High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3097/2017allowed

Kamaljit Kaur And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2018-07-25Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath9 pages

!" "#$%$&'

(

( ) ) ) ) * + ,-$!* ./ &0!1"/% "!$!$&"/% 2% ! !" .&- 3 &0!1"/% "%4&0"&!% 5'6 75 5'6 75 5'6 75 5'6 75**5 **5 **5 **5 /"%"&!' 5/* / &"1/ 809# !"8

/!1"4"!$!$&"/% 5/ 1$,1 /+ 8 8.&- 3 5/5 !!1809# !"8

//"%4&0"&! **58 **58 **58 **58 1$%4"!$!$&$% $,"03:!1"+!1"/8;$0;"0;$ " &0!1/"" +$&/#1$,0/"& 0"#" %"0 +7 , /%""<$&=#+4"&% !$& /!1"0" !1 +7 ,3"# .%" &"=,$="&#" !1"5.&$#$4 ,.&#$,8 &=/./ 1" 4"!$!$&"/% 1 9" 9"//"0 !1 ! & 8 !1" 0"#" %"0 ; %&1$%+!/#:#," &0&"./4/""!$&=1%> ,;$0&"/$&=18/"%$0"&! *$%1 &4./ %!$; % ,,;$&=1$+&1$%+!/#:#,";1$,"!1":;"/" /"!./&$&= /+ !1"$/ 0.!: 1": ;"/" ;/<$&= ;$!1 !1" &=/./ / 0"/% ?;$&"#&!/ #!/@!; % /.&0) 58;1"&!1":/" #1"0&" / 7 /<8 31 !"8 &=/./8+!/#:#," +7 ,8;1; %=$&= 1" 0 ./4/""!$&=181$! 1 , 4"&"0%";"/ =",$0?%.44/!"03:3/$#<%@ % %1;&$&!1"41!=/ 41 !! #1"0 %&&"A./"1"/"; %&$&0$# !$& /; /&$&= /.&0!1"% $0%";"/ ="+ &1," &03"# .%"$!; %&$=1!!$+"8

!1"0"#" %"0 + ,#.,0&! %#"/! $&$! /+ 0$%! &#"" ",,&!1" / 0 &0%.%! $&"0+.,!$4,"=/$"9.%$&-./$"%&1$%1" 0 &0!1"/4 /!% 1$%30: &03"# +".&#&%#$.%"; %! <"&!$9$,%4$! ,8 &=/./ ;1"/"1"; %0"#, /"03/.=1!0" 01"4%!+/!"+ !1"0"#" %"0; % #&0.#!"0 $& !1" $9$, %4$! ,8 &=/./ $& ;1$#1 !1" # .%" 0" !1 1 % 3""& %%$=&"0 0." ! %1#< &0 1 "+//1 =" % /"%.,! $&-./: 8 ;1$#1; % &!"+/!"+ &0%.

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

.&#$,8 &=/./8/"#/0"0!1"$/%! !"+"&!% 1$#1 /""&#,%"01"/";$!10.,:#"/!$ $"0 /+ !1" "&B.$/: $! 1 % 3""& .&0 !1 ! 44,$# &! ./$&0"/4 , * ./6% %& & +"0 +4 , %& &-$! $&=1 /"%$0"&! ,,$ & &0 ./4/""! $&=1 %& !1"

,;$&0"/ $&=1 /"%$0"&! *$%1 &4./

%!$8 &=/./8!1%";1;"/"0$&=!1"-3 ;$!1 !1" #&!/ #!/8 & ! /.&0 )' 58 /$0$&= & !1"$/ /"%4"#!$9" +!/ #:#,"%83!1;"/"=$&=!!1"$/1.%"% /+ !$ , !"8 &=/./ + , 39"% $0 ; % =$&= $& /&! ./4/""! $&=1 &0 ;1"&1"/" #1"0$& /&! 7 /<.! %$0" 31 !" &0!1"&0."!

