Peoples Cause & ANR v. State Of Haryana And ORS
! " !
!"# $%&'
( ') * + ,' ' -'! . /'0 +,' 1 + 12 /3456178.9:6...21 /3456178.9:62-66./7/:%2 '
'.;.4+#2+&# ' $ ' + & ' ' '..
!#2%/'0 <<<< ...' #7 '..
!# '
+ !02+&% ' #/'0 # ,!=(+!' '=0>0
+& '-&?7,#:2.# (( '#2(= & #2(= 9,' '? ''+ /'+ '
+!
', ' 9, ' ,= +=0, '!
+'
2'
@A
, ! :
+ '+' ),' + '(&, ',( '(,B!'+ +(!' )? C (' B0'+#+ + ,,+ , 2'+ ) , '# , + + ) ! &'! ' #>,'' ), +' , ' '
> '
&,>?#2(= > ,,),>0 '( 2(= /'
2 !',' '0',= (+=0, ' '+' ) !'( '+ &) , ) +'')! ' , ( )( , '+ +#+ , 0( (
&+>'+ DD, +> ' 'B! ,+ +=0,/'0 8'= & ( 2!,'03/823$ ','#, ) ! !2 !','+' ,= !), '
'&' ),,') '(, ) ! , + B! # '
,! +! , ',+ + 9, ' $.,.;.4+#2+&#+# , & ' 3 !3# ' #>,,+ $%&'
( ') * % ' !=(,, >' , )' ,0 2(= #2(= 0 +,!''!
+ ) '/, +, , !' != ' ) '
, = != 2(= .+' + ' , '(& , ',( '(,3E+3'#2(= #4 +&)'
( #2(= 0#=+#, ) ,.!=$1)''#2(= +,. /'0 ' ) ), ++')'+=0 .!=$1)''#2(= 2 ,' #+#> + '
'(& , ',( '(,4=0 1+#2(= 9, '#+#,& ' ' ,!=F(' , ' >' :,= +, '= ) + ,!'=0 &'!% ( ),( &= ) != ':# ,>&'# ( +>,,',%, ), ,=
!,'*+ !, + #=0>,(G=+#>,' ((=' + >,,',, '0 !
+ !,
/ 3= ,.! '(!' 4,'0/( ,0 )& .!+ !
/( ,0#
D .CC # +'+, >,' ,+= +=0,.!+ 3!
/( ,0# + )# 7 !' 9, 1F, 8 &'0 !'!
'
(+=0, )2 >' ,+ '4/.+)'!'=0 '++
C)' + '&
'4/.+)'!', ) 2 >' ' ,
$ C ' ' ' ' 4/. E(
C# + 4/. E(
# ,'+ 4/. E(
@ + !',4/.E(
!=F,
!
( , + ++> , '9,!+ , )>,>'+(+ , '0'4/.!' ,0'
$ C# ,!# =( + ' , E( , 1F, 8 &'0 + ),+)'4/. .!=B! 0#
@C
#,1F, 8 &'0)' + '&
, )2 >' ',+(
C$
( '
'( + =0 ' ++ C
@# ) )' + '&
,+ ) ',+(
$ @ 9,
#,>&'#++ &',!+ , )>, ,+? +( ''
$ C ,+ ) +>,>' 'B!'+ ' +
' 0' 4/.E(
$ +,' '/>&'# &> , '&
)' +, )=0,8 &'0 1F, 7 !'0
C#,. 1F, !+ '+'++ @
C +' ) , 1F,
4'+ /( ,+ +!4/.E( 9,'+'>, )+ >' += ',/),!'
# 1F, 9,-$, ' ,1F, 8 &'0? )
&>,!
' ! >,,,!+ >' + !
,1F, /( ,+ 4'+ = ) +!,4/.+)'E( + '+'++
>,,>!=F(' , ) ,+9,'+'>,
,,E( ::#::: + 0'4/.!+ +(+ ,/( , )#4,' !' +/( , )# 2 >'= +!+=0,8 &'0#>,!)' )
', E( # ',E )0 =! ,8 &'0 ''=+ '
,E( '+'&+,'+, ,!+ + ? ) &>, ,,1F, /( ,04'+>,,> +! ),E( ',> ),+, = ' +'+ )= ' +! ) , E( + >'+ ) +)' 9, '(( + ,4'+ :
+-$, ''+'
++
>'' +=0,.0 + ( ), +
A
9, .!+ 3 !
, /( , ) + != ' ) , ) ) , '+' , -$, '
'( ),!+ ::#::: + 0'4/. , ) ',E( = ) +!+=0, &'0 1F, 9, >+(+=0 '
+. ) 7!+) ,1F, /),!', + ),,.!+ 3!
