High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5166/2019dismissed

Ishwar v. Bhim Singh And ORS

2023-08-04Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal10 pages

! !

#$%$&'($)* +,-.# '/0/0$'# 1'#+%+ ,0230$4,.$(/,'#+ '+5$('$/+

! "

# $$$$$

% &

"

'

(& )

" *+ *, * - /& 0+1 ("

& . 31 4

"

& 5 '

6&"

(( /& 0 #1 % 2" &

0"

# "

"

4

&"& &

"

"

&

9""

!

"

%"

4 3 .&"" 2 1 4 "" 0"

0 ! %

0"

4 " &

4

" 2"

"

*, *

* '

(""

4 3 ""

& ) :"

.

1 4 "" "

;

2

:"

208 !

-'< 4

& &

"

"

:"

0 !

/ (

4

"

2 & # 3& &

& 5 '

6&"

(( /& 0#1 : % : &" *# *- * < :

"

"

"

!

9 3& !

; & ."

1

" &

4 0

" ."

1 " !

" 2

" 4 " ("

&

*

* , /& 0

" 2 2"

& ""

)

& ("

!&

& & & &" 2 &

0

" 0& 4 " %

" !

)

4 &

4 4 0 2 " &

&" 0

" & %

" /& 071 + % " (&

) " & 4 2 " & : 4 )

"

&

" &" 2 "" &

" "

4&"

2" <

2 " '

) " &"

& 2;

, = &"

&&" & 4

& 5 '

6&"

(( & 2" 6 5 '

6&"

((

& 4&"

>&

"

&

*

* , /& 0 = &"

&2 5 '

6&"

((

/ &

4 "& / & "

&

) - = &"

&2

&"

4"

" ""& &

= &"

& &2 4 "

("

&

*

* , /& 0 1 " 2" ) & " &"

" &

& ?2" !&

!"

# $ $%&'#( !)*)+) , )-. / # ($! , $% # $1 # $2!

/'# &23# $%&'#( ! , 44( &56+5&7)*+5

! $3&2'&7 8 , &++9+-&7)*+.%:% *5*.)*)*

* 5 " &"

&2 & " /

4&" 4 " 2" = &"

& "

;

& = &"

& 4 &

"

4 & &

& 4 2 " &

& 4 = &"

"

& ?2" !&

$% &'#( !! !#;

$%&'#( !)**-+)24 ("(&2 ' !(!99+

$%8&4 ' $%&'(<# 8 &4( '0!'

'(

$&7$% '

77!!&< ' &$ 44( , =>9*&7)***%:%)5*-)**6

& #2;

!8#2;

$%&'#( !)*+)> , 6*

) &2 " &"

5 '

6&"

(( " 4 ) ; 5 '

6&"

.1 ((

&2 / )

& "

#

$2"

$% !!&'

!("

$' '# '

$%&'#( !)*)+= , .9- ?2"

/ "

&

) " ?2"

/

4 4""

& % ?2"

/ " (& 4" &

& & " ) " 4

&

"& 4 !""

& 4" /

!

((

4" " &

& ?2"

/ 1(!#;

,!

, $

, )**>+66+ ?2"

/ &"

;

& &2>&

&"

& &2" " &"

" "

&" / 4 & )

" " " ; &2 & " &

& & % ?2"

/

&2 4 &"

4

&

& &2 ?2"

/ &"" & & "

& 5 '

6&"

.1 ((

&" " " " 2" & 5 '

6&"

.1 (( 4 "2

2" 2

2 4&" 4

" &"

&" 4

& "

/

& !

& ?2"

/ &"

& &"" & & "

& 5 '

6&"

.1 ((

""@ & 4&" & ?2"

/

&0 A

!

!

" #

!

! #

$

%

%

!

&

!

!

!

%

' %

#

(

)* !

!

!

! !

! #

!

! # %

% #

! +

+

! #

! !

(

!

!

!

! !

, -$ #

%

!

.

!

/

0 !

%

# %

%

1

1 # 0 %

1%

1(!#;

,

, $

, )**>+66+

+

$

!

%#

%

, -

%

(

$

0

! % +

.

!%

!

!

%

/

3*

!

0 #

!

%

%#

%

4 !

# %

!

! %

%

/ +

%

!

0

%

'

0(% &#% (

, &#% $ 7

?+5.9>.-*@

+

%

! %

.

0!

% ! !

!

%

%

%

$

' 2

2A $3#, #&&

?+59>24 ("(&2 '+-+*+59>.

-=+@ %

55 #

# %

%

$

!

*

!

# #

!

6

!

% !

%$ ! !#$ 3& (,(<0&7 '

'(7& $% $&2$< ?+--.B--+6+-9 +9 +.=@

%

*

!#

! !

0 %

%#

%

78

%# !

! +

%

.

9

:

9$; 6

5<<7 5 6 # $ 1%

! "% 1 6'6 0 %

% /

(

5

.

! 6

=

#

#

/ & % #

!

% ) # %

&

0 %

>

#

!

8

0

%

# ?5

55>

0 % #

0

$

!

%8

)

6

/& 0

"&

2&

& " %

2"&" % 4

&

""

2 " B & &" 2 & "

% " &

4 "

>&

4 (&

&"6 & 4 &

# ) &

& " & " &"

)

& " & " &"

>& "

4

&"

"& / & " &" & 4 (&

& 4&"

2" 4 4 2 2

4 ?2"

/

2 ) 4

& )

" 2 4 "2

2" 2 ) & 4&" 4

" &" 4

"

" 4&" 4

17 89 &$&2$<(%&$*>*-)*)=

! 0

& 0 %@

( A@* &

( A@*