$A$&= 3/$#<.&0"/!1"#9"/ !1"%";"/ =" &0 0." ! !1" ,"9", !1" #9"/ 1$=18 +!/ #:#," + , / ++"0 !1"/"$& 0." ! ;1$#1 + , ",, 0;& /+ 1$% +!/ #:#," &0 # .%"0 $&-./$"% ! 1$+ &0 !1" 4 %%"/%3:8 &0./4/""!$&=11 0 0+$!!"0 1$+ $& &=/./ / 0+$&$%!"/$&= !1" !/" !+"&!!1$+ & 8 /"#"$9"0 &" ;/$!!"& &!" ?.<< @ /+ 5 1$3 &=/./ !1 !

D 4 !$"&! /4 ,%& &-$!$&=1/"%$0"&! ,,$ &1 %3""& 0+$!!"0$& &=/./$& $&-./"0#&0$!$&8%"&!> /! <$&= #!$& 1"/".4&8 &=/"- $&=1 ,&=;$!1 - $3 $&=1 EEE8 /" #1$&= $& &=/./ / ! <$&= #!$&8 /"#/0"0 !1" %! !"+"&! 4 !$"&! ./4/""! $&=1 %&

,;$&0"/ $&=1 /"%$0"&! *$%1 &4./

%!$8 &=/./;1$#1; % !!"%!"03: &=/"-$&=1/+!1" 39"% $0%! !"+"&!8

.&0 !1" ##.//"&#" 0" !1 + , %& &-$!$&=1 ,,$ 0."!/ ++$&= !1" +!/ #:#," $& #9"/ !1" %";"/ =" ;1$#1 $%

.&0 ##.//"&#" & !./ ,,: "= /0$&= ;1$#1 !< #!$& >% D 1"41!#4: !1" 4 ! 0 !"0 ) F& +#1 ,$#" ! !$& $!: &=/./$% !! #1"01"/";$!1 1"0" !1 + ,1 0##.//"0$&#$9$, 1%4$! ,& 1" ##$0"&!!<4, #" 0."!4, #$&= !1"3/$#<.&0"/!1"#9"/ !1"%";"/ ="&!1"/ 083"$&=!1","9", !1" #9"/ 1$=18 0." ! / ++$&= !1" +!/ #:#," !1"/"$& /"= /0$&= ;1$#1 !< #!$&

( >% D & !1" %! !"+"&! ./4/""!$&=1 "= /0$&= !1$% + !!"/8 ,% -$&"0 !1" &$! /:&%4"#!/ %9$/$&=1 5.&$#$4 , .&#$, &=/./ $& !1" "&B.$/: 1 /"9" ,"0 !1 ! /"= /0$&= !1$% + !!"/8 ,"= , &!$#" 1 0 3""& /"#"$9"0 $& !1" 5.&$#$4 , .&#$, &=/./ /+!1"09# !"# /"

"4.!: ++$%%$&"/ 1$38 &=/./ /"4,: ;1$#1 1 % ,/" 0: 3""& =$9"& 3: 5.&$#$4 , .&#$,8 &=/./ 7"= , !$#" &0 41! #4$"% !1" /"4,: /" !! #1"0 1"/";$!1 ! $% <&;& /+ !1" 7"= , !$#" !1 ! !1" 44,$# &!1$&0"/ ,* ./ 39"% $01 %!

$," !1" #, $+ # %" +.&!$&= ! %.+ .4""% ( , # = $&%! 5.&$#$4 , .&#$, &=/./1": /" 44$&!$&=!1"#.&%", / ! <$&=!1"$/,"= , #!$& #!$&#+"%! 3" ! <"& & !1$% 44,$# !$& 3: !1" ,# , 4,$#" /0"/ + : 3" 4 %%"0 / $,$&= !1$% 44,$# !$&G

E 1"% $0"&B.$/:/"4/!; %#&%$0"/"03:!1" 8 &=/./8 ;14 %%"0 &/0"/&$!8;1$#1/" 0 %.&0"/' ( >

E $/8 ! #&0.#!"0 !1" "&B.$/: !1/.=1 $!: &=/./ ! 1 % 3""& .&0

/+!1""&B.$/:!1 ! #!$&1 % ,/" 0:3""& ! <"&4/"9$.%,:.>% D/"= /0$&=!1" ##.//"&#" 0" !1 + , 1" 44,$# &! 1 % ! $," !1" #, $+ # %" +.&!$&= ! .4""% ( , # = $&%! 5.&$#$4 ,.&#$,8 &=/./ &0,"= ,&!$#" 1 %3""&=$9"&!!1"#&#"/&"00"4 /!+"&! $&!1$%/"= /01"/"$%& #!$&!3"! <"& 3: !1" ,# ,4,$#" "&#" !1"/"$%& &""0