, 7 !' ),+
!= ' ) :
#,>&'#& 4 , ,/),!'+,'+'
,-$, ' +! , +, ,.!+ 3!
, 7 !' ) !,
9,.! '(!' ,= ,
+& +=0, .!+ 3!
+ )! + ! +,++ + >,,',!
>!,'*+ ,+ ) # +
#=0>,(G>,,',+, !
+ +! ) ,+ ) + >,,' ,+ , =? ) (F'0 ((=' ',+ ) 9,' '# % ) , !' != ' = ,> ! + ! G = + >,,',= !,'*+ !, ) # + #=0 >,(G>,,',, !
+ +! ) !, ) +C >,,',,=? ) (F'0 ((=' '!, ) 2& 4 , ,!' 2F=. ), + ,'& ,. !
F= +,'# $C51@# , E , = 0 != :
'5) 1! # 31! 3$ ','#
'(+ =0 , !'# B! , + / 3= , .! '(!' . 8' , &4 > . ),,!
+,'# 2:1 .
# + , , ,' >,, ++ = ( ,*+ > , , ' , 0 + , '+ +,+'' +' ' (&' ' & &+
,# 0#=0>0
+&9,E ' 0+ ,'+ "#>+#(!# !' 0#( 0,,, ', >,,+ ', & )#>, != ',,= ! )#, >'?+ =0,( ,=, #, '! ' 0(' ' ''+=0 ,(:5' ' >,,,!',+ +'+'#:! + ( 0(' 0>' ) , ' '+ ) ,.# != $ '+ +>,!# ):5
$ 9,1)'0 ,!'>+'+,(! !'' ( >,,+1! +>! +'!'
+:5>, =F !
, '(' '&++ ' , 1! >' +$ +:
#>+,,'>( +
,1)'0 ' ! ,+1! &' 0, + , ' #.'2 >, &?,F!'+ ,! != ' +# ,0' +>,, + #'!'
, 9, >'( ,*+=!> !
+,, !'> !
++>,:5>,,'! 0>' :5 , , > &)+9,0>',' ' )#( '+ )
> ' +
E ) 0 , > ' +(? )!=0 (? )) ' ) >,! 0'',=!,!=F' '
>,' 0,+ E ' 'E !'=!,!=F('!), ='+9,#>+#>' != 0 ' ) ','
, :5 +> ),F!+ ( 9, ' >,,,= + , !' != ' ) =0, '3 !3 + ,'# ,' '# = ,>! + ! G>,,',=
!,'*+ !, ) # + #=0>,(G>,,',,
!
+ +! ) !, ) +>,,',,=? ) (F'0 ((=' '!, ) 4+#, '' = ,> >, != ' , 3 !3 , =
! )#,>'?+ =0 ,=, #, '! ' 0('
' ''+=0:5' ' >,,,!',+ +'+'# 2 '# ):5# = !=(, ' ) +,,+= +=0''0 )!'',
=!,!=F'!,>= ) !+ 9, ',&(' 0+,,0,& ' ' ,!=F(' ,>' 4+# ' ,!
( (', 1 ?, '( , + ( E + 0 '&'# +! ) , != ' ) ''(& ',( '(,E+' 2(= #,'+ ,!''!
+ )' ',+ '
') ), ',( '(&+ '(,''2+' # +#,+= !+ , +31 F %0 &.
/'0 3# @@C #+++ D# ''(& ), ',( 9,> >+=0,+ 3!' >
( &. !
F= + ,'3#CDD@ #+++
C D#=!,/82!,'#>,>' '(! , +'
, +( + , , >' ' ,+ >' #!' > ( &. !
F= + ,'
CDD@ 9, '# ,' '# ,& &+ 0 0 ,> , E ,1! #,F!+)( / 3= ,.! '( !' + ,!'# '$' ''+#,,0,&,
!, 4,(0#, ' ' '(& , ',( '(,2(= $/',),>02 0 ,
>)& , '
+ !02+&% ' #/'0 # = ,(? '! ,(' 9, ',( ' +(!' )? C(' &,>?2(= 0>,, +B!'+=0,/82
% :
,'+'++ @ #>!=(+=0, '
+ 2++ 2+&% ' #/'0 #,( )>, +!
+', ,'( , .,'.!'F. ),#2+( ''#/82 :
,+( )#>+++,F ' = ' '+=0, 6
'A.! ' + ) 6 ) ' ?A6E!& 6 ) 'A' 9>
'#2(= =!=(+/82# ,?! # ' '& :> +,#'+ ),( )#,'>' , A((' = ,( +
' +=0+
' ' 9,+ ,(>' +=0? )(!'( ,=0,
,
'9>
'#2(= G 5 +2B!
