High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1044/2015allowed

Gurbeer Singh v. Satguru Singh & ORS

2017-10-25Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan7 pages

! "

#$% ! " #" ! "

$#% &'()*#+,-.$*/**&+&. 0" % 1! 2!34

" "

! "! 56 2!34 #3!2!34

! 7."4$1 8 #&' "

3 !" 9!! !

: ""!8 44! "$ 1"- 2 "

' 4 "4""8 !5!4 "

"!% 7 3 ""1 8&

625 &! 62+ !9!629 3

$ " 0(; ! 1 9 3 4

44! - "!49"" 4<8"" 0(7 ;:7= "

!3 4 '"" 44! 2

3 ""!! "

.#7! ! 79"" !

0 4 > 1 "!4 ?? / 4 "

4 2 :@@ "

4 ' 9 ! 8 " !4"! + !3!6 - 4"! 9 """ ! 3!42 9!!"1 #"27 2 A4 9 " :B 1 1 "44 !

!1 1 "

" 3 ! 41

41 " 9!! . 3 ! !4" "! "!

< 4 " !"

8 " "!"

9 ! "

! !3

!3 4 4

"" "144! ! ! " 1 2 "1!"

"! 8 411! 4 1 " 9 13! 8 "

!4"!+ !1 3!6- 1 "

" "!44! 9"! 8"!1 9"

! 1 44! )! 4"

! ""

7 ! !48"

!4 4 ! < 4"! 111 9"3 3 1& 4 !! 3 !

4 "

!9!!"

! " " " )! 4" "

! 7 ! 41 !4"!9" 3! 32 !4"!

9"! 4 9<! " " "

! "2 2 " ""&

" !

" 15"29 "9 ! " ! 8 "2"4 4"21 "

! 9!! 3!

4 - !! 9! 41 " ""

! !48 ! !4"!

9"4 " !

"! 4 " " "

! " " 4 8 "38 - 4 ! 4 1 3 "

! " 4

4 9 ! 4 !4"

!"3"

44 4&' C$ " 1! ! 4 ! !4821

1 !"

! 1

8 41 1 44! " 11D"4 9"#" 7 A2 1<A7!!!4 "

C "" 1

8 "" ! !48 41" #" @= A! 8

8 1

" !4" &' C$

< 39 !4"!" 8"2 ""

! !4841""!%

@= C CE72=@2@ A "$

! "

=70)#@2 !"!% F - " " 1

1 1 !36 9!9 !4"!1 #5 "

! 9"" 35 8

8 "" 9 3 5 8 9 !4"!

! 115!

! 3 5 1" "

8 #"= A #"@ A 1 !

" "

8 #" 2 A #" 2 A 1 2 " 4"9 ""

!4"!9!9"

"! 89 ! 84 1 88

. "!1 ! 4 3 ""15 !"2 !" " < "

- ""23 8152!

" " " " 3"2 9 4 " 4 4 ?? 4 / 4 "4 2:@@ 3 8 ''4 ''- 2 3 15 "" ! ! " ! 1 1 !

G CC CC CC F

"4 1 9 15 "" ! ! " !4"! " 4 ! 3! 41 " 44 3 !

4 "1

8 ! 815.

" 4 411<9 ! "4 8

58" H " *3 154 ! 3

3!"

- 8 ""< !4!!34

1 1 " ! 1 8 - "2

" 1 " "

4 8 ! 41 " 44 3!!4

C 2 2 AG "$ #

$ % &'

() "

=0)#7?

2 8 !4"

&' C$ !"!% F: "

1<" 4

" 3" !4"!18

41 " . "!2 !" 4 "1! 9151! " ! ! ! ! 41 !4"! CC CC CC CC :1

"!4""2 4"

844 !!

" 39 " ! " !4"!23 " 9

8! ! !4"!29 ! ! 41 " CC CC CC CC

- "239 3"!4""" " 3 !

3"" 4 ?? 4 2 . ! ! 8 "" 4 1

! "2 15 1! "" !4"!2 9 18 " 3 ! ! 41 ! 41 " G .39 4 ?? 4 ! 3 !

!4""2 " 3"44 141 " ! 4 9 8!" 4 151 "$ * +

,- "

2 ? 0)#

?2 !"!% "!" H 1 :@

!4"!9" 8" ! "9 1 "9 "!!15"!

15! - < 3

? "34" #"

A- 4" " 1" "

4 " 4"-< 3

"34" #"

9 1

" !4"!2.9

< " 4" 1

"! ! 1< 3"

A 4 15"!! ""

4 G .39 !4"" !32 154 !

" ! 3!

4 6 39 4 " 4"2#" 2 A"9!!

4 - 9!! ! : ""!$- 7! !

: 7"1! ! C 1 #"27 2 A"

4! #" @2@ A " 1 4 141 " 44 ! 1 "44!2 4 !! 3 1 9" "1<2 4 9!" 1 84 !"

! . " 1 " " "44! 1 8 9

3414 !8 ""2

4 "!441" 4" 4"2 "!1!

1 #"2

2 A"9!!3!3 1 !89!!8

2"41 " - 9!! ! : ""!$-

! !: 7"1! ! C "1 #"27 2 A 9!!"41 " " 4! #" 2? 2 A - 1 "

! 4!1 9 " ?B

= 1 1 !

I 1 (

" 8

9! 3 1" (#&)

! "

1 "

<A"!

J"A # % J"A