High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3433/2017allowed

M/S Bharti Enterprises v. Union Of India And Others

2022-09-07Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj11 pages

!"#$%$ &' ()(

*' +,* ( -. -( /////

! "#$$% !& ' #( % !& '# )# # !%)!"(* ' +,- ))**% !& ' ) ( !#% !& ' . ///// . -( 0(1 2 #"!*0# $'* ( &* --1--2'#"(' 34( &'5# ( ' " ' 6( #4 # & ' # 4#&(7 8('.%19%1:1 ;<(

-= - > &(* 4 $# *' ' # & # #4 4 #$(' *45# & 8 * # & # & $7 -!# $ '8#*4$*'

*'& 8 *$# *'' . ($8

# &6(#$ ($8 $7#% &88(& 5 &! $7 # ?1?--?+@ '8 # ''& ' -5#$7#5 &* (&&'(*

*' && &5 &!7 # '(#& # ## #' **8 8 & ' # * ' **8& & +:?--?+@'*'4#' '#6( 7'& # & **8 5 *! +??.-?+@ 5# ** &35* 48 ## **85 $ $' --?.-?+@($8# # !' ' *7 & ' * 7' 78 # #& *&(* #

## **8 *45# *7'9%99@A +B'#$ * & 78#(4# 8 ' ?@?@-?+@ '8 34 ( C(8'#&(7 8('.%19%1:1 6(5 8 $7#'348 # # **8 *45# *7 ?2?@-?+@ 5#&# 5 #5! && '# # #* # **8 *45# *7' * 7 785 ?D?@-?+@ 5 & $7## # 8 '6(#

$4 ?@?@-?+@ #5 ( # 8# &?D?@-?+@5 #* 7 ?1?@-?+@5 ( 7%# 786(5 ($8 #<534

7?2?@-?+@!5'"* (+++;='#48 #(& # #5 ' (* # $7!('

&+?'#) *"* (&%+9:2 4&8( '8%' 7 && 46( $( 3$7 &$ 7 '#"(''& &* # 7# * 7'#&$ %# &#& 4# **$ & 3 (8' 3#<

7 '5 5#&##"(''& . & # # # ! ( # ' '## ?D?@-?+@ ?1?@-?+@ 5#* 7 #''&5 534 #(& # # **85 5# *78 8$*( "* (+++;='# 48 @ $# *'' # $'* >

&(* 4$# *'' +,-# &

# # **85 $ $'--?.-?+@5!% ## # ( **8(?:?@-?+@ # # 8 ' ?@?@-?+@ 5 &! # ''& '

-! * ?2?@-?+@?:?@-?+@&% #5 * 7'+9 7&!4## **8# & # #* $4! 7$''#

8 '( ?@?@-?+@% #* '&!4'# 8( *45# *75 ?D?@-?+@#'(#& # #6( # 485$( 3$7 . #7# ! 3 &# &# 8( 5 * %#&(7 $7# ! $'' D ))**% !& '# $# *''

. & # "* (+++ ;=

"* ( +D ' ) * 8 " '

(&% #

* ' +@ 7 5 4 5# * ' # .! #4# &&# 78 % # *'#*5(* (8 & **7 & &** #

87&(7 ** $*$'' $7#

4 8 1 '&8 #&* ( (

! "#$%& ' !!

( & &

( )( ) ' &

* ( ! "#$%

' &

( #

("$ (+ , , ,( ! '

)

( -

% & '( )*+

' '

% ( -)*+.

/ ) -* 0

#( '

. & !

( ( ,(

/ 2

#( 4( # #5 ' (*# '

54 # * 75 ## '#% # $7# (#''4#&(7

! * && &5##8'#& & '(#& # #8'#& &%#!' 7 ( ''&* 4 '#8'# *%# 85 ' $* $ ( "* (.? # ## * !8 7 ! * $*#8 &# # $ 9 # !# * &(* 4$# *''# &! # !4#(4##* 4 5** & *45## : # (#& # # **8 6(5 $ $'--?.-?+@ #4 & '+@ 7< ?D?@-?+@ #& '# # &?D?@-?+@ ?1?@-?+@5''&#* 7%##

