High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/908/2016dismissed

The District Cooperative Union Amritsar v. The Presiding Officer Industrial Tribunal Amritsar & ANR

2016-01-18Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain3 pages

!"# $#%&'&() !"# $#%&'&() !"# $#%&'&() !"# $#%&'&() !(*!+, -

!(*!+, -

.#&'"+&%"/#+!"&0#(&(- 1+&"'!+ #"&"&(#+ 2#+'*'

.#+#'&$&(3

&%#+!($!(".#+ #'/($#("'

) ) ) ) 4 56 66

4 56 66

+#'#(") +#'#(") +#'#(") +#'#(") +2&'.!76.!+1!- $0%!"#

+".#/#"&"&(#+ 88888 88888 88888 88888

- #"&"&(#+.!' &7#$".&'/#"&"&(*($#+ +"&%7#

".# ('"&"*"&( ($&! '##9&(3 ! :+&" &( ".# (!"*+#

%#+"&+!+& +;*!'.&(3".# #</!+"# !:!+$$!"#$ =

((#<*+#> !($".#+$#+$!"#$

= ((#<*+#> ?-:.#+#@,-!//7&%!"&(10#$@,".#/#"&"&(#+ +'#""&(3 !'&$#".##</!+"#!:!+$ ((#<*+#> -:!'$&'1&''#$ 5#!+(#$ %*('#7 + ".# /#"&"&(#+ .!' '*@1&""#$ ".!" &( !%"- +#'/($#(" .!$ .&1'#7 7# " ".# A@ #"&"&(#+.!$(#0#+/!''#$!(,"#+1&(!"&(+$#+;*!".# '#+0&%#' +#'/($#(" #'/($#(" .!$+!&'#$!(($*'"+&!7$&'/*"# %.!77#(3&(3.&'"#+1&(!"&(@,'#+0&(3!$#1!($("&%#.# !//+/+&!"# 0#+(1#(" +# #++#$ ".# $&'/*"# &#7$ @, "($*'"+&!7+&@*(!7 +!$A*$&%!"&( .#%!'# +#'/($#(" -&(@+&# -:!'".!".#

:!' :+9&(3 :&". ".# /#"&"&(#+ !' !%.&(# !( '&(%#

!($.&''#+0&%#':#+#"#+1&(!"#$( ? @,".#/#"&"&(#+:&".*"&''*&(3!(,("&%#-%.!+3#>'.##"+ .7$&(3!(,&(;*&+, #"&"&(#+ &7#$&"':+&""#('"!"#1#("!($$#(&#$".#

!%"".!"+#'/($#(" .!$:+9#$:&".&" + ,#!+'!'

!77#3#$":!'$#(&#$".!"".#/#"&"&(#+.!$"#+1&(!"#$".# '#+0&%#' +#'/($#(" ":!'!0#++#$".!"+#'/($#("

.!$.&1'#7 7# "".#A@!($$#'/&"#&''*!(%# ("&%#" @,".#/#"&"&(#+-.#.!$ !&7#$"A&(.&'

$*", (

-:.#(".#%!'#:!' &<#$ +#

+"'

+#3!+$&(3 '#""7#1#(" @#":##( ".# /!+"&#' !($ + &7&(3 +#/7&%!"&(-((#!//#!+#$(@#.!7 ".#/#"&"&(#+!($&"

:!'/+%##$#$#</!+"# (.&'#</!+"##0&$#(%#-+#'/($#(" !//#!+#$ &(".#:&"(#''>@<!'!($/+$*%#$(+#%+$%#+"& &%!"# $!"#$?

<.&@&" &''*#$@,".#!(!3#1#("" #'"!@7&'.".#+#7!"&('.&/ !'"#+!($6#+0!("@#":##(".# /!+"&#'6&(%#".##0&$#(%#7#$@,+#'/($#(" .!$3(# *(+#@*""#$-".#7#!+(#$+#'&$&(3

&%#+0&$#!:!+$$!"#$ =

+$#+#$ ".# +#&('"!"#1#(" +#'/($#("

:&".%("&(*&", '#+0&%#!($= B@!%9>:!3#' .#+#!

"#+- /#"&"&(#+ 10#$ !( !//7&%!"&( + '#""&(3!'&$#".# #</!+"# !:!+$ .#'!&$!//7&%!"&(:!' $&'1&''#$ @, ".# ($*'"+&!7 +&@*(!7 0&$# +$#+ $!"#$

= .&7# $&'1&''&(3 ".# !//7&%!"&(- &" .!' @##( ("&%#$@,".#($*'"+&!7+&@*(!7".!"".#+#/+#'#("!"&0#

".#/#"&"&(#+.!$!//#!+#$(??$!"#'@*":.#(".#%!'# :!' &<#$ + &7&(3 +#/7&%!"&((

-((#.!$ !//#!+#$ ( @#.!7 ".# /#"&"&(#+ !($ ".# %!'# :!'

!$A*+(#$ + #< /!+"# #0&$#(%# +#'/($#(" "

#'/($#(" %7'#$ .&' #0&$#(%# (

!($ ".# %!'# :!' !$A*+(#$ " =

:#0#+-(".#'!&$$!"#!7'-((#.!$!//#!+#$(@#.!7

".#/#"&"&(#+!($#</!+"#!:!+$:!'/!''#$&( !0*+

.*'-&(".#/+#'#("%!'#-&":!'#0&$#(" ".!" $#'/&"# .!0&(3 ".# 9(:7#$3# /#($#(%, ".# +# #+#(%#@# +#".#($*'"+&!7+&@*(!7-/#"&"&(#+.!$ !&7#$ "/*+'*#".#'!1# (".# !%"'!($%&+%*1'"!(%#' ".# /+#'#(" %!'#- ".# !@'#(%# ".# /#"&"&(#+ @# +# ".# ($*'"+&!7 +&@*(!7 (

%!((" @# '!&$ " @# @(!

&$# + *(&("#("&(!7 .# 7#!+(#$ ($*'"+&!7 +&@*(!7 ".*'-+&3."7,$&'1&''#$".#!//7&%!"&(10#$@,".#/#"&"&(#+ '##9&(3'#""&(3!'&$# #</!+"#!:!+$ 3+*($ + &("#+ #+#(%# @, ".&' *+" :.&7# #<#+%&'&(3A*+&'$&%"&(*($#+ +"&%7#

".#('"&"*"&(

($&!-&'1!$#*" &'1&''#$ 6

!(*!+, -

1!.!0&+