← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1291/2014allowed

Gulab Devi And Others v. Krishan And Others

2018-09-20Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa5 pages



    



 !"#$# %&''( )* +,# -.$ //** 0.$)$ 1.#$- % -.$  $/ %2%  

      

.$% & $'- ,% .3 *42, "

! . .'5'1' ,42, "

! . $'

.'1)*3#%2.5#%6-42, "

! . .'5 %7, 8 *42, "

! ..$/ %2% % '9'

:::

      (; %$

//*#"

# %  - $  +%  !#*2  )%2.  5"

# %  ;  !  <#=#

# %"

$>#%6" %2 %

# % !2* 8 !2 8$

- $ "")..2 #%!#*#%6 -#%$

*'

 #"#% //*#"

# %- 2+%#$$)2'

 )%$*! . -" % #%6.$/ %2% % '9?%$).

%" =/ %8 $"- $%% !#* %8./*8 //*#"

# %' )%$*,%2 $%

$.# )$*8 // $ //*#"

# %' 3,.4-$)+=#

-/.# 2 !

2* 8= 8+@"*)223-#* .2#%6#% #% -,% ) *# 8 ! %8 %- %"2" =/%$

# %+#%66.

2'

1/#%6#%,#3 ,.=% $= 2#% //*#"

%2 $)+=#$$# %$  = 2  +8  " )%$*  .#%6  ! .  -  " % #%6  .$/ %2%

% '9?%$).

%" =/ %84/.

8.#$ ** 32'

* 8 !2 8$#%!#*#%6 *$

%2$" %2 %2'

 #%// * -#$#$"* $A *$>#%6%- %"=%

 " =/%$

# %'

.#!*84# = 8+% #"2

"* #=/ # # %)%2.5"

BB ! - .0-#"*"

4((3 $!#*2$>#%6" =/%$

)% ! $'9* "$ % "" )%  !2

- ! %7 #% = .,-#"*

>/* " %9';''* $3. -/ .% *$ =#% .+.

-2"

$2'* 2 $$.

2

3-#* %7

$/#**# %.#2#%6 = ."8"*4 -= ."8"*3 $$ .)">+8 /#">)/ ,-#"*+ .#%6.6#$

# %% ' B9C3-#"-3 $+#%62.#,%+8 1.#$- %#% .

$- %2%6*#6% = %%.'

* #=/ # # %- ,#%6+%" % 24! ** 3#%6#$$)$3.

!.

=2+8 *&  

       

         

 

! 

" 

         

    

       # $

!   %&'()*+), -(    !.        !.     

         / 0## 1 1 %  2              2       

  /0##

    3   !   !.

         

      

 

./0#& ( &4 %$ !

$$$) '#$" %".%24!#%2#%6$3..

).%2#% !

, ). ! -"* %2# 3 $-*2

2

- ! %7 >/* " %

"" )%  !#%7).#$$)!!.2#% % #%, *,#%6 -#%$).2? !!%2#%6 ,-#"* %23-#"-3 $+#%62.#,%#% .

$- %2%6*#6% = %%.'

9 %$ !

$D) )= !" =/%$

# %#$" %".%24,#2 .2

2''/ $$2+8 -'''4 .% )*4

*" =/%$

= )% $';494? * %63# -#% EBF/. %%)=- $+%

.22#%!

, ). !"* % '% =*8)* +,##''= 2"

$2'

5#%" - %*8#$$)#%, *,2#% -#%$

*#$3# .6 .2 D) )= !" =/%$

# %4- ,- .2" )%$*! .

$  *$  " )%$*  ./.$% #%6  " % #%6  .$/ %2%  % '9%$).

%"

 =/ %8'

 )%$*! . $.

#$2 *#=# 2$)+=#$$# %3# .6 .2 *- ,#%6% .22 %8 22# # %#%#%" = .2$ !) )./. $/"

%2#%$)!!#"#% = )% - ,#%6+% .22)%2. " %,% *- 2$'

. " % 4" )%$* ./.$% #%6 " % #%6 .$/ %2% % '9 2 $% 2#$/)

-" =/%$

= )%  .223 )*2.D)#.

+%- %"2 $/./ = .$ * #22 3%+8/@ ).

#%  



    



 !""

#!

$ G-#*  " =/) #%6  -  " =/%$

# %  = )% 4  6  !  2"

$2- $+%

>% +(8 .$ %2= % -*8#%" =- $+%

$$$$2 $'4(((?/.= % - #''

/ .3# -  -=#%#=)=3 6$

2=#$$#+* 2 #*83 6. $ % -2

'5)"- $$$$=% #$ +#%6/) D)$ # %+8 $' #% .,% # %#%$)"-.6 .2 #$ -)$"

**2! .'

"

$2 %7 3 $" %"22*8 + "-* .' "" .2#%6*84

*- $.#6- !)**8= 2 ;F22)"

.2$/.$ % * %2

 *#,#%6@/%$$ ! -2"

$2'-.#$!).

-.% 2#$/) 3# -.6 .2

6 ! -2"

$2+#%6(8 .$ $ % -2

'

%2.$)"-"#.")=$

%"$4 *- $.#6- !)**8 //*#2

-=)* #/*#. !( -=)* #/*#"

%2'

.#+)% *- $4- 3,.4 ,.* >2 $/"

3# -.6 .2

22# # %#%#%" = .2$!) )./. $/"

$'

* 2 -=$*,$$

2

-2"

$23 $$*!

=/* 82'1/#%6#%,#3 6 ! -2"

$2 +(8 .$4F #%".

$#%#%" = .2$!) )./. $/"

$#$6.

2+8! ** 3#%6 2#"

)=* #22 3%#%  A "

$$)/.

'

-

/ 4 *- $ %*8 .22 $)= ! $';4?

.2$!)%.

*@/%$$' 5)"- = )% 3 )*2% 3$

%2%- %"2

$';4?' ).

-. $)= ! $';4?#$ .22 .2$* $$ !$

'

%,#3 ! + ,4 -" =/%$

= )% #$.

$$$$2

%2"

*")*

2 $! ** 3$& 5.'

 '

  *")*

'

%" = $$$$2+8 * 4(((?/.= % '

F  #%".

$  #%  #%" =  .2$  !) ).

/. $/"

4(((HFIB4(9? 9'

;F22)"

# %$ .2$/.$ % *@/%$$ ! -2"

$2'

B4(9JI94? B4(994I94? '

 =/%$

!

//*8#%6=)* #/*#. !( 94@I4B? 4B@(IC494;? ;'

 %,% *- 2$ $';4?! .!)%.

* @/%$$4 $';4?! .* $$ !$

'

94? B'



*

$'C4B4;? -  ! ."

*")*

2?.

$$$$2  " =/%$

# %  = )% * %6 3# -#% EBF/. %%)=!. = -2

 !!#*#%6 ! -"* #=/ #

#** "

) *.

*#K

# %+.* $2#%!

, ). ! % ')* +,##''

= -2"

$2'

;   #$4  - 3,.4  "* .#!#2 

 3-#*  "

*")*

#%6  #% 4  /.# 2  ! 2* 8 !   2 8$  #% !#*#%6  - /.$% *  3 )*2  $

%2 @"*)22'

// *#$ ** 32#% ! .$ #2 .=$'

       





*)">8 G- -.$/ >#%6?.

$ %2& $? G- -. / .

+*& $?