#6( ' 5** # *7'* 78 8'#" &"* (+++;=?2?@-?+@%#5!%# && # 78 "6(*7 5 #&& (# # 5 &8** # 8 ' *4 5# #

#'* $7# %#7# ! 3 * # ?D?@-?+@5 3#* 7 (* *7%# 78&(* # !$ #7# !&#

#' & 5###''&5 &* # 7 (#8% &'& !8# *$8 ## ## &# # . *45## 78?2?@-?+@*' # #7'( &&# 8 # *#5 8'* $7# # ' &'&* & '# 5** 5 ( # &8(*!&&(8 &# # 8 '5#&# 5 ?@?@-?+@5 $7# ' 4 # 8 *45# 8 *#4 5 * $7## 8 7?2?@-?+@ # ' *45# # ?2?@-?+@5 &! $7# ?:?@-?

+@ & $8 # 3 $''#554$7 &&4# 785#&#5 $4 5##8 & '#& & # *& $* (7!# &+?'# ) * "* ( &%% +9:2 *7 & 5# # (#* 7 8&#' **5# 8 34 # ($8'## **8 *4 5# # *7 5(* $ &8#$* # # 5(* $ &(4#* '#& %& **7 5## '6(# * 7$4 ?@?@-?+@ *'5 #5#5(* # !4 $7 4# ' '#8*'%& **75##5 !

'**54 ( 5# # (# &!74 # 4! &' && &'# '$7#''& *'

. +? #(&! !8'# *45# 3$7#8($8# ' &8 (! & '*&$ ' ''# '# #5(*

*7$ 5#7 75# $*( & 5(* &##&& (#7, 4 # '$74 %'# (#75 5**4 &&# 8 #

*'#&'&* 4#4 8 $7 #'(#'**#& *' !('#

( #"( &&#($8'# ++ # 8 (# & #( $ 8 3 7 ! 4' * 5#&#$4 **4

4 #%5# # * $( $*#

*$ 8& (&# '#''& *'#

(# +- #* #& $C& $# *''# # $ &* (<#& # #!' 7 (%#(4# 3&(# 8 7' $ +. # ' &$4& $C& # $4 ' **4 *7#8*!& $8 & # (& $7#8(4#$ *! **7$75 7' $ $7 $(4#* # (&# & (& # ' # 4&

(8 *7'# !$ & 8 & ' (5##5 * '

* '(85(* 8( **54&8( 4'# 47 ' &F (&# 8%(4#$8 +@ # G$* (8 "( # 8 ' 123 3 4 /, 5

3 ;-??@=.""D..%# #* # 5 *4 ! # 5( &*--1'#"( 8 $* # & ' 44! 7 '& & &( *$*4 '# (8 *75# # & $ 78 % '**5

0 , ' ,'

!' $ , (

!!' (

,(& ( &

112

& ! 3 ! 4

& ('

$ #( & & ,5 ( ,(

+ '

8 $ $ !

9:;.$<2*=&

- >?( '

' ,!

& (

, ! ! ( , (

(

,(& ( & '& 3 !

& ( ,

& , ' !

! & ,

( '& ( & > 3 $ 6

B A 9:<.. $.;:=

& ! 3 ! 8 + ( $ ( '

( 9:;:.$ *<:= - ( $ & &

C ! 3 (&

C ! '

$ 6

)

(% 1 , C

(( !!' (&

, ! ! ,

112 1

&' ,

'& A '

A 9:<2$12*=&

- >

(

()

, & ? ( C !

& )

$ ( , & ) ! ( ' & (& !

,& , &

' & ,

& &

'( & $ ( $ ! !& !

, & ' &

$ ( $ ' &

( (

& !

' ,

& ( $

& C

! ! ,(

( C (

> +D *7%#"(5(* $&* 8& ( 4&'(&#$* 4 '#& &( * (7! 8 ' 4#' &F '& #8 ( 4 # & ' *4 5#&# &(* # ! $ *! #' & $7'4 (% #5!% 34 *!5#8 %# &$4 8 +1 # && 4*7 **5 # ;<(

-= &4''('#&(7 8(' .%19%1:1 '# & * # ' &(7 8( *45# # ' 1B'8# ''*4'#** $(8'

# ' 8( 1. -( 4 - * 0 D 0## 34

H 0## $*