High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/23364/2019dismissed

The Punjab State Cooperative Supply And Marketing Federation Ltd. v. Appellate Authority Constituted Under The Payment Of Gratuity Act And ORS.

2019-09-23Mr. Justice B.S. Walia4 pages

!&' "'( * +',-!./&!&' 01'2!& 3'/,1145 !"!26'& 7'"'2!& 8&"9 7!2+ :'& '2 ;'2),) 11'44!&',&+2 )& &,&'","'2 &+'!5<'& 2!&, &5(&= 2) :')1"'&)

2')'&* )'+!/+!2<!9"3(!&' 2&+'1'& '2 >>>

?@ 2&+'2'!))!)!2'<'& '" &+'!114 9&+')!<' !44A'" !)' )2')&2'"& &)2 !4,<.'2!"2'B,')& )&!6',1

2+'!2 7&"!5 ?

+!44'7' &+'A2 &1'& )&2"'2'C,2'0"!&'"

DA+'2'.5&+'!11'!4

4'".5&+'1'& '2!7!

)&&+'"'( &+' 7 ,&+2 &5 ,"'2 &+' !5<'& 2!&, &5 (&9 E +'2'

&'2 2'

'22'" & !) F&+' (&G A!) "

))'" .5 &+' 11'44!&' ,&+2 &5!((,& &+')!<'+!3 7.''

4'"!

&'2%E"!5) 2'('

1& 2"'2.5&+' &5 2"'2"!&'" D1!))'".5&+'

7 ,&+2 &5 A!) 2'('

3'" &+'

(' &+' 1'& '2 H D772 '3'"!7!

)&2"'2"!&'" D&+'1'& '2

4'"! !11'!4 12!5 7 &+'2'

2 ("!& "'4!5

7 &+' !11'!4 +' 11'44!&',&+2 &53 "'2"'2"!&'" D"

))'"&+')!<'&+'

72,"&+!&,"'2( 2(,<)&!(')&+')!<'(,4".''&'2&!

'".'5" "!5) &+'"!&' 2"'2((2"

7459&+'!11'!4A!)"

))'".'

7 <'.!22'" ?@ 8'!2'" (,)'4 (&'") &+!& &+' !11'44!&' !,&+2 &5 "

))'" &+' !114 2 ("!& "!5) "'4!5 "')1 &' +,7' "'4!5 .5 &+' 2')1"'&

7 !114 .'

2' &+' 7 ,&+2 &5 +!3 7 .''("'".5&+' &59.') "')9&+'<!&&'21'2&!

'"& !4!"+!2 !"

7 !11'!4 2'B, 2'" !1123!4 &+' +'!"

(' !&

7!2+9&+'2'

2'9),

( '&(!,)'A!)<!"',& 2(" 7"'4!5

7 &+' !11'!4 .,& &+' 4'!2'" !11'44!&' !,&+2 4'" & &!6' &+' 2'<'& '" !)1'(& &+' <!&&'2 & !((,&9 &+'2'

2' &+' <1,7'" 2"'2 )4 !.4'&.')'&!) "'9"'4!5

7&+'!11'!4("'"!"&+' <!&&'22'< &&'"&&+'!11'44!&'!,&+2 &5&"'( "'&+'!11'!4 !((2"!(' &+4!A ?%@ +!3'() "'2'"&+'),.< )) ) 4'!2'"(,)'4/'(& EE &+'(&9123 "') 2<!C <,<1'2 "!5) &+'"!&' 1!)) 7 2"'2.5&+' 2

7 !11'!4/'(& EE &+' (&2'!")!),"'2*0 I51'2)!772 '3'".5!2"'2,"'2),.0/'(& %9<!59A C&5"!5) 2<&+'"!&' &+'2'('

1& &+'2"'2912'

'2!!11'!4& &+' !11212 !&' 3'2<'& 2 ),(+ &+'2 !,&+2 &5 !) <!5 .' )1'(

'".5&+'!11212 !&' 3'2<'& &+ ).'+!4 * 23 "'"&+!&&+'!11212 !&' 3'2<'&2&+'!11'44!&'!,&+2 &59 !) &+' (!)' <!5 .'9 <!59

& ) )!&

'" &+!& &+' !11'44!& A!) 12'3'&'" .5 ),

( '& (!,)' 2< 12'

'22 7 &+' !11'!4 A &+' )!

