M/S C & C Construction Company v. M/S Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd. And ORS
!"# $% # #& #'
(&)* +, -
!"# $% &$.$/.0#1#."' + -
!"# $% (*$!2).3'
4 -
'
56 7 7 7 7
! " " #
" $% #&#'$'#& " ! !(
" )& **** 7 7
# +! !
, ! -
.,/ !% $0'$$'#) #11 !
2!
#344
.+
!( 5
!
6 !+
78 !/
, .
0 0& 1''- ! . " )&! % /, ! - ., FACTS NOT IN DISPUTE $ #31$'#' 0'' % /!
/% !!
% / / :
!/!
! / +!,! ! ; :
%!+ /
/
" 9-'<--14<$ . .:
!/!
!// . . !% /! ! +! % :
=% ( =:
.%! !%
=
1 !( =%
!/ ! !%, ) > . .
. . & ?
. !/ !
! %/ % .
-
! "
# $%&'()'*'+,)-$
-
. / /%%
0 1
! / #
*2 3. / %4
5 4 $6 < (/ !/ !
% . .
" ) & = %
! - ., % ! ,
. . " )&= ! SUBMISSION OF LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE PARTIES. 1
! ! . . ,. !
/ %@
!. , =
! %
: / ! / % , %!
/ A
!
, ! B % ! / ! !/
! / ! % ! / / C ! . ! , ! % ! , % ! " #B
., 0
/ ! " ) &B . !
!. /%
.
+
! /!
, !
, .
! ,= , ! . 4 ! !
!
%
! 3 %
!% +! .
- "ISSUE NO. 3 -($1
" / "$1 7
4 % . * * 8988 :$$/ 7$4;<3$ "
# ' 7
#
+ $=
. .
7$4;7$4>$ - $ =
40 :
8 " ?1 3 # # $- @5/ >,0 ?
A
' ' $=
$- @5/
/
,$+$ >,5$
?:
7$4 $ ?:7$4 - # $ 3 :
3 . "$4 $ - 7$4 / # # 4 1
$1
# / >,0/ # # "$ -0$1
Sukhdev and another Va. M/s New India Insurance Company Ltd., and others CR No.3412 of 2011 decided on 3.7.2012; Bharat Kharbanda Vs New India Assurance Co. Ltd. And others, ACJ 1701 (P&H); Jai Parkash Goyal Vs United India Insurance Company Ltd., II (2010) CPJ 183: New Indian Assurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Kusum & Ors, II (2010) ACC 518 (SC): Ramji Lal Vs. Padamchandra Gupta and others, 2011(1) T.A.C. 2000 (Μ.Ρ.); Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Meera and others, 2011 ACJ 23 and National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs Challa Bharathamma & Ors. III (2004) ACC (SC)$ -5$8
/ +*2 3
/ #
#
#
# / $ -)$3 / $ +* 2 3 /
$ -+$; # # ;
$ / "$ 1 ! /
$ 1 * .United India Insurance Co. Ltd. Ve Kamalabat Mukunda Kumare and others, 2012 ACZ 1011
#
/
# #
#
$ 1 ! / 1 # /
/$1=B# = 8 # # # =B# 783 5- ;
$;/ # # =B# = 8
/ /
#
$ -@$;Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. Va Meera and others, 2011 ACJ 23
#
/ " .
/ / #
#
$;/
#
# /
/ /$;/ // 83 5- 8 ;
$ -,$;Jai Parkash Goyal vs United India Insurance Company Ltd. 11(2010) CPU 183. / / $1
# / # "$1 / #
$ ->$;National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs Harbhajan Lal, 2010 ACJ 709
! % 0 C
; /. !
# 8 National Insurance Company Limited vs. Laxmi Narain Dhut [2007
(3) S.C.C.700]. / #
/
- # / ".
#
#
$D 0($; . / $1
/ / /"
/ / >,0/ ## "$1
#
$ 0 $
/ ". #
. #
#
$ - $6 #' 9
/ ! . ! %
!
/ . / . :
/. != 7
.
%
%! !
! ! / ! % ! / / !D %! %
!
!
,D .
. ## IFFCO Tokio General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Geeta Devi 2023 INSC 954 != 7
.
!! !
,
/ ! %
( / !
,. , !/
%
D , ( /!
. , / / ! % #$
. , National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaran Singh AIR 2004 Supreme Court 1531 !
,! /! !
/ / ! , ! / .
! !
% / , %
! !
+!
!
! %
@
,/
! #) / % !
% !
@. ! #&
. ! ! !! ! ,
!% +! @.E-# .,: /
5 ! 8 %! ! %
: / ! / % ( %! ! / ! . . ,. #< = %
, ! / 5F@#$8
!.
( ! / +!
. . ,
+! !
.,- " #
, . /
D , ! ! D %
.
,%
( #1
. ! ! % ( .
+!
! %
,
. ,
@
/ ,/ % ! (
! ,+!
! ,.
! . !
, #0 +!
% !
, . ,
/ %
+!
. ! / ! ! / (
,%! ! ,%
%
#4 % / /
!
.
/ , ! /
+!
% %
!
#3 D , ! / .
! . $' / 58 ,
7 7
+ -
E! (/ -(/ (/ E!
;