High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1654/2014dismissed

Oriental Insurance Company Ltd v. Gurjinder Pal Singh & ORS

2019-09-16Mr. Justice Satpal18 pages

! " # !$%&!' ()

$$ *!& +&!,!-$ .//! 0

!$%&!' ()

$$ *!& +&!,!-$ .//! 0

+&!,!-$ .//!

$$ *!& 0/..&/! 0

+&!,!-$ .//!

$$ *!& 0/..&/! 0

!$%&!' ()

$$ *!& 0./ ! .//! 0 "# $%

& &%&%% -!

!*'/&/!"1

!! 3 2 22 ! )."1

!! 2

$$ 2 22

%&%% ' $$/ 1

" 2"

2 22 !5& !/!../! /( !$ !.& /6//5

# /&.// /1 (/$! !'$7! &$"0& .!/! !! !!8/ 7! &$81 !6! 1

/1 $ (/ &! (/$$..6! 3'7 # '73 "! 1$( 2 $ (/&! (! & '73 ! ./$! 2 22 /1 $ ( / $ ! / 6! ( / $! 7! &$& / 96!:&!/ ./"1 6! 3'7 # '7 3 "! 1$( ;! !( !/,& /!/ $/$ /96!:&!/!/& / ./ /6!!&!./ !0/ 0 .!

# & 3 $ ! !. !.!-;< <-<3 2/ ./6 !1.

/!6/&!&;/! ./-= 6 $$6./ 1/$ // !

, =//$!!1 ( / ./!//!1& 1$$.!!'

!("/

.7!&5 !.!.!>0< ?< ??!1 ( ! !/.$.!" (.6!/

6!. /!!&5./!6//96!:&! / ./6!!1$$.;/96!:&!/

.// %0

# @A-6!.! -$:/.!/"7/$;$/&!%// B&5 $&/!/.$.!1. /

1/$ (!1!7/$"6/!/ 96!:&! / ./" ! !!6$ '7 # 3 5. & / //!

! '73 6 ! !! (0./ ! ./ 6! /$!5. & ./ 1/$ 96!:&!6

(!$"/&6 $ !.&/$!"/! (!.& "C< !

/ / ./6$ (!$"!&. / /($ 9-/!=!50$(+!&

-! !($! !;$ '/65"0 .! !. &

"C< !/7/$ /-!6!$ $!6 $$(./ B&' 6"/&" !( ! 7/ 6! !1! /

. 1/$ $$(

! &6!6 $/! /$ /(6! &$$( !A !? 3 7/&! (/$ $.

/& /!&/$'1 6 /$"6!!1! /

.!&56 $ )!7! &$ !/ $$6.&'7

# < =//!96!:&!!1/&$! 6//5 $

# &3! 1$$.!6/7!&5 !.>0< ?< ?? . !1 (! D--

=//!! E!1!6/1.1$

1!1.$/ $$.D%

D-0 3 =//!1/$B&6 .!16/&1$ 0'"!& ! ! / $$. D% "

D-0

=//! & ,! ,! !( !D% "

D-0

% & !1"6//!$!$. D% "6/& !6/D-- 0$ )!7! &$ !/ $$6.&'7 3 < =//! / ./ ! 1/&$!

6//5 $

# &3 ! 1$$.!6/7!&5 !.>0< ?< ?? .!1 (! D--

=//!! E!1!6/1.1$

1!1.$/ $$.D%

D-0 3 =//!1/$B&6 .!16/&1$ 0'"!& ! ! / $$. D% "

D-0

=//! & ,! ,! !( !D% "

D-0

% & !1"6//!$!$. D% "6/& !6/D-- 0$ )!7! &$ !/ $$6.&'7

3 < =//!'!-;< <-<3 2..!

1/&$!6//5 $

# & 3! 1$$.!6/7!&5 !. >0< ?< ?? .!1 (! D--

=//!! E!1!6/1.1$

1!1.$/ $$.D%

D-0 3 =//!1/$B&6 .!16/&1$ 0'"!& ! ! / $$. D% "

D-0

=//! & ,! ,! !( !D% "

D-0

% & !1"6//!$!$. D% "6/& !6/D-- 0$ )!7! &$$$//!$ !.

/ !& / $&// B&5 $&/!/.$. /!1!

