**)></6** F)(G>/+3@>*+/*1+;0*3*-6*3*>**>/6*)*;2

!0.

C(:+3320+3/+3/61+3>+3*+

*93**>*></6>/+3'-+/3>*6++/6 *)*;2 .0.

C(:+3+3*=12*;1-:+*;(20 +3  /1:  2 )*+  *93  **  /  *-:  *  ://:-:  >*6 2 -</))></*;**-/6+3+/:2-);0

40>3/13/

% :+/*  0% % C(:+33201//6+3/2*1+0 +3*)*;2)*+ *93**/*-:*  0.

C(:+3 "-2/6-#+31)*/:*(()/1*+/0/+/:+/+3*+*++3+/:2 *11/+03>*!%;*2*6H31)*/:*++((/++3 >/+  =A0  3  /1)  3  *6  *  !  ;*    (  +3  1)*/: *(()/1*+/0+3*62)2)*+ *93**/:+/*=-+ .;*>0+3/1-:+*;(2+32/)++*=)/3 +3*62 *93**3)*'+11/+ )*/:/=-*)0 3*99*>3/)1//6+3*2*/2*1+/63+);*-:+3*62 1*/1+/:/+3*66-(2%%.;*;);/6-(+3 *-+3/+;1/+/   #% !

&

 $'(0/1* +/+)F0&% ' & !

 '

6'

0&%9 ( 8 & !

 'G01//6)*+

*93***)2:();(0 .E/1*//1:1:-+ += 4 .C*+3:+3);/1:1:-++= !0 .C* *-*)/1:1:-++= !$0.

C-+/+31*/3*0 )*'+11/+ )*/:/=-*)03*99*=;6//6.

E/1* *-:+3/1:2)*+ *93**++3+-2 %0.

C >0C%+3-1+/+>*(*)A(/+-*:-)+/()/2 %>*/63+);*(()/=;+3)*'+11/+ )*/:/=-*)0 3*99*+31*/3*0+31)*/:*+>6/ 

C2 2-*)*)*+/+* 

C+>*)21+/-:*) 2-(//*6-/*122*+32+3:/13/) +3>/0 +3  1)*/:*+  >  +/+)  +    .0

C  +>*  )  2  +*+0

.0

C+>*2-*)A(/+-*+>*)21+/-:0 +3>/2>*+/+)+ %

C*/:/)*);0+313/)>-) 3*=+/+)2+3)2)**221+/3)*'+

. 11/+ )*/:/=-*)03*99*3*6*+ 40

C+>*+3 1:(*+/*+3-:++*)21:(*+/*>/+3+3 *2*//1:/:)+3*:320/:;(//0+3 1:(*+/2 40

C6*+=;+3)*'+11/+

)*/:/=-*)03*99*/9-+***=)*+3*:+ I-/  *;  /+21    />  2  :;  /1-/0  +3  I-*+-:  2 1:(*+/*>*=;+3)*'+11/+ )*/:/=-*)0 3*99*/>**+

% !+I-/*;/+21 !

3)*1-)2/-*11:(*;/  .!

%*/+3()*+3*+@*+;***/8(+ 0+3/>* +3)/6*)///6?/1*+3*1+=*/66/+*+/  ! B%>*=/6-//)*+/2+3+:*1/+/2+3 /-*1()/1; 6*/6+3/2*1+0(1/2/1/-!*.> 2*:  =;  +3  )*  '+  11/+  )*/: /=-*)0  3*99*  3 )*/=-*)3**)+>/+3+3/->3/)1//6/- / (** $+!4+31*/3*0+3//6?/12(+  @*+;***/0//(1*A (+3/ //6?/10@*+;***/>*1:(+++/?/63+*(+ ,3/1)**1+*+3///6?/1>**)/-(+ 

320+3/*(1/2/11/+*)/+3//6?/1+3*+(+  >*1:(+++/**1+ 3  )*  1-)  2  +3  *(())*+C/-*1  1:(*; */+3/-+3*+>*++*<>**++*13>/+3+3/*1++));0 +320+3-)*>/63+2+33/1)>*:+3*>3/13/ (1/=2?/63+*(+,3/1)320+3/3-)3** //6?/1+/3*;63/1)3*1/+3/

4 *(1+2+3(+1*@1+/ 1)*- 2/?/63+'+,3/1) >3/13:*   

  -

   

 ,      ,

  -

  

  

!  

 ,   &  ,

'

  9  :'.22   -3 6/+*+/

+/2/1*+2 *1+=*/66/+*+/  ! B%/A  0 *11/6+>3/13+3-)*>/63+2/13*1+/:+/* 4.

56320=;:*/+1*=*/+3*++3*/*1+0 +3-63*++*13>/+3*>*++*<=1*:3*;63/1)2 >3/13+3//6?/1+/3*;63/1)>*I-/2 (+ 3/);0+3)*1-)2*(())*+C/-*11:(*; *)+<+3+*+3*++3*1+>*=/6()/2*(-(+3 +3**6/1-)+-*)(-(>/+3-+*;(://320+3>* /)*+/2+3+:*1/+/2/-*1()/1;3>*++*< >**++*13>/+3**1+));+3/*/+1*=*/+3*++3 *1+>*=/6-2*(-(/22++3**6/1-)+-*)(-( 3/*(1+2+31*//63+);*)+=;+3)*'+11/+

)*/:/=-*)03*99*/(**!%*!.2+39-6:+3 >*++*<1*+=I-*+>/+3*K+*/)L*(@1+/ 1)*-!B0/+/+*+*K:/+*/)L0:* 

  -  

&  ' ,

        ,  - 

  ,

            !

- '



   , ,    &   - 

 3201//6+3*2*/2*1+0+3/+3/6 1+3>+3*+(+ @*+;***/>*+3)/6*)/ //6  ?/1    3  >*  //6  *1+  >/+3  >*++*<  /

$ 1+*+/  2  +3  +:  *  1/+/  2  /-*1  ()/1;  3 2//66/=;+3)*'+11/+ )*/:/=-*)03*99* (+*//6++3/-+I-/*;/+21*+3*:* *11/6);-(3) % />2:;*=/1-/0+3)*'+11/+

)*/:/=-*)03*99*/63+);*>*1:(*+/2 40

C *)6>/+3/++/2*-2+31)*/:*+32//66/=;+3 )*  /=-*)    +3  /-  2  *=    +  I-/  *; /+21320+3>*(*=;+3)*'+11/+

)*/:  /=-*)0  3*99*  *+  

% !  /  *11/6);0  -(3)

-)+*+);0  +3  *((*)  =*/6   $  %  (2  =;

*(())*+C1)*/:*+/9*+/*+3*+3*((*)=*/6  .!

% (2  =; 3  /+ /*  -*1 :(*; ?/:/+  * *11/6);0/:/ 31(;211/2:+3/=-*)=+=*1<+ +311I-*+ /6*(()/1*+/"#0/2*;0*)+*/(22 3+1(; 2 +3/  = ()*1  +3 2/) 2 *+3 11+1*

!

04, $,,.   

4-;=3 H3+3(*</6C*

 H3+3 (+*=)