← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/28497/2018allowed

Nanti Devi & ANR v. State Of Haryana& ORS

2023-08-11Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil10 pages

       



  

 



  

! "

 # !## #   

# # #  $ % & $ # #  $ &  



          



 

   ! "

# $ %%%%% #  $ &'

 ( &) & (  +  "",-"".

)(

( 

0 (  1( 

&& 23 "2&.

45( 6,7 0*

 8 

(

  

*

"

 )(  * 9

 8





 (

* * 

 ( )

 ( 4:(8 //7 0 (*  ! &

  ! "

$ 

( 5 ( (

 

(

(

&;<<



 = ( 6 ! "

( 

 (

 6 "& 2< &;;&



  0 8 

&$ &2 &;;3  



8

 ( ! $



 &2 (

 (  &;3.

4  

> &;3.?

( '*( 6 (869 *( )(  +

8 

 

&; 2< "22;

 

) @  ! &<$"

"2&& 0 

8 2< 2A "2&$ (



*( )( 0*

 8 

0 "A +  8



8

 

( (    8 "3 2< &;;, $& 2. "223

'0

 



 * 

 

(     0( 

 

 ( (

(  

  * ( '*( 6(869 *(    $& 2. "223



(( 





(  

)@ ! &<$"

"2&&

8 2< 2A "2&$

, 9 ! <$3 "2&< 

  

2< 2A "2&$  ) @  0



 8 

8 &; 2A "2&3 ( 

&; 2< "22;

    *( 8

( 

   8( (*1(

  6

 

)( 8(

 )@ ! "22&26"2&$ +

  *

 && 2; "2&$

 

   + 

 

9 ! <$3 "2&<

 0 8



  )@ ! &";.

"2&3



 2; 2. "2&3

 +



  8 

 *(  



+

.

 )@ ! "3.22 "2&3 

8 2$ &" "2&3 45( 637 *

  

&3 2< "22;

 8 (

 

 )@ ! &.$.2 "2&A  +  (

*( 8  

2& &" "2&, 45( 6A7



  (



(   *

0

+ ( 8

8 

8

( * 

0  , 

(8 0 ( 8 8



   2& &" "2&, < /

   8



  8 

)D) ! ;$3 "2&.

(  

8 ! $ 

&& 23 "2&.

45( 6,7 (*8 (

   8  





0  8 

8

0 

"& 2A "2&< 45( 6.7 *



 8  ( 

(* ;

/ (

 1( 

8( (   (

     * 

&& 23 "2&.



   8   *  1( 

 

 *

(

&2 ' (   8   (   ( ( 8    

     

   

 0 

 ( ( 

     !

"#$ %&''

()* +, )

( 8   -    !

.!!

$ /0$  1   !

%&& 

  '%&&  *(  0 (

, < &;;$  *(

   ' 

8 0 8 (    8 8 (  

8*  



' E  8 * (  8 0

8

8(  (  0  (*    

  8 *  0  F(

8(



8



8   8

0   (

 / 



8(

0   (66

0 0 8 8

 6 8 

  8

*8

( 0 0 8  

&& 



      8  *  

 ( $2 >

 = (

0  4=8  ( 7 &;;2?

( 



 (



 ( )

 (

 (  ( &"

(  ( A ".

( )

 ( 4:(8 "

 /:7

 0

(

 &2 2$ "2&"

0(   0    $& 2. "223 &2 2$ "2&"

8

0    && 2$ "2&"

 8



8 &;A3  (

0  

2& &" "2&, 45( 6A7 )@ ! &.$.2 "2&A &$

 8 

 

   ! "

# $  0  

 ( 

"A 2A &;;$  ( 5   8 ( )*(

 F( 4)F7 ( (  88  &"-".-= 4F7- ;&-6&  ", 2, &;;"

5( 6&7

*(   0

(   8 8



 &3

( 8

8 *(

(



 2< 2< &;;A

   8



 ( &A



  +

8 0     ((( 0 + ( 

.

 0 8 

(

 

 = (

  

6 



       

 



   ! "

 #  $ "  #% " & '



"

 ""!  #  ("

 %   !

 

  # ) &,

  (   &.

