← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1462/2014dismissed

Reliance General Insurance Company Ltd v. Amrik Singh Gill And ORS

2018-12-13Mr. Justice B.S. Walia10 pages



     

! !"

#  



 

 %$ )*  + (($$  ,%& '%-. /0$$ 0% +  (  

 

  '%-. /0$$  0% + (($$  ,%&

'1&% 0% +  (    

 ! " 

%  1% .&'  23%0(($$ 4 56! !"

57 %(   4 57  1%  $:&'%.(023%(($$ 4    57 %(    !4    56!!"

57  1%  ;

01$0%23% '( )4%(   9 57 4%(   6 56!!"

57   %%' /%(    <<<  " #  > 0 %% 0$$     56!  #89  !"

5  0)%%''' ?%!5 " !"

 

$ % =!>

56!!"

50A $A)0(($$ B  %$   '( ) - /  /  ?%  '( ?0$    #89  !"

5 0 A  $ A) 0 (($$ B$'  - / 0 ' 0'( ?%  => *% $%0(($$ B  %$ '( ) 0  /C& /$/ ? %%$)%%A) 0$% 1% $'%A& $2&%/ 40% %%%% D0%A& $E7 '&0%'03 0$)F? 

GF    &%' . /02  0  A  A$0 0 0   &%% &  /$/ %A&A$0  /%&- &% ?00(($$ B  %$ ) &%0%00

 $ '0!"2"""BF(%' 0? 0 0/0%  =5>

%  %2 $% $ % $'      5 00 /$/ 0%3%0  / %&-?$% 00%% & 03'30$ 03 /%'' 0%%0%&- & & (($  A%-A)0%3%0  /%&-  =9> *% $%0$'  #89 !"

5&%0% 00%3%0  /%&-A  %'0  %A  /0%&- $ (& ((% A%0$% %A& $ ? C& $)(%H (%2 A ? $%  (%$'  %   *% $   0   ((%  0   0 %&' 2 0 %3%  0   /%&- ( 0? FAHH($ 0'

%

$&% ?000 -($ ?0)0%&-0A (($$ &    0 '$  0 0/0?)   *% $   0 0 0/0?A)  &A0 /$/ 0 %3%0  /%&- *% $&%0% 00 $% %A& $0$/%$$)%% (%/%(0 0 ?% 0A3 00 -($%&$%0  /$/ %3 /0  /%&-A)%(   F%3% 00%?  /$/  0(%0%3%03'E30$  &%0%00A &$)($ (%3A)?)3 0 0  /%&-?A /%3 3%)(  %0

/$/ '

% 00%3%0  /%&-& $)(($ A%-%&$?00% ?000?%3 /%'' 0%&- 0$0&/0 &A?0&)0%3% 30$ $$? /  0% 30$  '      2 A&  0

0%A ($A)0%(  A%0$% %A& $ %0 3      3  A  $  3  &// 0 0 %3%  0 3'E30$ ?000?%3$$ /? '  /    %' 0 %&-   *% $ &%0%   0 0 %3%0%&-0 3 A0%( 0? AH%A& 00$' ?0% GF2&%'. /0?0?%3$$ /  0 3' 30$ ((   0 ?  AH  ( A& 0 '

% ?000 -($ &A 0%FH'  0&$ $$?0?0(0% ?000)?% %3$$ /A&0%A& $0$00' $? &  0$00%?' /$/  0(%0%3%0%$ 

$ % =6> 520(($$ B$' 03&/0  0 ' '(  0/%& 0 '& ??%  & &&%(%(IA2((%(%'( 0  A ?% &  3  $0  =8>  03  % 0 &A'   $% $ % 0 (% &A0' 03  GF2&%'. /00 0   A?  0   / 30$   0 3' 30$ ? ((%H'$) "      0   - / ($2 GF2 &%' . /0 $ 0  &     &A 0   %C&%  A '  A? ?30$ 0/0?) A 03A '     0    2 A& 0 ' ?&$  '( &(  0 '( A?%0$'  #89 !"

