High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1839/2014allowed

Santosh @ Santo Etc v. Union Of India Etc

2016-09-21Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan5 pages

!"#$#%&'&()* +,"+!("'-.+!("!($!("-#/ 00#11!("'

2#/'3'

(&(($&! #'0($#("

) 45 + 6 5+ /#'#(")7 ' 8"!-!83/9$:%!"#9/"-#!00#11!("' /##/!;!$!!(9$:%!"#9//#'0($#(" <-#"-#/"-##0/"#/'1%!1(#='0!0#/,!>?#!11=#$" '##"-#;3$@,#("A ?#/##//#$""-##0/"#//(" <-#"-#/"-#;3$@,#("'-31$?#/#0/"#$&("-#$&@#'"A 77 77 5+

5 -&'&'!00#!1?>"-#0!/#("'+-!/,+&(@- $#%#!'#$ '( !/"!0 +&(@-9 =-'# %1!&, !001&%!"&( =!' $&',&''#$ ?> "-# !&1=!>

1!&,'/&?3(!19 -!($&@!/-#(%-9 -!($&@!/- &('-/"4"-#/&?3(!14 9 :&$#;3$@,#("$!"#$B -#?/&#!%"'"-#%!'#!/#"-!"(B !"!?3") 0,9 +-!/, +&(@- '( !/"!0 +&(@-9 =- ?#1(@#$ " +!-!/!(03/9 !1(@=&"- -&' "= /&#($' ?!/$#$ <7!/,#/ 5&(8 C0/#'' /, +!-!/!(03/",?!1! !(""/-&'(=!/$;3/(#>",/&"'!/"&''"!"#$ "-!""-#'!&$"/!&(=!':#/7%/=$#$<-#("-#'!&$"/!&(/#!%-#$38-#/& !&1=!>+"!"&(!"6,DB B7("-#?/&$@#!(@/&/&:#/(#!/,?!1!9 "-#"/!&("8!'3$$#(;#/8!($"-#$#%#!'#$#11$=(/,"-#'!&$"/!&( !($@"'#/&3'1>&(;3/#$#=!'"!8#(" :#/(,#("'0&"!19,?!1!

!(""=-#/#-#=!'$#%1!/#$?/3@-"$#!$-#/!&1=!>01&%#/#!%-#$"-# '0"!($%($3%"#$"-#&(E3#'"0/%##$&(@'!($0/#0!/#$"-#&(E3#'"/#0/"

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

/#!$=&"-'#%"&( 7"-#!&1=!>'%"A <-#"-#/"-#!001&%!("

' &'

!/#"-#'1# $#0#($#("'"-# $#%#!'#$&("-&'%!'#A

#1&# -#/&?3(!1/#%/$#$"-#&($&(@"-!"=-#("-# /#!%-#$ "-#'0"9"=/!&1=!>@!(@7,#(!($"=0#/'('9(!,#1>9+3(&1!($!("-#/ =#/#0/#'#("-#&(;3/&#''-="-!""-#'#!/#("0''&?1#$3#"!11/,! ,:&(@"/!&(("-#'!,#?/#!"-9&"=!'!1'-#1$"-!"&"&'%1#!/1>!%/&,&(!1 (#@1&@#(%#("-#0!/""-#$#%#!'#$!'-#=!'-!(@&(@3"'&$#"-#"/!&( %,0!/",#("!($1#!(&(@3"!($'"/3%8=&"-!/!&1=!>?/&$@#9=-&%-&' %1#!/1>!'#1&(1&%"#$&(;3/>$3#"%/&,&(!1(#@1&@#(%#("-#0!/""-#

