Ram Singh And ORS v. Gurdeep Singh And ORS
! "#$ %&'
( ")* "+ ,! -
"
,! .! /,+
0 ")* "+ ,! -
!0"+ $# 12$ $$ 33
#3 $,$. ,+ '+4
,
"
,! $, 5/0
'+4
,, !0"+ 33 00 * ,+0 %78
,!9* 6 (
%* 7"
+ 0/, * 0,0 %,( (* 4 + ) !
+!
+7/ ! ! ( ! "
+'* * +0/, * * !0,0 %,( )+ !** 9*(
,0!!
!! "* +7
"7
+7% 3, !0"+ /,+
0 ")*'+
*6+ ,
9*
:
! /6+, ! !
:
"
,0!!
!! "7
+7%/,+
0 ")*3, !0"+ 3+
*6+ , ! 7
,( "
+ " 0, :
" "+00
6 ,
!9* * , 00,
"
,4 ,!%
)+ !** "+3, !0"+ '9"
, 6 :
),
!
7 , ;' &&; " 4/, /,+
0 ")*3 !0"+ * 6
, :
"
+9 ),
!/"
'&& )+ !** "+3, !0"+ * 4 ") :
+ " 4/,/,+
0 ")*3, !0"+ '* 6 ,!0 0 ,,( " 7 ! ! ),
!
7 ;'&&; )+ !** "+ " /, 4 6/+)
80/, !/ !+ !( !!
+ "+ /6 "
(7 ,'&&<7/ !, , +" /"
' ;
, + ! : %
,! /, ") * ! "
,4 " ") 0 , +' )+ !** "+3, !0"+ * +!6+ 6 (* '3 !0"+ = 4 + 9 + !
+! +
+ "/ ,% &' "/ ,%'"4 9 * ,+0 % "
* 4 ")7
" ,
++/, ")
" % ' ( * 9 ! ( % " !/ /, ") " % ,!0 0 ,,( ' (* '3 !0"+ = "! ,, !/ 6 !3 78
,
( ")* "+ ,! *,/)*
++
+/"
>'> (* ! (06
% " !/ , !0 0 ,,( 6 + 7% /,+
0 ")*3 , !0"+ +
, !0 0 ,,(
),
!
!0 !!
+ " 4/,/,+
0 ")*4 + 8/+)(
+4 (7 ,'>
69 !0, ,, 8/+)( 7% )+ !** "+'*9 ,'
69 ! 6 +7% (* "6% 9* * 9 ! + !( !!
+ 7% ++ "
6 !
/+)
4 + 8/+)(
+ $ , * ' !
"+
6 9 ! 6 + 7% ( * 8/+)(
+ $ , * ' * 7 ") " 7!
,
*6+ !
? :
" 8/+)( "++
!!
+ 7% ++ "
6 4 6 /+) @ " , 4 ! "A'
80/, ' 9 ,, ! 0!!
!! " 6 "+9 !!/ +,7
" ")0!!
!! " "+ B* " "
9 ! ,
+ ,( 6C
, , + 6 4 ,% 0!!
!! "!/ 6 "+7%/,+
0 ")*'+
*6+ ,3, !0"+ '
! D 78
,! "
,4 * ,+ 0 % 78
,! , ! !
6 4 ,%0!!
!! "
*6+ ,* 78
"!7% + !( !!
+ " /6% =' ; * ,+ , +
+ /6% =' ; 9 ") + "
67% 78
,!3 !7 , !
/+)
* 6
+++ "
6 !
/+)
4 + 8/+)(
(7 ,';+ !( !!
6 * 06
"
,! 7"
+ 0/, * ,! 0,0 %,4 6/ "! +
"9 !, +7 , :
")/, 7% 78
,! !9 66 !7 , 00
/, * ( "78
" ! !
0/, * 6 "+'(
!/, ") )* ; !9 ! !9 ! !+
! )* !=E !9 !6 "+7 ")* 6!* / 6 "+(
!/, ") )* ! !9 ! (0, !
+ "5* !, <;<@;3 A'<;&@=3<A'<@3A'<@=3A'<@3;A "+6 "+(
!/, ")
!9 ! ! 7 ") F !* / 6 "+ (
!/, ") > !9 ! 6 (0, !
+ "5* !, &@3A'&@3A'&=@3A!
+9 * " "/
. 66 /++ "0/,'/7 *! 6 "/,' *! 6 "+ !
