Birmati & ANR v. Ajmer Singh & ORS

 



   






!"!

##$$ %!& '! (""!

)#      
 *!

!

+"'

"$,$-.!

!

/

"$,$-. !"##$$



0 ("-.!

!

/&!1-. !!#2 

!

&.!,-. !!#2

 &" 4"(5&6! !-,""0#$  5&  7

 "!2(&!1!-$6&!"($( !.(    8!&!  ."$  5!(  !(!  2 9)7:

"!!!!!"(."$ 56!#2 ;

'! ("-"!"!$,; !!!&("!;

/!."5!&("$#&!  " !

%"$(!#  '! (";!.!-)'";

,!4<<&!8 = 1&!!"(

 ."$-$(#"&) 7$0"

  -  $$  "  "!  !#  "  ##!   "$# <&!,!! *!,! !>&##!&$.

#$!$-" !8$?!5&$- 1 "!!!!!"?!5&$ #"$# !(!$2 ;/!.$6#) 7-@ $(,"!A B#!&!"&   "  #  $$  $  !$C  ,  $$,-  #65$  56  $$  " !#'$6.!$$6-,"!"$#5"$ $  2  ;  !-  "!$,    "    , 

$(((!.-5""$".##!"" 8&!56,6$("#!##$-,"",& "!#-,"".#&##!"!&("&$

<"."!$!&$!"#!5(( "!&(""!!

?"?!5&$$6".#!&5! "!&!("!#2 ;'! (",&"! "    56  !"    ($(  !.(    "  (  ."$ !&$(" 4" '! ("5(!.!-)'",!

4<<&!8 = &!!"(."$,! "$5'$6.!$$6$5$#6"# ?" ?!5&$"5!.6.$!" &!#$6-,""("".5$."&!#6

 $5$6#6# ?"#$!5"$"&! #6",!"(."$!#2 " (!!!"&!#$6DE ) ".&!! #&!"!"#!.&,!-"!!""&!5$! "!5(!(!"&!!&""&! #6  ,  $5$    5  E!-  ,  !'  5!.(  " ,".!."$.!56"&!#$6!!!-" $5$6&!!!""!#!6!- .",!!#&!"!(.6., &!6#!.&!  7:" 1&(" !#  



   

 


  !

"

##$%&' ".5!!!

?"?!5&$"$5!."!#2 , "$(.$.!.($"!$. 9,.!-  $    "  $  2  ;  !  ;

"!$,",!'!"!""!, .","",#&#"-,"! !!&("! /!.,(!) 7-@ $6&!&$$5$6!  " !%"$   ?"  !  ##!"    "  ?!5&$    6  "  $  "  5 !!&

  #!  #      "  $-  "&5    " "E#!",$0!"!"!$,; $2 "!$(/!.;$2 ;&("!

 ""5!!>&6&(( 6! " ".($"!"!-","!(($$"!5$( ,!"!!"!"-!"!#!$" &$$$$5$(,!"!

 ""$". "56&$6""-"6".5#!."! $.$ !$65& !""! ""&$505#&#" &!("!$( #!(!$&#!-"!$, #!!!,""!,,&("!$,!.!&$ ! ?"&#56"$"!(!"&$ 5!6#"$$6!"!"0("6#!"$., "!

?"&$!"$"!!!'&(( )



"

*


+
, " - $!

5!"?!5&$,"!,5!."#! &$#6!6"!!@&("!! $#!""!"!@"! 9,.!-" &"!6,,!($60!56"?!5&$ =!&$!"##$$"!!!#E8&! &"!6  .

/ 

0 1  2 

"3+ * 

4$

 2-$,"!,"$$(," ,"!#!-,""!"$6$($ "!E#!!&("!-&"!!&("!,&$ #  "&("  "  ,    #    "!  "!  <  , 5!."$($!#!.$#."

7 ,#"!,$#6 ?" ?!5&$  "  "&("  !!!    "  &"!6  5&  "  $!$6 !#!"

=!&$!"##$$"#$!$&# '&(( ) 

"

*

 ) 22
,"

1

4#-#556.5"F&'!9("8&! ,"","#!!-,", 5"$!"$68$<"!!$($!#!.-" 5!"!G5!"!G,,!"$5$($!#!. "$#"568$<"!

=!&$!"##$$"&!"!!!! '&(#568! ""8&!
77  $ 0 ( ) 

"3+*

!

2 3

,"

-  ,"!,5!.". '!!(-"#$0(""!! $"$# <,"!",!!,(5($!6 ""6&$$0"!"!-,",((#6&

."6!'!$"&$($!#!. 5&,"""!!!  

 " ?"!!- "'!$#!#" ""!"!

?"!!-<",,"!$,$0 !,!"&("!$,!$&##!$(!!#. "!".("! $!$6!!(!$".($"!"! $0,!"!"!!"!(($5$(,!"!

 "!(.(("0.!& 4!"!&-"((.56"?!5&$ "$ !$(#5 &&!"!"((.56"?!5&$ "$/!.$(#&!  " !%"$"&) 7-@$6$ &5$"$

2,(">&&# ?"?!5&$ "0"(56! #!.!" $-","&"$,5(!&$&!-&" "!"&$505)

-@#!"

?" $".$6.","", ((   " .   (!&$&! ! " " ,  ".(  6 (!&$&!$"!!!"!-",&$.(6 #$ ?"!!"!#&56"!("&"$,!0 !50! 2&5-,!5& "  $6  56  (  "&"$  "!  $&(  0(-  $( &$-,"($"((""&"$! &$>&6&"!.!!56"&"$$6" $6-",.!-!5$&50"!(! < *  6)    "

 

  "7  /    "

4  #

 2-$-"#E8&!".$&"!5& "&"$,) -@#!"

<,-,""0 #$

<'&(#568! "$ "22.

8  2 

"

*

*

: 1

4#%*
-"$!"&,, 05) 7-@,,!&&!#!#

<"!
 : ".($.3""2&"

2"

    H568! "" 8&!-"$"&,,5) 7-@ #!"

<
7: ".($/ "




 !

 "

:

  568! ""8&!-"$"&,, 5) -@#!"

/#(.,"!&"-" ("-"50(!&"#!-<" ,&$5#!#!##!#!"$"

4"05) -@#!"

<",6-"&$!5&&) :-@

-E 

/#(.,"("-"&$#$! 7 "&$5##$ ?"#&) -H-@ :- E 7

?"$!$() 7-@&!"" &!$E#&!) 7-@,!$

?"&"$#&5) - -@

-H-I-

?"  ?!5&$  "  ,!($6  ,!  #   ) 7-@$2 $(,"!"!$ $&#65$56$$"!#'$6.!$$6 ?"!!-"##$$56"$$$,

H ,"      5"  "  $  !  $    ) - -@   #&!"!"6,&$5$(!A: 7B #!  &  !  "      $(    "  $  #  $$  &$ !$C"&) - -@

"#,!-"$5$6"$$5' .!$    $$  "  !#  ?"  &  "$$  5  ##!   $$,

*!2 ; !  ) - -@  *!2 ;/!.  )

--@ 



 !'

 

!"#$ %&"'

!()$*  "&#

'# !+,

 "&#