Punjab Health Systems Corporation v. M/S Nagarjuna Construction Co. Ltd
!"#$%&'()(*#" ))"" +( ,-( '( '. /)
0 1
!"#$%&'()(*#" ))"" +( ,-( '( '. /) 2 0 1
!"#$%&'()(*#"#())"" +( ,-( '( '. /) 1 02 1
!"#$%&'()(*#" ))"" +( ,-( '( '. /)
(
(+$#(&*$(34# 5"6 (*3 (#))""
( $/*3 (#()
8#(( &#"") ())" "# &)"%((- (4(()
(""#'(( (( "!)"* &(( ( + $#(&* "( $( ' " % 5"6 (*"( "))(- #"
#))"" & # " )( # ( ( 1 4 29* 9* *
,:8#&)"4 )
!43(* & " ;#(-(4-3* "&"%*
)2 2 2* #'((" #4(<&)"** "4(< (" ( )4% &)"8# -#* ))"":&)"%(3<#" (< #"= &- % -#& #( 2 * ,:)( %# - ""4& $#)(4(3( 4# (-( ()3 "&* "" # ) 4( ( (( # ( ((-#-3 %#/>) /34>;)( # ( " 3- # )(( ( ( ( (* # #) %/>#3- "((3 * #&(* (&*4( ((#( ("8( "- #( ( (( 8# ( (( (( "% ""4 # "&
( -# *9*11*2,:"-4# ?&) (
)(#)(3 '" 9 #(8#(
()#&"6)-34#4 ""(#&(< 4""# "#(#) - %#3( -* (# "#3 &(#0?&)"(8#( (" ( "" ( ((-#( &4## ""%4((3#
#"&= &
0#( -@""#(( "% )8#( ("( "" (( ((" (%#& 2 * * ,:"-4# ( ()%&
* * ,: (&)" # (% 4""*#)(&#" ( #(((&"""#
(#3 <( *3(#( 9 * ,:)( &# ( -#
'""( %((4)(&* # (( "(""%4# %)(& #()(# * * ,:* #( (* ( # ( * ,: )( &# !
(#( &##(# &(- #(& #(4##"
-( (#""-)( )(3 $21 #A# <() #&(*# 4( "4(4-#) ")"%*& #"* ;& #&*)())""B)
( (&# )""-"% #) ( (#4( # ( (("& #)(#4#(4( "34 " & - )""-"
((*( $/*"( "))(- #"
() (- ? #(# " 90* * ,: )( * "-" * * ((B ? # " & 4(< 29 9 (( 4 (( * (*& (4(<#"(% 8#((# �#( -@""4##)(#)(3 #(& #(# ( %#>-(*4#(# #$"3"(-#"%*"&# ( 8# "&)( *"-" 8#' ((:))(# 34### "<; %#( ((*3
(&
()34 ( "" %!B " $ )(&' (
!"4(
( (&)""-"%4 " ""4##( "" %!B "$ )(&' ( (" ) %(+$#(&*$(3 #$%&' ( & ) *
* + ,( '&) - #()(& "34 ( "" %!B "$ )(&' ( - $ # % ./ 0
) . &%& & )
%
+ * #( (*"#& # #))""#""-# &) -(>3'&) -(43(""-( )( (#( ((*#( (*#))""& #3 43)(#)(3 $1 00 #
(-#' (
(&# - (#""- 4( ""-4##("& $21 00
A#3#("( " (#)())(# ))( < 8# -# # ( "
#*(- & ( +$#(&* "($(' """4-#&) -("""& #( ?"<3(%(3 --#( -##(& #()( "("%'" 9 4##( ()( #( "4 :
1 "
2&
&
3
4
3 )3
&
%
4
& 3# &
) & 3
3 &## 5 # 67 4 &
4# &
3 )##' 89 & 3 )
4
3 )3
' & 6 )
&
3 :
&#
&
&
%
)3 )3 4
9# ; & ) &
%
:
)3
&
' & 6 &
4# &##4 &
&'
&
3 :
&#
& 3 4 3 &##
3
) &
< 4
&
3 = & 3 ) & > #;
)3
4
9# + ' & "6 )
& > #
'
3&% &
&
%
)3 )3 =
* &
) & )# ) & 4# ?
4
' & &
& 4# &##4
&
3
34
&# &
& (44
< @4 ## 4)
&
4 '&3& & &#&
42& 4 ) & 9# ' & 4 53 &
3 :
#
# ! & ' A &) (*"%#(& "" "# #(& #(*)(& " A#3-#( -##4( #( ((;
--3 %#( ((*-(-#&)#(
*9*11*2,:3::3"& *& &"- #(-#3 (-#)% #)(- (#( (("" )#&)"%()( 0#@"" & %#((* ")( #&*4#($)()(# && 4###(= (& "4A# ( % # >-(::'# * # * 3 # (( # -
&)#$&"("%*#("(-(-(" # (%* &% 34* - # ( (( )( * "-" (("<#(
# (%-3 (#( 4(<& (% #4(<(-(/*3# /-(-#"= &-&) %#)(&* 2 * ,:)(%#"#" %#( (( #)(&#"%4(<& -90* * ,:4" # * 4#"))"%- ?##"&#"# # )(& ( 4# (& # (3 ( -#((8#( ("( " -;)(* - #(( ((#3-#&(;3"%8# ' (#(&#( #))""' ((:;&#
3 34 ( "" %
: 3 4 !43( # ) "( ( & #*A& #34#4(- #(C ? &) "" # "& #-#"% )#&"* & # "* ( (-# ( #(-*A"" )(/*3
(-(-#4#(-((#(
(&#"* ("%-( (( #(#( ?
)( & &) (8# (/* 3))( %#' ( 6)- 34 # (& * 4( # ( (("""&( )#" !43(*#(& #4(""#"& #""#"& &)"(C?)8#(#"" &) ( D## (&& *""))"()("% ""4 8#(#"" #-# ( " #( " !"!! "# 4'
$%&$% '(% )*+,- % '.+%/0 %'-.
$%&$% %(.
& %0 %'-.