Balbir Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS.
!"#$% &!'()*&'+"","#$ &-./+
0(1( .&! 12&-3+(
(45(
!"# $%&'(#
(' ")$%*+#
() * &-./+44(
*( *'&++--.+&6&,, 12&-, !+.&
77777
(' ")$ 41(1&' + 5 5&5 $ "#$ , *
(+&- & 5'&(4(&5(9(+-:!+(1;+5&;+( 4;!&:
6((/&5
+/&'!+4+4(;4( + 5 5&5 8#
"#$ <=1 >"? 4&((5 -: + &'& 66((< 1?, 12&-5(6((/+&44&!5&/&(+ 5 5&5 @ % "#$8 <=1 >$?, ;+-: + &44'& ! + 4;&(5(6((5-:+&6(66((
* &-./+4,;+(4(4(,(1-65 +&+65&&44'&+',A&5 '5(,;+,55 5&5
"5'5+(5& !!'+5&B1:&5 '!:+,!&:,;+&5'+4&44&-! +6 '64&' ;+ + &!65 5, + (5&
!!''51'5&B1:&5(1-65B1:45&5"
+!!'+&+(5!'':! /+&&5 (;&(!&5 &6!&5 &6./+ (&(65+B1:4 +&&5'64(5C+&(& $8""D@ ,$8"8&5$8" D@ 8-/ +'&44&5,+!,'&-&5-/&&'1 44:
;&(!1++5+&+5!'':+&6!&5;&( -'!5-:+ +&-&4&6 41(1&'+-(&(!+(5& !!', + 4 !5 & &44'& -! + .4'& .'&:,
+&-&4&6;+/&55!'':&6!&5 &5 51/ + 45': ! + &44'&, (4&'5 (( <64(&&5 +&-&?',$ % <!(+E$ % 'F?;&( 4&5+:&"##% +4&(!5&'(1(9/ 5'&&,;+'+;&(5'5=>4&5215/65&5 "##
//&5'+''554&6(45+'5+ 4B1&&6!&5 &6./+,.+&&5&./+ +-&((!+5'16(4&'5+!!+'(1;+&!1+ 5''!:+5('4&':,!5'5&(41( +&!,+ 44!5&&44'&-!+.4'&.'&:, 1> '16>&6(66((, 12&-15+ 12&- &'9&/& 4( <(4(&?656',"## <!(+E"## 'F?(&/+&+ &6'&(! &6./+'
(45/,-1&'+&(-&9 +&5+(&5&44'&;&(5(6((5555&5@ % "#$8, ;+'+ ;&( '+&/5 -! + &'& 66(( < 1?,
12&--:!/&&44&,;+'+&(6;++(&6!&
(1-65+&++5(4&((5-:+1(
, -;&&:/&,&-&:&5121( +1(-;+& &9'(5&+55&5
"4&((5-:+' A&5 '5(, 12&-,;+-:&5';&(((15+(5& !!'+5&B1:&5'!:+6(&9 +4'5/(; 45/4"## ' (144!+(',514+& 5'55'151 -./0 1230 405 -2-&0 2 70
.
)8989,,&5,+1(,1/5+(1! (/>&(5!+641/55(
'&,*( *'&++--.+&6&,41:5'& &, 12&-,4(/+.&+&((1-65+&+!'&65 -:+4(+4((:6-&5;! 1@ >!+ (4&'5 ((<64(&&5 +&-&? 1(,$ %%&(+ 4'15&44:!&6&+&8$ @8,;+&(+ 65+&44'&!&68
.++&(514+ 5'(55-:+('1
, 857:0-0;05 -2-&0 0:0 09)5'55"
"#$#,;+ +&(-+5+&+&44'&!&6'&-6&5&+& 8$ @8 .+!1+(1-65+&+!/!+&44'&&!& 45!8%:&(-!+&6(66((!&6!&5 ;&(6&914+5!'':;+1=4&/+(&6+& &6&5,+1(,1/5+(1!5(6((&!+;4
+&+&5+44(,&5.&'1(&5 !+;+&+(!'&5(1-(&'+(1-6(((!+ 4
( 4 + 4(( ! 1 @ > ! $ %% 1(, +
4'15&44:!&6!&548$ @8,;+&(+ !5+&44'&-!+&6(66((+:&$
, , &!8%:&( (&&5&:;&914!6(16-&5&(+ '&6&+(-&5(&/ +4+&(&(6&5!!( 5('(&-1++/&+(! 5(4&'54((,+1/+;&( &565+&+;+/&+( !+&6(-1&,+4+&(&(- &-4+&+(+:/&+!+(!&+.+&./+&5 1'( &6./+&5&./+&( (4+45&5 "#$"'5!6+(5&*&151/+4'5/(-! +&6(-1&, &6./+,&./+&5.+&./+; &5 (&5&5&'( G1(&5(4&&:&5+&-/&5 &''5/+&6 *//4(&;15;4 1+5&:&5&'+( *;((1445-:+&5'55 '151-:+H-.1461 %
( 700 7 .
- -2- 07:0) (& ;!+&!655('1((,+'&6!+ 4(6&&&--/-&5-:&;!6& (1&:, +;4(&5(5(6((5
0<.) 8
(' "9 03 -.
$%*+# .
.
-= 0> ;? 0-
-?
.
.
= 06
-?