← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1521/2014allowed

Mahender And ORS v. Sachin Chopra And ORS

2016-07-04Mr. Justice Arun Palli11 pages

   



  ! "#

 $

% & '

"( ) "( " '

) ** ++ "

! ,!   - ' "'*) "( " '

)   !*"( "

!

&# ./&-&/-  

 

 

 

 &/-01/2 

    

!  "



$%&''()*

     #

  

  ,- (. $((%

$ 

"

 

 !

"

 "





#    ,0 # 

 

# 2 

 

4

+  2   

  *($**67.(  

  ,

#



# #



 "

!

"

 "

   



8  



   !   3

5  

 

  2 5 :

  

 

8   $6 (. $((%

 ;<

#

  , ,% (. $((%

  ,

  !  2



,$





$((((()*



      





5



 

#

 

+  #

 

#

>   

$(((((()*

  ,. (, $(,'

'

? 

    ,

$

 

+









8  +  

"

   

# #    ,

  

"

   # #  +  2       



     ;<



  ,

   

3

  '

 



 

  

 +  "



8 

    , 

  

@

 



     

 



# # 



 , ;  #  



 

+

    

# #    ,

 +



+



   +  

  

 

  

 

&

=

  

 

  , + 



 4* , 3  



  !

:

9 

     



  ,

#



    

+ 



4*$  : 1 



  

  2 5 : + 



 ,- (. $((%

   $6 (. $((% 5   

 #

&$'$%)* 



 A= *%   

 



.

@





  

 



    

  # #

    ,

- A  #



 2   

 

= 

#+





 #    > 



 

> ) >

 

 

%  

 4 ('5 "(   '

)!

 -

    '

)  "( '

)!

0 $((, /-0 !

,%.

6& + 7 "( " '

)  6 ) "   +  "(   '

)!

$((% /'0

0 6(' "

   ,$







*





$6((()*





  ,)'  /+     0



  ,6

     

 

$$6((()* ,&((( = ,60

+



,(((()* + 

 

&$''()*



  

 



$%&''()*



 . 7 

 

  

 



$%&''()* ,( ;

    ,









  '  #  

  + +  8 



,, 

    # D   



  

 



>  # 

  

# 

 

<

  

  ,

$

 

+  

E  E  

 ', ,( $(,6

  

  '

 





 

% 

 



>  

    ', ,( $(,6 ,$    # 

+



  +  

 

 #

+

 

+  #

   

  

 

 #

>

,'

 

    

 

+

 



# 

 







 ,$

#

 >     

   

5+

 

 





,$

   



    #

 

 

+  #  

 # 



 +

,((((()*

+

 

 

 

,6



   >  

$   

"



+  

 

8 #

!'  "(   '

)!  9! 8: )- ";' "( '

)!0/$(,'0 % !

, < +6 "5 )

"( '

)!9!6 !')  " "( '

)! /$(,'0 .

!

6.  

+  

$7(((





> 



,7((()* 



/+

"

  8 

+  #0

 

$7((()*





+ 

   #

 

=

7((()*    "



 :

,7

 

> ) >





 8 # 

('5

6& + 7!.

 /  0





# ,$



 $6((()*

<

 

+

+



   

<

!

/<!@0

    



= 

"

  

 







5 D 

      

 + +

+ ,(

# 

 

"

 $6((()*

  E,7E

 

<

"E 

>  " 

,%%.

$ !      ,%--

+   ,6 ,, ,%%6

  

&

!  *  

 ,7((()*





<  

"

 ,- (. $((%

 

  ,7

 $ ! 



 ,%--

5  #

+

 E

"E / #  

 0 +

+

>  "



$((% <   





# ,$



 $6((()*



,& <

   

#

2 +   (, (. $((%

"



 



 '%,6)*

 

 6&%&-)*

 



> 5+



  = &

  +    



8





"



 $((()*

 

 $6((()*

<  +  

# +  





 + 

 

 "



 

+

,- $$)$'

   

+   

 



@    

>













#  

>   #  

  







   5+ 



 

+



  

#





,.



 E

 $6((()*

 = > 

 

 

     



  

,)'

 $6((()* +  

@

   + 

 

+

,-

=

  

-<   - )+  , )< "(   '

)!  9!   +'

) "!*) )*)

"  "(  " '

)0 /$((%0 & !

,$,

 E,-E +

  

,7 $7

#

 





5+ 







+ 

    +    

 = ,-





'(

  



  E,6E "

# 

 0

+

6,*67

 <  







#



  #

+ 

#

>

  + +

#   /= 

0   +     #



+

,-*$7



#

 F +

#     0  

E



# 

 

+ 

 

5

+  





  E,-E +



 

5



 



 E

 $6((()*

    ,)'

+ 

 ,&((()*



  E,6E











 $$6((()*

  

/

0



,-   

8 #    +

+* ,0 + 

0



 $$6((()* $0 +  

 

 ,((((()* '0 +  

   $7((()* +  =  7((()*  

 '76((()*   +

 

 7.&.()*







 



%

 

  

<

%H

  

$((%



,%%(



 & 7 . 7 



+

 =  



1&/-2  9 

(6 $(,& )# #