High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2872/2013disposed of

Jagir Singh v. Jagjit Singh & ORS

2016-03-30Mr. Justice A.K. Sikri7 pages

#$ !

!"# #"!# %

#& !

$%!

!"# #"!# &&& '

()'

* **

' '()!*"+,"# ''-)!*"+,"#"!." ,,, *

* - /0"*+"!,##!#,"(1! !!

##!03'""++!4(#/0%)$%%5# 6,"#")7/0%89'4/4#."#2 !2",

03*% ",1++(##$%!!11!!

+"(#"-"###!!#"#!",03#+"((" %!( /,+#"

)+(#$%!!

1""45*:"103(#","+0 #".";

2 - /+1#0!*03! $%!1##0#!(","#0"%<

( 13+!*;$)0%#0#" .";

<2 6, ,! " # 7 ",,! 0%#89 0 !*#3)3!#!03 6#"! ." 9)+(,"(""#!+"!!#!"+-+%# ",(+)+,"!+#!0""++%#+*! (%#"%#!*"%# %# /#=,"(" "."

%! +"# !

",=!:4"!#+",++! 1##!##"!." :"+"45 #+(#!$%!,!1" #"#*"5"*#"#", <<",'"" +#+)

6,"#")7+",

89+(+"(#"(! !*)"1!#%",",,!+##"!# /#"!#+"#!"#0%+"#! *!+!!%+!03#)!/0%3"1!0" "# ! 1!! +"(#" " % ",

> "

+($%!! #)2

>"+(" 1#",?@%(,"(!",,

"A"#"!#1 "3!#*3 !0"3+"(#"!1#!+!#"!." #%++"(3#!(,3#%! !###,! 1 B%%( ", +"(#") #+(#,!## /#%0(##"#(!03' '()!+"%#," #!''-)!+"%#,"#"!." #%++"(3*0!!+"!%#!

. #$ . !

C!+"%#,"%! #%#!(%*"%# %#+%!,+%+5,(% #!!,+%#,,(%#!,"1+!"%!" "";0+(!#0!!%" %#)0%!/0% 1!!"3

>,""##",+"(!!!"+"#!# ,%+" !#03 1+ !+3 ,,+! # ++3 ; (!"#A!!#%("3"#()!) #"" ! #+ ! + 0% ! /0% "1! "3

>%!#!#/("%1!!"++"%",! #%,,##"!B%!#"1!03!/0%# ""1#! " !) ! +"%# ," #"! #%++"(3#%0(!+"(#"1!!03! /0% +"*# +%3!" +%3+"%# "1+ !#%,,!"##!%" %##%#!03(

2 +,!"0"+"!3!"+%(" "*#"++%"!#)!/0%!!"##### +"(0%1!!

>"++"%","##",+"(1+!"# ""0"/0"#%0#**!+""* "++%"",)+"#!(#+#%0"%)# +"(#####!# #?)

>("++"!"!#03 +,+ D:

2) %##%,,!03#%!(5 (!#003 @+1#+#%0"%!1# !"(%1"5)(#"!"%0!#03#%,,!03 (1"%!!*#3,,+#++3=*1",1! !"1

,%+"!#03B%1"0"!3",#5#

@1+1("%""##",++3"%", #?

> (" #<)

>%(/1# 23#"!1 (1++!3(%",E <E("%+"(# " <)

>++"!3)("%", #2

>1!!03!

/0% ," !#03 #%,,! 03 # +! "

> :F G 5#H"#,!1# !(!#"#"

1 %#"##"#%,,!

++!;1##%,,,"(,+%+5,(%#!! ,+%#,,(%#!,"1+!"%!"""; !*"! #"3 "0(# ," 1+ 1# ,! " "# ;"#)'""

;1#!(!#"#"

!1#!#+!" <

/ " D!% ", ( (!+# + "*! "%0#031#"1!03!/0%-%#+ !#%,,!1"#"%#,+%#!1#"!%") (3"*00"!"#"(1"5,"#,*("#) ,")("%",

>1!!"++"%","##",+"( #+!" #?)

>/("%",

>1!!"1!# #"")#+!)#*+",!#+!" #

> #!!""D!%"#"1#"")(%# *#"##"(("%"#""!0"!"!", #,(3((0#1"1!"(!%"!",# "#A" / ("% ", #

> 1!! "1!# !

#%,,0""1#!)0+%#!#%#! *"%# %#!#%,,!1",+%#)#!("%#+!"

> =0"*(#)#!! "+!+"(#"",

. #&. !

$%!1#"*+(",++! ""5+"

/"%*!1!!!

("%",

>1#1!!#+"(#"03/0%)0% !%+"%#",%(#)!+"%#,"*3,3 +"+!!*!"!!! 2

!/0%*"+!

!#03",1#1"35# @1##

< 1!!!

1#++"!"!#03+,+

?!#03#%,,!031#"3 @)!!%+!

+"(#"" #<?)

>/("%", #<

>1!!" ++"%","##",(#",,!%"!#03#%,,!03 +#,""*"#"*!03:F G 5#H" #%,,!,+%,(%!%++!!1#"! %" ," #( ; 1# !#+! "

##,+"3 +"!"1+(#(!"#A!," !3#4"#! *3", %3#%,,!03("%",

> 1!!"1!#!#%,,#+!" #

>/("% ", #?

>1!!"1!##""!!+#+! "

>/("%",(!+0#"!%+!03 !3#!#(0%#!03!/0%+*"%# %3 #%#!031#,+%,(%)#"0*"%# (3"*00"#%(#!31"5,"#1"("#! +"#!#+#%0"%("%",

> 1!!"++"%","##",+"(#!B%=0"*(#) $%! # ! ! " +! +"(#" ",

> ++"!3)0"#,!03# !$%!3"1!!1!!!

##! 03 ! /0% # ("!,! / +! ("% ", +"(#"#0!"#!03#"!." #%++"(3 12?!3#,"(!",+",+,!+"3",# %!(

,1+#+(##0!"#" +!("%",?@%(,"(!",, A" /*