High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/8909/2016dismissed

M.P.Singh Wasal v. Union Of India & ORS.

2019-01-29Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu13 pages

!"#$##%

!"#$

% & ' "

( '( ) *'+,+'- ) *'+ ++

)

)""* "(

+ ) * ( +

($* ( +

, " * -"

%. % "* ( + /

1*'+ 2 '+31 '

4"-( " $ (! !" 5"7 $* 4 $7" !"8 " -" "9 * + 66:71:$"( - ' " 9! $*(($ "( "$"

"( $ !"; ( " ( 7" 2 ! 2 ! ! 7" !"

4"( " ($ 1$, 7 $$

"$$ < ' /" ;$"* 8* '2 1' ( $" 2$ (($& . ! <

"- (( * 2 ! =7$>''?=2$ ? 7" !" !$ "& $ 7

1-( * 2@ 2 ! =7$>'?- /

5 " 2@ 2 ! =7$>'?- < 9 ($ !" 2@ 2 ! "." $ ( "( ( 2 ! =2$ ? "

= "A 28!$ 5/A?-" 28$

< " @( ; $!$ ( " ( ( !2 ! 2@ 2 ! " !" 8 " - " (

! " " ( " ( ( !2 ! =2$ ?-! "

!! "# #

$ = " B7" !"* /C?-""@( ;- $ 9 * + <5 :71: $ ! " "

-! " 28!$ 5/ " 7" !"* / 4"$ " ! " * - $"* " (- $ ( 7$' ($ 4"D 4 $

'-"$"(" 55" * & 47" !"" $!"(-

. -"E .$ !" " 7$''7$''' 7$'%( $ 7$'( 4" 9*-$$- / '-"$""( -"" ( "(2@ 2 ! - < - $!$( "( ( !2 ! =2$ ?

-" "" " 6 (" 28 !$ 5/-""@( ;( " !" 4"( -( ( !2 ! =2$ ?

1$$9 *

+ 6:71: $ !( ( -

" -" " " ( ( ! 2 ! =2$ ?" 4"-"- 4" $ ( 7" 2 ! " 2 ! !

7" !"* - 4" ( ( "" "( 1 $ ""-$$$!$"( " 28!$ 5/ 4"( -, $ !"% !

& ' !

())*+4""( $"9! $*(($ -" "" " (! '-" "( ""(7"2 ! 2 ! ! & 7" !" - !$( *$$" ( !2 ! -. ! "2 ! ! " 7" !"* "!" (

/ "( 4"- ( ""(7"2 ! $$ ""7$# !2$ $# !$ 1$"

# !

2$ # !-$- !"2 ! !

4"( !" ( !2 ! -$!$ ( "(7"2 ! $ -($ " 1 A$ ( 7 01%231"024% 566 $"1#0- /+7889.:+; '-$($"$

( ! 2 ! 2$ # ! " ( 7"2 ! "( - ! ! 4" "( -""2$ # !- ("2 ! !# !

4"( -! " 28!$ 5/-" "-(($ $" ($" 2$ # !&47" !" ""!"$( "$ 4"2$ =9( # !? -" "" ( $ ! " - ( !$ " 2$ !$7

"2$ * 4" 2$ !$7

"$ (($

!"(7"2 ! " 28!$ 5/ 9 $ ( ! "!$ -$$!$"( "-. ! ""# !"2 ! ! 4"( "($"( "( 7"2 ! -$! "

,-*.*/* !

)="B 5 $C?-" " ($"7$# !2$ $# ! $

; 1$"# !

4"$" ($

./ 0 # .1

()) . 00 2

.30,"

())4

./ 0 # .12 !30,"

())-" "( (($ $& 7" !" " )& 4 7" !"2 ($$

A(-" "" ( (( 7 $7$ ( 3(>*8 7 " $"* "& 47" !""$$, "( " ""$" " ( (( ( !( ,7$ "$$ ! " $ " !(($ $ "

%)<!$+78"$4$7"#%01%231"0 5 1=$506741" 151%20-

/9 :+ -$ 4"( ( !2 ! =2$ ?9( -" ""( - "$ !- "(7"2 ! " $ $ -$($ " $ "& * "(7"2 ! -" "" - " 3 ' &

$( +- $" / -" "- " ( " ,$ *("$"(7"2 ! $$( ( !2 ! =7$:$ 1$":2$ $?

"8F# !-"-!$ "! ( !! ( 2 ! ! ($ ! E

& : ' 4" $ ( ! -" " 7 $3 4"D 4 $"$""($ ! $" "( -$ (( * 2 ! =2$ ?

7" !" 2 ! ! " ( * 2@ 2 ! 2@ 2 ! ( !

2 ! =2$ ? " ( 28 !$ 5/ 1"$ !" 2$ # ! " -""8F# !

* $"(7"2 ! &47" !"- ! "

,-./ !

) 4"

./ 0 # .1 !305"5

()) - "

,-./2

) "

,--./2

(($ $" " ($ ' "$"B7"2 ! C " 7"2 ! =7$?" $ #.=8F8 "?

4" (( ! " ( !

2 ! -"" @( -. ! " ( - D " . 00

.305"5

())4- ! " "( (( " ,# (($ =2 ! !# !?3(>*

' "$"A7"2 ! A 7"2 !

