Harjinder Singh Waraich & ANR v. State Of Punjab & ORS




  
    

 !"!#$

%"&' ( )*%+!,!#$ %- ./ 01%%&1% .% 1 

 '

'*'

/%" * -%)% .1' 

'2 . '




  


    

' (3

/ 01,.&%,"12 '





    5 %6 12 ''78*%'1 0"1..%.#9 !9 4##6  2%''.  )+  1  /2&%  /&%+4&*:4 ' %  *1+, 2%:   "  *' 0  % .  )%  2: ,  * -%),    2*2.

;&'"'2<'* ./& =>"1 * -%) 0 %% .<

%

0% .2: &,#??>5"'1,@1#??>&@6,<1)+

'  2".)+ "12 %0% '1..%.

$ !# "1".: '%,%A*.1% %%2:  *1+5"'1,@A@6,1%') .':''.


1'%. '

 ,  1  2 5'6  8*' .  1  .  "  1"  .: '%, A.<1&11%:,* """* 1'* ."/  !,*0 1%'4




,A*.1% %,<%'.*&.":#!B B"1 %).%:* <10% &"12 '<%'1% ""* *011%) :%.%% CD 1"%&'"1&%'%71'

A1.2 %*&  != !#="1'%""4 1.&::&%''%+42%'',*0 1%'4




,A*.1% 1

  2 ',<1%"%1% .' '2&+,0%101'). '2& "/  !" '

=,##,#!,$!!E4 12 '.2'. '

?!,==, >>E4 <1*2 1).<%'%&&2.

1%",12 ':.%

%22&% .%.= != !#>"1'* ."/ ' 10* .

1%1" &%& <%' 0.%':% <11#'2  * "* %+' "1'' <1<%' 0 % %.% 1'% ""&,A%&&2.18*'"1'* ."')*"".

#!B"1%& +1* " '

=, =,>!E4% .

"* .1)%% &%:*  1%00.2 '".%22%% . %22%'1%<%'* ..<  !> !9 !#> 1+&1% 0.)11' .')"1/2&%/&%+4&*:4 ' %*1+,2%:  "  *' 0  % .  )%  2: ,  * -%),  <1  .  .  .%.

#$

!# %<.1 '   2%% .:% ..1&%' 11".: '%,A.&.1'%:%"'1 11"

.: '%,A...%.$ !# 5 496'*)'% %+ %&&2.1%22%% ..*&.1"".%:* ":#!BF B"

1%& %:* , '% .1.*'2%+%)G

C=D /%00.,12 '%0% ". ' 

)"  1  /%   :   <1&1  1%'  )  * .  .<  .  1 :2*0 ...%.#9 !9

C>D 1  %)4:  .  .'  "  "" 0  1  &

%:* %* .&1% 0 1 '% <2

C D 3% +4".  &  '  1%  )  %'.    )1%"  "  1 2 '

'+,'*0.1%1' ) . 0& %&)< 1 2%'%'12 '<1.<1"")"&*.&*: %  %: ,1 & ""*&*.):%.H'& .+,'%0*.

 1% 1%)' &"& %&*%% '12,/& =>"#??>&'  %%&.H1.+,1""*&*.):%. + %&&.% &<11 :'% .& '<1&1< ".%1:"1%*& 1.

!= !#=5 4#6<1 %'0%.1""*,1"< 0<%'

2..(4

  
&%'1'*&&''"*)...' .2'1 #>B%:*  <1 !.%+'":1.%"%*& , 1 #!B%:*  &%'")1',>B%:*  &%' "/ %%.+.2'.)+1:'1%)""."1 %22&% .' .2'#>B%:* <1  !.%+'

":1.%"%*& % .1%22&% <1%  &%: 1'0%.

C$D

"1+,"%%1""*'2:''),&% ) B"1 %:*   .2'.  )+  1  2 '  % .    B  "  1  %  '% & H';1+,1%& "1%*1':2' 0 B""*'

.'&: % 0%' ':%&&*:'% &',1""*%<%'.*&. #B + " &':%.1..%.9

!#5 4#

C9D % 0  1%.  % .  &* '  "  1  2 '  %  % & '.%) 01,<. " .% +: 1"1&  '

C?D 1  "'  ''*  <1&1  8*'  .: %  '  <11 2' '"/& =>"1#??>&%%%&.1"%&'"1 '% &%'I C#!D /& =>"1#??>&.%'<1'*:2 % .""* ")%&1"% '" 
''*)4'& 5#62.'1%<1% +% '" :%7'."%* 12%+: "% +& +,)%&1% + & "% '""% +% .)*. 0)1,1'% ""&:%+,

 )+ & < 0,&%*2 1% '"'1<&%*'%'<1+% 2 %+)  :2'.


