Mehar Chand v. Union Of India & ORS

DHARAM VIR 2019.06.02 19:16 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document

  


      

  


  











 






 



 





  !

 

 

!

"#
#





 $%
& !#
#



'

(

!

  "

 #$%& '()*+,-.

)


*
 
%


  

+

*,

-,
"
)*#
%
.# %#

*,
-

)*

"

"



*,

"/

!
0


-,
" )*
#
12




!"
&3
- 


 4"
 5


-,
-








"#



&3
 -
%
"
&6


&
*,
*%

7 /+ 87&

+



*


-
"

"%



 
36

&
99/ '

2


7 

-,
!
&6 
*


+
 "






)

*,
-
 
 :78
#
&6#
-

 -
 
 "


-
%
"
&6

&




 -,
6

)
'-,



*,
%
- "

%

"
"


"

) -,
6










- %
*,

 


+




-

"

, -


,
%%





'

-, 
-

"


-





%
 
6
-

"


%




 *,#
#

-

*


,
"

"






!


'


-,
#
1 4 

*
 


;
;5

+

(




%

)*
"

-%
      


  

                  

        !

 "   

 

 # 
      

 !   )
"/#



*

"# <"

"/
 '


=
)
" 

<"
>
&

=

),

*%

 
"



  
#

""#

 $     %

   $    
*,
> #




> # 



-




 )
'-,

<"

>

  

"
&"

=
-
"


-

,

/ 
>


 

"
&6

8


  ,
)

-,



*%



 

*

"





-, "
,



-

-


*,


 


 ' 
3,

)

 

#
*%
-#

*
6
 %


*,

)*

)
)*

"





" 





-




%

 ,

"



=

-


 


",


>





* 

"
"






-
-
,
"% 
 

&6
-,
!




"



 
 +

*





"
% 

"





 



* 
%


%



-



, -

-

"%




! +454 5


#
#


-

*


 ,
"
"

-,



 
*6%
 
"<


% 
*,

)*#








 






=
",

#


*


# 

",#





-
%
"

&6

&
*,
*%


7

/+
87&


-

"






36
=





 "


&6
!
"



-,
!


 
-




6

 

&

!
%

-
#


*6

*

*
 
%#
-#




3,
) )*



 
"


%


 







"

",


=


-
6-

"


-



 ,
%

"
-

-
"%
*6#

#

, 

*

 %
?





'

<"







&6
-
 =



&


4*


&





 *


5

%



%
"
, * 
-


"6
#


*
*

 ",



 







6 
*

"


*,
?-#


*

 ,

*,

-,


 
%
 ;
#

)*

"





% %
-

 


-


"



#


"






+#
"%
*,




, "


 
*


#

"
-



)#


*
"


"%




6

"
6
--

 




%




'*%

"%
"
 +


*


%, 



",




'*%




-,

"
 "



+


 

, 


-
 "



+

)#

)*
 "


"



"%

"
"
 "




+
%
-,


"

 

% %
-


7 +
87&
-

3

"%
)# 
-






*

"

%
 




,
-




-
 ,



%
"



+





 
*-



=

= #

 
, 

*


,


*



-

 
%
"





%


"


 
3,
-



-


 

! +454 5







"
-

*

 
"

)
)*



"
<



" 





=

=




 
"
-




-

,


 %#
 #
,

"


,-

8#
7- 
&6#
-
-
 ,


*
%%
 6-%






-
*%




"
&6

&
?-#

=




" 




6






)
@
-
*#


-


"




"

%

"



-
 * 
%#

"


*




6


"


-

"

"

* -

*





'-,A
)
- 

*

%
)





*,

-,
 

-
,%



-,

-


- "%


%
%
-



-

*,



)
,










%

 

)



*
<"
* 

)*
* %


@,






-

>
-  "


,#
-
%

-,
#

*

 *,

#
-#

>#
-


*
<"
%
 
@,


*
<"
* 

)*



=# 






,


"

- -
%


 "
 "
"



-
,% 


-,

"






+
)#
 





 



>


 




"
#
-
-
%

  "

 #

,
 "


>


"
- 



"


@,

-



 -
* 

)*
)
#


%%


-
 ",

=

=



 
*

, 

*,

-,#
-
,
#


  

)*


"

*


A



 %

 





"%


 "#
 <
@
-
*
-
-

%








-
*
*


A
)
-


*


 %
*


"%


-

"

- 
*


-
%
-
,%
%

 




-
*
*



%

 "


)

,



,
 



?