'# ,?! G6E!&6 ) '#/82& # 2(= G6
'#/82#2(= +,'& !
2?, ,(>) ' '+ '(,',>,,)&,+ , ' '>,, ( > 'A! '#?,' !(='# ' +,2(= !
' ' 2 !(='9, + & &+ ,>' >( +' + H
'E( 0 *)*)(
',>+, , ' '0&' ', #( + > $ 33 9, + B! '+ '(,B!'+ =!
+'0 /82 + =0 E ) '+ (+ 1 )','+ +,!
+ 0>0 >,,/82 +
9,+ + ,, *)*)' !
2(= $/''+ E &,>? +,? 0 '!+=0,((' = ,( 9,!#,
) ,=&+ + =
'&'#, ,& + '(? ) ,+( ' 0 = 4!#, 2>'+ , '! , = (+0 .# , , + ) >, , '!
=? '(,! ' '( , &> :#,' '# ' +,, B!
! + =
'+ , +&+! ! ' '
&' ,''+')'+ )! , ' E+=0,!,' :
,! '+ )& , '#, , , '! ' + ! +=? &' .!=( '+0(+=0,6
'# /82#2(= ' +"
9,=&' '>) +=0,'9>
'# 2(= G 6E!& 6 ) '# /82 & # 2(= + , 6
'#/82#2(= 2!' '=0>0
+& .,'-&?7,#:2.# (( '#2(= & #2(= #,= + !'+0# >,,,= ? ''+2')'+, ' > '
+
'(/'#>,, ), B! #>,',, '+ ,&= '!+#+ '$ > $ & '(( )* +',
-.+,/0 '1-2,'3*4-.4-2,)/5 +4(2-+(-/67(2+-/3*4('(+4(2482,'(2+,+(0+4,9( :((/./2+'7.+(0
9, , 6E!& 6 ) '# + '( &+, 'C $ D++ +(( . ++ #,!=(+,,' ' ' ! * + B! >, , & #,'!
+ & = '
>+ ) ,'+/ # !',' +'B!'+
'>+ ) ,',2 ' ,' ,'
'F '! * , +'&'#,/$@
/
, = ' ''+ / '!
& #414'# ,?! &+%&'
( ' '+' CA $ 416 ++ 1)'+ ), ,'+ !',''' + ++(0 =(+>,6E!&6 ) '# '! & /),>0##41 4' ,?! : , = !',' !=(+ =0 , 6E!& 6 ) ' , > =0 , =
'!+
, /),>0
2(= , +)', + /),>0 ,$2('' >, /),>0 @ '
& )4 9,'
( ) '(;, +> ='( +,'!),,=0 > '
'( , +)', +!
F=+>'+/'+> = +,'!),,=0 9, 0 '
> = ' , ', '(; ?,>?
&,>?'&'#,' ' 1 ) '+'!
+ 2(= 0 +2(= #+!
>,,( '
> =+&'+ , ' + 1 )'+ I!',' , 6E!& 6 ) '# 41# '! & / &+ , ' ++ ,
'(+,,>'? ( '&( '
/$@ >/$
2(= /'1+ '(;( 2(= '2(= 0 ' =0 >+ ) +' ), )=0 '&+ )4 4!( !+!( +44!( ! ' '&+=019/&+ '1A/A CA
A A/1A/$ ++ 9, ', ' 0 ' ''+ , & '( '& & 41#2(= I',>'? I!'
)#,& = 1 C'# ', ( +, +>+,!
# E' + 'B!'+ ' , ( ' '&+ ( '&'#, '! =0 /$@
')' :
&> , =& ' ' 6E!& ) '##'& & #2(= + '! & /# ,?! #,' + ! *, + B! '>+ ) ,'+ / #!=(+,+=&=0, 6E!& 6 ) '# '& & # 2(= + '! & /# ,?! ,
' > '
> = ='!+ !!'#
=! , '& =0 +' )'+G + ,' 'B!'( + '( ! *, + B! '>+ ) ,'+"
2')'+,(=)!0'!
+' '! #,! ' ' ' > $
2(=)!0')'+ ),'!
+' +' ;
9,,'> (=)!0= ',/ 3= !'')'+ ),' + B! >,,'
, + ? D(' ' '+=052
DC ' ? C(' ' '+=052
' ? C (' (+ =0 '9, > )= > ' 0,=& (=)!0')'+ ), + B!
