Rampal Singh And ORS v. State Of Haryana And Others



 

  
       
  



!

"#$ %   

"#"&#'

!

"#$

  


  
      
 
 
  
($  )* (

+
 ++ ,

 )* (

+


,*  

   ! "  #"$"% &'" (#  )"*%

* % " ""+# ""#"

%  % " "" )"*% &'"+# ,#"*  ,""'#" "% &'" #&"$ " % &'" - "$"% &'"" 

#"#"% &'" (  .

 //// ++ ,

- 

0 #  '*"$  $"

    #  "  +      (  "

$" "$ $"

 #  '' %%$( # *'  " 01234205(# " "" &$%# %#

*" *" ($"'6%#%#'$

."*&"*(  (#6 *'   4 #  *"  '*  "

"  (  #    #" ('(**  ' %    *")  $%    #  $" "  ( '020(#
 #"7$ "" " "'  "  '6% 
#"*"  " 
*$  '%  4208 9#"(  (  #  (    "  #  :'  (  4208:; "  '"$

 

' " #<'(4208:%# # " ""' 40(4205%

&+#("="' #"(%#"# *" " ."*&"*(#*&" *'  #(%# #""  #"# *" % '&(#"**"'#

"'6  '       # "  '6  '%  0531 9#"((#'"** "#:'(0531:;#'$ (** $" %"#"."*"&"*(  (# *&" *'  %# # " "&"*"*('$

*" ($"'6        


     



                   

  

! "

#

 $%#"

                   "   &  $%#"

'

  ""

 "'        ( )#   

 *  "

# 

"  "

 #' #

 '  ""' "

$%#"
+ 8 #""& #+ %#"#  "  +  "  "    # '"*    (  #     *"  +## "  " ("$ "  " #

*"  #  "* "'6 #*" (# ((# &"* (#"'(('"9;( "'6%" " (#"+" %#  #"&  ") (# *" " #"&"**" &"'" *"   # :*" 



1 (#"& #+ %#"&+( '*">(# *'  " 01234205(# " "" &$%# "'6 *" *" ($"'6#*&" (#

*' 9 ";="' #"( ,
-.# $

 ""     /   0"  

 &"'            '   " 

' ( !

   "#

    !

&  ""

 

! "'  

"   
!

&"

 #'    '  ""'  

*                   "

  1'  


2&

( !3#

 "   

 "  

 *

  4   

    

'    "   "    "

 "   

     " '  %#"      & '   "  #  "'  %#"  

 

        '    "   ''       

 
5!4 "       

*

    "&

!  ##

"# 

 6 

    #



    
? # #"&"*(*  "9=.

>;(#"#'' ) *" (#*"  &+(# *' 9 "; @ #"(#"& #+ %#"#

.

."'6 *"   #   "   '" *A#*" " $"#%# *" *"

($"'6   &"*."* > *&"$##"#  '..

  (  #    '#"**  #  "'6  '   # #  #  (*  7B.0>83>  (  422?  #  "   +"

  ( #7# #"& ' "+0@2>422?"

# # #  " "+ & '% #+'*"$ +"    

$  #  #+ 7$$&%# ## "  9 ";%"'"$$"

#+ 9 ";%# 7"*"  # .

(# &#+ *" %#**" '$"

#+*( #  # +  7$$  ''   +&%  #   #  +

7$$C' #'*"$(=$ ($"'6(#

%# #$") " 042@4223%+# +" #* %#"#*"9;(# *" %($"'6"# +* "(('#6 *'   5
*"* %#"+" 9 ";+"$"

 #C' (# '*"$($"'6%## #"  "+  #  #+ 7$$042@4223 3 #  *"  '*  "

"  (  #    #"

*") #$%"&*('0209 ";"+**"% "'#('*">(# *'  " 01234205(# " ""

&$%      #  "  $  '$  '$ ** # %#("'(" '(''=  ""

"

#  0@(#  * %"(( "&%"(# #  #   '' %'+#("="' #"(

%

70
- 



"         '               '

 
-  

$

 % '"   

 



#
- "

84
11,   5/1     

'          "

" 9:8

4
511 

'0;

" '5"# 8

4
5110

'

' "' 
-      

"

  #'   

 

            
-     

&   &   <5      9         =>


+ 02   "

  (  #  "  '%    $")  "

#'

$ '9;%#"# *" ""$") (#"



*'  " # "*A %"*A"*%" %" &"*(("'*" #"

 *'  76* %# '*(# '"" %#"# *" " #  ."*    &"*  (  ("'*"  #  "

  *'

 #'"+**" " $ $ %# & ('020(#:'(4208:&+(# *'  "

01234205  7"* %    &"*  $"  (  "*  *"'#

"'6 '   #:'(0531:%#  # %(" %(# *" % # % '"** +#  #  & *  .&  #  *'   %  #    "# '$ ** *"+(*#" #"#"&  $

"&*('020(#:'(4208: % *'  "

01234205%'$ ** '"

'" "*"" #"

/

  #"  #  "      #%  "

"    .

