← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/24497/2021dismissed

Kanwaljeet Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2022-09-15Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu16 pages



      

 !"#$!%&'&"()*++  

  

 

      ) ,-

+ .  .. 

 

  !"   



 #     $

 .. /+    

     " %%&

#   "

     

   '

  "  #  '

   #

  (    (  '

  "  #

)   !      *+*,%*%, -.  !

  

"

    %.*/%*%, 





0 " 

1 2  0

 "

   2  -   -,%3-,. % 1"      . $!     '    1 # !



  3 #        (   $!  )

!

 "   .%

 2-    

 '

  "  #  #

 !

  "  "   *+*,%*%,!     -  

 

 

  



 !

  

  ! 

   

 "#$%   

&    " ! 

   

   " 

 

%"

 " "

  !

!'()*+ "  

! ! # ! !

 #

%" !" , 

 ,

&   # " -

.    -#  -,"        , + 

!  

&  " /$ + +  

! 

 +

0!   )+   ' '+ 1  ' 2+ 1"  ' 3+

 4 ' 5+

","" ) 6+

7 ) 8+ 9 ' :+ - " ' *+ ; " ) )(+ <" ' ))+

"  ' )'+ &  ) )2+ & , ' )3+ &7" ) )5+  '

)6+ =

 , ) )8+  , ) ):+ +++, ' )*+ +1++, ' '(+

  )   

        3>'?

 " 

   !

>@ !

     "

 !    !

    

!, 

  

 "      

 "  

 ! 

?='('(%"!"   " 



"

  !

!'()*!" /$ 3>'? A 

 "

  B 

        >?

" "#$ #

,+ >?    !" . ,    !

, C #D  >!?   

 #  ,#    , " ,!7

%, 



 E !

  "

 # !

 

%!

   

 !

! !

!  # !  ,   ,  , !"

,# ! ""  ! +A 

"   "

%"

 

 

3#  ",

65#%"!" +     )+

" !  "  &!

%"   



" !

 #  ! !   # " B E  

   ,,+ '+)

!

 ,

!/$ >? !   "   .

 !

 !.> ?  "  #+ >?

 !  #      # "  ! ,  ! , !   ! "    , ! ", "

!  !=

"   #  "+ '+'

 !

 

! " 





 A

B# !A%

!#  "  #+ '+2 = %"=

)(#

! + '+3   " , ! !7,    B   " !



 "    ,  F " !   # "  

,%""!

 + 2+ !

 " & 

 " !

   

 %   # " !

 ! "=6

"

   !

>@ !

     "

 !    !

     

! , 

   

"    

" 

 ! 

?='('(

%"!"     "  



 "

  !

!'()*+ 3+ #   

  &  "  !    

  ! !

 "#!

 , #!,

!&!

! " !  + 5+ 1

     " ! !  " "   "    7 , " "  

   %

 "  # !" !  "    7#   

! !# "

 !

!"& +        # 

  & 

  ,

"

! 7   !  "

!  !!#

  



E+

  

      & 

  ,

"

!!"    "   "  +

      

 "  B 

       "/$ >? "  !

!   !  

 

! %"!"   

D  >? " ,    D  >!? 

        !# !

 !

D  >? "      "!

"9   9 

   #    %   !

  # !"9  D  >? " " 

"9  !"

!  "     7#  !#

!"  !

"& +

               !

 "#$% &  $       '    '     '    ' 

 !&     (    

    % "' ))* +  

     ,  ,        

   *  "  !





"  

" &  "  ,   # " 

   !

! '()*  %  " 

   !

>@ !

     "

 !    !

    

!, 

  

 "      

 "  

   !  

? = '('( %%%%+

+, + 

   !

# !

 

    7 %%%+

+, + "!

+ )(F('F'(')5/((& !

 !%" !



 =)(((F$ >=  "



#?

  %"B !  !" "!

+ #!

  !

