High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1131/2015disposed of

National Insurance Co. Ltd v. Baljinder Kaur And ORS

2018-08-13Mr. Justice Satpal5 pages

!" #"$%&%'( )

) !%' *'&+, '$"-. '/0!# .."** '! 1",&+& 2-! *3%'#",4 +, '#!5",& "&.'#"'!&

2-! *3%'#",4 +, '#!5",& .."** '!& 1",&+&

%2%'65 '# '!5", "&.'#"'!&

,"&"'!( ,2 '#"".2+,%7#8$ !" ,!5" .."** '!%'

'# ,,"&.'#"'! %'

&- '#"".4 +,7#8$ !" , ,&59 '%,, 7#8$ !" ,,"&.'#"'!&! %'

'# ,!5" .."** '!&%'

, '' 2%'657#8$ !" , ,-,%:2%'657#8$ !" ,,"&.'#"'!%'

'# ,,"&.'#"'!%'

;;;;;

5%& ,#", &5 ** #%&.&"

& <!5 !5"- ,%&" +! !5" $--' 9 ,# # !"#

=. &&"#</!,$$%#"'!* %-&,%<+' *722 6 ,75 *% >,%<+' *? ,&5,!

5 & <""' %*"# </ !%' * '&+, '$" -. '/0!#&"":%'6,"#+$!%' !5"$-."'& !%' 9 ,#"#95"," &

5 &<""' %*"#</!5"$* %- '!&&"":%'6"'5 '$"-"'! !5" $-."'& !%' 9 ,#"#</!5"*" ,'"#,%<+' * 5"$* %- '!&795 ,"!5"9%#97$5%*#,"' '#. ,"'!& !5" #"$" &"#7 %*"# ."!%!%' +'#", 2"$!%' !5" !, 1"5%$*"& $! &"":%'6 $-."'& !%' ' $$+'! !5" #" !5 &<%, 2%'65 %' -!, 8"5%$*" $$%#"'!95%$5!:.* $"'

=9 &,"6%&!","# 6 %'&! ,"&.'#"'! ! *%$" 2! !%' 0 *,+ 5" *" ,'"# ,%<+' * ' $'&%#", !%' !5" $!& '#"8%#"'$"',"$,#5"*#!5 !!5" $$%#"'!%' @+"&!%'!:.* $"#+"!!5", &5 '#'"6*%6"'!#,%8%'6

"'#%'68"5%$*" </%!&#,%8",,"&.'#"'! 5" #"$" &"# 9 & ) /" ,& *# ! !5" !%-" $$%#"'! 5" #"$" &"# 9 & 9,:%'6 & %$:", %' 5 ,!% "! %* ,%8 !" 0!# '+, '# 9 &" ,'%'6&A

BC.",-'!50" ,'"#,%<+' *7%'!5" <&"'$" '/ #$+-"'! ,/ "8%#"'$"7 5"*# !5 ! !5" %'$-" !5" #"$" &"# $ ''! <" &&"&&"# &-,"!5 '!5 ! $ &+ *9,:- '%" <+!&

BC.",# /7 &

BC.",-'!5 !!5"!%-" 5%&#" !5

D9 & ##"#%'!5"%'$-" !5"#"$" &"#!9 ,#& +!+,".,&."$!& "#+$!%' B !59 &"

"$!"#' .",&' *"E."'&"&+*!%.*%", 9 & ..*%"#0" ,'"#,%<+' * 9 ,#"# &+- &

BC ! !5" $* %- '!& & $-."'& !%'7 !5" #"! %*& 95%$5 ," &+'#",(C

!" $$%#"'!

= 6" !5"#"$" &"# &<%,2%'65 )/" ,& * %- '!& *3%'#",4 +,"!$!! *'+-<",%'6 2, " #& * %- ,%<+' * 9 ,#"# -+'!&

'!5*/%'$-" &

''+ *%'$-" &

BCE F &A

##%!%'

D ' &A

BC ' +!+,".,&."$! & 7

= ! *%'$-" !5"#"$" &"# &A

BCG 7

BCF &7 )7

",&' * '#*%8%'6"E."'&"&B &7 )7

BCB F & 7

!",#"#+$!%' .",&' * '# *%8%'6"E."'&"& &7 )7

C& 7

F &)7=

A +*!%.*%", % !""' ) -+'! $-."'& !%' &)7=

BCE F & 7H7

H 0&& $'&,!%+-!$* %- '! &7

0&& $ ," '# 6+%# '$" , -%', $* %- '!& '# &7

+'", *"E."'&"& &

, '#! * &

5"," %& ' #%&.+!" ,"6 ,#%'6 !5" #" !5 &<%, 2%'65 '

= #+" ! %'3+,%"& ,"$"%8"# %' -!, 8"5%$*" $$%#"'! 95%$5 9 & $ +&"##+"!!5", &5 '#'"6*%6"'!#,%8%'6 !5"

