High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18533/2024disposed of

Union Of India And Others v. Ex Nk Dalip Singh And Another

2024-11-29Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma16 pages

"#$%

#$#&$'

"#$%(

# !"$"

%& '

( ) *

)% *+) ,,

, -

*+) , ,, , ) !-$ ./0 &! "1 "1 12$,12!/3

2 $ "

!"6 &! 2!72 -1

9 ::::

, -

. 1!$-1

!8"96

, +!2/"

;$2"1 -6"

% < 8 =$!

93 +2""

!> !?

.$ 24 ? ?

./"

?42

-!2

2447 ,

/'0&/1/'23 #&$"

52?

$ "1

244/ @

, !>/ 8!+"

- 24"9

% A<A "?12!-

2!"

% 1"

,2/"

!44

?$!

!+"

2!"

5!>

72!,"

?>+4

!2?

$24

!>3

-!2

2!"3

-!2

2!"

12 ?

+42?

-!/ 8 !>2

2- "

12 ?

? ,

"?12!-

7 5

?>+4

!>"

-2-

2!"

,2/"

;$24 5/

"?12!-

.!$-1

& C2!,3 ?1 -2!,

"2.4

2!"

?42

+!?

"2.4

2""

& C2!,3

?42

"2>

>2/ 2++

A )2

2++

2++ @

?>+

2$ 1!

< A

2--!

!> !?

.$ 24 ? ?

./"

?2"

?1244

25!

!8"9

3 ?2>

2447

% <

+2!

!2?

!"#$" % &$'$(

!"# ! ) '' % %

*+ $%&#!''!#"("'") " !#"

# *! " )!$ "# "+ )* # !($#% ($",-'*#! .

#" #"( $"

*!$$% /"#$%&)!..("+#./"*

)!$"#"+ )*&#'+"*!

#"(!

. #!# !($#%!

+"#"(!("),-0 /+#$%&!

'#1#!#$ 2 $!#" &! !($#%$! #"

)!$ "#"+ )*"$!##!*## !#"+3- '*# !($#%' " ,

( %

-. &$/0! '"+'1/2 &$/ %% "$/! %

!3%

4 &$/ 5! 5

4 *!

'! &"!$#!&$'7! %( (

4"$/!!%!&"!$#!&$'7 %

% 4 *!

2--!

25!

+2""

8"$+!293

!> !?

.$ 24 ? ?

!8"9

, 12"

2-2

#4056#& 0 <

+!?

>2E

2,@$,

5$4 2""

2 ?

5244>

2 /

"FB 2 / >.

!44

2!>/3 "+

?>.2

"1>

"2>

$ ,

2++"

!$+

? "

!$2.4

? -

? "

!$2.4

2--!2B2

2?;$ 5!>3

@$,->

G.4

?2"

!!.)

""+ !3 +!

,-56 5

+2!2-!2+1"

!2?

! &1! 6 % (

( 8 * 02 9

% %

&$/!

: -

) ('1;&< %

=+330-

'>?2! 02

% % !3%

!@-

"A-

'70 2B! 02 , % %

% % % +

% %

12! 023% (

% % !@-

'702B! 023%%

C % (

!@'70 2B! 023%

= %

(

. !@'70 2BD 023 %

. %

+33%<E

0 )2(&$$&F<: *E

)

>(; 1 %

! ?$!

G( ( %% % %

2, -8"9

2.B

!2?

1$-1

,4/ ?42!

2 / >.

?>.2

"1>

$+ 3

1$-1 2 / "$?1 "2.4 >.

B24

!>/3

2""

""3

2""

- >

2 / >.

?>.2

"1>

;$2 $>

?42!2

& C2!,3 ?2 , ,4/ +! $ ?

2--!2B2

?42!2

: -

) ( '1;&<%

=+330-

'>?2!

!>!

1$-1

"$>+

2""

+H+

"$ , +1/"

2 / >.

"1>

? ?

"+ 244/

!44

?!, 2.$

2 / &!

1$-1

24"

5$!

"$>+

2 /

??$!"

"$."

4/3

./"

12++

8"9

2 /

"$>

"1>

4/3

+!B

,7>

;$2

8"$+!29 +H+

? ?

>+4/

?2"

>2 $ , "?12!-

$+ 3

?42 >2

52?

!?$>"

2 ?

? ?

?4"

"?!$

?42!

2 /

"FB

? ?

;$2

2 ,6!

"2>

2--!2B2

>2/3

24"

5$!

+4 8"9

? ?

2??

2 ?

? ?

