High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/41755/2020allowed

Krishan Lal v. State Of Punjab

2021-03-31Mr. Justice B.S. Walia5 pages

!"#"$%&& '("#) $* + , ""$ ( - (#.# / 1 , #2$3 $

( # $% ( (4"$3 (/"$5)/ 6)$738!

() 2 ""$ ( (( 1)0/"$5)9 +"

7 7.$0 1 :::

# "# 1 "$5 6 $ .2 ( ) ("$5 )(.5) -"3

$ ( $!"$53. 8"3;2 $3 4"! ( < ("$) 2 ""$.$3 (/ !"$&; ( "# (5( $ ( 5.+ ( 1 "+ ) 2 ""$ ( "$ !

# = 3 3 7 ( 5"# ( 3 .$3 ( / !"$ 7 / !7 ;= +"! / "$ "< 42.( 7"#("! )"$3 & * ($ 3!.$# + () 2 ""$ (!$ $3#) #2 () 7 2+"! 2 (<> #2 (++"$5>) $) <$"! 3 <.$52 (#$>") !(22 3) "(#""$5.$3 ( ( $ () > ++ ) < + # +$< $ ) #"3 + $ !

$ + 4"$( +6"$5 "$ ? # (!)"$5 ( ( $ 2+<) $ 1 5+<"$5$) 5(.$3"$>)"!)#("2# "$@"!

$ 1+ # > ( !+ (+<8"#"1+ $3$# "$5) 2+"! 2 (<7# "3<.$54 $5

AB 2 (2+ @ 3 $3 (" 3 #!

2 (4 ) #2 1. ++ 3>$ 3.

1# !+ 7> 22( ) $3 3 $3$!) !6"$5 ) ( ( $2+<) $ 57C#("2# +2( D+ 4 1+ # 45 !)!$ "$"$5 ? "$@"!

$ 1+ # ) 8"$5 1 !) C7 4 $.

!.("$5 ?7 @2"(<?7 +"$@"!

$ 1+ #> ( ( !8 ( 3 * ($ 3!.$# +!$ $3#) $>"$ ##> #2( # $ "4 22( ) $3"$5) 2 ""$ ((( !8 ("$5) !$( $3 (4) ( ( $2+<) $ 1 57) 2+ 5> #$"$) 2## ##"$ 2 ""$ (1.> #+<"$5$) 5(.$3 $3) 2 ""$ (> ++ 5 3 1 +6"$5"$?# (!)"$5) # 4 7) ( ( 7) E. #"$ #>) ) ( ) ( ( $2+<) $ 1 5+<"$5$) 5(.$3!.+31 # "31 "$ ) !$#!".# 2## ##"$ ) 2 ""$ ( > 3 1

1+ "##. 7 ) 2 ""$ ( > # $ "$8+8 3 "$ $< ) ( !

# .$3 ( ) / !7 $8 #"5 "$ > # !42+ 7 ++ $ ) 3 1 $ 2( # $ 3 $3 ) 2 ""$ (> #"$!.#3<#"$! 7) ( ( $.# .+2.(2# >.+31 # (8 31<3 "$"$5) 2 ""$ ( #("

+ ) !

# >.+3 6 !$#"3 ( 1+ "4 !$!+.3

* ($ 3 !.$# + ( +" # .2$ ) 3 !"#"$ "$ ;"$!

# "+ 3 #F 5#"(/"$5)8 (#.#/ 1G7

C&& ="$!

# "+ 3 #F > $'.4 (8 (#.#/ .$0 1G $3 "$ !

# "+ 3 # F) (4"$3 ( /"$5)8 (#.#/ 1G7"$>)"!)1 "+> #5( $ 3) !!.# 3 $) 5(.$3) >) ( ) 2+ 57!$ "$"$5!$( $3) 31 $ )(>$ > <1<) !!.# 37E. #"$ !$#!".#2## ##"$>.+31

4 ( ("

+ +"

$! ) +#1 $2+ ! 3$) 3 !"#"$"$

"$?

$3 &&&& "$ !

# "+ 3 F $0"/"$5)8 (#.#/ 1 $3 +8"(/"$5)8 (#.#/

A&B .$0 17 "$ >)"!)E. #"$ !$#!".# 2## ##"$ > # ( 3 3 1

1+ "##. "$8" > ) 2+<) $ 1 5>)"!)> #"$) ) $3# ) !!.# 3> ++ 5 3) 8 1 $)(>$1<)"4$# "$5) 2+"! (<1<)+3"$5) "$#.!)!"(!.4# $! #72( #.42"$.$3 (/ !"$

/!7;= !.+3$1 3( >$7 #) ( > #$( !8 (< (4 ) !$#!".#2## ##"$ ) 2 ""$ ( $3) !!.# 3!.+3$1 +"$6 3 >") ) ( !8 (< >)"!) > # 3.1 .+ $ # "3 !

# 1 "+ >

++> 3 1< 6"$5 "$ !!.$ ) ) 2 ""$ ( !!.# 3 ) ( "$ ) 3 .$3 (5$ ; 4$)# $3 3 <# !.#3< $3 ) ( > # $ ) ( !("4"$ +!