) C&5"!5)9'C&'"&+')!

".5! ,2&+'21'2 C&5"!5)

?23 "'" ,2&+'2 &+!& !11'!4 .5 ! '<145'2 )+!44 .' !"< &&'" ,4')) !& &+' & <' 12'

'22 7 &+' !11'!49 &+' !11'44!& '

&+'2 12",(')!('2&

(!&' &+'(&244 7!,&+2 &5&&+''

'(&&+!&&+' !11'44!&+!)"'1) &'"A &++ <!!<,&'B,!4&&+'!<,& 72!&, &5 2'B, 2'" & .' "'1) &'" ,"'2 ),.0/'(& %9 2 "'1) &) &+&+'!11'44!&'!,&+2 &5),(+!<,&@I ?H@ +,)9!)1'2/'(& EE &+'(&9!1'2)!772 '3'".5!2"'2 1!))'".5&+'(&244 7!,&+2 &5(!

4'!!11'!4.'

2'&+'!11'44!&' !,&+2 &5 A $"!5) &+'"!&' 2'('

1& 2"'2 &+' (&244 7 !,&+2 &5/!

$"!5)(!.''C&'"'".5$"!5)&+' )&!& (!)'9 (15 2"'2 "!&'" D A!) 2'('

3'" .5 &+' 1'& '2 H D A'3'29&+'!11'!4A!)&

4'"A &+')& 1,4!&'"1'2 " & <' & A!)

4'" %E "!5) !

&'2 2'('

1& 2"'2 &+' (&244 7 !,&+2 &5 ?$@ (2"

!&' '(+ &+ ,2& # $ % & ' ()(*$+ )) ,- . '/. 0 1..$ /. '!"

2 34561

&7 ) < 4!2( 2(,<)&!(')+'4" !),"'2* J+,)9!)1'2&+'!.3'123 !51'2)!772 '3'".5 !2"'21!))'".5&+'(&244 7!,&+2 &5(!

4'!!11'!4 $"!5) &+'"!&' &+'2'('

1& &+'2"'2.'

2'&+' !11'44!&'!,&+2 &5+')!

"(!.''C&'"'".5$"!5) 1'2,)!4 &+'!114 ,"'2/'(& H &+'8 < &!& (&14!('"2'(2"2'3'!4)&+!&&+'('2&

'"(15 &+'2"'2 'C,2' 0% A!) 2'('

3'" .5 &+' '1!2&<'& .'

2' DD !)!4'&&'2A!)A2 &&'&,"

&2 ''2!49') 2!(+9 7!2+ 2&!6 7'('))!25!(& 3 'A

?%@

&+'2"'2"!&'"DE &+'12')'&(!)'9&+'!11'!4+!" & .'' 12'

'22'" A &+' )& 1,4!&'" 1'2 " !&+'2 &+' !11'!4+!".''12'

'22'"!

&'2&+''C1 25 D "!5) &+' 1!)) 7 &+'2"'2.5&+'(&244 7!,&+2 &5+'!11'44!&' !,&+2 &5 +!" &+,) 2 7+&45 "

))'" &+' !11'!4

4'" .5 &+' 1'& '2.'

7& <'.!22'"K ?E@ &+' 4 7+& &+' 1) !) &'" !.3'9 !11'!4 !7!

)& "'( &+' &5(,4"+!3'.''

4'"A <!C <,< 1'2 "!5)!".'5")!

& <'9&+'11'44!&',&+2 +!)1A'2&("'&+'"'4!5"< &&'"459!11'!4A!)

4'"%E"!5) &'2 2'('

1& 2"'2 &+' (&244 7 !,&+2 &59 &+'2'

2'9 &+' !11'44!&' !,&+2 &52 7+&45"

))'"&+'!11'!4

4'".5&+'1'& '2!((,& &+')!<'.'

7& <'.!22'"8'!2'"(,)'4 2&+'1'& '2+!)&.'' !.4' & "

)& 7, )+ &+' "'( &+ ,2& 1..$ /.

$ &+'2 1 & +!) .'' !27,'" &+' ( 2(,<)&!(')9 &+'

<1,7'"2"'2"')&A!22!& &'2 '2'(''),4&!&459&+'A2 &1'&

))'" 4 < ' /#!4 ! ,"7'

!< & #+'&+'2)1'!6 7 2'!)'"* ')

#+'&+'22'12&!.4' * ')