Manpreet Singh Gill v. Kuljit Singh



IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA

AT CHANDIGARH Date of decision: 14.07.2015 Manpreet Singh Gill -.. Appellant versus Kuljit Singh --Respondent

CORAM:

Hon'ble Mr.Justice Kuldip Singh 

     

 !    

 



 

    




   

  
   

 !  
 Kuldip Singh, J.



    "

 

 #"

     $%$$&'

()  "

  )*"

++ , -"( #" ."

  / ) 0"

# / "1 .

"  

# " 1 "

# 


  "

.

      2

         1  "

#    " 

(    , -"(  #       

 3'     34      (    ,

*"

 55'
  6   55'67 .

"

 ) $&% )

.    - 

1  "

#


   "

 .

$ 

"

#/"

8




  "



  *9"

#



7 .

"  

"

#/"

"

"

) (   



      "

   :#   "  "

 "

  ( "

#  #"

   / "1 .""

"  

$4   55'-    




  "

  

    ;5

"   55'

   

 


   "

  1  "

#     (       / )    5&  55'





   9

""

)(  % " 

 "

   )-   

"

"

( 7

.  "   




  "

 "

"

)  (   

 #"

   :# "7 .

"   )  "

"

# / "1  < "

 " #"#

= #"

" 

( ) !#  $&&4    : ;4&    ;4%  - ) .   

  

  "

 

$&&%"

= #"

" 

( ) !# 

: >&4 >&

 "   "  

55'2

"

# 

."

#  .     "
 



 # 

$%$  &    '

 (%%

  

    

  (%%           

%

 (% )        

'

 (% *          

    (% +   , -  ,  -"(         




  "

  $&;'

.   1

"

# 

 


   "

     '&&  

  *9  "

#    %   7  "

          *9"

#  54

 - -"(    "

#  



  "

 "

"

) (   

 #"

 

 :#"

"   $4   55' -          

 

   

 

 .

" 




  "

.     "#



.       7    

  

 

)# #    $4   55' "                      -  

                        

         ,   $; ) .

  "

 #"

 "

      

-# 

 

'

 . /'

 -

'

01     

      

       3 01       3

      

  ,    %   .          

 .""

  #   # 

  "

) " "

     

    

     

  4   5       (

 

      / 

       / 

   2   6 /    

  -- 01

     ' 

3 01

 

       

  



      3 01

   

                                   7 5    (

/ /   

   / /  ' 5 .



   //



8 % ' 

6   

  01  01   01/9   





/5    (

  '

  



 

  



 

 6     "

? "      (       )  

>  ""

)    "

      55'    

 !       "     #  8-  : 

    

 

 /

 

% ;   / 01             < 

 4 /      '

  2      < 

  

   #/        6 

   

  #8 1 



  

  3 1    

'3 1  /   

2  '    

 

 

 

 3 1  

 



   # 
*: # 
=
5 # 
=
> # =+ # =+: # =+? # =+. # =+! # )@A: # *B*

4 %.

/
@+B 

   . C444

 :

 

9

 

 

 '  3

1   



%  ;   3 1   



$ '

4  #$ '3 1      

   /

     6       

/    %  ;    9    0 !  1  

   

 -

 '

 3

1                 



    

  

      /     



  /     

   % ;   

   3 1  /    '      

      # $ ' % ;    

#'   $ ' 



     # $ ' $ '

4 / 



 ' /

 

  



 

 0614 

  

      

 

    



       

%#8 % '     

            

 '

/    

  3 01   ' 



 '

'    

   

    

               0<1 



%%  :/
@@)0% : @


@@)1 

;   

 

'  

   '  3 01     

 %D (

 0.

  

1:/
@* 0%: 


@* 1/  

    

3 014   ' 



 % 

. '   :/
@**0.: 

@**1   

'       

  

   3 14   -    

 

  /  #   .

   ?

      .

-

 '  #           %  .