,' $* 6 ' * + 7
" +/6% "!0
+ 7% 78
,! ,( "/ ,+* ,7 ")" ,%, ,+ ") " % "%!/ " ,% , ,+ ") !
% " %
, "+ ' !
" 4/,
! 7% ( * ! 7"
+
" 9 6! "
+7%
/,+
0 ")* )+ !* * "+ (* 66/! 4 * "78
/!
6!! ! 9 ! 6 + 7%
6!
),
!
* +7
" ,
+,7
" ")8/+)( "++
4 (7 ,'> " "" 4 * ,, !0"+ ! * 69 ,00
/, "! + + "
"! 7!
,4 !669!#3 G! * ")! !
"+ / 6+ /"!
6 , 78
,! "
8/+)( "+ +
> 9 ! 7
+ 7% +
*6+ "+ " "" 4 9 *
* , 8/!
/!
6!! 78
,! /, , "
* +!6+
6 78
,!4 +
++
+>>
, ")4 ! ?
;< "+(/
"*
+%7
"
+ " , 4/, "+"978
,! 9"
,! " 0!!
!! " 4 !/ 6 "+ , 4 6/ !
"! +
" ! + ! /!!
74 78
,! ( ")
% 0/, * 6 "+ ,( 7"
+ 0/, * , 7/ 1! ,( 9*( 0/, * 6 (!
" 9"
,!7
/!
*,/)*8/+)( "++
!*
+>F !" !7"
+ 0/, * ,7% /, ',(9*( 78
,!0/, * 6 "+' ! !
, ! " 9"
(
66% 0/, * , ! 6!" 9"
, ,+ ")6%' (% ( "+ 78
" " C/ " ! + 4 + "% (
"++ ,4 7 + !( !!
+H * ") ") 74 !
+ "+ ") 69 , 00
/, ' /"!
6, !* ! "
" 4/, /,+
0 ")* )+ !* * "+ ( * ! 66/! 4
! !/ * ,/6 6 ! 0 "! !* 66 " 006% " !/00, * ! "
"' * 06
+ , " 8/+)(
!" # $%&!'&@A @ 4 6A< * "
:
"
"6
+ /"!
6, ! !
/, ! 7 69 * + !( !!
78
"! ! 9 */ , ( ") !!/ ! "
"+ ")
/, ! 7 69 !*/6+ * 669 78
"0
"7%
" * ! "
:
* ( 0,4 ! "! ,+ , /6 !& "+ "+ "
7% !/(( , 6% + !0! ") 78
"!' " 66 % * + 7
'
((
+7% /, !7 69* * ,+0 %78
"!7 ? " !/ * 7 +8/+
+6 ?
" "+ * :
/, /6+ " * + !( !!
78
"! 9 */ , ( ") !!/
"+9 */ 669 ")
6
4 + " * ! "
:
'8/+)( "(!)*+,%-
./!
$ $$%&!
'@;A
@ 4 6A>=>9 !, +/0" , * "+' 6
+ /"!
6 , , !0"+
*6+ ,!/7(
0, " 06 6 !0 "!9 667 0, " 4 9 0,4 ! "! ,+ , /6 9* *!0 66%0,4 +
/6 !&< "+ ,+ , 9/6+ " 006% , ! !
, 7!
,/ " " :
"
, 0!!
!! " ((4 0,0 %7% ,!" 9*( 8/+)( , "! ,, 0,0
, "!
" 6
* ! :
"
" , "! , ,0 % /"!
6,
!0"+ 06
+!
,"), "0& !$/+% 1!/ %
(/!)&&%2/!$%&!
'&@A=; "!/00, * ! "
"
0, " 06 6 !0 "!9/6+ 006% ", !0
"! ,!F
"! 9* ** 7
6 !* + (( + !!/7(
06
7"
+ 0/, * , !" "!
4 +7% 0, " 06 6 ! 0 "! 6! ( , 8/+)( " %
3
$%&!
'@=A @ 4 6A& " !/00, * ! "
"
78
"! !/7!
C/ 4 "+, 6 ?
!+/, ")6
" " 7 +8/+
+6 ?
4 6!/ 7/ *
7 !/(( , 6%+ !0!
+
6!06
+" 4&!
&5!/) *4%#%$
3" 41!/ %$%&!' &&<;9* 7!
,4
!") 6,/6 6 9
" 6678
"!, +7%
78
,, 8/+)( , +8/+
"6 ?
!(
,%' ,+ , /6 0,4 +
"!