$ <' 2.),-1(0:=+4( 8(+-+-/('-/
2'(8'+(0:= > / %# 2'(8'+(0:= > /
(1,'?2 AA A A ;$
AA A A ;$ AA A A ?$ 5 + (+=0 ' ;
>,'# ' 52 ''+# ; (' AA A ;$ AA A ;$ AA A ;$
AA A;A
AA A;A
AA A;A
AA ;$
AA ;$
AA ;$
AA ;$
AA ;$C AA ;$ 9, +
' +!>' ) ?,' AA +
AA # (+ , 9 ; C' 9 ; D ' 9 ; C ' 9,=& ,>, ' +( '+
1 #;,' A A #, +! 0(!' ? ('
>, , ',(!' ? (' 4+# >' )?,' !(=' AA + ;,' AA ,+=
(+ , 9, '' = ! ,! ' , & &+ + (,' '+ ) 0 9,!' ',,= + ( ,' >,0, !0(( '#2(= #! + ' '!=(,' ' >,,>,& '!+ +> ,( 2 '! ,=&!' ',>,,' ' >,,6E!&6 ) '## '( '! *
, +#>,,+= ',+! 9,+ '( + ,!
+ '>+ ),'+'&'#,' ,'
'F ' ! * , + 6& ,'># , + , =
' ''+/ '! & #414' ,?! &+ %&'
( ''+'CA $ 416++ : ( +,' )'+ ' += '!+'!
+2(= 0 +2(= #+!>,,,( '
>! +=+&'+
, ' +' )'+ ,' '!( , , = !=(+ , C ' #>,'+ ), '#>' ) ! , +,& +& ! ,& !'2(= #) .
/'0 '' ) +/82 '(+( , )A+() ),,
,B!'+ + +, '
+& 7!+).'& #2(= #&+ '+'++ @ # >+, '( +)' + F!
+'' +,+ '( '(+( , )A+() ),, , A
#+ + ,,+ , #E +! ' >
# 9,C ' >,,& +& !#'+ ), '#' ) ! , +/>&'#,0' '0 , ' 6& ,'>#,B! >,,', ! , + B! ' = =&+ +!!'
> +>,,',& !'( = >! +'B!' +'
=0,!' >,,,& !' + )9,!' = ) ,( E' ! '&'0>'F!'+ + , = ,>,' ) ! , +# ' :(0 = +,, ',& '
& +
&'(+0+(+ ,, +,=
B!'+=0/82 +,0>'! +! 0, + '>,,, ( , = >'++ 9, /'0 8'= & ( 2!,'02# 3, 23$ ','+ >, >'& ' '( '(A + , 2!,'0 ' =! + ) '!+ ,' "
. D = , 2'+!
+'
& %*('+(9-.+8('2/2 '18'(1-2(2@),/0
7+4'-+=':7-)0-/5./2+'7.+(0+4('(/$ :
, '' 0
'!,'*+=0,( +$ EE EE EE EE =, 0 ' !
!,'*+! + ,2!,'0'=! + ) '!+,' $ , ' ' 0
' !,'*+ =0 ,( (0#
>, + ) 0, ) + 0 ># ',
(= ) '#=0 '&+=0 + ' &+'&#' & = ''&
#' ' ! #, =0
E ) 0 ,!'+''(,' !! ' !, '(A +'=! + )' !,,'
(
'(0= ''=+# ! 0 ' #>, ,((+=', , '& ,2'
, '! '(+ ,'!
+'# & , + '(A + ' =! + ) '!+ ,' '
+( ,!
!,'*+ '! + ' + ,>!>,0,,! + ='+'+'' ') ' =' )
'(0 >, , '& ,2','! '(+,'!
+'# ,(0=# + !, ' ,>! , , '' 0
'!,'*+ =0,(>, '+ & +0#, ''
0
' !,'*+ =0 ,( , '+'
'B!' ),(&!, '(A +'=! + ) '!+ ,' ' +( , !
!,'*+ '! +''') '=' )
'(0>,, '& ,2','!
'(+,'!
+'#,(0=#>, !','
'+ & +0"
:
,'!( #, ' ,& ) '
+& ,'>#, + = )'B!'+ ' '! ), ,),>0 '( 2(= /'G =+# , ' ,& )
$ '
&'(+0 ) = ', '!
+', 2 ' & , )+ !
!,'*+ ! , +
B! '(? ),( '0 = ,(' ' ,'
!# )'!
+(+! ' ' ), =0,!'
E' ! '&'0>'F!'+ 9,' '#? ) &>,!' ',,= + +,& !,' + )#>! +=F! + ' ',)#
'
' ,(' + & ', '
+!,'0 +A'
,!'+ >,,! ',( '+ >, > +, '& , 2#,(0=9, '(0# +&+# ', , ( !,'0 =0 ) '0 !
+'. D , 2/>&'# '
' =0 ,!'# ,>' ,,= +>'' + +, + + '+ ) 0 ...21 78%6 2-66./7/:%2 78%6 '( $ ,,' ? )A' + J
,,'1 '=
J