.!&596!:&!/ ./$/!$1 /$!"6///6!!1$$."6/$ $$( . / 7/ $ ! &!( .$.&./ ! (/&! (6. )! &$ ! /

$$<%&! ' ( 1/$(!.&//$!! &$/.!$(!!6!. /$& / 96!:&! / .//!;//$!,! /(! & /7/! !"/(! $( "/(6&$ $/!$

&! /!*/$% &!/!/ /!1$$& 6/$/6!C!1!

.!&5&//(6!! ! (/$6(!/ ! " &/! !"/!! $(6 $!/6!C!1!

/!&5 &!&/!)!&$1/$(!.&// $ ! &!(.$.

! !/1!! 7/!B&66&./ !/!1/$ //! 6/<<$$"! &!(.$.$!$(& / ! // ./6/$!1./$'!% &!/! / / </ ./ $5 / !( !1. & > !1. $ $ !! 7/! !" ! &!( .$. / ! /

!1 )!&$ !/%&!' (! / $& !.!../$!"& //%&! ' (6/6///$!6&!" (/$ /!1.$ /</ ./6/1!

/0 !/ -=< <,(:&!:6!

/ ! 0$ $ & /,&. />8 $

& !'&!&()*+,-*.-%*/0**.1,2(0+3+*,-.*4.+50*.6( 78*.9%-7-,(1*.1*.,2(0: -;-4: !%"/&"

//$ !1 /$ .!&$ )! &$ ! / $" ! ! ! & / !.& 1& // $ ! &!(.$. 61! (/%&!' (/6!% / (&/ $.1&../!$

6/!.!"/ $ ! &!(.$."& (&!/!!"1!! $

! &!(.$./7/ $!&$ !

/&! (//$ .,! /"

/"/! !"$( " .!!% &!/!& //!B&

($$& 6/$/!1!C6! /

!&57/!&/1!!!1!" ! !/ //!1!6! /6 A "/ !1! /

.!&5/ 1# )! &$ &!/!& // 6!/$ .!/&$ /%"/&" !(//

$ $ ( /&! ( / /$ $$6 'B&$(" 6!/$ / %/1/!$!&$ !/ !/1. /!&.//!!6//! $ % ( ! " / !.& ! ( $! &$ !/&! ("! $( /$

(/ //.!&//(!,! 6! /" $ $!.

/$ "$!$(./!.& / ,&&!"!$1! ! /6//! &!

< F

$ ! <

$ !

!.& /&! & < ( G (/ !6//&/,&!(H!

(/6! / ! !(H! 6/!//!&$ !/" ($$!

( /$.$! !1 /H! ((.&$(&/! (/ !&!!

$$!( /$.$! !1 /" /( -!1/6/!$$/$.$! !1 /1 , ( &/

$ !

$/$$ /$

! !/ $$/$.$! !1 /$.$! !16//1 ," /$$ $ ! /

$I 7/!8$.$/!8 /7/ >8 $

& !'&! .,010,2(0+&,*)0-(4*.1*.,2(0;(0+5+

.-,(1.1-*.+50*.6(*.1*.,2(0,6 & <:"!,/

$//!./ $.$/&$ !$$ (/ !1

$7/!$.$! !16/1/ ..$& '-'"6// !&! <

J).$! !1K !6/ $6! !/ !$& ( !6/!$6// / 6/! !(&!&! !1/!!

/ !6//1$1//

!(&.!&I % &!/! !1/&$&$/!1 &

! &/ $.//$$.$! !1"/ $ $ % /

0,010,2(0+& !"/>8 $ & !'&!/$//!

# $.$! !1$&//! $(!.!&!/

0.!"# /)0 //!6/ /!&/6!$/,/(7/>8 $

& !'&! &7, *.=50-(0*;(0+5+2( 0-(.,*4.+50*.6( 78*.9%,1.1*.,2(0 ! & / !1/$.$ ! !1/6/&

!& / !& !1/$!$( 6 "/& " ! /$% !1/16//!$ ("/ $" /$.$! !1"6$$ $ 7/ &!( !1&!/" !1&$ & ! / / %"/&"$ //$.$! !1 ! $ $ $ &! / % !(//(/&$ & /7/$"

/"!$($%$.$/! / ./!

$!$("/!.&//$!$( "1 (!!, )!&$ !/&! (& $( // !"/$/&./,!6!&!!/ /6!$1../!$.6//! !-= :$%! ./ /$/ $$( / / /6$$/ !/!6!&!!6!$1../!6//!

!7/!1!!./%/ ,&.$&7,501(;>*50*.1,2(0+;(0+5+2*07*4&-.?2 *.1*.,2(0! % :"/$/1,!&./! $/& $.$! !1!$/

$ / /! !' 6&$(6! /,!/6/6!$1.,$(6// !/!

