High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1073/2015dismissed

United India Insurance Co. Ltd v. Jaspal Singh Rana And ANR

2016-04-21Mr. Justice A.K. Sikri11 pages

! "

#$ %

""""##"

$%&''

(# ')* & * """"& "

'!! % (# ')* & """"##"

$%&''

&+* , * """"& "

--- (

)*( + ++

." $# '* / 0 * ## 2 3 " 4 3 "

2 3 "

." *5 / 0 * ## 2 3 "

4 3 " 2 3 " 4"

." '*+#/ 0 3 "

2 3 " 4 3 " 2 3 "

--- +

+ . 6* 5 ""

7 .

# 67#/ *)* 21 * / 8* 67#94/ 7 0 1 5** .

3 "

"" * # ' ::

1 * .

$*# / ;

* / 8* 1 ;

94 1# 7 (# ')* & 2# ##4 5 ## 5/ * )0 * 5 # 7 0/ 1# 7 *

5* 5*

7) ) 3 "<= !; 2*1 1 * 11) 94 5 * * 7 (# ')* &/ * # * #1"

<# / * 1 * ;" "

7 "

"/ (# ')* & 2# 4 5*# ) ) 1

* + 1 ' :

* + 1 ' / *)* 7 1 *

#/ 5 * 7 * 11) 5* * 5 * 11 #)* 1 ' :

5 ) * * 5 ) )# 1 * " > ##) 5 * * 11) 5 7) 0 *# / )#)# 1 ? ) * #)* * + ) *

@) * / * # * 1## * ## ?" * / 1 & 3 "

" "

5 ) < # ' ' /

*)*/ ) * 0 1 * 11) " ' ::

1 * 1 ;

5 1# 7 * # ) * 0A

5 1 * 11) 5* 5 # # )

1 * ? 7 * "

6* 5 7 * 7 1#) 5 " & 3 " * 0 #0) * " & 3 "

) ## # 7? 0#7# * * ;

##) * * * 7 1# ## 5* " 7 #) # 1 # * 3 "0 * 11) 5 * #) 0# 110 0) # * 1 * 11) 5 7) 0 0 # 1 * # "

* 0# 1 * / 5 #" = * * 0 *) * 1 * * "

) * 0 0#7# * 7 7*#1 1 * / * # 67# ## 5 * 5

* 1 &"/:/:A * # # )5* * 1 :B 1

* 1 1#) * ## #C "

#) ))0 1 *

5 7 # 67#/ *

1 # "" 3 "

" # 1#) 1 5* *

5/ # (# ')* & 1# # "" 3 "

6* 7 7 # # 1 * *0 7 * "

/ #$/ % * 0 / # # 1 * ##

) * * 0 1 * 11) 0*# 0 #0 * 5 * # / * 50/ *

## 1# *) * " 6* 0 *

# 0 # 7 * 5** 0 * * 11) 5 * 0*# 0 #0 * 5 7D# 5* * #

0 E

" * 1 # )) * 1 & %E"</ * # * +/ # 1 * 0*#/ 5** * * " 6* 0 5 * 11) / &+* , / 7 * #1 ) * 5 E &F / E &F &+* &#/ '/ * 0) 11

1 * / 5* 1 * * 0) 0# * * 11) / 5** 5 . '51/ 5 0 #0 * 1 * * 1 * # ) * " 1/ * 11) 0*# 0 #0 * 5 6 '1 5** # 7 / */ %E"& 5 1# *

* 1 &F / # * # 5 ) ) * 0 5 1 * 11) 5 * 0*# 0 #0 * " 6* 1 * 0*#/ 5** * / 7) 7#*/ * # 5 #

* 5 1 * 11) "

* ) 1 # # 1 * ##

" # 1 * 1 & %E"< * 5 * *

# * #/ * # * 0 ## * ) 7 1 * 0*#/ 5** * * " > 5 E

* 1 * / 5* 5 0) * 11) 0*# 7 * ) ## * * 5 1 * 0 1 7 )* 71 * " F*

* # * 5 7 E/ * * *

* #/ * * # * + 1 * 11) 0*# G6 '1G" * 0) 11 &F &+* &#/ ' 5* * * 1 * * 5 7 6 '1" 3 5 5 7 * # * 1 1 * 11" 6* ) 7 1 * 11) 0*# * 1 & 5 11 1 1 1 * 0*# * * * " %0 1 1 * + 1 ) * * # * * 1 * 0*# G6 '1G 5* 5 G. '51G/ * 5 # *

