Barinder Singh v. Bharat Gupta & ORS
!
" #$
%%&& '()
$ * #+,*
"
% ,(
( '-(.
&/ 0 %%&&
( 12 *&2(/ 0
"3 "%(/ 0 )( .%3
(( "51/ 21 &5 050 & 65 . )5 7)( .( 01)&( - %& & %( %%& 1()51 .1( 1. .%
2(
//8/ & 1()(
& 9% % (.
:/;/8 <
/ /8 = . 1&% (0 9%
//8 ))( .& 9%/ % )(5
//8 < .8)(6 .&3 &8&0
//8 >)& %%&& (5) 7)( (( ?
6& &&3 % )% 1(/ 1 95 6 %(% )(1( (5)
//8 9% . 1&% %%&35 6) %%(%( (@)( %%& -5 ( & 9%3 0. )%%( / 1 (& )% >)(
!!"#$#%&
' "()*+!
$
),-.)/0-11(!2%(!()",--30-14
1( )6. . )& &. .3 %& (%(
>)& (%(5 )( .%3/ ((3/ (5) &. )&3 .% *(6)& %)6&3/ 7)( . 1 7)(3 ) -5 ( 7)( ?
6& &. )( & ) ?
6&3/ 1 6 %(% ?
02 5/ & 1 = 3( .(/ &. 1&& & .)
;/:;/8 21 (5( %(% )( 1 .
21 (5( (0
B8 %( .1 %5 )
//8 >)& &. )(5 &)&5 (0 (@)( &&2 6 >)(
!!"$2 $!$56
*1 >)( 21& &&25 = 1(5 - ( $C6& ")%(. >)(
#!
'
7 $ $!
+%
"$6) *) 67"
0--3,
% % 88 21( $C6& ")%(. >)( &- )(.3 3 2(5 .( 5(0 ( !0(3 ( ( .(
( >&. *(6)&8 ( *(6)& &)& (&3 . / &./ &5/ .. . 2&& )/ %(%&9 62&( 1( 5 0(5 .5 *(6)& (.5 @)).
.&( / 2&& & () 3. >)( & - ( 6(0 . !"!
"
9!
!
* *! ) (
"$6) *) 6)
*%)" 5$ ''
+)'
$133:0 18;@) 1)
= " %(%( .1 .%) .1 3 %()(/ 9% 9%& 9( ((3 / () 3 %(%&/ &- )(.3 &. )%(6&3/ . .%
#!
'
"()*+!
$$2 $!$56
211 2 &( &&2 1( D)5
1
!$+'
5'
% "( )*+!
$ #$ ( ")+ " "( ")*+!
0-1,0 % % ;;-
/ .9.).
.6& 21( 0.
5 5()% 5 5()% B = 3( ( 5 (5( 6&3 )( 0./ &&2
.
)6& 1.
%)(% 5 (0 / & 9%3 & (( .( 1
&&2 02 .(/ &. (0 3 05 (.
!!"$2 $!$56
1 &5& ( 6&5 1)& 7) (6& .- 5 .3 . ./ 6E/ )( %( ( &(5 & %( 0.
1 1&( 2 10 & 1.
)() )(( 02 .(/ % 5 (0 )& 21
&. 2( ).
&-18 .& 9%/ % )(5 .) - ( %& (%( 9% 02 60/ &. 1&& & .)
;/:;/8 21 ( A: ?
%( ).
(.
% && (&E & .) 1&& & 0 9 % (. 2( % 6)(. 1( & )67 6(0 . %(
2(
( (55 (/ %%& %(&3 ( (.
!"
F11( (%(6& G