?!,

& C2!, "2B

?1 17 ? ?4$,

$ 5

, .9 / 5$!

5"3 >2/ 24"

"$."

? ?4$,

& C2!,3

"2>

? -

14,"

?$4,

12B

=2>

? ?

>2,

$+ "3

"2>

12B

,$!

8"$+!293

& C2!,

2" "

? ?4$, -

24"

?42!

"$+!23

>2 ,2 !/

& C2!,

5447

12+

I*$

& 8&

J I

!24 !

+4 "I A

12"

!>"

2.B

!>/3

=2>

>2,

+ +

?2>

?!, 2.$

2 ,6!

?2>

2++

,!>2

2- &!

24"

52?

12 ,3

?2$"24

=$"

!$+

2 ,6!

5"3

!" 3

!44>

2E +42?

+ +

./"3

>2/ ? ?4$,

!>/ "$?1

?2>

2--!2B2

2,,

24"

-2

?!,"3

& C2!,3

244/ +!?

>2E

?1 ?E3 +2!

?$42!4/ 2++

2,B

1!$-1

>+4/>

$ B

.4?E ?12

5!>"3

?2>

"$!?

, &!

>+4/>

4" "$4 4/3

./"

>2/

? ?4$, ;$2

!$+

"$."

2++"

2E +42?

? -

2--!2B2

!5!>2 ?

!2!

4/3

"$+!2

>+4/

2++"

2E +42?

& C2!, ? ?

2,"

? ?4$"

,!>2

2 /

,!>2

+!1

2 / !"

2!>/3 2B/

< 5!?

"$4

"$."

!$+

5"3 ,$!

?$!"

7$4, $!244/ 2,

? ?4$"

& C2!,3

!$+

?2>

"$!?

?2$"24

./"

7$4,

2B$!3

!2?

?2>

?!,

& C2!,

7 /89 :;

2"$24

!($#% ##(#!($ #" )*

!)!#(%

)* 27 7"# *"*# #

)* !

"2! 2'*+* "#"!'"

)* 27 89 K AA

K "

"!, ! < 2,

?!,"

24"

2++"

2E +42?

?2>

>2,

!>"

+4 8"$+!29 ?42!

G.4

?2"

!!.)

""+ ! '!

& C2!,3

?1 17

5!.

!>/3 >2E

-" 5 "3

?42!2

@$,->

8"$+!29

./"

"$>+

?$!!

52B$!2.4/

,7 "2B

1$-1

"$>+

?2>

?2"

! 7

?2"

2,,$?

"?12!- $"

"2B

"$>+

$!244/ 24"

?2"

!$"

,$ 24"

& C2!,3

-2-

2B$!

$ -3

1!$-1

>+4/>

.4?E ?12

?2$"24

?1 8"93 ./"

>2/ ?2>

$ !2B

2!>/ !"

?2>

"$!?

52> !/ &!

./"

24"

5!> ? -

?2>

2--!2B2

?2>

7 2,

8"$+!293 "?4"

12"

?!,

/+ 5!>

2" "

12B

?!,

8"$+!29

,4/3

"$>+

8"$+!29 12"

./"3

? "

-1 2-

.2!,3

!2?

8"$+!29 "+ ?$$"4/3

./"

2""

"$+!2

5!> 2" 3

./"

52> !/ !2!

4/3

?42!

2,,

?42!

2--!2B2

& 05 &7866#$#405 1 / $ "'#&$ 14# 05 9 0606#$

?$ "

5$!

"$.>

.$ 24

2++!

B24 $

2??$

"?12!- 12B

+42?

-!/3 2 ,6!

"?12!-

12 ?

? ,

+4 ?/3

+!B -$42

-$42

!>/3 <A

52B$!2.4/

!2?

"$?13

-!2

'>?! I %

% %

&$ !!!!!!!!!

4/3

2!-$

2 ?

+42?

.$ 24

?2"

,&25:6$"

,6$35; $6#$#4$"6//$" 3

?1 6!6199 /1#< #4

?2>

2""

"+42?

2 ?

=+"

$42

>2,

72.4

?2"

"4,

B24

2++4 ?2.4

?2"

"4,

"?12!-

12B

+42?

-!/

2" "

2""

2.B

2!-$>

2++

@$, ? "?

244/3

8"$+!29 2""

& C2!, ""

?2>

?42!

2--!2B2

1$-13

,&25:6$"

,6$35*'/ =&9 />

=+"

$42

>2,

"4,

B24

2??$

.2!, ?42!