/! <$&= #!$& !!1$% 44,$# !$& 0>

:.40! ,$#"8

$%!/$#! &=/./ 5 7 0> /.40! ,$#" &=/./

( C 7" /&"0#.&%", /!1"4"!$!$&"/%1 %%.3+$!!"0!1 !!1"0" !1 + ,1 %##.//"03"# .%" !1", 4%">&"=,$="&#"&!1"4 /! !1"

5.&$#$4 , .&#$,8 &=/./ % !1" ,$0 !1" + &1," !1" %";"/ ="8 ,# !"0&!1"+ $&/ 08; %<"4!1 , 4"&"03:4, #$&=3/$#<%.&0"/$! &0;$!1.!=$9$&= &:; /&$&=>$&0$# !$& !1"% +"1"0"#" %"0#.,0 &!%""!1"1 , 4"&"0+ &1," /+ /" %& 3,"0$%! &#"3"# .%"$!; % &$=1!!$+"8!1"/"

/"81"1$!!1"% +"8 ",,&!1"/ 08%.

"/"01" 0$&-./$"% &0.,!$+ !",:"A4$/"0!$% ,%%.3+$!!"0!1 !1"; %="!!$&= +&!1,: % , /:

( > /+1$%"+4,:"/$" &=/.// 0"/%"1 % 44"&0"0 #"/!$ $# !"$&!1$%/"= /0;$!1!1$%4"!$!$& %&&"A./" 7" /&"0 #.&%", / !1" 4"!$!$&"/% 1 % %.3+$!!"0 !1 ! !1" 4"!$!$&"/% /"!1",0+!1"/8;$0;"0;$ " &0!1/""+$&/#1$,0/"&8;1 1 9",%!!1"$/3/" 0;$&&"/$&!1$% ##$0"&! &01 9"#, $+"0#+4"&% !$& !!1"!.&" ( , <1 "4 / !"/"4,$"%1 9"3""& $,"03:!1"/"%4&0"&!% &!1"/"4,: $,"03:/"%4&0"&!E$" 8.3 $9$%$&8 &=/./8 1" 1 % /"

"//"0 ! !1" 4/#""0$&=% +"&!$&"0 1"/"$& 39" &0 !"%!$ $"0!1 !!1"+!/#:#," !1"0"#" %"0 + ,1$!!1"1 , 4"&"0,$0 !1"+ &1,",# !"0&!1"+ $&/ 0"%4&0"&!%8HD1 9" 9"//"0$&!1"$//"4,:!1 ! + ,1 %0$"03"# .%" 1$%;&&"=,$="&#" 3"# .%" 1" ; % 0/.&< ! !1 ! !$+" "%4&0"&! $" !1" 5.&$#$4 , .&#$,8 &=/./1 % 9"//"0$&$!%/"4,:!1 !!1";/$!4"!$!$&1 %3""& $,"0

!"/ ,&=0", : :" /% /+!1"0 !" ##$0"&!!$% ,% ,,"="0!1 ! ;1"&"9"/ !1" %";"/ =" $% =! #," &"0 3: !1" 5.&$#$4 , .&#$,8 ,, 4/"# .!$&% /" ! <"& !1 ! !1" + &1," ,$0% /" 4/4"/,: 4, #"0 ! ; % 0"&$"0!1 !!1"%";"/ =",$0; %<"4!1 , 4"& &0!1 !!1"/"; %&%!/""! ,$=1!8!1"/"

/"8!1" .,!,$"%;$!1!1"0"#" %"08;10$0&!! <"# /"