6
8/+)( , * ! " 7
" "! + 7
+8/+
" * /66% "! + , 4 6 "
"! 6
/"!
6, !9 66 ! /"!
6,, !0"+ * !*, C/ "9* * !, C/ , 7
,( "
+ " 0, !9*
78
"!, +7% * ,+30 %78
,!' !+ ,4 +8/+
+ 6 ?
4 6 !/ , !
/6+ * 7
" + !0!
+ !/(( , 6%" 7 ! ! (
69* *9 " ,+ B*
!
+ (
6' " "
/, 4 +
,% 4 6/ 9 !/ "/)* /, ,( "0 " "
78
,! " 66/! " 9 * 8/+)( , )+ !* * "+ ( *
! 0, '/,+
0 ")*, !0"+ +
*6+ ,* +6 /" * 0,
+ ")!,!
? ")0!!
!! "7% 6 ") ,!0 0 ,,( " 7 ! ! ),
!
7 , ' &&; )+ !* * "+ +/7 !
+ !/ +0 "+ "), , +>6")%
,! "+/6
6% /6( "
+ "
, 0!!
!! " 7% 9 % !0 0 ,,( 7% 8/+)(
+4 (7 ,'>" , "
")0 6
"
* ,+30 % "
(* ! ,
+ " 0, 7%0/, * 0,0 %" "/ ,%&' )+ !** "+ ( *
"6%' +/ % 7/"+ 7% 8/+)( "+ +
!!
+ " 4/,/,+
0 ")*7/ 9*
( ")*
!9** 8/(0 + "
, % 7%
? ") , !? 0/, * ! ") 0,0 % 7% ) !
+!
++
+/"
'>9/6+7 0,
!7"
+ 0/, * ,!' ! , C/ , 7
,( "
+ * !3 78
,! 6 (
7
+ 7% /,+
0 ")* ! 66/! 4 )+ !* * "+ ( * 9*
*6+ , /,+
0 ")**
?
" /0 !
8/+)( ,!' 9 * " 76 C/ (
9* *9 !6 ?
6% 7 !!
+'* +!6+ 0,0
! * /66% "! + "
" 6
+ /"!
6 , !9*
, /(!
! 0, ,, !0 !!/ 7 , + 9*
!!
+ " 4/, /,+
0 ")*' +
*6+ , , 0!!
!! " 7% !0 0 ,,(
),
7 ,'&&; ! 66/! 4
9*
7"
+ 0/, * ,!' ((/"
0,4 ! "! ,+ ,
/6 *
( ")* "+ ,! +(
+6%* C/ , , )* " 0,0 %+/, ") " % "/"
'>' 9 ("
*!1 0, ,
7
+ 7% /,+
0 ")*' +
*6+ , (*
+% %7 !/7!
C/ 0/, * ,* 4 ")
C/ , +, )* 7%9 %!
+" "/ ,%&'
!0"+ ( * 6
"* !4 "+, )+ !* * !* 3+ * )+ !** "+'8/+)( , !7/"+7% "%+
,,+ ,0 !!
+C/ 0,0 % "+ !0/
"
"* , )* !
( ")* "+ ,! C/ , +,( ( * 6! !/78
6
" ,, !0
9*
%9 (06
% " 6
"," 4 " 0,
6 ! 669 +7%!
! + ,+ ,! !!
+7% /, !7 69+ !( !! ") 78
"! :
")/, ! !?
, !!/ "+, 3+
,( "
"
,4 ,!% 7%0
6
4 + '"0/,0!
9/6+7 ,4 + +/7 :
")/, !, C/ , "! + 78
"! 6 +7% =,+0 7/ ! %! + ! ,
" /, "
,( "0 " "9*
"
/,
! " !!/ C/ , 0,+/ "
4 + 7%
! "!/00, ,, !0
6 (!,9*
!
! 76 , /, +8/+
/0" 78
"!" 7 ! ! + /( !9* * ,!
+( !! 76 !0 0,4 ! "!6 9 " 0,
( ")* "+ ,!* ( ,9 ,+ +
!!
+ " 4/, /,+
0 ")*'
*6+ ,3 , !0"+ " ),/"+
7"
+ 0/, * ,! "+9/6+" 7 )4 +7% 0, " 06 6 !0 "! ! ( 6 ,C/ "* , !
" ")%!4"&&%2/!
3# '&&<@;A
@ 4 6A>; ")6 " * * !/, ', 6% ")/0" $&!" %
2/!