*






*


"
 #

"
-

*


#
*




-,
 






%

B
-
*#
-, 

-
,




-



,
* "%







""
A
?-# 









 


#



 
*


-

-,

,

*

*,
 )*


"

*
'



) )*

"


-
"%

 

*,
% 
-,



6




*

"
 *,
-

-


)
%


@


-
 
-
%
"
 


+
-
% 
6


%
-
"
*6
"
 +


 "

 
*,
%

-,


%

6

*%
 
-



"
 
 A
C
@
- *
-,

-
%

 +










"
 
 A
)


-


=


 


6
"

6
--
-


  




*


"
 
 # -
",
-

%
-
&#




D
3
-



  




%%



%
*


*,


)


 


3,
-


,




- 
*


*,


)
3


-
-
 
6#
"*



)

*
*




"


"%
 




"
-
%
"
%
6 %
(

*


*


#
-

 ,



*,#

)*

"




 

,
*
*



"


%
 *

-






"%

*
%

?-#

*"
"

*


-,

% 


%

*,

)*



 

 %,
*
-

",
<"

"


 

-
,
%

*,

-,

 "





-,
%
D



"
 
#

"
"%

*



%

 *

-,



"

"
)#


* ,






*6

%,
* -
 ,








*


*,
 

%

3


%%


)#

",

-#

%

*,
 )*



"


-
(


<


E,3, 

,(3% 45 3,% +43"6 2 #/.

#343&.

#




",

%



*,


-,
"
-

*

 


3



-




%
*#
 
"
"#



*


"
*

6
-


3





%

"


-
 


% 
*
-
*


"
-
 *
%
*,
%








#

 *
-
 


-,
)


*





-


%
"





#

6

*

*
 



,



,
%

-
#
 




*%%



#

< 
-
"
*,

-,



*,


 


-


*,
-
 

*

# 

6
-

#


*
"


-
6 % !




#


*

*# 
-,




#


<#
 "

"


"%

"
-

 -

%

-,
 
",

-#


* 


-


3



%
" 

,
*





3
*,
,
%

"


)
-





%

 +
- 

-


"
 






"%



)*
 @


#


<#


 +
-

* 





%


"/ 














*
6







%





*
6

-
 -

"%

!
 +45
4 5



#

#
 "
-
*


,
" )%


"

#

,
" "

"


!



-,



-

4"5
#
 #
-


:6
*
 "

*


 1
:6
-



"

2

)
<
@
-
*
-


-
* 

"







" 
)



%
 


"

* 


*,

?;*
!"


3,% +43 #5'8$%.

)
!"




 '   "% ( 
      "

 

         

  "   

        
     

 ) 

(  (  

 ( 
        * (

%



       ( *   

      " 



        (   +
%     "    (   

  

 "     

    !

  ,  (


- 

 . 

    (


 

  +




 "* /(0 $(  1 
& 

   2  (


    

      ( $ 

3( "

 
  (   .
  

               

 

 





 



    %


   
      * (

  

(  

(   %   (     4 )%

<


3,% +43 #5'8$%.

* 


"




"
*






 
-


)*#

%


-

*
%

 "#
-#





-

*

*, 
)*


"


*
"

 "
"

*%
-
*,




 

*,


)#

",
#

"
*
 



%





*
6

 #


"
*





%
-
 -
*




,
"

 1
:6

 #

%
"

*%
-
)#




 /
-
*


 1
:6

" %-





 F

"

*

"









,"

(
%,

)
"


*


@

*,

 "







-#
-#

 -
*

-


# !

  .

8$3&  "

7      =
6%/ $ =
* $