) &/"4,:8," /&"0#.&%", /!1"4"!$!$&"/%1 %%.3+$!!"0!1 ! !1"/"$%&"9$0"&#"!1 !!1"0"#" %"0; %.&0"/!1"$& ,."&#" ,#1, / !1"/8 !1"/" $% & ":";$!&"%% ./4/""! $&=18 ;1 ; % ,,;$&= !1" 0"#" %"0 ! !1" !$+" ##$0"&!8 ;1 1 0 # !"=/$# ,,: %! !"0 !1 ! !1" ##$0"&! 1 0 ##.//"0 3"# .%" !1" ,$0 !1" + &1," !1" %";"/ ="8 ,# !"0&!1"+ $&/ 08; %<"4!1 , 4"&3:4, #$&=3/$#<%.&0"/$!3: !1" 4"/%&8 ;1 1 0 #," &"0 $! / ; % ! #," & !1" % +"8 / 1$% ;& #&9"&$"&#"1"% +"$%!1"/"4/! !1"4,$#"8;11 0+ 0" &"&B.$/: !!1"%4! 7" /&"0#.&%", /!1"4"!$!$&"/%1 %/",$"0.4& $9$%$&

"&#10"#$%$& *"/ , $=1./!/"&0"/"0$&!1"# %" C5 / << / &0 5 / << / &0 5 / << / &0 5 / << / &0 &!1"/ &!1"/ &!1"/ &!1"/2%! !" *"/ , G ! !" *"/ , G ! !" *"/ , G ! !" *"/ , G ?

@?$9$,@ ( &0 0"#$%$& !1$%./!/"&0"/"0$& ( ( ( (!$!,"0 %C.%1+ &$ C.%1+ &$ C.%1+ &$ C.%1+ &$2% ! !" .&- 3 &0!1"/%G ! !" .&- 3 &0!1"/%G ! !" .&- 3 &0!1"/%G ! !" .&- 3 &0!1"/%G0"#$0"0& D E 7" /&"0 #.&%", / !1" /"%4&0"&!% 1 % &! /"

"//"0 ! &: 4/"#"0"&!$&!1"$/ 9./ 1 9" 1" /0 ," /&"0 #.&%", / !1" 4 /!$"% &0 4"/.%"0 !1" 9 $, 3,"/"#/0;$!1!1"$/ 3," %%$%! &#" /+ !1" #!% & // !"0 1"/"$& 39"8 $! $% 44 /"&! !1 ! !1" 0"#" %"0 + ,%.

"/"0!1"$&-./$"%$&!1" ##$0"&!8$&!1"+ &&"/8%! !"0 3:!1"4"!$!$&"/% &0.,!$+ !",:%.##.+3"0!!1"$&-./$"%&B.$/:$&!1" % $0$&#$0"&#"; %#&0.#!"03:!1",$#"$++"0$ !",:!1"/" !"/8;1$#1 #.,0&!3"0$%3",$"9"01"4"!$!$&"/% /"!1",0+!1"/8;$0;"0;$ " &0!1/""+$&/#1$,0/"& 0"#" %"0 + ,&!1"# %" .%1+ &$ .%1+ &$ .%1+ &$ .%1+ &$ ?.4/ @ ?.4/ @ ?.4/ @ ?.4/ @8!1$%./!1 0 ; /0"0#+4"&% !$& , <1%3"# .%" !1"

0" !1 # .%"0 3: %!/ : 3.,, ;$!1$& !1" 5.&$#$4 , /" & !1" # %" 5 / << /?.4/ @ 5 / << /?.4/ @ 5 / << /?.4/ @ 5 / << /?.4/ @8#+4"&% !$&; % ; /0"03:!1"./!3"# .%" !1" 0" !1 !1"%#1,=$&=3:8;1 ",,$&! 4!1,"&!1"+ $&/ 0 1.%8 + !1$%#&%$0"/"04$&$&!1 !!1"4"!$!$&"/% ,% 0"%"/9"#+4"&% !$&$&!1$%# %"$&#"8!1"4"!$!$&"/%1 9" !! #1"0!1" % , /: #"/!$ $# !" !1" 0"#" %"0 + , % 4"/ ;1$#1 1" ; % " /&$&=

( > 4"/ +&!1 &0 ; % :" /% =" % %! !"08 !1"/"

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

(

( ) ) ) ) 1"!1"/%4" <$&=>/" %&"0 '

"%> 1"!1"/"4/! 3," '

"%>