High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9276/2016allowed

Rajesh Kumar v. Chandigarh Housing Board Chd

2016-07-18Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal16 pages

!"##$%&%'( )

*( +, - -

""" #$%

& '$ ('

)($* + , -*. /0 -

& ' +$. / &

- . & $123 #)%

& &&& & 0 & & & 4& & 5 0 $167 & & 8

&&9/

)($'

#'%

& / &&0 4 4 !

(7 (7 )(('

4 0 4 5 ($ $$ )($) 8 4 /

: &

& / 0 & //0 0 #7% ;& 0 )((6 4 / 4 / 4 / 0

& &/&

8 0 / 4&& /& 0 & & #3%

4 /

& $70

$) ($ )((6 8 4 '$ (6 )($3 8

8 / &

/0 8< - !.#*-/ !0#&/12.!34-#'%3&&%&"!'"

> 5 $ $117-$113 > ) $113-1* >

$11*-12 > $112-16 > $116-11 > * $111-)((( > )(((-($ > )(($-() > )(()-(' > $( )(('-(7 ????? @' $$ )((7-(3 > $) )((3-(* > $'

)((*-(2 > $7 )((2-(6 > $3 )((6-(1 > $* )((1-)($( > $2 )($(-$$ > $6 )($$-$) > $1 )($)-$' > )( )($' + -$'. > +9-)($'. #*%

$117-13&&9/ )($'44/ 0

4 4 & / A< = 3 )2 (* )($3 2B$' +$. +.

$'+).

$166 && C8 < 4 /& =&&B $2'

/ &/0

8 && 8 4 & &&

& 4 A< &D 04& < & D 4 & 4 && & 0 /5/0 / #2%

8< & )$ (7 )($* + , -3.

& 4

& && /

&' / &

. & $123 8 4 4/ & / /& #6% & ' +$. / &

. &$123 -

#1% <0 )($7 &4 &&4

- ! " #$ % & # '

' ()* !

#$(%

&)'0

'$ ('

)($* / & 0 4 &0 )7 () $111 /0 && 4

A&&4 /- #<% ; > &0 & )3 0 D & 0

& 3(0

4> &0 3( 0 0 /E +. 4 > &0 330 4 /4&&

* 4 &0 3(0 &)3 0 D & 0

330 0/ &&05/0 0 > &0 &)3 0 D & 0

& 3(0 3(B33 0 0 / ' & / &0 / 4 & D D & 0

3(B330 0/ <> &0 & 4 & / &&4 && 4 & 4 &/&&4 360 4 0 4 &

4 /00,&

/D 4 5 0&& 4 0 5 & & &0 /& #$$% C &

D / > &0 4 /

& < / D

& / , #$)% 8 & & 4 0

& >

4 & &0 / & &04 0 / &4 & &0

&& 8 /& & 4

4 0 / & 0 /& & 4 & 4

4 0

&/ 0 & &0 /05 0 /& &

8 & &&&4 &/ 0 & F & 0 &0 / & 0 5 /

, /0 04 & 0 0 &

& 8 0 0&

&0 /& /& &0 &5 0

/&0 04

#$'%

& &0 < 4 5 &0/ & 0 0 &0 = &/ 4

&0 9 '$ ('

)($* )'0 )

&' )($7 0

4 & / /& &0 /0 4 4 )30 D & 0

3(0 0 / 8 4 40 0 / / /04 $30 )(0 )3 0 '(0 '30 0/ #$7% @ & / & 0 & )( 0 &

)'0 )

& ' /

#$3% 8 & &0 )7 (7 $111+ , -).

4 /D &0

/ 4 / 4&& * 4 &0 3(0 &)30 D & 0

330 0/ &&0 5 /0 0

> &0 4 &)3 0 D & 0

& 3(0 4 &/ &0 4 & D D & 0

#$*% @ & ,&/ & )30 + , -1B-). / / &4 &0

/ & &0 4

& & 0

4 0 && 9/

)($'

9&0 A< )2 (* )($3 4 2B$' 4

$2'

/ /

#$2% @ & & /0 $7 $) )($3

, 0 )((6

A< )2 (* )($3 8 /0

G-- G - '

8 &&

>B > < 0 )((6 4

& 0 & & HHH< =& >

/-)(($ 4 D 4 & 4

& &4 /0

&& 0 D

8<D 09 & &

8 0 & &

4 &

)7 (* )($3 / 4 /0 & :

)7 (* )($3 4& / / (((B-

& 8 &

D 0 #$6%

&&4 - +$.

8 &&

0 +). < 0 )((6 4

4 && &

&/0 04 & & 4 /0

&& 0D 8 4 /0D 0 4

0 & &0

+'. A< = 3 )2 (* )($3 4 2B$'+$. +.

$' +). $166 & & C8 4 $2'

/ &0 /& +7.

4 & 4

)7 (* )($3 &4 &: #$1%

G-- G & & / 0 D & 0

/ / $30 )(0 )30 '(0 '30 0/ & )(-)3

0 & 0 & )' 0 )

, -1B-) / , #)(% 8 / & D

&0 /&

&& 9/

)($'

8 4 0

& 9/ )($'

8 &D 0 0 )((6 & &0 & 4

8&0 & &/& && & A<

#)$% @ & &

!!"#$% &''( / &0 A<

& & & &0 -4&/&/,- 4 /& #))%

& & 4 D & & && 4 / /

&0A</ < A<4 ('

($ $117

8 / 4 /&

A< &04&

$ $30 &04 / 4 &0

/0 5 / &

& & < < &/& 0 8 4&/0 / 4 4 & &/&/ 0

&0 & 0/ -4 4 /&

;&&4 : & &0& - +

, + -

. +%''

& %

/ &

010(((2

& / 3 4

& /

. & - #)'% @ & &&0 8 / /& && & 8 0&4 &&0

/ & &0 0 4 & & )'0

4 /& & &0/ 8 & & D

4 D / & /

#)7% A && &04 & &0 / &0 4 0 / & / 4 = & / )7 () $111 8 / & / 0 / -4 0 / & 0 < &0 &4/ / / & '

/ &

& $123 #)3% 8 &

/& & 0 )((6 4 4 &4, && #)*%

&0 )' 0 )

F, A< & <A<&,/& && 0 40 A<4 )2 (* )($3

$2'

B&&/ &

#)2% 9

/ & / /& 8 /& // &// / & 8 '$ ('

)($* 0

/ /&& F / / && &/ 4 / < & 54 &&0 / #)6% <& < 4 4 '$ ('

)($* 4

'( (* )($* &/& / D /0 D ;

&&4

- $6 (2 )($*