Shakuntla And ANR v. State Of Haryana And Others

1









   
  

!"#

#$%&%'( )

*+!,-'".!
!'/
!'"+#0

1#"%"%'#0& 2#0&-& *"!"#

!03!'!
!'/
"+#0& 1#&4'/#'"&  (

5 6

*
 2
* 7
8

* 9 6

*

 668






 
 










 





  !

"
 
 

 

# $

%


  
 

&'

()
 


!"

"

"


"

!"




*+  2
* 7
8

*
 6 $

,


 "







 

*
"



 


 -
!
"







 



.

/


0 
1

$23.


1
1






 






%.
(%+



%4$5 %



 


 


 


 

         
  



""
 

 "




"
 

1
"
 
!
 

 
!




)
 - 
 " 

2



"-
"



 
 

 "

  ! 


%.(%+



%4$5



!  

    !"

 # $#$" %    

 !"

" !"

!  &'      ! "( 

    )      !"

! & 
" %) %  %%

 ! !   *"

(   "  )     !  " '  "( 

 "     "

 # $#)$! "

! & "

! +

 !  )   & , % -.   "

  #$ ) %

"

  )-.-. ,   ! "/  "("

 #$ !  "

 !  & 0

" %   "

 !  !!    "

" !   "

'   !     ) 0  "

   ) 
   %'  "  ) 0'"

  )   

    '!"

 ) '  ) 0    

 , *  1 1      ! "

 #$ !  "

 !  &    "

     ! "

   "  , "/" ! 2   

      "

  #$  "      )    %   "

 3  !   (  

)!"# %$  ! !" !  "/ "

 ! "

! +



)    "

   """ %     !  "

 !  &
 "  ) (   "

 &  !  4 "/  "

 ! +

    ) ! !

'     "

 &  !   "

 " ) (  52   ! "

  # " $    

     !  "/  "(
"!2  %  "

 

3 ! (!!  '"

 

"

! & )   6 %6   ! !" ! "/ "

 ! "

!

+

 7
" )  "

    "

& # $! "

! +

'     "

  "/   "

 #$  2    2   ! "

   "  , ) (     "

 ) (      "

 & # $ 4 % %  !  ""

3

"

 %( !"!("

 ' "  "

   "/  "(     "

 #$! "

! &  ,   "

 #$! "

! &  )    !"

 #$  !"

 # $#)$ 8 , ! 0(  "

! +

"

 "

 #$)%(!/   9   :" %  )   0(

"

 ! "

! +

'          (  "

 #$! "

! &'" ) 0    "

 #$ + ,   ! "

  #$  ( !      ! "(  

")   "     !     "

  0    "

 !!  )! "

! &"    !"'   "( !  "/  ( %  ""   

, !) "!      ) "    ) *"

   "

 !! 

 "

 #$! "

! & (   % " ! "

  /   (   ! ""



"(! "/ "

 

  "(

(     ! !"  !  "

 !  &' '

 


       2)"

      ""

 "(  

% %  /   (   !  ! 0(    

"(   !    ! "

      !"    "/ ;.

)
 


!



 

 
$


$5
-




-

8 
#
./99$$ $%9%





 
%2 $3:.

"




)
 


 

!

 



1

 
 
4$ $323



.


0 
1

$23.


!



-  -

 ;






9--


54
" -
)
 
 

 
!





/


0 
1

$23.

4

!



%< 4$ $334
)



"

 
"
!
 "
*=
#
5.$2

$334


-
!


*

%5 $335
) 



1






 -

!



$.

$335
!
1"




1
>


 



 


-





$.

$335









 







 
!



!




 - !




 
%44:

%442




 


 -

 
)




 

1
"










!
1 






1

  
! 







 

 
 


.
?
/
 
!
1 

- 


 


- 



 



$2



$23.

 
"





"


1
"




%.
(%+




%4$5
 


"
 





1
 

!
 
!

 


 .

'

"

-
- 
!








0


 

 "

!



 


!-
 








!
-





-

 

 


"

 


 



!

"


"



1
"



-




1 "

1

5

1




!

*

* = 
#
5.$2

$334


 



-


 
%5 $335
)






 
!

@!


-
*

>


 

 # $'
%.
(%+



%4$5
 
!



 




 







"


1
" 

!-
 






 
 
 
!
"

 ; -
#
%$3

 
$.

$335





@!


A
*





!




-

 "







 
 

1 




1
 



 

-

-! 
)





 











1


!  
!

 




 
 




 


 

 



 

"



- 



!-
 


- 
 


-

-





 
-

-


!

*

0


'
B"


! 


 

 

- 
 
 
 "


1


 
!-







 
 

-  
 




 
!

 

 


"


%.
(%+




%4$5

- 





"
-




%.
(%+




%4$5

 


C
-

 
!


 


 
 




1


-

6




- 

 -






"

 



 -


<

=
 


!-
- 
!
!

 



-
- 









 
 

!






 

 

 
 

 

 

1 


 


 
!

@!


-
*

>


 

>
' -

( +
)



"





!  

+ )"


 

 









1
- 



 

 

-



! 




 




- 
!

@!


A
*

>
' -

( +


@!


*
 "


 
 








$23.

 -
- "

 







%.
(%+



%4$5
=

 -
1


 
-- -

 "





 

!
"

 ; -
%$3
 
$.

$335


-

 "








 


! 
"






 ) 




 
 









 




 



!


!




 


)

!

7

!







1

 
!
"

 ; -

%$3
 
$.

$335







 
 
 

 -



 
-

-! 
)

 

 

 
 





1
 
 






!







 











1
"





"
"


%.(%+

%4$5

"

!+

 




- 



- 
!
- 

!



"


- 


 
- 
)

!

"




 

 
- 
 
 "





"



%.(%+



%4$5

 



 
!




"




"

1
"

+ C




-
 

1
"


!
 
!

*


 



"


* = 
#
5.$2

$334
 
!




""

1
"

-
!

*


 
%5 $335
)



 


 


5/5
(3+


"-

%.(%+



%4$5
 
!






 
"


1
"



!
 
!

*

8

D
 




1




"

!







1

 
!
 
-

1
-








 


  /



1


!






-- ;


5/5

>
' -

( +



 "

 


 

 





1
"
!
 

!

"



 -

- 
 
 "


"
 




1


-





!




 

 

 
 


 


 
 



 "

!

"


1
!

"
"


%.
(%+

%4$5



!"




-
-




 


- :

"
-

- 



"
  





-

 -

)



-
 
1


 
 

( E>
 #8D
B +
















* >DC
B&)>*D
( &#
00>+





B&'

D
4% %4%%








Manoj Bhutani =
 "9 
F9#
=
 !


F9#