"'#%'68"5%$*"</%!& #,%8",B,"&.'#"'! % 2%'65 0" ,'"# $+'&"* , !5" .."** '!B'&+, '$" -. '/ #"& '! $5 **"'6" !5" %'#%'6 !5" *" ,'"# ,%<+' * ' %&&+" 5 **"'6"%&* %#&*"*/!!5"@+ '!+- !5"$-."'& !%' 9 ,#"#! !5" $* %- '!& </ !5" *" ,'"# ,%<+' * ! %& $'!"'#"# !5 ! !5" *" ,'"# ,%<+' *5 &9,'6*/

,#"# '%'$," &" %'$-"I

D!9 ,#& +!+," .,&."$!& ,"8",7 &+- &7

BC " $5 ' $$+'! *&& $'&,!%+- '# *&& $ ," '# 6+%# '$" ! !5" -%', $* %- '!& <"&%#"& &

, +'", *"E."'&"&5 &<""'9,'6*/ 9 ,#"#</!5"*" ,'"# ,%<+' * ",$'!, *" ,'"#$+'&"* ,!5"$* %- '!&&+<-%!&!5 !%'$-" !5" #"$" &"# 5 & <""' 9,'6*/ &&"&&"# & &

BC .", -'!5

95"," &!5"-%'%-+-9 6"& +'&:%**"#9,:", !!5"!%-" $$%#"'!%'

=9","&= )BC.",-'!5%'!5"2! !" +'3 < !%& *&'!%'#%&.+!"!5 !!5"-%'%-+-9 6"& '+'&:%**"# 9,:", !!5"!%-" $$%#"'!%'

=9 && =)BC5","

,"7%'$-" !5"#"$" &"#&5+*#<" &&"&&"# && =)BC.",-'!5 9"8",7*" ,'"#$+'&"* ,!5"$* %- '!& &9"** &'&+, '$" -. '/ ," #%#"-!5 !$-."'& !%'%&,"@+%,"#!<","9,:"#%'!",-& !5" 3+#6-"'! !5" '?<*" 2+.,"-" +,! %'

!"# $% & # '$'

()*+,-.,/.*)00 4"".%'6 %' 8%"9 !5" $!& '# $%,$+-&! '$"& !5" $ &"7 %! %& $'&%#","# ..,.,% !" ! &&"&& !5" %'$-" !5" #"$" &"# & & =)BC %" !5" -%'%-+-9 6" +'&:%**"#9,:",%'!5"/" ,

=%'!5"2! !" +'3 < 5","%&'#%&.+!","6 ,#%'6 6" !5"#"$" &"#%" )/" ,& !!5"!%-" $$%#"'!'$," &" = D5 &!<"

,#"#' $$+'! +!+,".,&."$!& +*!%.*%", 5 &,%65!*/<""' ..*%"#</!5"*" ,'"#,%<+' * "#+$!%' B=!5 %'&!" # B !5 5 & ! <" ..*%"# %' 8%"9 ! % ! $ '

% 1 ' " " $'

..*/%'6 !5" -+*!%.*%", 7 *&& #"."'#"'$/ %& 9,:"# & &7) 7)A BC 5" $* %- '!& ," *& "'!%!*"# !

BC %'&!" # &

BC' $$+'! +'", *"E."'&"&<"&%#"&&

,*&& "&! !" &+- &=

BC %'&!" # &7

BC %& 9 ,#"# ! !5" 9%#9 !9 ,#& *&& $'&,!%+- 5" $* %- '!& ," !5+& "'!%!*"# !! * $-."'& !%' ! &

7)A BC %'&!" # &

BC 9%!5 %'!","&! I A D.", ''+-5"#"! %*&!5"," ," &+'#",(C

=).- %"7A=7HABC.", ''+-

! *%'$-" !", ##%!%' !!5", !" = D' +!+,".,&."$!& A=HA2A=HA3-)D F7 =7HBC =7H47 =7HBB=!5 FA)7A

!",#"#+$!%' B=!5' $$+'! .",&' *"E."'&"& = ! *#"."'#"'$/ !", ..*/%'6 -+*!%.*%", A)A

3 F7) 7)A

0&& "&! !"

0&& $'&,!%+-!9% " =

A +'", *"E."'&"&

$ &

7)A "$8",/ !5" 9 ,#"# -+'! $-."'& !%' <"/'# &H7

BC9 &&! /"#</!5%&+,! 5"+'. %# -+'! & 7

7)A &

7)A C&H7

B &5 ** $ ,,/ %'!","&! ! !5" , !" A D .", ''+- ,- !5" # !" !5" ..*%$ !%'!%**," *%J !%' ..,!%'-"'! -+'! $-."'& !%' -'6&! $* %- '!& &5 **<"%'!5"& -", !% & %E"#</!5"*" ,'"#,%<+' * %,"$!%'& !5" ,%<+' * %' ,"&."$! ! - ''", #%&<+,&"-"'! $-."'& !%' -+'! ! !5"$* %- '!&&5 **"'+," K%!5!5" <8"& %#-#% %$ !%'%'!5" 9 ,## !"#

=7 <!5!5" .." *& ,"#%&.&"# ,

. 1

*6()*7 &59 , 8' '

" 95:

$;< : 8' '

" = ;< :