High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1256/2015disposed of

Bharti Axa General Insurance Company v. Santosh Devi & ORS

2017-10-30Lok Adalat Bench - 36 pages

!" # $%& '()

*%* !+ , ) !

* -,."% ) !

$/0 12(3/45*6 $3733*141

"# $

&'(") *+,&$ -"$+&..//& $0 1-12 -""#. $ 0 34-12 %"

&"5 ") *+,&$0 34-12 -"$+&..//& $#0 34-12 -""#. $# $60 1-12 %" )7" "&*&",&$ -""#. $# 1& 0 1-12 -""#. $# & 0 34-12

+."# $&..&/#+&,( -/&*& #$$+&8&"&$ 3 6.&##(9%$" $#/&5#"(7 &/:&"

&/0-"

#+"$;$+"(7 &/;2

1 - 1 +&# ( -/ (9 $+ 5.& 9"&# *$8##7# "#$/9$+##7"&#(9$+ 5.& 9#$+&$$+"8&# &#$+&#8&#

* * 5$"9/& +#$"7<$+$"&/"-"5(+ ) /9$+&$ &#8&#7/9*,"

(9 !"#$$%0-"

#+"$;$+"7/#;2 $+"-"8+/&8&" *$+5. &57 $ ",(9$+/&5& $#7 "$+"7/##+7/+&,( 7$ $+ &..//& $#0/&5& $#2+&, ."&9-" +& 5 $-5. "&# *$8##7# "#$/9$+&$ $+"(7 &/+&# $ #"$+$&<+5#&/&"9/## 5$&=> & # /9$+&$57/$./"- +&#( &../8+"&#57/$./"

1#+7/+&,( &../&#$+&#8&# 49&"#/ +&,+&"/&"

#/-"$+.&"$#& ."7#$+ .&."?(<# )-&"&#$+##7- # $+ "&# (9 $+ /&"

5.& 9 +&# #7(#$& + $"&##$+&$$+5$"?9/+$$"&/"-"5(+ 9#$&$#$+&$&#&-#$& #+7/+&,( 5& (9$+5$"9/#$ ,8-$+ 7/6 -$+!

! " &'('& 5","$+&$$"&/"8&#.&"< &#$#$9"#+&(7"#$ @&"

9-7"$+"

./&"/& 7. $+.#$ -)& ',:75&" A?","- $+-- *$"7< +&#./&"/& $+# #"."$&# )"* B# ) !

#$&++,-!+#' )"* . ) 89(/ !

7! 01 2" -

*$$

#/-"$+/&5& $#&"*7$+&$$+"8&# "&$+"$"&/"8&#( *", &"&#+&

$5&

" ","-$+$"&/"#7 /9+& *$+/& & &../#7 ("&<#&#&"#7/$-8++& $$<./& !

+&,"5 $#5&(9$+/&"

5.& 9+&, /*#$#$& "#$/9$+"8&#& 98$ ###+8&"

&9&/$$+& $8+8&#$+.// ""& .#&# A?

" *$+#.#$ $+$"&/"8&#* * $+ & &""9 *" "#& $+#" "#8"."$"7 *7$-$+(9- $+$"7< #." A?

$"&/"+& *$+/& & #7 /9&../ ("&<#&#&"#7/$-8++$+"#+& * *7$-$+(9-$+$"&/"

."$+"7*+$+#$5&+-$+5$"9/#$ +"# ,

"(7$$&/ ."7 (9 $+ 5.& 9 , $+"8# $+ 9#("&$+ *+$& /&$$+#&5$5 #&"*75 $"&##$+&$-$+"8&##7 ("&< *$+5$"9/#$ #+7/+&,5& #&-#$& 8+/", *& -"$+&$"/& #./& $ /9 $+ 7/#(7$ $+$&$ #"-""&(, $+ $+"+& $+"/& #( *./&7. $+#$&$5 $-$+"," &" *$8++$+$"&/"8&#.&"<&#$#$9"#+&(7"#$7$ ,"/& )-&"&#$+-"#$.&"$-$+ # $# $ &&#8+"&5$"9/8&#* *(+ $+$"&/" $# $+&$ , $7&/$9$+&$&#&-#$& +&#$(5& "# $#&&#- +& * *-/& (9$+$"&/"& $+"&-$"&../9 *#7 ("&<#

#7+ "75#$& # $ &

$ ( =.$ -"5 $+ 5$"9/#$ $ 5& $+#$& &#$+#$& 87/("#7/$-#8&9 *-$+ +&,9,+/ 3 +# /5(-$+&"*75 $$+&$$+$"&/"8&#.&"< # $#7(#$& $&$(9& 9, =.$$+#$&$5 $-$+","

B"9 , $/9 /9&.&"$-$+#$&$5 $-$+","#"&$ #$&$$+&$$8&#.&"< "& *-$+#$&$5 $&#&8+/$+","

&5$#$+&$+#,+/8&#,"?/&& ++&# $ $+&$"

"# ."$"7 *7$#$+(9-$"&/" $ /9$+#, -"

&"*75 $##&<-$#&##75$+&$$8&#.&"<","#&9#$+&$ /9 +&/-.&"$-$#$"&/"8&#.&"< <&+&"&& "#$8&# $+ 5$&/"& $#&&#-& $.&"< * #7+"75#$& #

