← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/28513/2018dismissed

Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd And ORS v. M/S Vipul Motors Pvt Ltd And Another

2024-02-20Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj10 pages

  



  

            

 !

"## DAKSHIN HARYANA BIJLI VITRAN NIGAM LTD AND OTHERS



  M/S VIPUL MOTORS PVT LTD AND ANOTHER 



  $ %&$#'

(

'#) *****     

  ! "

#

  # #$  ! "



  %%%%% (

'#)+#,-./ 1.

#



 #   &  

   #   '( ') '*  +, #  # ,!-

 



  . !  / +   !

 01 " # ! !

, ! '0 

 "

 # 

 !

  # 

  

 2        #  +

 + #-   #   3+ #  ! !

, !

!

 +

 !!

 

 45.'''6 7 018 "5.4  !

,#+ 

" 

 

.# -  "

 

&!#!9+,#- " :;



/ +

0 '< '6

&# !##

 &

-2- "

 

 # ! !

, , " 4   !

, "



 - ! , 7;8   # &  !

 +  "" !

 #  ""   !+

 !

- = = #;  #!!

" #

 

& #

!!

 !& ## 

 

!

  !+

 # -   .#  .

    0 '< '6 &    !

, # " &     # $     " 

 

#   

  



 -  & #" 

( '< '6  

 &# !#    !

 & " +, # 

 

 !

( "#! !

,! ''0 .# &  &    * ') '1  .# 

   +

  !  " >(* " '<  

 #    &# !# !#  

& & #  "## ,  !

 ( " # ! !

, !  ''0 &     +

-



+ 

#



-  5 &  # - &#  # &  

 & !

  # 

 ?""

! # , "

- ') '( '6 .#

 

&

   +,   !#

 # "

 -  &#

  ( ' '(&"

+,#

 

.## , #"  & #         #  " - +,#

 

# , 

"

#

!

 ##  !  +

 !

 !, 

 # # 

  

 & !,

!

--!

!

 

 )2< ;# #   ## !

,+

!

--!

!

, &! + 

-3-  ""   ""    +, #    -- 

 5 !  # - &!

!,

 #- &

#,   !

  !

 "

 !



 

  

 # !

  # # +, # # , & +

!

!!



"#  !  +

!

 5!

 # #,

"!&   & +,#

 

>#  

 )2< 

 -

#  / + "

#  " !,

 

 

   

" #      > 9#  # # +



(21 +

"

#!

--!

 !

,  5 !

  # # 5. 4   !

!

 & # # !   !

  "'1@#,+

# - 

''  ,

@5.

 .#&#

#"

 # = "! !

, 

&  #   " # +,# ,&# !## A 

            

    

  

                            

      

  

 

     !"              

          #$ #% &# '     



 



  

      

               

        

    (    

-4- &    



 

        

 

       )*+    !" '

#$ &# %

    ,     '# 

         

  

  - + .+/&-+

         &%#'&-01  &2 -##01 







 

 

  3       #4  6   (

       &5 #5 &# '    

           ")        78 *&#

    

      9      9    ,    ,     (

       

   

                 

 



&  "   ,                 / 

 

  

       

 ") /            "



 '

:;<"   2 = &# '    :  ) < ;  " :;<*&$*&# '7

 ;   7'  

   '

             

   

               

        

-5-  

     

        

  (

  >    

5#

           ?         

'

' 6    

      ?       

                    9 

       -

:;<;  2 8 % 7 @             

  

      

       

                     

                9          

 

         

           

            &% #8 &# '   

      #$ #% &# '   

     ; &8-#8$%*7       

  (

 &8 #8 &# '   !"      

     

   

 :;<  !"   %

              (

        ,     3   

     9         9   

    (

 



-6- (

    >

  

  

        

7            

   



      @     3        

    9      

        

        



    6              ,  7(

        @ 



        

    *  9

   @    

   @ 

     

   



         

7       

 (



9       :   

 

                                

   

         !"         A            

7   $          

     



              

         

             3             &%# '&- 01        &$$0!           

              

          9  "    )    "                     #

-7-

#

          (      !"          

 (

  &8 #8 &# '   &- #'

&# '          @                     )

 

 

  &##% 

            (          

     "      

 (

&5 #8 &# '         6   A

            

 @

       !"      ,             

 5#                        ; &8-#2$%*7       



 @          3      

  9 (                                !"

B < 5#!

 ##  !  +

!

&-

, B-

 !

 +,## ,  &

!# # 

 +,#

 & +  # #

 !

!

&+

 "

# "

&# !#!# ,#+  .#-!-"

#

+"

#  

 '* '0 4  !

#"!!

! -- 

& 

 & # # !

 " #        '1 ') '0 #

-8- + "

#+,#

! -- 



+,#   !

,

"#  #+ "

# #!

"

#!   "

#  +C!

2

 " , ( ?

-#

!

"

#!  !

  ##,# 

+C!

 # "

#+,# ! -- 

* 4 #  #   !

 

 +#" " # !      #

 # # #  !-    +

!

 ) .#          #    " #  !

!

"

!,

!

--!

!

, 

4 

   # # 

  

  &  "   

  )2< 

 

#  / +& 

(1 #   / + .#!



"#

 

 # ! 

#

  !

,    

   # !

--!

 !

,   

(1 .# !&,!

 +,## ,  #& 

&!! # &  "

#  "  "

!

"#! ! - #

! -- 

&

   " #

! -- 

#+  #

# " # +   # #

#!

 + #  "#

 ##& 9 "  +

 9 #- 

D

   -+ " D -   !9        + 

& # # # ! # #  +  9 # "

  

 # + , #   .# -!#

,   D -

 #

 -   +     "!

#!

  "!# "

#  "!,

 # & 9 /#   +,#

! -- 

# #  !-   

 # 



 ! "

! " # !

- ,  #

-9- "! ,  !   # - ,      ! 

  !!

 +

9 ! -! !

&,

! &"

 +

 .#   ! 

   ,   " # - , & 9

 # -  &   # #, B-

   !

 +  # -+ " - ,& 9

#

/# #! -&  

# - "

 ! + 

# - " 

! -&

+

     # # !

 +  &   =9   & # - , -+&"

 # & 

!

"# !#  -+ " # !  & "

 # #  ! &     #  !! " -#

 ,"

 - & 9 /# # . "

 "

#0-

#&  +,#

! -- 

  #, #

!

, " !# "  & 

#"

 

#   ## !#&

,  -    # # &

- -  

   

 (1  #   / +  '

.# +      # -

      !

   .#    #+ # "



!

+, ## ,   #   , " !

!- !   !

 

 #  #

+C!

   +, # 

 # , +   & # +, # # , 

 #+ #

 # "



2+  " #  !

 +, #  # ,   !

 + " -#  "#

! -- 

 .# & 

  - 

-10-  ;

-  !!



,   # -

   '( ') '*+,## , !!



,""

-  #  ,(

'#)/ +  !

)  >##9

2

 E2 >## +  E2