High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1071/2015disposed of

New India Assurance Company Ltd v. Kuldeep Singh And ORS

2018-04-27Mr. Justice Rajesh Bhardwaj10 pages

! ""##! $ %#"&'( !( "

%#"&'( !( ""##! $ ) & * *! ! !( "

!"#$%&'() $'&)$*&+(

! " !#"

+ & ""#,*

! -

! ./ 012340/5.1 + & ,*

! -

""##! 012340/5.1 -

! .!

3 0.54.0/5.1 ',-.-*,/0% () * "! ""#(*)!6"!

'!( ) !( ! - ! .5../5.2 " )7 +

! #8 )#,&&' ,+ (#9#! -

:!( )#;<,( )7

#8!,%#"&'( # !( , ##

./,=5,555>0-

!( - &'(,() #8!0""##! /0 #? % , -!( #8!0""##! 30+! #

#8!0""##! .0%#" &'( #, 8

*( #

! !( ) & * *! !) ' '!

! 05.3003@34 / #8! (* -# ""# 9 12340/5.1< 6' ( 8!

(# --'*( #

! ( '(! !!' - " )7 !( )# ")$ ('1 3 #8!(*

)!(8 -

!" /2

#8"!! ,( ( - ## A0 ! "

# $ %# & #'#() * # ! ##" +) " "

#, )))) - ' " " .+ !

# /##0-

" !1 ! !1 "# " !1 " ) 2 ##1

# # !

# ! 3 )

14 "" 3 ) 0 1 #

) " ! 3 1

*)# 5

6"# " ! " ! - ' %'07 "

# - ' # &

) # 3 " ! # "# " ! "1 ! ! # 1 ) ##! " ) * 11)# #1 # ! # * 1 # "

%# & . 0

*)# "# " ! " !

"! # ! "! # 8 2 " #8!, !( 21 7 - ' '4555>0" 8 !(# 7 "! --

8! ' '!(

!, .5B ! .=54/5.3 '! !

# &!! %( ( )# (# !(!

! !

( '#'! *' - !( --' *( # )7 ! * ("# &'( "

! 1 0.54.0/5.1 "

! / 012340 /5.1< /C(!( !( #8"!! !8!)#DE ! "

!( )# !( -' !(

'! , * --'*( # 1 !( ""# 1 1 -# )7 - !(

--'*( # () (##'* -- !!(! #8! *'" -

! & 13 8"# 7;&!! !,.B2@9#! -

C!(& !E<,

#8! )

8 *'

* 7

!( # ""##! ( ##' !(! )# ( '

*#7

(# '

' "!

- 15,555>0 -

8 8"# 7 0& (

# " -=155>0-

! )7 #8!!( - &'( '

-(8"# 78! -8#7 ( ) '

& !, !(7 ! !!#!

!(+

$( # ! = (* ( #

# -

" ! (* " !( "" 0)

-!( )#!(!( ! 4 - !( --' *( # (

8 " !( !( ""# 1 1 '!("#!(! #8"!! !8!)#" "

* -& 13 -!(& ! @ " # - !! !!8! -# )7 ""##!0

9 8"7)-

!( )#,-!(! ("# !( "#7! ( !( -""##!0 8"7 "#7-#)-

!( )#!(! #8!(* #87

!( - &'( !(& !, (, #8"!! )

& 13 & ! B

# -

#8!0 "

! . !

3 (#

) *! -* ( -% !6'( !

, ( ' !(! "

()! ""# (

#8'!8"# 7 -!( !( ""# ! -#'! --'*( #(# 87!!! !

) *!

! ( -!( !

!"#$%!,( # 8# *()!6 .5

""##!0 8"7( #"

) *! - ;)#"F ! -

&' (

$ ) *

+ !"!""

! -(

!! !(! !( ' !

8"# 78! ? , #8 "!! "

* +

$( # ! !8!)# .. # 7 ,""##!0 8"7( !!6 7"#)-

!( )#!(! #8"!! )

& 13 !(& !, (,!)

8 '!("#-

!(- !!8!( ""#&

#7,!( *

!(! #8!(*'

!7 )-! !(& !-

8!(8"# 7 ./

G0. &'(,

!! - )# & (

# ( !!!(!!( (

#'*! -15,555>0!

-8#7 -!( , ( !8"

78"# 7 -!( (

#8 ! -15,555>0'*)7 !( (

-8#7 -!( !

)!"" !

)

(8! ! ('

! -" )7&

! !

-8#7

-!( # !

!(" '

-8#7 !( " "

* -!(& ! .3 -) *

, ",! ! # -

8!(- ! !(!!

(!( - !6-

!(- !!8""#

!("# # )-

!( )#!(!"!! )

& 13 & ! ;)#"F !!(! ((#- ## A0 $ *" : !

1& ;&$ '

" ! " ! "1 ) " ,*< =) 1 # "

) )#1 310 #

## # ! !> )#1 ) 1 ) > >1

) " > > ,*< =) ?

57 ?

61# "

> 0 >)#11#"

#> #@ ! # , #:)

# )

# ))

1 ")! 1 #"

# 0 #1)

" "3 )!