 # 

 %   !   ! # 

 

, ," "  ! +  !!# 9 

   

G

 

H 4 5   " "





 " 

       

'

  "  #

  1 

 

 3   !

    "  6   !

  "8"     %/*&%*%,   

   

   

     

!

,62)9 " #  "

 " %*,+   (  " %*,+)    

 2

%*,.1"!  

  "  - 

F C&  

= -  &&1=  =  C&= C  ==  &&   C;1 

 I- = 

= -  C&= '()* =+

+  

 

 "  

&  = 7 )+ < %  ," 

 ,"

, >)5#E !

 "++!+-% 

 -,"9

# '()2 '+  26+ J++ J++ 

!   

 

 

H : "



""      !

 &  

 ; "8 "     ,4*/%*%, -,, 2 

     "    

!

2   !

"

   %.*/%*%,!     - 9 0=& C;1 = & 

C

G  C&=

= > C&== 

 1=-?

F C&  

= -  &&1=  =  C&= C  ==  &&   C;1



! %"

"  

# % 

 %!" "

'2+(:+'(') =

 + &>"+F +?

-=KF-C1K & >"+F +? )+ 35+ J++ JJ 36+ < % ,"  ," 38+ *' J++ J++ ( !

, 0C  &&

 = &  - K1  - 9-  C=

C;1  -=L - 9=-

-  "../* " &"0/10+  '2+(:+'(') () '2 )/((&>  =

+5? '3 36 '/2(&>  =

+5? &  ,"    )3$(:$'(')H < =

 2       *&,*%*%,  ,4,*%*%, -,% 3 -,. "

!2  2 ,& > < ? %. "          !  '

  "  #

 "  



 @

  

'

  "  #

 1 

 

  A!             / A"  

 + 5   "      

   #   "

 B "        "

  "     "

  !

         #

  '

  "  #

%*%*  ( %*%*)!

  

"

#

  C"

  C  "" 

   2 "   "   2  " 2 9 " 

  &+"   !

 " 29 ""  " " C

 "  

 C "

 7  " 2 9 "

 "0 "  "    ! " 

 C "

 1 "    

  !

9 "%%2 !" *62   '

  "  #

 @  ;   

 C   "

 "

   .** "      

  

    '

  " #

 1  

   !    "

   

 

'

  " #

 @ ;    

  "

 *&,*%*%,3,4,*%*%,  2 !



"

,&><?%."    

 '

  "  #

   2  

"2

! 

,* D        " "    



9 "" "  *&*/%*,. 2

 @ "

  ;    

  "       0   "    "

"

 !"  " %+*/%**,   "       ""   

  " "  

 "   

 '

  "  #

 @  ;      

"

 

   !

 %&*.%*,&C"

 ,,*4%*,& ,**4%*%,7 

 !

9 " ,42/   !" %+*/%**, ,**4%*,&6 2   '

  "  #

 ,,*4%*,&  ,**4%*%,  "   



 @

  2             0    '

  "  1 

 

E

!

 

 

  E



   2-      "   "

  ! " 

" ,, A  "       " ,%  4    %*%* !

 0 "          '

  "  #

   " !    " - 2#*          &   

   *3 >)?JJ >'?  

 "

  B 

        "$

>? JJ++D >? JJ++D >!? 

# ,#   , " , !

%, 



E !

"  # !

 

%!

   

 !

! !

! # !  ,    ,  , !"

,#!""  ! +H  !  2           0     2   2    !

"

C  9 "     2 "   "@ 

 !   !      

 2 "    ! "

      ,6 2) 9 "  !     "

"2 "  ,. 5          %4 0 "       !     "   !

 "

 "C   0     "    ,*   

 8   "

   2    

  "  ,4     !  "

 "     

   '

  "  #

    "   "  

C  "

" 0 "  9 "   !