/! $!6/16A !507*-4>*50*.1,2(0+;(0+5+ *@*2*0%*4&-.?4**.1,2(0+: %*@(0*41

! % -++*.1-.- -.0*.1,2(0+;(0+5+70-/&-.?2*.1,2(0+ -;-4::"/'&!/$/ < =/$$($ !$(5!

1$ .&! 6/ / ! 5./ !"&. 6/! ( $/7/$.$/! ( / !/ /C/$1I ,!.!/$6!/$$ *.1-.8& !7/! !"/$!7! &$/!./$(/$ /$ $ $/$ $!1 )!&$ !/ &! ( /1/$( !.&//$ ! &!(.$.

!"/! /$$/%/!.!" !/-= ;/! ./"(6 / ! &! /%0 @A-/ $$( //B&5 $& /$.$.!/!1. /

.1/$ (!1! 7/

.!&5"" .!1!/.$.! !&5./$!6/$.6!6!. /! %0/6 ! $(!.!% &!/!// !1! /

. !&5 / 1 ( / $! & 1$9&$.!";$/&!# !$( & /!/$$ 661/$"" !"

1 $ ! &!(.$.%$ / / 1 1 !! /6 .$./ ! /"/ !&!$( /.!& /$$0 !/!.!. &$$( -=5>505;-4**.1,2(0+;(0+5+>5.=5=*77* 2*.*.1 ,2(0+ -;-4:! 6/!/ >8 $ & !'&! .///!1!6A"/ $$5 $&/.$.%6/$/

. .1/ 1/! /! 6//!$1 /./ / &! ( / 1 5 / $ ! &!( .$. 6! % " $ / /! $$& 6/$"/6!!1! /

1/$ 7/ $ $$&

1$( & ( / 1 !!'$$& !&!$( &/ !1!/6! /

.1/$ /6 A 6!6 $/! /$ 7/ 6!5 /$7/! 1!! (!$"&/$$$& 6/$ //6! !1! /

.1/$ //! !1!"/!1!"/"/$( 1/ !$ !.!.& %0

# 7/! !"/ !&$!7! &$/ !!$(./ $ ! &!(.$.6$$/

$$& 6/$"6!/!1! /

1/$. / $!7! &$ /

// B&5 $&!/.$.!1. /!1!

.1/$!!/! (& /$7/! &//

.1/$6&$(&!6//

$$<&! ( /!1! /

.!&56/$.1$

1 $/ / !/ /!

/&! $("6// $1/ &! ( $ $( (/&!"/1 &7/&"/! !

$ (/&! (

! % '7 # " $ / 96!:&!6/$ C< !/ $! 7! &$6!& 3" "C<6/!/! L !

& !/ $. /$ $$ &$ !$ /6!& C3!6

&$ $! # 6

$/6

(!$/$$(" & "C<& &!$"! !$!6 6! )!&$ !/

$$!$& ? 6/!$ /& 6 / #C< !/! 6// 5 $ 1 ! / 6 (! $ @/ !( ! 96!:&!6$(

(!$/ 7/!1!!/ 5. ( & ! !. (/. /! ! >61!" / 6 $(/&6 7/$ / !6!$$$1.

./!%$ $6/.!&&!1!! (

3 //&6 B&6// $ &!!!15$$ 6!5!7/'&!3(1 *0/*+2*.1,2(0+;(0+5+ *7&*058*.1 ,2(0+ ' < "?? ?"// /&6 "6/6 ?(!$" 2"C< !/ ! 6//5 $/(! /

!5 $

# 7/6

(!$" $ !6$5. !/!/&/$%/ ! !&"!

! !/$

/ 2"C< !/%16 /.&$ >8 $ & ! '&! / *,-.*4 .+50*.6( 78*.9 %-7-,(1;(0+5+ 0*.*9&(,2-*.1,2(0+! -;-4<"

!& &&! ! /! L2C<

!/6

(!$/ "6// 5 / / 22C< ! / % !

,&. 1 /'&! *0*7=-,&-.?2*.1*.,2(0;(0+5+ -4)*?2 &-.?2 A *??* *.1 ,2(0+ -;-4 :< " &

/ 6!/

/ /&<6

$(.&$ $! #" !/ .&$/,&. />8 $ & !'&!

# 30'0'1$22" ( /$"/! !" " "

C<22A A7/$!$$ "C< / ! &!$A C<$ %!