  5 8 

  (*8

    

8  (8   8 

2& &" "2&, 45( 6A7 (

   8

0  ,  



 )@ ! &.$.2 "2&A  ( (  0



(   4  

7 (

  8

 ( *(

( 2< 2< &;;A

( 

(





(*  ! & 1( 8 &< ' (G  8 - 8

+

  

 (  +

 ( $ ",   ( A ". A $2 ( )

 ( 4:(8 6&  6&7 (  H,

2 (*3

* "

%"

$

 "  "

  $ +$

  "  

"$

  

  "   



% !  "

 # 

# " ,

"

 !  

"$  #   # " ,

"

 !  

"$   #  

"  

    " "

%  " 

  

 

! " %

" ! 

% # $   #  

"   

!"

  - .$ !  /""

+$

  " ! " "

$    +$

  %"   ! "

 "  

 "  

"$

  

  "   

 #



 #  #   # " "

"

 "

 !) ,

)3 " 



"

"

#  +$

   1 !

   

 # . ( 2  0

  " (" 3 



"



 +$

  % "

1   

 #   "

% !   ,

)2 3 * +$

 4"

" " ! 5



%

"



 #  #  " 



 !       "

 "$) &;

' 1( ( *

E*

(8



44 1 & 2 !

 &

  -5 /6 "

 8 

  0  $ 

 2   & 0 

 (

2, 2< &;;$

0

8 ( 2; 2< &;;3 ( 

0



 *

   

(

E*

(8

 (

(  (

*(    6(*8   

(



*



  

 

 (

(8 0 0 ( 1( 0 *(   

 

E*

(8

     *



 8(

*    ", ( 8

6 

$%   % "

"

!



 #

 !  ""

% "

 "

!"$  

"  



   +$

% ! ! ! "5 % , 

"

"  % !   " !    

 "

 

"  ! "

   "

 %

 

 "

$ 

 

 "% #   " "

 6772  76778 %  #



% # !

 "

 

 !"   

"

  

% !    "

 

%# !   "

 !

 

 ") "2

8

 

 ( ( $& 2. "223

   6  &;<<

8 )F 2< 2< &;;A



! "

    



  8 (  (

(  

(  *

 (

 8



( *(

(

  >   

   

$  1  !

     & )9 "&      5   8

", 2" &;;"

 *(

5 ( 0 1   88  !

: 8 ; $ -

 ," $

:, %&)&  %& 0     F(

8  

 

 8 ( *     =    

  





*   (    8

* *  ( ( *

(  ""







5 ( - 15 

  < !

: $

:, %&'2  %2 0 

* 



( 8  (  8 8 ( 5      (

8  (  

 ( ( 0(



 

 &3 &;

"& )(

  8 8 (*8  8

 

"$

F( ( $2 

 = ( 

4=8 

7 (  &;;2

 1(

  ( *06 2

"

 %

"



$"

"

!



" # "



 #

 !

 9  "

  

 -!

/$ .$"

("

"

  

   "  "

"

   !

 +$

 "!- " 

"

 ") "3 /  

 ( 

0

(*   (  &;;2 

 = ( 

 (   ( )

 (

8 8 8 8

8 



"

 "



0 ' (

8

(8  *     

 

* ( 8

0   $& 2. "223 &2 2$ "2&"

8

 8 &;,3 0    && 2$ "2&"

0

"A

 (



( 8

(  *

 

*



8    

*(

* 0 0

 ( 8 /

(

(

 0 (



( (   8

>- 5     !

  .$

:, %&%  % &9

(8 ", 

 (

* 

(  /

( 1( 

8(   



 

*8 

( 

 *(   0 8   * ( *(

( ( 

(



0

(8  !

"#  :=# $

:, %&  $

(*1(

  (  !

   .   8#$

:, %&')  2) 

0 * 6 : "

 # 

 # 

! ! "! !

 +$

"

 "

  ! $ ! $! #"



 

  "

 

 ! 

"  "!" 

" ! $" % 

 

  "   

5   

 :

".

'(

 

 

 )( 4F

F( 8 87  &;.<   



(

8   &;4&747 )( '  8

8 8 

  

 (

8 

(   $226

8   

  



(

"< '

   

( (

9

 0   8( (  

 ( 5  *

";



*

(



 (  *  ( 

  0    $& 2. "2&3 &2 2$ "2&"

8

0    && 2$ "2&"

0

0  ;B  

(8  ( *(

(   

(





2< 2< &;;A $2 

0

 8 (#  $ &)

 

  ;  < "

5 #="  >"=3 < ! >"=3