  1 "!    " -

2+0/4 ( 5  + 0/1 5  ( . 0/ ++0  " ( . 0/  + +6 "   5  (-  ++0((0/ -/ &" (0 /7 + +6 " 5 

0("0 ++0((0/(0/5 (-  &4/8-6'5 .

/*)9*):)))&+  / -

K&+;!= 9"  + "+=" % !#

  

 

& +  +; %  ! !#I#  

 & + MMMMMM "                 +   

     (&; * JJJ+ JJJ++ JJJ JJJ

" !

   " ! "  , , E

 !    !

  !

 7 !

   !



   "9 

    " !   

 & 

 !  

  " 

  +

 " 

 !

  %

""

!  !

!+

"!

       "

% , !F !

 !

 7 

 

)(( 7+ -     

 "  

 &  >%"     B !

     9

F1!" K ,? " "  :) +<

 ! !

B !

+ "  !

 7

 ! ! B !

%

%/$  9

>)

?  $ 3&7  9

>'



?  $ '&7   9

>)

? $ 2&7   9

>'



? $ '&7  "++  $ 2&7 &7

#

 9

,>" , "," 7?

"++"

%+ E ! 

"

B 

      &    "   

#  ,#     ,   " , !

%,   



 E !

  "

  #   !

  

 % ! 

   

 !

! !

!  # ! ,    ,  , !"

,# ! ""  ! +!")+( 7>  E  

'( 7? "%

##

!"E !#

"       #

)5#+

%

" "     %F$ !

 8( 7+ "! % 

"

"

% ,/$ >?

%, # #% 

 ! !!  !D >?

#   !

 ! %" !

  %     ! #  !

 #D >?  ,#

"

!

D

>?

# " "% 7 D >?

   , ! 

7   ,

"! D >?

#

 # !

,   ,

D  >? 0

", +

  "   #  , 7

! ! B !

 E ! %+H  ,6 "!   "

#

  %+

C  

-,

"

 - 20/ "=0 >1"- 7+-"?((5  -/ - ( "5 &( + +6 "'

0("0/(4+ " 0(&4 ("

" ((-. ++0((0/'&4/8-6 *)9*): +

+ = 

+  

"KF- K   9F &7 ) 35 J+ J+ J+ J+ 36+ 36 < %  ,"  ," '2 &  &  "  H =  %!



" 

&  !

 = 

 " 

  >

%"

'2+(:+'(')G'3+(:+'(')? + = 

+  

"KF - K   9  ! 

 @+ E+





2( 7 

% &7 9 

 ) 35+ J J J J J J J J J J 36+ 36 < %  ,"  ," &

"," "  , ' 3 6 '2 '* 38+ *' J J J J J J J J J J

,& =  2  "  

 "  

@"

:   2%**, .'

!

   :  2%**4

%'

!

 

 ! "

" 0 "  "   "

 #         C  $   . '

!

   *%

C

 $  %'

!

7 

 

2   *% C   0 "        ,<

     "

 #   *, C  

9

   %* C      !2 2  "

9 " 0!1"($

  2    ,6 2  5 "  ,6    "    

"

  

 !  9 "



"

"2      !

,42*<  9 " !" *42,*

 9 " '

  " #

5   

  !

,+2*6  )9 " #    3 :  "    "

 #   , C  9 "!222

  29 "  ,6 2    E  2     *4

C9 "*42

"

"  2

 2    ,6 2 !

  "

 #     

2   *4 C  9 " 1        2  

   

   

  '

  " #

  ! .**

     "

     

  

       0 "  "  

!    "   !    "    ,*   

 8 

"

         "  7 "  

   "

"C 0 2   2       "     

0  !27 

   2     

"

#

 !

#   

     "

  2 "

#

7     

   ! "

   

    9 "  0 "   "      "    2  2"  ,/ #"2     "   



@

  

 2 2 

   C 

5!

   9

       0    2        "   ,+ 5!

 !

#   2  

  

E   2

 *++    ..

    C 8 G ;   G ;