← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaESA/9/2015dismissed

M/S Pokhar Mal Kishan Chand v. Usha Gupta And ORS

2015-03-18Mr. Justice Krishna Murari4 pages



           

  !""#$%$&' (#)*+

,% -) ( ./$%) &) &0       122".. &!   3% 4! %) 52!  &0!)"(%       1 "%2&0"&!%  '  67

         88 

("%"&!'8

(3$9"-7 4: +09# !" (!)" 22".. &!   88  

$%# 22.$# !$&$% ..;"0 %2( <"0( )$%="#5!$&"#&022" .) %:""&$."0:<!)":>"#!( ? $&%!!)"(0"(2 %%"0:<00$!$& .$%!($#!50?"+ &$2 !+0 !"0 &5 (< @+  0$%4$%%$&? !)" 22" . ? $&%! !)" (0"( 0 !"0 #!:"( + A 2 %%"0 :< $9$. 50?" "&$( $9$%$&+ &$2 !+ $(4$&? !)" (0"( 0$%4$%%$&?!)":>"#!$&%5&0"( (0"( 5."%B+@ &0 (" 0 ;$!)"#!$&  ($"  #!% ("."9 &! ( !)" 0"#$%$&  !)" 2("%"&! 22" . (" !) !("%2&0"&!5&$./54 ( (?; %;&"(!)"%)2$&0$%25!"

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

 )"0"#(""(%2"#$$#2"((4 &#"; %2 %%"0 ? $&%!5&$./54 ( (? &0/ 4."%) &$;)) 22"&%!:"!)";$"!)":>"#!(8 22".. &!

4/54 (;)#. $4%!:"2(2($"!( ,% -) ( ./$%) &) &0+ 0$("#!$&?!)">50?4"&!0":!(5&$./54 ( (?!"="#5!"!)"% ."0""0$& ("%2"#!!)"%)2$&0$%25!" !"(("#"$9$&?: . &#"% ."#&%$0"( !$&

%@. #% &0?"!)"% ."0""0("?$%!"("0;$!)$& 2"($0!)(""4&!)% )"0"#(""0 !"0 ":(5 (<B+@2 %%"0:<!)"$9$.5(!; %#&$(4"0 $& 22" .)"0"#("").0"(("%2&0"&! %) 52! $."0"="#5!$&$& ;)$#)!)"2"!$!$&"($."0:>"#!$&%5&0"( (0"( 5."%B+@ &0  #. $4$&? ! :" $& 2%%"%%$&  !)" %)2 $& 0$%25!" % !"& &!  0""&0 &!8("%2&0"&!A%$&#" &0!) !)":>"#!($(4) %:""& ;(-$&? %44$%%$&?"&!$&!)"%)2$&0$%25!";"2($.+ ! !)"( !" %,82"(4&!) &0) %:""&2 <$&?("&!("?5. (.<5&$. /54 (  (? ..""0.<"&) &#"0("&!(4 %,8! %,8(4 2($.+ &0!)":>"#!() %2 $0("&!52! (#)A+ &!)" : %$%!)"("&!("#"$2!%+%"#&0"&) &#"4"&! ?(""4"&! &0#"(!

$$"0#2<  (4 D 6+ ($?)%  !)" 0"#("" ).0"( $& "="#5!$& ;"(" %5?) ! :" $&!"((52!"0 ("%) !) !)" 5(!% :".; ) 9" ! -"& $&! #&%$0"( !$& !)" 2)!%! #2$"%!)"("&!("#"$2!%+!)"("&! ?(""4"&! &0!)"(0#54"&!% $&#.50$&? !)" 22.$# !$& ( ("&"; .  .$#"&#" :< !)" :>"#!(82"!$!$&"( %5:4$!!"0!"#("! (<+ (-"!44$!!""+ &$2 ! %;".. %!)"$&#4"! = ("!5(&!)"<" (8A/ 4."%) &$+!)";$"!)":>"#!

 (($9"0 ! #&#.5%$&!) ! ..!)"0#54"&!%) 9":""&2("2 ("0 &0?! "="#5!"0 % & !"(!)5?)! ;$!) & :>"#!$9" ! ("%$%! &0 :%!(5#! !)" "="#5!$&!)"0"#(""(%2"#$$#2"((4 &#"2 %%"0$& 95(0"#("" ).0"(("%2&0"&!)";$":>"#!(; %0""&0 &!)") 0 .%$."0 & 22" . ? $&%!!)"0"#(""(%2"#$$#2"((4 &#";)$#); % 5.!$4 !".< 0$%4$%%"0  )" 2"!$!$&"( :"$&? )"( )5%: &0 &0 :"$&? ("2("%"&!"0!)(5?)!)"% 4"#5&%".+$%2("%54"0!) 9"-&;."0?"!)" % $02(#""0$&?%)":>"#!$&!)"2"!$!$&"(:"$&?)5%: &0/ 4."%)

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

(#)*+     

  % &> <