##"" 3

) " " * " 1 "

* ) )#1;&$ # ) ,*< =) , ) ( "= " # " ! 1 & ))#

) #1))##,*< =) #8 .2 G(#"

' -""#,+

!#8 )# !!

6 !!!#8! #8!)7!6' ! -& 13 & !(* ( - ;)#% !6'( ! , "( ) *" 1 -!(?'8!- ## A0

)#1 0 ) ! 1 # " )#1 ) 0 # "

"#1 #10 #1

)# 1 + A # 0 # )1 "

"! #0) & ;&$ # )#1#1

) # " )#1 $ ) ! # # ))# "

"! # " )10 )!

& ;&$ # 1" ) BB8 .1

! ( - !( ! 9% %, < , "( ) *" / -!(?'8!- ## A0 $

# ))## # + 2 # & ! = ' #!"1

&)=( "=

0 &) =

- ' #&./

$ 0 # 1++2 2"!3 #3 & ! )#1 " # #

0&)=# @ ) # )) # " )#1 "

! #

# # 1 $)")9 3" &)=#

) &) = " # # " )1 " )#1 # 0*

" # ))##

C !

' .* ( " = 0

1 1C !

' .#( "= * # * 0 4 *

1 $

) ! ' !# 3 ! " # ;&$ # * " # " )#1 ) 31 +A # ) " " :

# ;&$ 0 # * # !

5 * 0

* 1! "#$%& )# )#1#1 )#1 31 )# # 5

# 6 # ) ") +A 3 $ ) # " ! * 1 C !

' # ) 8 .= * -) *!!#"

! -#,8

" !(!!() -7"#')-

!( )#!(!!( #8 "!! )

& 13 -!(& !H) -7* !(!7

() #8-

! -

? !( - &'(#!!#) *!(!!( #8"!! ! )

!(+

$( # !'!!(!

!0-

,!(""#9 0 .54.0/5.1<-#)7 8"7( 8 ! !( .4 ( )# !(

- ./,=5,555>0 !

#8!-

!( - &'(,( (

8"!- ## A0 9< 8 -!( &'( 9< ' -!( 217 )7!( )# 4.55I./<J @1/55" 8 9< #

8 -!( 9*< # #!-! ""#7'!( 8#!"# -.2 @1/55I.2<J ..B/@55 9*< 35K -9*<!

-! "

" ! 9..B/@55L314@25<J .115=25 9*< .>3 - 9*< ! !

" # F" .115=2501.=@@5< J.5334=5 9*< -

- #F" /1555 9*< -

# -# *-- .55555 9F< -

!8 .55555

2 -,..

2 .@ ( )!!(''

" -2.!

217 ( )#(#

8"!'8 !

( 35K!

8 - !( !

-! "

" !

/,/1,555>0 !(

*! #(,( (" #!!#)7 ;)# "F ! -

&' ( , .$ # .

2 " &" +, !

) !

! !

/1K 45,555>0 " !*#7 .B

# -

#8!0""##!

(- #7

!(#!!#)7 ;)#"F !

? # . , " ( )# ( !6

8 - !( "

* )7 #8!, (, !(

" - ( 8!

/1K!

8 -!( !

) 8 !

-! "

" ! !( 8 !

*! # ( -

!8, # - !! - # F" # !

) !

! !

45,555>0 (

( (

#8! !!# - ## A0 9< + !(#7

8 - !( )7!( )# 4.55" 8 !( "

" ! 4.55L.441<J @@41" 8 !( 9< /1K - 9< ) * !

-! 9< .>3 -9<) * !!

" #F" @@410/B1@<J 1B.4" 8 !( 91B.4I./I.2<J BB251= 9*< # #!-! ""#7' !(8#!"# -.2* -' 9*< #

!8 25555 9*< !

# -!! .1555 9*< !

- #F" .1555

& 2 2 /5 M# -87) * ,!(""#9

< -# )7 ! ( 8 ! !( 8

"! -!( )#8 -!(

## #8! -

!( - -.- '34 -

8 02 0 51 !

020 251 M!#7, !( ""#

-# )7

#8!6'( 8!

,( 8 !!(8 8 /. 8"7 )' - !( --' *( ###"

!!(( #8!0""##! ./!( )6

"7 !( 8 !(

'( 8 -! ( ( #8!0 ""##! 3,( 8

,##)"

! 8! #N)6

-F"

!!##!(" (!!8?

!7!,( * ,8 # !(!!()687!6!(

8! ' '' -8

M ! !(!8 -"

! -!(8 !!(7(## !)6!

) '- (

8!( )#!

'!!("78! -!(8 !"

!( 8-! !(! -( !!'8?

!7() * () !

* #8! -

8 7 ( 8! !

,!()6##7'*!

) '!(

- )#!

'!!( "78!*-! 8

#8!(!!' -8?

!7#8! /0&8! #? % , )' 8 !( ! # ' - 8

#8! (##) !!# !

'! ! ! !(( - 8

! !( )6, 8 !(#7, M ! #7, (#- 7 #7

# ), " (

* !

8!F" -( )

'(!" // !(*! -8 -7 #8!)-

-! "' - ,

-(>( ( (##)"!

**'

#8! /-6

0 '&)$*&+( ?6 %&*$ , )* "/ D / ,)# D /