-

 '#    :/
@+
0%:  *


@+
1

#$ ' .$ '3 14     



   '9    3 0214    

9 

 % ;   /  3 01  4       -  <   

       3 14  

 D  

% 

 

%#8 % ' 

 D  

% 

 

%#      0<1



 %%  :/
@@)0%: @

@@)1  

;   / /  

  / ' 6  

    

 D  

 % 

 

%#/   /

  

6   6   



  6   '   

    3 014     /   / 

 #  $ '/    

  /           6       

'       ' 

 

            / 

 #$ '/ 

    

% ;   3 01  4        /      /      

  /  



/    %   '       

       

            

;

#$ ' 

     

%  ;   3 0'14 /    / 

       



    % ;   / 

  #$ '/ 

# $ '/  

    

% ;      $> "  "

? "  #"



 

.""

   $ !   

   

-:

 

      / /- 01

   <

4 3 01 

 

        

        01

    '

   '

      



      3 01  ' 



  80 1 % 

. '   :/
@**3 0 1E (

 0%' 1:/
@+=3 0 1!

%    :/
@+ 3 0 '1  !

  ': '   0%' 1 :/
@A=3 0'1    4   0%'

;

 1:/
@AA3 0' 1 '  

 '

    3 0' 1             

   

   ;5  "  #     "

# 

( "-   "

   %&     '  0
1 #  '

-  0 1/ 5

 



- 01        

    /        2 /     

  .

 

4   :3 01                          

  

  

 3 01      

3

01       

    /   

            /       

- 0 1 

 

   3 0 1       

     3 0 1 

 /   

 '

 

'

  '

3 0 '1     -         '

  .

 

4 

 :



  :3   5          

    '

 1  4     

   5  /                   /      

   / 

              5

  

- 01                      

&      /'

          /    /

    3 01                 

6   



'  

 

   3 01  

 /        

  



3 5   

    '

 01  4    /    9 

  77         

   59  0
1 '    0@1 

  
BA/                33 " .  (    )

"

   (("

    :     



    - 01 /        

 

 

'

/       

  /                

 /  3 01      

         -     33
 .

.  

   " # (     "        " ()

  "

 )    "    (   )     

 

#   "



 (    )

 

 # 

"

   

 

            

 (        .  #

 "

)"

"

 *9"

#  %  " .

"

% .    )-   

"   33
  55'




  "

. "

"

(  "

 .)   

 


   "

  .

 ?"   .  




(    -"( 

)  # 

"

 

;5   55'  

 . "#"( (  #"

      $>   55' "

)  $4 " 

(

    (   #"

   "

    

 "

    



 )  !   ?

 .   "

    .



? .

."

 @  55'

9    #"

 

."

 #     " - # "

? "  

"

     55'  # ."

 (     " 

"

  ;5

  55'-   "# . .     "

  #"

 

.

 #     " -   " #   .

.

" 

)  # .

$

   "

"

) (  .  

 #"

  

:# " ""

  (  #"

  #"

"( "

#27:'3 &&$&%   

55'$&'4; '37* 2  "

# "   

(           ;5   55' 

 #"

 

.



   "

 

6

 " 6   "

 "   33


. "

"

(  % " *9 "

#.    )  )     #"

 

   

 )  "

 

"      "

? "        55' "

#    

"    ;5   55' -  "

) "

*   F &   ? &'#$& / B
. 0. ' 1

+  ()  

  

   "

 

     "

  "       .

    .

) "   "

 -"

 *  "

G    #   '  ?  #   

 / B
B0
1 . 0. ' 1=A(   "4 /

/



 ;

$%    

   #




@@)  :      

   

            

    

 

%

  

     /



        # BA

%%  :/
@@) # 




@@):, ( "

#  "

* "" .   



(   " #  "



"

(

  ) ."

# )

.  - " #   $%$$&'

()  "

  ) *"

++,  -"(   #  "

  "   

?

)"

   1 "

#8

..

         

         " 

 ."

" "



"

#/"



  .9   "

# / "1  14.07.2015 (Kuldip Singh) 6 Judge