"* &"* (#   *" %#(("'*" # "

 *'  %"#" %"&*(C'& '$ *"%"$"

 #"# '' %" '# "&C'&#'$ *"%$"("&%#"#

*" "" "*'$ (#*"  *"*"  #'$ *(#*&" *'  #(%#*"

'*(# #""*  *") #"&" $% # $ # &('020(#:'(4208: " D% % *'  " 01234205 00 7 '*     &  (  +#  &  # "'6  *" %    #      '' %  #  #"

   "'9;(('"9;9 ";%# +##"'$ "*+(#"'6 *" 
*"* #&$( '$ *    "*  +#  &  #  "'6  *"     #   ."%#$")+**$ + +##"$(# & '    :* =7#'"(  

!" # !$  

%&'(

) 
)& &$")"*(# "'6 *" # # *'"'#%#&(  *A %#=' (#"& + ""*+% "#"*%"# #"'$"'$('# #"( " ""%#+* "**#.& $ # *'  9;#(%=' "& "=' "* ''$"'%"$'#"% '''( #"6   ="  $  (  '$ "  $   $ %  # $") #*6 "%'"" #" ='#6%#%# #"  ""$(."* 

0

&"* ((#"'6 *" %$" '$"

  #"( " "" +&%#"&=' ""&"*"* #' (#'" 04 7 '* "*+##""  #*"



"* &'" "*% " ""#"+# "+"*(# *'

9 "; "'&' "(#  " #"& #* # *' 9 ";*)* .'"**  08 #%#7"*'"* " *+#!!

,-.

! /! . 012.2!3 45

    6#!*&

 )

%#"

* #

"*+#$*""#"+ #*&"

""

"

#(#& '9 ";"="' #"( 7,
?" # ' 

" "     

'

       "    6    #'6 

  ( 789#### 3!

2:#!   4 #4
!  !# 22 ;% 4<2

!&&! - :=4!  :

  #     10-          !24#

!&#4#:4-20 :

%  !!

% #     10-&  !  4<2  2  #  4   > ?@ 789###! 4 #4
4 30! 4 2! 4& 02 # 

  44&    4#

3  # 

2

 44 2  4<2!  .43!&  2  #  4   > ?@ 789###

44# ! 0!3#  !!# # 4<2

# !:4-20 :

%

!!

%&#32&# #

# ! :2 ;&&#

42!:#!.!!!!& 0 .24-#  @ 5,
- '$;5;@"

           

 " #"  

   #    "      9'  # 


A# #



 

1

   5;@

 # 

        

-"

"    

$

'   #$; 5;@ '= 4
55; 

"

' '  1$%#"                  

    '      

"

   # "7 #

+ 7 +
=#' &"'      #        $  ;           '    $ ""

! #'       

 $  ;           $

'                  $ %#"1 '  "#' $  0          

,         # 

  " 

 "7 #

+7 +




@;
-"

$ 5;@ $0

, "  

   $;
-#'' $0

,



&    $  ;
 -          # $; #9  '




-  



  

"  #              "        $  %#"   "

6#  9'  '


@
?

" #$; #   $%#"  "  *  '  "

'  7 #   +7  +    '

  4 42!.2:

4 .2.!
7-.# !!!2..

8 @
  

  #  

       =B

$

"    

  '   $ ;5;@   *



  " 6"

 $%#"    #

   

 #

"7 #

+7 + 

 '

#& ' 7



+

 -      '      '   

!

   '    

    $  %#"  9'     &      $  ;          5;@ #$'#" #' 9""

 


""

    " '

  
C  #'  ""

       

      !


-  #" '

  ""

 

      !     &"  $    

,
D  

 #$ %#"1 '  "

 "

  #      

   

                   



-# #   "           "

   #             & "( 7AB'

B,C67'8 - '   $ ;5;@ 7  *+   " 6

 '#"                

        

      #  " #

+7 + ' 




AB'

B,C67''8 - 4
! '#
- $;'#   #   

' 



  '



AB'

B,C67'''8 -                  '#
 -

# #'      #  "  7 #

+    7



 +'   # 

 *     

 #  " 
+ 2#34 !

"5

"&6

01 "($"#%#7( $#+ % #"$ '$ ** (&*%#6  $

+#'#(%#"$ $ +#'(
?2%222D.

 "'#(# (#+#   #$+## :- 4#

 !# .

 (

# !# 

* ($ " # ""* "#"'' 0? '#$"'"*(#" ' %#%"**#

  "

*'"9;%(" %"*" 9;   (

8++ ,9

 8,*  

    )"& # 7

:

3;2#<

"# !

$ 

"

7

:"63=4

$ 

"