./"3

B24

"4,

D ? ,2!

4/3

1$-1

./"3

2??$

8"$+!29

"4,

$ 5

!>/3 ./"3

B24 , "$4

,4/3

B24

"4,

B24 "4,

>2/3

"4,

B24

/3 >3 12"

?42!

2--!2B2

./"3

1$-1

$!24 ?!442!/

B24

"4,

?!, , "

"$?13

B24

"4,

?!,

12"

+! $ ?

& C2!,

D3 $+ 3

!>"

=+"

$42

8"$+!29 >2,

,&25:6$"

,6$35* '/

=&9 />.!2

./"

./"3

"4,

B24

->2

?244/3

12"

B24

""3

42!-

@$"

12"

,6, "?12!-

12B

+42?

-!/ 2 ,6!

"?12!-

12 ?

./"3

B24

!5!?

=+"

$42

8"$+!29 >2,

,&25:6$"

,6$35* '/

=&9 />.

2++4 ?2.4

>3 >2E

"$+!2

=+"

$42

"4,

./"

-!""

@$"

7$4,

"2B

2!$"

52?

$>3

"4,

$ 5

./"3

$!244/

5$!

? ?4$, 24"

"+2!E

52?

2,B !"

>2!E"

?2>

272!,

,$!

3 $+ "3

,$!

1$"3

7$4,

12B

+42?

-!/3

12"

, !2!

4/3 ;$2

B24

12"

12B

+42?

-!/

12 ?

1$"3

2??$

"4,

12"

!>/6 $

2.4/ 2??

-!/3

./"3

-!/3

? "

!$2.4

B24

?!, ,

A 73

?2"

2.B

?!,

$+ 3

-2!.

!>/ 2$ 1!

"4,

!>/3

+42?

-!/

24"

B24 ,2

"2> "$4

./"3 "+

"$+!2

/3 ?1

?42!

52?

D3 "+

52?

!>"

"$+!2

=+"

$42

? "

!$2.4

D3 ./"3

B24

+2""

!>/ $ 1!

12B

?1"

2.4/

2++"

!$"

.4 -2

?2"

>3 ;$2 "4,

8"$+!293

1!$-1

+!?

>2E

B24 -"

2.4/ -6, "?12!-

"4,

12B

+42?

-!/

2++ 2!"

"$+!2 12"

!>/ $ 1!

,4/ $

2.4/

"?2+

!$"

$ !/ .4 -2

?2"

272!,

!>"

"$+!2

=+"

$42

?2>

,7 , %

!>!

!$"24

>+$- 24"3

2++4

2!!

2!"

7 5 A ?1

+! $ ?

,&25:6$"

,6$35*'/ =&9 /> 1$-1

@$,->

+2""

G.4

?2"

2" ,&25:6$"

,6$35; /$"#05

8"$+!29 +2""

A 7 >2 52?

1$-1

-!$ ,

12"

+!"+

12"

!"+

2""$> -4/

=+4

!"+

?2>

2""

8"$+!293

+2!2

+2!2 12"

!2?

2.B ?42!2

>2,

"?12!-

2??$

2""

? "

!$2.4

L 5$!

"2>

!$ ,

D "$4

?42!2

1$-1

24"

% 3

"4,

!"3

+! $ ?

@$,->

,7>

>2,

$+ "3

% 3

? "

2!.

!2!/ ?$

7$4,

>+4/

"4,

?2>

"?12!-

>2E

8"$+!293

"4,

?2>

"?12!- "$."

+2""

8"$+!29

2++ 2!"

"$+!2 ?42!2

+2""

8"$+!293 "$?13

?42!2

>+4/

"2B

?42!2

>2,

8"$+!29 >2E

?42!2

=+"

$42

./"3

=+"

$42

>3 >2,

8"$+!29 24"

>2E

$ , !"

? 5 !!

"2B

? ?

% 3 24"

? ?

2 /

-!2

,7>

A >2,

$ , !"3

5$44

?>+4

$ , !"3

.2!3

2 /3 42/ 42?1 "

>2/3

>2E 2 / ?1244

25!

2 ?

3 24"

?42!2

!>"

"$+!2

=+"

$42

>2,

,&25:6$"

,6$35*'/ =&9 />3

5 "$4 4/3

? "

"6866$3

$+14,

>2,

.$ 24 ? ?

>+$- +2""

.$ 24 ? ?

!> ,

"+"

24 -7

2++4

8"93

2 / =,

, -

=, , )> (

@24 1

"+ 2E -6!

, 0 K "6 1

K "6