77 $#%#!'#$"=!'3/"-#/-#1$"-!""-#01#'"-#?/&$@#(#!/"-#/!&1=!> "/!%8!/#&C#$!"'3%-!$&'"!(%#"-!"(0!''#(@#/%!('"/3%8#:#(&-#&' '"!($&(@("-#@!"#"&'(1>0''&?1#&!(>0#/'(&'-!(@&(@3"'&$#"-# $/ "-# %,0!/",#(" -# #:&$#(%# "-# %70!''#(@#/ =!' (" ?#1&#:#$ -!:#-#!/$"-#1#!/(#$%3('#1'/"-#0!/"&#'!($-!:#!1' %!/#311>@(#"-/3@-"-#&1# &/'"!119&"&'"?#'##(=-#"-#/"-#$#%#!'#$=!'!?(!&$# 0!''#(@#/A-#0#/3'!1"-#/!&1=!>"&%8#" ((#C3/#77 '-='"-!"

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

&1&">'3&%&$#&'/31#$3"/,'#:#/!1 !%"'&/'"1>9"-#$#%#!'#$?#1(@#$"+!-!/!(03/!($-#=&11("%,#" '3%-!!/!=!>01!%#!($%,,&"'3&%&$#?>1>&(@("-#/!&1=!>"/!%8 ',#=-#/#!"(&@-""&,#+#%($1>9"-#/&?3(!1-!'1!&$#,0-!'&'(1>( "-#!%""-!""-#-#!$"-#$#%#!'#$=!''#:#/#$!

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

($=&11("%,#"'3%-!!/!=!> 01!%#;3'""%,,&"'3&%&$#?>1>&(@("-#/!&1=!>"/!%8 "&'!1' ?'#/:#$"-!""-#$#%#!'#$=!'%!//>&(@!:!1&$"&%8#"!($-#=!'!?(!

7D7 0!''#(@#/-#/#&'!/31#'"/&%"1&!?&1&">&(%!'#!11!0!''#(@#/ /,"-#"/!&( :#(&"-#0!''#(@#/&'(#@1&@#("9"-#%,0#('!"&(%31$ ("?#$#(&#$3(1#''-&'%!'#!11'3($#/!(>%1!3'#'+#%"&( 7 "-# !&1=!>' %" -# '#1 &(1&%"#$ &(;3/&#' !00#!/ " -!:# ?##( ,&'&("#/0/#"#$?>"-#/&?3(!1"&'!(&(;3/>9=-&%-&':13("!/&1>'3#/#$ ?>:&%"&,"$#'("&(%13$#"-#!%%&$#("!1&(;3/>9=-&%-,!>?#$3#" (#@1&@#(%#"-#:&%"&,5>&(@?#/#"-#"/!&(/;3,0&(@&(/(""-# "/!&(%31$?#!#=&('"!(%#''#1&(1&%"#$&(;3/&#'#/#9&"&'3($"-!" "-#$#%#!'#$=!'0/?!?1>:&1#("1>"-/=(3""-#"/!&(!($=!'/3( :#/?>"-#/3((&(@"/!&(9&(=-&%--#=!'"/!:#11&(@ -#/#/#9#:#( "-3@-"-#%70!''#(@#/=&"(#''$&$("0311"-#%-!&("-#"/!

&(!($$&$ (" &(/, "-# /!&1=!> 01&%#9 "-# /!&1=!> &' '"&11 1&!?1# " 0!> "-# %,0#('!"&( '&(%# &"' 1&!?&1&"> &' 0/:#$ &( !%%/$!(%# =&"- 1!= %%/$&(@1>9"-#&,03@(#$;3$@,#("&''#"!'&$#-#!00#!1&'!11=#$ -# /#'0($#("' !/# /$#/#$ " 0!> ' 1!%' %,0#('!"&( " "-# !00#11!("'&(#E3!1'-!/#=&"-&("#/#'"!""-#/!"#F0#/!((3,/, &#=-#("-#%1!&,0#"&"&(=!'&1#$"&110!

* ';8' <-#"-#/'0#!8&(@ /#!'(#$ ) #' <-#"-#/#0/"!?1# ) #'