High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1644/2014disposed of

New India Assurance Company Ltd v. Sharda Devi And ORS

2019-01-11Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh3 pages

!" #"$%&%'(

)

*"&"'!(

*+ &, -./#0$ !" *!," 11"22 '!

&- '#""1+ 3*/#0$ !"

**"&1'#"'!& !4

," 1*"&"'! 11" 2 #%*"$!& $, 22"'5" 5 %'&! 6 *# # !"#

71 &&"#.8!," !*$$%#"'!2 %-&*%.3' 2/, '#%5 *, 6,"*".8$-1"'& !%', &.""' 226"#' $$3'! #" !, '9"8 * & #%' -!*0",%$32 * $$%#"'!!, !!912 $"'4 :

,"*%.3' 2, & 6 *#"#$-1"'& !%' &7 / )

#"! %2"#,"*"3'#"*( ''3 2%'$-" !,"#"$" &"# &

/);

##%!%'%'%'$-" * 3!3*"1*&1"$!& 1"*$"'!

"#3$!%' *1"*&' 2"<1"'&"& =!,

32!%12%"* >&& #"1"'#"'$8 &7 /74/ )

3'"* 2"<1"'&"& & :/

>&& $'&*!%3-!6%#6 &/

>&& $ *" '#53%# '$"!$2 %- '!&7! &/

!!,"3!&"!/%!%&1"*!%'"'!!-"'!%'!, ! 11" 2 5 %'&! *"&1'#"'!& ;! &! '#&#%&-%&&"#0%#"*#"*# !"#

;

1 &&"#.8!,%&3*! '!,"$%*$3-&! '$"&/'28%&&3"!, !&3*0%0"& * $'&%#"* !%'%&6%!,*"5 *#!?3 '!3- $-1"'& !%' &&"&&"#.8!," *%.3' 2 3'&"2 *!," 11"22 '!%'&3* '$"$-1 '8632# *53"!, ! !,"*%.3' 2, & 226"# ##%!%'%'%'$-" * 3!3*"1*&1"$!&@7 A & 5 %'&! :A!, !$ '." 226"#%'!,"2%5,! B3#5-"'! 'C.2"!," D31*"-"3*!

-1"'& !%' 226"#3'#"*$'0"'!%' 2 ," #&'""#&!."*"&!*%$!"#!&4

%'!,"2%5,! B3#5-"'!& 'C.2"!,"D31*"-"3*!%' $ &" &31* '#

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

, 0"," *#$3'&"2 *!,"1 *!%"&/1"*3&"#!,"1 1"*.9

7 '#*"$*#& "*3& 2 &! !"-"'! , * -, '# E &3.&! '!% !"& 12" !," $2 %- '!& !, ! #"$" &"# '9"8 * & # 6 & 1"*- '"'! "-128"" 3'B .,"-%$ 2& '#*1&*!"$!%'>%-%!"#/ , 2%&%'$"

)) , !."%'5&/' 32!$ '." 3'#%' %'#%'5& !,"*%.3' 2 226%'5."'" %! %'$*" &"%'%'$-" * 3!3*"1*&1"$!& !!,"* !" A,"12" !,"%'&3* '$"$-1 '86%!,*"5 *#!$-1"'& !%' 3'#"*$'0"'!%' 2," #&%&-"*%!*%3&6,"'"< -%'"#%'!,"2%5,! B3#5-"'!&*"2%"#31'.8$3'&"2 *!,"%'&3* '$"$-1 '8 '0%"6 B3#5-"'!1 &&"#.8!,"'&!%!3!%'"'$,%'

$ &" &31* '#,*""3#5""'$,%'

!"*#"$%&%' !63#5""'$,%' C !"

#%&

'()*##(*+++%!%&#% %$32!! $$"1!$'!"'!%' $2 %- '!&!, ! 22!,"$2 %- '!& *""'!%!2"!2&& $'&*!%3- '0%"6 !," .0"/$-1"'& !%' 226"#.8!,"*%.3' 2 3'#"*$'0"'!%' 2," #&%&*"#3$"#!&4

'# & $'&"?3"'$"/ $-1"'& !%'%&*"#3$"#!!,""<!"'! &/::/

,"%'&3* '$"

$-1 '8632#." !2%."*!8!*"$0"*!,""<$"&& -3'!/% 2*" #81 %# !!,"$2 %- '!&/.8 %2%'5 ' 11*1*% !" 112%$ !%'." *"!,"*%.3' 2 *!," *"5%'5*" &'&/!," 11" 2%&1 *!28 226"#%'!," *"& %#!"*-&112%$ !%'1"'#%'5/% '8/&! '#&#%&1&"# "9, %!! 2 3#5"

) -, '.%-.*