5 3?00? 0?0?%3 /0 3'30$?00? A /%3 A) 0%(% A)0 ' ' .0%'?0$ 0   =#> *% $%0(($$ F  %$ '( ) 03 0(  GF2&%'. /0

( 0& (($ A%-A)0%&- C&  =J>  (%&$  ' )  GF2 &%' . /0 %3$ 0 03 /0K03 A&0- /'%/ )A%-A) 0 %3%  0 %&-L     2 0 %'   '   GF &%'. /0A$00A%-?%& $)(($A)0%3% 0%&-A&00? ?%0'%/ )A%-&$A- A)0%3%%&- 0(0A % 0A-/%&  /&$  !50  /&$ 2 J#J?00%& % F

$% 



  

 

 

            (% 0 %'   /&$ 2  (%  %3 /  30$0$$(($)& A%-H(%)%  ?3%2 0A A320%3%0  /%&-  $)A   0%&-00 A&?$(%H(%A% 0 $%  %A& $     (   0 ?  AH  $  ) 3 H($ 0% %0& (($ A%-%0 '

% ?000 -($  ">   0 /2 $% $ % 0 (($$ F  %$   '( ) &%0%   0    0 A (A)0&%0  "A? ?30$ 0 0/0?) ?  C&  2 0%%2 ' /$/  ? %A&A$0%3%0  /30$2 C& $)20$A$) C&'( A(0$'  #89 !"

5A((% ' /0? ) 

> 

%  %2 $% $ % 0 %(  F    '( )   0 %$)2 0%   3   ?0(%  $$/  /$/ A)0%3%03'30$A)0(($$ F ) ?% ' A%0%A& $ %? ) 3  %(0%$A%0%A& $20%%2 ( 0(($$ F )%0($0/A%0 &% *% $&%0%%%%(%/%(0 #03 A)?)3 GF&%'. /0?00%& % F 

                    ! !

    "

   

$ %      "

!  !         !

"             #  "  !"   

     !

 $ ""     % 

  %  $& '



  (

 )    *+     !       

 " !

 +, -     00 &%%&0 /$/ %(    ?0?%3 /0  /30$ %0 /$/ '

% ?0&$$? /0%%&$ 00$?)%'0(% $3 /0%&-0%IA200A $%(%$' % A)0&% *% $&%0%%%%0%FH'  

GF&%'. /02%$3 H%?00%(%&& % F K   %%  &// 0 0   ? $$) %&$  %0 

/$/ %3 /' .0%'%3%%?0 & - ?

%&- ?0000%&-0% A-L 

 0 A  0 '2 $% $ % %(  F  ) 0? 3 &//

GF 0 0   0 -  ($   &    %A&%)

/$/ 20%%2? ( 0(($$ -&(0($  %A&%) /$/ A%0&%  !>   '% 0($$% $%0%(  F  )  3?0(  A32 0 ($ % ((% '   '(   A ( ' / 0 ? %;($$) 0%? $$/ 

/$/ A)0%3%03'E30$A)0(($$ F '( ) ?% ' A%0%A& $ %? )3  %( 0% $ A) 0 (($$ B  '( ) A% 0

$% %A& $ %?&//A)0(($$  GF&%'. /0 0 %FH'   0 0   0 -  ($   &    %A&%) /$/   >  0%&' 20($0(($$ F  %$  '( )  /$/ 03 / A (%3  '% (     %/% 0 ($ 0  $  '  0     !"2"""BF    0 0/0% 2    / 0 0  ?   $)  C&$  / % 03 / (  0  / % /&% $%  ''&  A&?$ / 1')

3%)2 (%%''- /A$% 0 0  $  '  0  0 A     0/0% %2 $% $%0(($$ B  %$ )0

A A$&A 0A%0($  5> 

% %2$% $%0$'     5 0  3?0A /0/0$) C&$2 0  '   !"2"""BF (% ' 0 ?   0 $?%   9>   03  % 0 &A'   $% $ % 0 (% '03?0 & 0A /C&$  / % 03 / (  0   $%    ''&  2 A2 A /  &   12 0  $  '  0  !"2"""BF(%' 0 ?%%  ) %%   6>     #89  !"