/,&. />8 $ & !'&! *?7*(.(0*4.+50*.6( 78*.9%-7-,(1;(0+5+*.5 *74-*+25205 *7*.1,2(0:

-;-4 3 # /'&!

$&20- *7(.(0*4.+50*.6(78*.9%-7-,(1 ;(0+5+(*.,>*50*.1,2(0+'

$$/$! /! $ "C<& $ !$!&'$ !"/&"$$ "? "

C<$&!

< ) (22A A " "

C< ) "C< &!$A "C< ) !$!& "C< ,*4 "? "

C< 7/& $!(6!/

$$"

$("/$$& !/&$&$ 1

$$!$!/! 2 L !&! 6!& !/ $. / $$!$M

! & .$ /$$ /! A (/$!7! &$! 7! &$! ! &! & /$/$$&!

!! %'73 " / / ./"6 "C< !// ( 1!!!.!.)!7! &$6!&

3"#"C<6/!/! L !& !/ $.

/ $ $$ / &$ !$ / 6! & C3!6

&$ $! ?6

$/ 6 (!$/$$("& "C<&

&!$"! !$!66! 7// ./6$ (!$"

!&./ /($ 9-/!=!5 0$( +!& -! !( $! ! ;$ '/65" 0 .! 7/ $ E :$ %! ./ / $$( / !

& / ./6//;5 /!/! @A- 6 !&!! $//)!7! &$ /!!$(/$//!1 /A! ( / &// / C< ! / ,& / !& / !.. !"&6. &5$$$ &!!/ /-&, / / 6

C</ /./$(5$$$ &!!6 ?22C< !/ : .16/ "!&1!!$&. / 5 / ./"!,&A /2 C< !//6 (! $"!& &&! !

!%16 /.&$$6 (/>8 $ & !'&!

#30'0'1$22"& C3!

$"/! ( !!. / C<2 <

$(. &$ $! # ?" ( /$ "

"C< A A#7/$!$$ "C</ C< ! &!$A $ %! ,&. / >8 $ & !'&! *?7*(.(0*4.+50*.6( 78*.9%-7-,(1;(0+5+*.5 *74-*+25205 *7*.1,2(0:

-;-4 /'&! :::$ %&! ' ( ) *!& 05 /! /! 6// 6

3 #$.6/ $&20- *7 (.(0*4.+50*.6(78*.9%-7-,(1;(0+5+(*.,>*50*.1,2(0+'

$$ ! $ "C< & $ !$ !& '$ !" /&" $ $

""C<$&!

< ) ( A A# "

"C< ) !$!& "C< ) "C< &!$A "C< ,*4 ""C< 7/& $!(6!/

$$"

$("/$$& !/&$&$ 1

$$!$!/! 2 L !&! & !/ $. / $$!$M

! & .$ /$$ /! A (/$!7! &$! 7! &$! ! &! & /$/$$&!

! )!7! &$! / !.

/$! /$//$$!1/ ! 1/$ /&!B&! !! ! /.!7/ !116 /! ! /@.!,(:&!:6!"

*$&!-= "6/1/$! !@A- // ! !

/1/$6 "

"22 #7/&/!//&$ !

/ 1/$ "

?"? C< ! 1 @A-3 7/ $ ! 6

&!/ (/$E0./ ! ./ 7/

2 B&5 $

# )!7! &$"/&"6!& "3?"? C< !&./$1.1$& "C<$.6/ !/! L !& )!&$ !/

$$< &! ( / !.&//$!6&!6//!&! ("

6///!,/$ /6!/.!&//!1.

$ / !!1./!6 !&//$ /&$/1 /&! ( /$!/ 1 $ >1./!$!&$ !/ !../!&./ /!!"% (.!&6/1!!

!/ &. 6! 3 &/ !.. !"/!$

! &!(.$."/! !" !1/1 $ /&!! /$!%16 /&/ !.. !

! / . /$!7! &$// B&5 $&!/.$.!1. /

.!&5"

/$ $ & . &/$!7/ /.! /$( /$! B&"/6//! ! /*$&!-= "!1$/&!

./!7/ ! !!$(& $/ ! /!

$ 7/! !"/&" $!7! &$ /!!$(6! / ! /!$/$1.1$& )! &$ ! /

$$ < &! ( & $ &($$.$(! !(/6! 3 '73 =/ / 1 / &

" 2 22 !

2 ! %-+*-44

! " # 51?( ! =//! 5.C!

NC =//!! ! $