# 2 $3"$5?3 !"3 3 "$#)"4 $3) ("

+> #$+"6 +< !$!+.3 $ (+< 3 * ($ 3 !.$# + ) +# ( +" 3 .2$ ) 3 !"#"$ "$ && "$ !

# "+ 3 # F("$! '.4 ( 8 (#.#/ 1G73 !"3 3$;7"$>)"!)) !!.# 3$ # "$5) 2+"! 2 (<1 !

4 2 (2+ @ 3 $3)( > 2+ 5!

((" 3 1<)"4 $3(" 3 + 1.> 22( ) $3 3 $3$# (!) ) 2+ #"! 57( !8 (< $ (!"!#.1# $! > #4 3 "+> ++> 3"$# "3 !

# 1< 6"$5"$ !!.$) ) ( > #$"$3 2 $3 $>"$ ## !!.(( $! 7)

+# "42+"!

"$ !.+3 $ 1 (.+ 3 .7 ) ( > # $ ) (!

# .$3 () /!( 5"# ( 3 "$#) 2 ""$ (7) "$ ) !"(!.4# $! #7) 2 ""$ ( > # $+"6 +< !44" $<

$! .$3 () /!>)"+ $1 "+7) ("

+> #$+"6 +<!$!+.3

$ (+<3 1 #"3 #) 2 ""$ () 31 $"$!.#3< (8 ($ < ( C ( !$( 7 + ($ 3 / .$# + !$ $3 3 ) ) 2 ""$ (> #$ $"+ 35( $ 1 "+ #) !$( $3( !8 ( 3 > # !44 (!"

+ E.

$"<7 ) ( ( 7 1 ( / !"$ &7 / ! >.+3 22+<> 8 (7") #$1 $3"#2. 31<+ ($ 3/ .$# + ) 2 ""$ ("#$"$8+8 3"$ $<) (!

# .$3 () /!

AB ) 8 !$#"3 ( 3) #.14"##"$# + ($ 3!.$# + () (" # # 2 ( ) 7 ( ( $ 2+<) $ 1 5 > # +<"$5 $ ) 5(.$3 $3 ) 2 ""$ ( > # +6"$5 "$ ? # (!)"$5 ) # 4 > 8 (7 $ >"$ ## > # 2( # $ ) "4 22( ) $3"$5 ) 2 ""$ ( ( ( !8 ("$5 ) !$( $3 (4 ) ( ( $ 2+<) $ 57 $3"$) !"(!.4# $! #7) E. #"$>) ) () 2+ 5+<"$5 $) 5(.$3 $3>)"!)) 2 ""$ (> ++ 5 31 +6"$5"$? # (!)"$5) # 4 7!.+31 # "31 "$) !$#!".#2## ##"$ 2 ""$ ("# 3 1

1+ "##. 7) 2 ""$ ("#$"$8+8 3"$ $<) ( !

# .$3 () /!7$8 #"5 "$"#!42+ 7 ++ $) #1 $ 2( # $ 3 $3) 2 ""$ ("#"$!.#3<#"$! 7) ( ( $ .# .+2.(2# >.+31 # (8 31<3 "$"$5) 2 ""$ ( #("

+ !

# "#+"6 +< 6 !$#"3 ( 1+ "4 !$!+.3 !!(3"$5+<7>"). 6"$5 $< 1# (8 "$ $ ) 4 ("# ) !

# 1. 1< 6"$5 "$

!!.$ )

( 4 $"$ 3 #2 !# ) 4 (7 " !

$ ( #$ 1+< 1 2( #.4 3) ) 2 ""$ ("#$+"6 +<!44" $<

$! .$3 () / ! >)"+ $ 1 "+ !!(3"$5+<7 ) 2 ""$ ( ( 5.+ ( 1 "+ "#

++> 3 $3 ) 2 ""$ ( (3 ( 3 1 ( + # 3 $ 1 "+ 2 $3"$5 ("

+ #.10 ! )"# .($"#)"$5 1 "+ 1$3#?#.( < ) # "#

!"$ ) + ($ 3("

+ .(?

?.< 5"#( 7!$! ($ 32(8"3 3) "#$ ( E."( 3"$ $<) (!

# $3 .() (#.10 !)"#!42+<"$5>")) !$3""$#!$ "$ 3"$/ !"$&H&I ( "# +#4 3 !+ () "$) 8 $.

+"< ) 2 ""$ (1 "$5"$8+8 3"$ $<) (!

# .$3 ( ) /!3.("$5) 2 ("3) "#$1 "+"$) "$# $!

# 7) 1 "+ 5( $ 3) 2 ""$ ("$) "$# $!

# >.+31 +"

1+ !

$! ++ "$ $ $ 22+"!

"$# "3

!1 "$548 31<) 2(# !."$

B > 8 (7 $)"$5 # 3 ) ( "$ 18 #) ++ 1 !$#(. 3 1

$ @2( ##"$ 2"$"$$) 4 ("# ) !

!"#"!