"1% '""%'  2%+1%:*  .* 01<12 %+%':2'.* .'*)4'& 56,'*)4'& 5 6"

/& =>"1#??>&,2.'%'"<'(4

6 
"  1  % '"  "%'    2%+  1  %:*   .* 01<112 %+ %&&.% &<11. :%.* .'*)4'& 56&::'%)%&1"% + 1& "% '",1'% ""&:%+,)+

& < 0&%*2 1% '"'1<&%*' <1 %2."1+.%+',<1+% ."'*:2

"1% .)*. 0)1,%'1&%':%+),% .

""*"1<1% +2%"1: +,"% +, 2%. '2&1"<1&15'1%)8*% 

2& "1%%:* "1& +, '% .1.*'2%+%) '2&"1% '" "1% .)*. 0)1'1*. ):%.

C##D "  %. 0  "*1,    <*.  )  *'"*    2.*& /& 45J:6<1&1." '1;2'' @% '"@,<1&1:% '(4

"  '(4
 1'  &,  * ''  1  & ; 1<'8*'(4 ;;

;;

;;

;;

5J:6F% '"G:% '%2' ', &*. 0%": 1).+" ..*%'<11 &2%. , <1:%')*. 0''.,%'.% '".

* .1'&% . &*.'1''*&&'''% .%''0 '

.

C#D
:%+)' ":1%)2.*&.2' 1% &% ')*. 01%') '.E%'.4*% '".* .1&,'*&1

 )*+E''% '""%'<1 1."  "@% '"@ /&

=>5 6%22'@%% '"@<1"%'1 *1:'% .& '

"1:."'%,%'% '""22+,%'1&%':%+)

C#
1 '% &%',12 '<101').."1 '%"'*)-&&::&%' 1).<%'%&&2.% .>B% ' : +<%'%'%&&2.

1'1*''.@'.@1:"% '

.2*2'''*)-&1%0.:'% .& '

C#=D 12 '<"*+%<%"1.*.%'"1 ; '%: '     )  .2'.  )+  1:


'%.  "  .2' 0  1  .* '%: 5'6,1+%22.% .'* ..1' 1'% %:* . 12 '@"%*1 *1:'% .& '"'%"1'

1) 0%)%&1 12%,/& =>5 6"1#??>&'"*+ %%&.

C#>D 12 '1:''1%%&&2.1%<%'%&%'" %: "' 1"%* 1+<  %2' 2%+1.* '%: '


<%'&% ..+%&7 <.0.)+1: 18*'.%.

= != !#>'*):.1'% ""&,<1&1%.'%'"<'(4

*1'*.. .%1":+' 1*2 ./ % %.%1"%:+' 0%: %% ." &% '''

< )%)2%+1'"*%

*% '%: ',72 0 <:+'2&"&%' 1 %: "2)&% &.% .:+% ': + .'&).%):%+)"* ..<1*% +""* %'%'2&%&%'

C# D
:%+)' ":/& =>5 6"1#??>&1%1 :2   *1+ &%  . %+ ""  1  %:*   .2'.  )+  % % '" ."%*,8*% #!B"1%%:* "&

: +, '% .1.*'2%+%) 
1 '% &%',1'%

  ""&1%. %+"".#!B"1%%:* "&

: +)*122%*1+%&&2.1%22%"12 ' %%0; % ..*&.1"".%:* ":#!B 1 1 %*1'1%) 2 .":' 0122+1*012

%*& 1'& .101')..,.*1%& "12 ',1 '' &"1%*1':%70.1'''*"".)+1:,)+ "" 01%:* "101')..'*+&%'"  " &)+ 1'* C#$D 12 '@2%1%1%*1'&*."" + "1%:* .2'.)+1:% .  B"1%'%&

* '& %+1;2''2' "'*)4'& 5 6"/& =>"1 #??>  &  <1* .  1  :2   *1+  '   .    "" 8*%     #!B  "  1  %  %:*   "  & ,  %:+,  1 %: 2&"%' 
<"1* %:)0**'2' % .;2''

% 0*%0"1'%*,12 '@&   1'0%.:'

-&

'0%.12%".'&: % ,1%"""*:%+ %+":&%'&%'.2 . 0*2 12&*%"%&'% .&&*:'% &'

"  %&1  &%'  1  .  .%.  9

!#  5 4# 6  .  *2  )+  1 2 '<1#B"1%:* <%'"".,.' :21 &%'%'1'%..<%'2%''.)"1%: .:  /& =>5 6"

1  #??>  &    !>

  1,  1  2'  ;2''+ 21).1%1"".%:* '1% ;&.#!B"1% %:* "1& + 1*',* .1* 4%: ..2' , )0% <%' 1%*1'-*'"+1%"""* 
1' &&*:'% &',""*"%:* %1.*&.%.' )&:1 ) . 02'*%'2&. %"1%: .:  /& =>5 6"1

 & !>

C#9D

1%' '%"4'%.,<. " .% +: 1'

2

':''.

  ! "

















# 

)*%+!,!#$ !  "



























#