High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3398/2013dismissed

Jasbir Singh And ANR v. Ishwar Singh And ORS

2015-03-31Mr. Justice Girish Agnihotri4 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

)

!&*%+,%'-.!'/!'".#+ 00, &.1!+,%'-.!'/".#+& , , ,(2 +!3*%+,%'-./4$!"#

+".#!55#66!'"& +7 !&.!8*/4$!"#

+".#'&9+!'$#85!':

;.#".#+#5+"#+& ".#6$!65!5#+&8!: *#!661#/"&##".#39/-8#'"< *#+# #++#/"".##5+"#+&+'"< ;.#".#+".#39/-8#'"&.96/*#+#5+"#/%'

".# %-#&"< .# $6!%8!'"& .!4# $.!66#'-#/ ".# !1!+/ /!"#/

5!&&#/ *: ".# "+ $$%/#'" 6!%8& +%*9'!6,!'-+9+.#+#%'!

"#++# #++#/"!&=.#+%*9'!6=

1.#+#*:=.#+%*9'!6=.!/!1!+/#/!&98 >2 !& $85#'&!"%' ' !$$9'" /#5+%4!"%' 64# !'/ !

#$"%' ".#%+ 9+:#!+&6//!9-."#+!'3"7!9+?

!''9

+%# !$"& ".#$!&#".!"'

)

!'3"

7!9+?!''9&%'$#/#$#!&#/1!&-%'-!6'-1%"..#+ -+!'/ 5!+#'"& ' ! "+!$"+ *#!+%'- +#-%&"+!"%' 2 2 @.#&!%/"+!$"+1!&*#%'-/+%4#'*:0!6 ,%'-.!"!'+8!6&5##/"!*9"

1.#'".#:

+#!$.#/ %' ".# !+#! 4%66!-# !9+!' ! "+9$A *#!+%'- +#-%&"+!"%' 2 2 ))$!8# +8 %+*!&%/#!'/.%"

!-!%'&" ".# "+!$"+ 1.%6# $8%'- " ".# 1+'- &%/# #&96"!'"6: !66 ".# $$95!'"& ".# "+!$"+ &9&"!%'#/ 896"%56#-+%#49&%'39+%#&!'3"7!9+?!''9/%#/' ".# &5" ,.# 1!& "!A#' " ".# .&5%"!6 !'/ +#8!%'%'- %'39+#/1#+#!6&&.% "#/"!3%'/+!&5%"!6!'/".#'" .!'/%-!+..#8!""#+1!&+#5+"#/"".#56%$# .# +#&5'/#'"& $'"#&"#/ ".# $6!%8 5#"%"%' ".#+#*:/#':%'-".#!4#+8#'"& ".#$6!%85#"%"%'=.# +%*9'!6= !1!+/#/ $85#'&!"%' B)

>2 " ".# !55#66!'"&1.!+#5!+#'"& ".#/#$#!&#/

#%'- /%&2&!"%& %#/ 1%". ".# !89'"

$85#'&!"%' !1!+/#/ %' ".%& $!&# ".# !55#66!'"& !+# *# +#".%&9+"

+!3*%+ ,%'-. 6#!+'#/ $9'&#6 + ".# !55#66!'"&"A".#56#!".!"=.#+%*9'!6=.!&'"!1!+/#/ =39&" $85#'&!"%'= %' ".%& $!&# *#$!9&# '6: ! 8#!-#+ !89'"

)

>21!&!1!+/#/!&5#$9'%!+:/!8!-#& !

"#+ "!A%'- ".# '"%'!6 %'$8# ".# /#$#!&#/ " *# )

>2 5#+ !''98 !'/ B)

>2 !& ''25#$9'%!+:

/!8!-#& !'/ B)

>2 "1!+/& 9"9+# 5+&5#$"& .# !89'" $85#'&!"%'!1!+/#/*:=.#+%*9'!6=9'/#+ ".#&#.#!/&%&'".#61#+&%/#+#&'".%'-.!&*##' !1!+/#/ "1!+/& 6&& 64# !'/ !

#$"%' !'/ 9'#+!6 #C5#'&#& !& 1#66 , ".# !89'" $85#'&!"%' *# #'.!'$#/&9%"!*6: ;.%6#!+-9%'-'".%&5%'"+7 !&.!8* 6#!+'#/ $9'&#6 + ".# +#&5'/#'"& "A ".# 56#! ".!" =.#+%*9'!6=.!&!6+#!/:!1!+/#/=39&"$85#'&!"%'=%' ".%&$!&#!'/".#!55#!6*#/%&8%&&#/ !4%'-$'&%/#+#/".#+%4!6$'"#'"%'&+!%&#/*: 6#!+'#/$9'&#6 +*".".#5!+"%#&".%&9+"%& ".# $'&%/#+#/4%#1".!"%'".%&$!&#!8%'+$.%6/ 9+:#!+& .!/ /%#/ .# 6&& $!9&#/ " ".# !55#66!'"& 1. 1#+# 5!+#'"& ".#/#$#!&#/$!''"*#D9!'"% %#/%'"#+8&

8'#: !'/ !': $85#'&!"%' 8'#: 196/ *# 39&" %'!/#D9!"#1#4#+%'&9$.6%A#$!&#&&8#1.!"-9#&& 1+A.!&"*#/'#"!1!+/".#!89'" $85#'&!"%'

.#""!6!89'" $85#'&!"%'!1!+/#/%'".%&$!&#%& B)

>2 !'/ ".!" %& =39&" $85#'&!"%'= 1.%$. =.# +%*9'!6= .!& !6+#!/: !1!+/#/ 9+".#+ #'.!'$#8#'"

196/*#39&"% %#/ #'$#".#5+#&#'"!55#!6%&1%".9"!':8#+%" !'/&!8#&"!'/&/%&8%&&#/

!" # $%