5 + ))
&!8..&
9*/":'& @
A ,, 4
" 6/! "
4
!0/, * ! ") 0,0 %,( "+,+/, ") " % 4 6!/ 4 "+,,!0 ,,( ),
!
'9/6+7 7/"+7%
4 "+, 06
%9 7"
+ 0/, * ,9 */ "
9/6+7 " "!
C/ * 0
8/+)(
+! 669!#3 G * "6% C/ "
, "! 7 + "
* !
6 ! 9*
" 7 !
7 7"
+ 0/, * , 9 */ "
0,
+ ")!
" , "! , ,0 % !4 ,% 6
, "
,(! ,+ ") +!
"' 0,0 %9* * !/78
(
, "" 7 "! ,, +!
, )* ! "% ,0 9* * ( % * /"+
, ,+ , ( "
" , "! , ,0 % + ! "
"4 !
"%"
0,
+ ")! 0/, * , * " % 0,
+ ")! 6
,6%9 * " ?"96 +) !/ 9* !6+ 0,0 % ! +/ % ,!
",(
"+ ")0/, * , " % 0,
+ ")! /, "+ "% 9,") , , /+/6 0,
" * ! 7
" ( 7%
0/, * ) 4 ! , )* , /!
" 0/, * 6 (+ 7/ 0/, * ,9 66 %!7 !/78
!/6 * , ' "(%4 9' 06
* !" "
0,
+ ")!' "" 7
+ !/!
/6
, ! " * !/, " 69 "+ ,8 5 /, . 6 (( !! "
, @00
6!A' /"8 7' &
@
A # &< I <& 9* *
"* 6+
4
!0/, * ! ") 0,0 %,(
4 "+,+/, ")0 " % 4 6!/ "+,,!0 0 ,,( ),
!
66 9/6+7 7/"+7%
4 "+,
%9 7"
+ 0/, * ,9 */ "
9/6+7 " "!
C/ H * /66% 00,
"
"6
+ /"!
6 , ! , ,+ ") "
+ , , ( ") !!/ ! " 0,
!( "
+* 74 0,7 !!/ !9* * /6+* 7
, + " 0, * 7
" ( "
+ * 74 " ,+
00,
"
"' ( "! + + 0 " "
9* :
") /, + !( !!
! 78
" 0
"! " !/(( ,% ( ""
,' *9 ,'
? ") "
"! +
" 66 C/ "!6 9 "+
*/ , ( ") !!/ ! ) 4 ") " 00, /"
0,+/
4 + '9* * !0 ,!
+( !! 76 '!/ * +8/+
" "" 7
(0,0 ,, "/66 %+/7 ! ,/
+8/+
"78
"! "!/ *(
,! !, C/ , 7 "+/
+ "
,(! ,+ , /6 &< "C/ ,% "+/
+ /"+ , ,+ , /6 !
:
"! 4 "
"+ ! !/7!
,
66C/ "!,
, )*
"+ "
" 0,0 , ! ") 7
0,
+ ") * 7
,( "
+ 7% :
") /, +/7 ' " !" % $%&!
) $%&!'&<& @A ;&;' * !7
"* 6+
9* + !0/
C/ , ,+ ")
4 + ' !!/ !!*/6+7 , "+0
!7 669 6
4 + 7/ ( "/
6%! !
! 0, (%( "+'+" ,, , ( ") !!/ "+) 4 ") "00, /"
6
4 + 7
/!
7!6/
6% 6
7"
+ ,
"!
"7 "
66%+
,( "
+,( , /(!
+% " ,+ !" / 06
7!
,4 *
" / /% &!4 +&
*! ;
% /! $ %&!
' @=A 4 6 ' 669 ")3+;,1,!& $%&!
" % $%&!' &&<
I' !7!
,4
"
+, ( ") !!/ !9/6++ "+/0"
"+ , /(!
!
*
!" " /(7 /0"
:
") /,
(/!
0/ 6 ,% 78
" 6 + "
:
" 0,
+ ")! * /, !0
66% :
") /, 0, !/( 7 0!!
!!
+ 9 * !/ 9 !+( " 7 ! !
:0 8/+ 6 0, (
00,
9*
78
"! 6 +7% 78
, , 46/!'4 :
/!,9 * "78
+ :
"0,
+ ")!*/)*!/ * "7!
,4
"' , 6
,+ ,' 9/6+
00
/, "+ / 9*
, /(!