$"(7$"9 & ( &$$"(7$ $ $+ "," - $+ 5$"9/ $+&# $( ("7*+$ ""$+&$8+/&""9 *#7+& +&C&"7#5&$"&/8++8&#."$"7 *7$#$+(9-$+$"&/" #7-- $#&-$9#$.#8"$&< (9$+","-$+$"&/" )-&"&#$+ &7$+"$#"/7. (9$+/&"

&" $+#&" $&../&(/ $+-&$#-$+."# $&# # 5 &(,$+## $&&#8+"&,+/8&#-//8 *& $+"

,+/$+##&&#8+"+7*+&,9,+/+& *#$+/& & $ "#7/$# $& $ + 9+&# 8+"./&$+&$ $+5$"9/8&#( *", &$&,"9+*+#. &$+"$+9 8$ ###$&$$+&$$8&#", &$&,"95"&$#. )-&"&#$+ 8$+"*&"$7$ -$+

5. &8&" 7 " ;"7/#; # $+ #& 5&$$" # ,"(9$+# -$+.=7"$ &#-! 2" - B# ) ) 468 +"/,& $.&"& -$+#&'7*5 $#"."7&#7 "

D #5/&"#$&$7$"9=/7# -/&5",&(/ "$+ 7/#-#&(# $ +&$+8,"# $ 5& $+&$$+/&5#"(7 &/#+7/"5& (/,7#$$+ -&$$+&$$+/&5$8&"#/##- &9& 8&*#-$+ &#+&#&/"&9( "8//(5. #&$(9$+ 5./9" $+ -"5 - =?*"&$& - & &/ &###$&

5.&## &$*"7 #7 " 7/102 +/&5#"(7 &/ +&#$&'7&$ $+ /&5& $"5 $+ &57 $- 5. 8++&..&"#$$$('7#$ +&57 $ ",&(/(9$+. & $#E/&5& $#$8&"#$++&- .&9 & &//8& # $+ -"5 - =?*"&$& - & &/ &###$& $+"-"&

$(.&-"$+# $5$$+ /&5& $# "7$#$+&$$+ 7/#-87/5 $ ./&9-$+,"

5 $5./9# +&"

##, 7$

&$7"&/&$+ $$+#&5$5$+ 7/#- $ =."##/9 &(/$+. $#-$+&#,"

5 $ 5./9 $ /&5 #5/&" &57 $ -"5 $+ $"$-&#" "

9(&7#-$+& $&/&$+-$+ &#,"

5 $5./9 ++&"5 7#&.."&+ -"$"5 *&'7#$5. .&9&(/7 "$+$- 344 $+"-" # $ =/7 $+ &57 $ ", "

",&(/(9$+. $#-$+&#,"

5 $ 5./97 "$+ 7/#-$8&"#$++&- & &/ &###$& F7,&/ $$D.&9& $+"&//8& #G$+&$8&# /&#$ "&8 (9 $+ &# ,"

5 $ 5./9 $+

"5&/7"# +## $$#&9$+&$$+&57 $".&95 $ ",&(/(9$+. $#-$+&#,"

5 $ 5./9 7 " 7/ 1 02 - $+ 7/# # $+ $$&/ $$/5 $7 "$++&-D/##- 5G )-&"&#$+ /&5$8&"#/##--7$7"#&/&$ - 5& $+"

( -$#-$+&#,"

5 $5./9+&#7",, $+& $& #$//(.7"#7(9$+5 $+"/&57 "

$+$-344 "$# $,"(9$+ 7/#- )5/&"/9$+"( -$#=$ $$+. $#-$+ &#,"

5 $5./9 $"5#-#7(?"7/02$ #7(?"7/ 012 - 7/ 1 /7 * -&5/9 . # @- ", $ $ $+&$57#$"5& 7 &--$ & &

$(&//8$(7$8++& 98&987/ ( .& $ $+ . $# - $+ &# ,"

5 $ 5./9 &../9 * $+ ." ./ =.7 /

(//& &$"&& %&+&'& H#&##0#7."&2 G " *$$+&(,"-""'7*5 $$+5.

",7 "$+ 7/#+&#$(7$-"5$+/&5&####(9 $+"(7 &/ +5&$$"#"5$$(&<$$+"(7 &/$F7& $-9$+ 5. <. * ,8$+&-"#&#

)-&"&#$+##7"&#(9$+7 #/-"$+/&5& $#-"

+& 5 $-5. # $+/&"

#/-"$+ "#. $#$+7*+"##$ +& 5 $(7$7/ $ "&#& #"7#('$

9-&"/9#$&$#$+&$ $+#&##7#,"(9$+# -$+.=7"$ ) )

. B#

/$/$,::

) $+5&$$"+&#&/"&9( "5$$$$+"(7 &/

$+&(,#&&#0 1-12$#5&.."."&$$+&$ "(7 &/ 8+/ &/ * 8$+ $+ "5& &# 8// &/# $+ +& 5 $-5. ,8-$+# -$+.=7"$ &#"-""&(,

&"$# &" "$ $ &..&" (-" $+ "(7 &/

!4 < = 4")<

# A+$+"#.&< *E"&# #E A+$+" ."$&(/ #E