52  %/% 0 $' % &&% (%(   /0(%(%/%(0 6 4370  EA$0.&(%'&% '()*'+ *,-.'*/0!12'*3)1)(045 6.'*'3 0(7)'*4(70.,#

 !!)5)+

8#?0%0

$% ?$F'($) ?$0 5")%/25"M0A$0 '  0  ' & H '(     A  C& &&% (%(?0$'(& /0'(   0      ? !! )%  /   0

 $ '?!"2"""BF(%' 0 % /$)25"M 0 A$0  '  0  ' & 0 H '(     A  & &&%(%(?0$'(& /0'(  8>     #89  !"

5  %/% ($ % ?%  ((%(% '(  & %  3  $ 02  !92"""BF ? ?%   &   & %$ H(  ?0%  (% %/%(0  6 4370  % ).0E4.&(%72&'  92"""BF  $)()A$ & & %$H(  $-'&  &   $     ?3%2    &AC&    A)  EA$ 0 .&(%' &%  '91' :0*0.'+ *,-.'*/0 ! (4 ;, '*- '1 +)', !7-7.- '1 '*4 (70., 40/)404 *  8

 )* !)5)+ 220'+ 8

#?0$- / %$%  % ).0E 2  EA$ 0 .&(%' &% 0$ 0 (%       %  $$$$ %&'  % /$)2 (%   0  % 0$  $  '( 5"2"""BF0 & $$$ %&'  #>   0 $/0  0 (    A32   56!  !"

5$A)0  %$ )*'' ?0$ 5$A)0$' $$? 0$' %0$ $0$$? /'(

F 0'4, 1-*( ',,0,,04 <3 (70.)<-*'+ 1-*(',,0,,04<3(70 !-.(

' !"2"""BF !"2"""B

. 

$8% ! 

&&% %( * 5"M!"2"""BFN #2"""BF $ '  !"2"""BF 4!"2"""BFO#"""BF7N !#2"""BF 5  (  ) 4

&$7 !"2"""BFH !N !25"2"""BF 4!#2"""BFH !7N 262"""BF 9  ' H  * !

2#6BF * 262"""BFF!

#6BF N2 65BF 6  $ '&   % ' H & 8  1&$($%(($

#

# #  & 4?%(% $ H(   7 9"M!25"2"""BFN  2!"2"""BF 9"M2 65BFN  2982"#!BF J  '( ?%  2!"2"""BFH #N !

26"2"""BF  2982"#!BFH #N !#2!82586BF

"  * 

$$  %&' * #"2"""BF 4P5"2"""BF00 (% 07 J  * *   92"""BF 

" 

& %$H(  !92"""   92"""BF 

% 8 9M (%

&' 8 9M (%

&'   ##

=>  8#&#  => J>  % /$)2  /  '(    !

2#92"""BF ?%A)0%A& $20(($$ F$'  5 % 0$  $  '(    !J282586BF $ / ?0  % P 8 9M  (% 

&' ?0  %' 0   $' (  $$   ()' 2 $ ()' 2   )2 ' %$%   $  '   0  '( ) 0$$ & H $A$) C& &&% (%( A%

$ %  '- /()' '(  %'0  % ).0E   =!">  % /$)2    56!  !"

5 $ A) 0  %$   '( ) *'  '     #89  !"

5$A)0$' $$?A)') /?% !5 " !"

(A)0$% %A& $2&%/ 0H   A3  4 . G$7 &/

! !"

# '

G00%(- /B% 

B  !  G00%%(%A$

B