High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1778/2014allowed

Anil Kumar And ORS v. Govt Of India And ORS

2016-01-27Mr. Justice Arun Monga8 pages

!"#$ $ %% &$" '($ # ) $ *%

+"# $+

,-.+#

$+

,- -$ %% &$" '($ # ) $ *% /--$$%$$ 0%%$#12 0 3",# 4 52$$$$%$$$ 4 6 /--$-3",# -" 2$%$

- ,4 7$ $+2 $*-$8( $%%

2-%% $++$" 8( $$%

2- %%

5- 0 $$,,$ (-$$ 6

( 0-

--23 2- ,-01,

- 0$ 8-2

%8

80$ #% "-$ 1$# 8-2 $+2 $*-$8 $ "

%%$

, 2- ; 0 $"2# -23

,<"$- ## , 1 %$($ 1

, -0$21-

,-0$-$2 $$ 0,

-%"2

%

18-$$823 ="$ 1 0 -

- %$#$+ 6- ) - $,$8--$0 - <"$-0$80-$218$2 $$2$3"

- 20 -%$ -",-%

$%$< *( "

$

- -$%$0 >$ 5-$ ( %$ - 0$8$-"

! "# ""$

" %&

' ( ) ! *

+++$ * " ( # ,

' -

.

** /

' + 0* 1 2 0* * 0&2 $

# $$* 3

4

4 0 $3 " * -

$ 3 . - 3 *

*3 " 5 5-$2 $$ -2 $#

,0$

6 21?

,

-0$@-,%"$ $

8 0-$21 ,-01% # $$

-"

* 88A%$#$ 0$?"-

"

$

6)4 *

# " 6) * * ,

6)2 '"

/ 6) * * 4

"

" 6) & * *5 21

,- 0

,$ "

" %&

#$

" 7

8$3 1* "

$

" "( )

)

9 * #3# " * ** "#$ , .##

$

)# """

:

$ "- " ** / ;

"

3

: "3 * 3 " * )# "" 4 ""# #" 3 2

!

< +=3 3* * 78!& * * . >7 /2,&/2/

? ! $@>

7

8$3# **

"

$

# " # $ ' 3 *

*** $$

"

*

)# ! # * !&*& * ! 3* 3$

$ ""

$*

** #

"1

# * #

* + ." 78!.# 4 *

"0 =

*3 *A " *)2 4 &

)4 *B2+ =3 =# $3

* * " < * ".*

#

! "

# ,4:

* $#

78!.

" 3

# "* ,C37

:

$ 378!&7 * $

:

$#

"

;

$ #

# * ""# ""# 5 5-23

,<"$"

-0$0 $$1- 0 # $0$%$,$

,3

, -"

?

-3

$

8#"

- 8- $$ ( %$ B ="

$ % -2 ?

)-2 "$-$"

-"

="%$ "$-2 %

$ ++ $" 8 $ "

%%$

, 2- ,-01"2# --$ , 1 %$($ 1

- $$"

$ - ,5-

,$ $21-23

,<"$ %$ 1

0 --$ $-#$$2 $$ " -(?

-

,-01

0$

##$- - $$ - ($1$ - -2 5- $- $$ %

0-

- " 2 ?

)-(-$ $ "

$-%$ %%$ - %%$2? -( 0-%% $(2 0$$ "

2 $- 0

,$ +

%$ ( %$ - 0$ $( - $%$ 0 ",-8 - ,-01$%$ 21 "

-,$$-

$# $%$ 2" 1 -$2 $$ - ?

($ " -$ $ $ $#

, - #"

80-$

#1( 0-$ 21-23

<"$$ #%$- 2

$

,#823 0$

-

-%$#$+ 6- 23

,<"$- $ 8#"

- 8 , $

, -0$ $-?2$( 18

,$ $21-23

,<"$8$ -"

!

$

") & * )

&* *#

"

6)2 & '"

)* *

"

) &* *

"

"

" "

$ #$

$ $ * #

"

! $ $

$ '

$ ' $ $ **

$ $

", ! $ $ * " $ * " # !

$* *

" "

7

8$3! " $ $

,8A4B 7

8$3 ! " $ * $ * *

,&( !

1 " * * 3 * !

*3 $ * 1* " *

,= " "5 $ " 6+D 6 4D *6D * 3

# 1 # " $ * $

3 + !$ 3 3

$ *$ :

:

= "# E "' "

$ : "3

"*

3 :

# . 3 "

# * # !

3 " " >: =

**)

"

" * # * "

$* 3!

$*

,(A?BAB 7

8$3! * !

$ * *

* # "

"

"

,&! 7

8$3! A / /B !$ # '

3 !

8 # "' "$ A"

# 3B ) & * )

&* *#

"

6)2 & '"

)* *

"

) &* *

"

"

"

# * #1 "

"

3 *

33

"$ 5 5-$2 $$

- 0 $- -"

(

3" 1- -

# %$

" $ 1-$%$$#-$( "

$8#"

- 8?%

,

( 0 % 1- ,- :

,-01 %$> # 1 - ?

-

- :

,-01

0$

( # #$ - - $ $

- !%"$- 0 3",# $ $21: C2 +"%$#<"$

!'

""90( $

A,B# A B2?, ,-01 1(

8

8 " $$2$ - (

2$",- $ $ 21 -

0 $( ( % 1- 0$

,-

$ %$-3",# $ $21- ( @

-- <"$

( .

F 9G. A/B))A#B ,?4 )

8%$-

"#

- 8- ="

$ 0 -

-"

% $@-,%"$ - $2 $$-- -$*88A%$ #$

"

- - - 0 $ -( $ -$

$"

- ,-01

$

, 18$$-23

,<"$ 0$ -$2 $$ $$ ) 2$( -

:

,-01 # %%$%$ #% 10 --0$$2 $$8

$ ($2 # #% 1-#

$$%$(

"$$

,-

$0-

-

"#"

,($11 %% $ 0 !"# "#$ $