!9 )* +9 * :
")/, +8/+
78
"! */ , ( ") !!/ "++
,( " ") 78
"!!/(( , 6%B*
:
")/, "! + , ") 78
"!0 + 78
"! " 7 ! ! (
6 '9 */ , ( ") !!/ !' "7 0, !/(
, /(!
+ !0/
+ + " , C/ , ,+ ") 4 + ")*!; 4&!
% 3 &&>@A @
A' !* 6+
+8/+
"78
"!+ !" (
, ( ") !!/ ! ! %!"
!!
,%, :
")/,
,( +8/+
"H !/!
+ ",/6 !+ !"
"+9 * , ( ") !!/ !7/ C/ , 00,
" 78
, "++ /( " !/00, !/ * 78
"! ( ") !!/ ! ! */! " %!
!!
,%
/, " 00,
"06
+ ")! 78
,!
!+ /( !7%8/+ /!
"( "+
, ,00, /"
%
, ")9/6+(
"G +8/+
"H
*6+ ,/,+
0 ")*" ! ! ),
!
7 ,'&&;* +7
"0/,!/ ")* ! , )* ", ),
!
, !/ 6")0 , + "+9 /6
6% !/ !!/6 " )
" 4 (7 , ' > *
3 78
,! * !
+ "
!* ! ( * 9* * (!
6 9 6! "!
+/, ") " % !/ , !0 ,,( * ! 0, !/(0 "
( * * 4 ") 7
(06
!/ 9/6+ 7 7/"+ 7%
*
"" C/ , , )* !7
, )* !9* * (* 0!!
!!
+'9*9 6! 0/, * , 0,0 %+/, ")0 " %
"4 9 74 + ! /!! "' * !/, ! "! + 0 " "
"" 7 7 :
" 0, " 06 ,/6 !6 !0 "!/"+ ,
" , "! , ,0 % *
7
+7%/,+
0 ")* !" "
66/! 4
7/ ! * 6% "
, 9* * * * )* ,(
),
"&&; 66
+
4 (7 ,'>
, % " +8/+
" "" ) 4 ++ "
6 +4
, )* !
*6+ ,* , /(!
! 0,
+" ,, , ( ") !!/ "++
,( "
" , )* !
!* 0,4 ! "!
" , "! , ,0 % %7 00,
+9* *,
!669!#3 G 1! &! .!.&!%, .&$ / % !& % %&!&%J/, ") " % " "% /, * 4 ")
*, %9 * " 6 ( !"+ : 6/+ ")
((/ "+5 !*( ,,
76 !* +7 %"+!/ *6 ( !7%
64 ,"( "%!/ ,0,
+ ")!9* * ! " 66/! 4 "+ " 9* * "% , )* ((4
0,0 % ! + ,
6% "+ !0 66% " C/ "' 0,0 "" 7 "! ,, +, ,9 !
*7%
"% 0 !/ , 0,
+ ") !
, )* ! "% , 0
/"+ "% +
, ,+ , 9* * ( % 7 ( "' :
/"+
*, % /, "+ " !/ *
,(! ( (0!
H ,+ ") 74 +0,4 ! "!' :
"0,4 + "
" , "! , ,0 % !
,/6 6 !0 "! !* 66" 006%9* ,0,
+ ") ! 66/! 4 '(
" ") 7%'
!
" !* 66 " 006% ! 0,4
,!" , ! !
0!!
!! " " ),/"+
9* * ! !/)* 7 :
+ *
"7
+7%+
*6+ ,' " 66/! 4 ( ""
, "
" 4/,/,+
0 ")* !" 66/! 4
' "4 9 +
, !!/ !9 C/ , 7 , +", !9 667 0,
"+9/6+7 )4 +7% 0,4 ! "! ,+ , /6 9* *
!669!#3 G ,+ , /6 #3
/6 ! "
"!
6
33 * ") " /6 !&< "+ !* 66 006% , ! !
,7!
,/ " " :
"
, 0!!
!! " ((4 0,0 % 7% ,!" 9*( 8/+)( ,* "! ,, 0,0
"!
" !/ " 9* *
9 ! 0 !!
+ , + !0!!
!! " "% !/ * ,!"
'
:06
"#" * !,/6 'K "! ,K " 6/+ "! ,7% 0
"6 9H "4 9 74 + ! /!! "'+ " "+ "% ),/"+
, " (0/)"
+,+ ,! *
6 !+ !( !!
+ $ %&' @$$A !
"8