> " # (($ , 4"(( !" ( !2 ! -"" @( -. ! " (- *(

. / 0 # .1 ! 30 5"5

()) 6 /"7"2 ! " A7"2 ! =2$ $?" $ #.=8 8 "?

4" (( !" ( !2 ! -"" @( -. ! " (- 4"2$ # ! "$ ! !"(( "(7"2 ! 4"4 $ $

(" "( ! !"( ! $!$ "$-$$ 4"4 $$

(" "( "( $ -" " "

$ "2$ # ! (( 7" 2 ! ' - @($ " $ ( !2 ! 28-"$ ( -"" (

=2$ ?-( 7"2 ! " ( ( 28 1-,7"2 ! ( " "

) $- ( 7"2 ! 4""9*- #"" "

)

)"""( "

, " * ($"( # " " $ "(

4"$; " -"" "( -"-. ! ( !2 ! =2$ ? $!$ ( "(7"2 ! " 2 ! ! & 7" !"

4" !" "(( ( "(7"2 ! 2 ! !&47" !"

-! " 5$ 4"-"$1 A$ ( 7 "

9 "; " -

%.!

0 !

2 / 0 # !

6 !!80

# !

0 8

! :8 0

;+ 1 A$ ( 7 " 5$ $ "$" !(( - !7$$

1$"2$ $ *"$ ( $ !

$$ !"(7"2 ! "- !" ( ! 2 ! ! "- !-$!$( " (7"2 !

4"$ %<*

# !

' 00 !

00 # 0# !

0 !

6 !! ,0 !

* 7!

= >

< #0 "

*9 !

# !

*- #0 00 #

# !

3 # !

67 0# # -- * ,

0 ! %

00 # !

0 " ?

+ ?

0 '!

00 #

# #

0 ?

* "

0 * * ?

0 *

0 ! %

(<# # !

0# !

0 !

+*- !

! !

0 !

0# 0# 0 * 7!

00 # !

0 !

'! ! A % *# ' ! *8 BBB (BBB <"# # !

0# !

18 BBB !

! !

5 0

A ! 00

0 !

3 # #

' !

0 !

#00 *+ 7!

0 !

* @

( % !

+ # % !

.1 / 0 # 2 !

3 # &

0 +*" ! ' !'! 0

! !

0 ? '! ! #0 *7!

! ! *7!

? 0 ! !

'! ,

(# % ,, !

! 0 &

0 +*C !# !

( # % ,, ! 1'

'! &

0 !

+*7!

0# 0 !

# 0

*- !

! !

#0 !

! *" 00 '

# # # !

?0 ,

0# # 1 !

!0# 0# ' ! !

# *7!

!! #

' !

# # !

' !# ,

('! ! # % !

- ./ !+*7 !

! !

0 !

*7!

! .# !# # !

*7!

! !

'!!0 !

0# !

0 !

! !

# !

*+ 4"7+*(( @8$5-" "

%7!

00 0 !

' ! &

6 !

0 &

! ! '

& 0

*+ 4"7"$"" B7"2 ! C"- " " 7" 2 ! 8$ ! F 8 "

4" "

( 7$ 2 ! ! 2$ $ " $ -$$ ' ! " " "7 $2$ # ! " "" 4"( "$+ ::55>7" 55"3 ' 1 *+-

$" ( 7" !" *

*(( @>''=8? " $ ( " ( " 2 ! ! 9! 4" $ (7"2 ! ( ( !2 ! " $8F8 "=? ( !

2 ! =$ !7 $?=? ( !2 ! =7 7 $? =? ( ! 2 ! =$ 1$" 7 $? =?

( !2 ! =2$ $7 $?

9"$$(-$

" 2 ! ! 9! *$$ " ( ( 8$ ! 8 "

4" ( ( ! 2 !

=2$ ? - "

4 (( ( !

2 ! =2$ ? 2@ 2 ! * 2@ 2 ! "2$ - " 1 *+- $"6 " $ > " "

4"( """ $"$ - !"(($(-" > $$ !

'"$ " $" ($-. ! " # !! !$ 28!$ 5/ "! ! ($-. ! ""- !"$ - ! 28( $ 2 ,2$ (8" " ($" ( $ #. =8F2$ $ $ 1$"?

*$$ " $ (( " " ( "2$ 9( 7 $=2$ # !? -" " " ( ! ( " 8 F 8 "

7 ; $" $ $ ( "(7"2 ! 2 ! ! 7" !"

G" ( " " ( "

! 28 !$ 5/ 1 " ( * 2@ 2 ! 2@ 2 ! $ ( !2 ! "!$ ' 9*+ <5

$" " $ -$$-"

. @( $!$ ( 2@ 2 ! ( ! 2 ! " 28 !$ 5/ #"$ "!$ "-$ " $!$( ( !2 ! ( "

4"( """ 2$ !$7

"$ (($

!"(7"2 ! " 28 !$ 5/

9 $( ! "!$ -$$$!$"( "-. ! ""# ! ! $ ' " $"-( -"! $ !$ $ " ( "$ *( " $ !$!$$ $"$ "( $ $$(( ! " $

4" " " ( " 9,+': 9 ++ :

1%71"? -

! #"" (. !: H #""($ H:+