5* * 5

7 #) * ) 7 1 * 0*#" 6* 1) # 67# * * 11) 5 * 0*# 0 #0 * ## 1 0 * # 1 *

7) 0 "

/ '!!/ % ! # 1 ### (# ')* & ) * # 67# < 3 ";

1 * 5 * <F

@" '* <7 * 0 * 7# 1 %E"< )

5** * # * 11 7# * E B D 7 * # 5 # 7 5** 5 #+# 0" */ # 67# E 1 5) &"

/A 1 # 1

7# D#

* ### 1 # ) 11 7 * * # "

! # * * ## 0 ? 7 *

: 0 # * 1 * # 7 * 5 +) * 7 # 11 * ? 11 7 * " 6

* ) * # 1 ) 7 ) * 5 * 7# 5 # *0 * ?

+ 1 * # 5 + ?

7 1*/ # # # * ?) 7 *

!"! #$%& ' (

) * +, --. (- #$%& (/ (

5 # ) * # 67# 5 *) * * # E 5* ) * 7##

)

E # &"/ /A 7 7 * # *

1 &" /A * 7 7 * * 5 *0)

# * )* * # 1 5** * 5 )

&"A

*" %0 *

1 &" /A # 7 1

* # * # 5 )

1 &"A

* 1

* 5 +" 6 * ) / # # # % ) 0 1 2 ( -#/& +3 (

1 &"

/A 5 * * 1 11) 7 * # 5 "

/ 0 1

* 7# 1 %E"< * * * # 7# 1 * ## 7 * = 1 @ 1 <H.%&/

*)* 5 B" 5 * 1 * * 5 #+# 0"

3 ) 0 4 ) 0 (

#(& 33 #&

> G7# '

*# 8

& %#7 ) * * 1 ) 11 1 * 7# * # ) / > G7# E

< 3 "

1 &? , G 24 *# 8'

(

;

)

*+"

(

-++"

*+"

* */ * )* * 7# 11 7 * ## 5 B 7 * 1 * * 7 0 * *) * * * * 11 * # * 7 # 1# 71 /

" * ) 5** * #0/ # 67# * # ## 5 *

# # " *

/ * * 7

1 # 1 ) ) * "

1 # 1 ) / *

7 * * 5 # *0 11# A

* * " 6* 7# 5## #

* 5 5* * 5## #

+ 1 5 ?

7/ 1 * 1

* ?

) ## 1/ * 1 # 7# 1 * ## B" 6* ## 5 )) # 1 &";/ A

* * 1 " 1 1

7/ * ) 1

5 0 7

* B 1 * # " 6*

* ) 1 : &"/A

*" 6*

*# # * B 5 #

A * # # 5 #

&"/A" * ) : / * ## 1 G;G 5 # 7 *

* 7# 11 7 * ## 5 + &"

//A"

5 5 7 # 67# 1 * 7# 11 7 * ##/ *

## 7 0 *## 7 *

5 * * 1 # 1

* * 1 # 1 " ! 67# 5

/A 1 * 11) ) 7 * ## &"

/A 1 # 5** * ## 1

0 "

70 7 # 67#/ 5 7 )* 7 * # 0 * * * &"A

# # * )* * # " > # * 11 # 7 # " 6* 1 * ## * * * 0 &" /A 5 7 1 *

# E 7 * * 5 * * * 0 *

" 1

" > * * * 7 &" /A ) * 7##

) &"/ /A # 7 7 7 * 7 ) 7## " */ * 1) 1 # 67# * * * 7 7 ## # E 7 * 11 "

)# / * # 1# 7 * ### # ## 5 * 5 ""

7 # 67#

1" 6* *

1 &"

//A *## 7 7 *

5* 1

* 1 1 1

1 * ?) 1#) 5** * ### *## 7 # * *

* 1 "B 1

* 1 1#) * # ## #C "

! " $