← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9585/2016dismissed

Sushma Chauhan v. Union Of India & ORS

2016-05-26Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath10 pages

      

      

      



    

!"#$%!&'()$"*+,-)"#.),.+$#"*# 

    



   



 



  

 !"

# $%



 

   # &

!"





  '"

# "/0.1*2*  %

   "

())$( *     +

       ,

  -  

  .

   ./

!

 "  



   

, 0'

  '

 1 2





+           

      



 

  $(

$( &     "        

 

" , 0'

     3

   "  '

 12











 

, 0'

  

 

$( & 

  

  "    



  





      0         "  , 0  '

   -        

 4 5

       &    /   -  

 

0 / 

 

5 63 "    72

 

  (2 8  5 

     "   



               







"

- /%  

   "   "+ 2     + 24  9 

  5



:;

'

    + 24  9   ,

    40

 9 "   4

    8 

2 "    

     

 0

1 <2

=+ 

 ,

  ,

 : 8,> 

: 

 , >        

   

 .: 8  .

    >    

3

  

4%

"

    7 2  8   

   $7 2 

 5 



    

  "   

               



 



"

- /?   "     

            , '

  8    

       (2  "     "

  %     (2      %  .: 8  .      

 0  

  

5 6: 8  .  



 4       

4



   

 -/4"

-/  >   



 4 .: 8  .        

  4

 

     4

 

-/  



-/> 



 .: 8  .      

 

 -/ 

"

-/        "   4

   >      4 

.: 8  .     

 

 -/4 

"

-/? 

 



 (&$ @7*(   

  (23 

 

  

"   6

      

                      

      

      

    

 



4 >           

  

 !"#$           

 %    

     

      %





 

: <

           #



 !        &'&()&*+   ,-,./+0' 

11  $

213

4  11 - . )&*))&*511  $

        ,-6 +&5+708/  

 

    



 

  $( &      ! =    + 2        

              "       "    :' =$7)@((( (((A&)A)  "

7$B*)@*(   $7)@(('(((((7*B  -C 

/  "   7(&7)*((          (&$ @7*(45      

 

 

 

  

    " 

  

   

 

      0  >  



 

 $@$$( *

 

    "

5 6'  ": <

  

-:</      "      

 D     

4

                

         "   

      

D

 



  D   

    -$( &/    

    

    



* -/+ 

0       " , 0

 " $( &?



   

 

  

  

$ &$( *

  

  

  5 6%



7

     



-   7

/ "

  '

 1 2

 

 "



 )((((((45 E>+ 21 9

)((((((45

2 &$A*7 7B(45 

   2  "  4=@ &(&(( *@((7*&   

  " A$&)B)$(4      $( &   

  4 2    %      

       

2    



D

  "

, 0'

 ?



 

  



      E>  + 2    

 

     4 =@ &(&(( *@((7*&    "     

  

 

     )((((((45    2 &$A*7 7B(4      A$&)B)$(4%

 

 D   

   

     0 

 

   



 

()()$( * "





  

  

  5 6  

 

          

     

  7@$( )



D  &$B*)@45  7$B*)@45   =+            



    

  B(((((45           

 0  8   



 

      

   %   

  



"  F 

  )A7(((45 :;

'

   '  ":<  



;

   ($@B@@45   !  

            

     

:'   

 3 

  " :<  

  D   

       7$B*)@45F

"

 

 

 

  4

D   "    5   2

   

   .  +     

  4

D         

    

"  , '

    "  $( 7 

 @  G"





  

"     "         9  9>, 1G%>=0  9 =F.  =8,  :9 G,%>9=  9:  G08,  , 0  '>%>+8%9 3$( 7         72 8  

  (2 8  5  



     "  

     

  





"

- /%  

     "   

   



    "+ 2  + 24    9   

     5 

  :;

'

      2    9   ,

  40

 9 "   4    

8 

2 "  

  

 "

1 <2 

+ 

,

   ,

 : 8,> 

:

 ,  >           

: 

 .: 8  .     . <     

    "

"  , 0  

      '

 1 2

-3

 /?   "

  E>+ 2

 



 

 > 

5



    

 " 



 !  =    + 2  

  $( &           

    :'4=$7)@(('(((((7*B

C

;

7(&7)*((4 

:'   "4=$7)@((( (((A&)A)  " 7$B*)@*(45  

     

           :'      (&$ @7*(45 9 

 

  

 

:'  "4=$7)@(('(((((7*B  

 

:' 

 



  !=  + 2 

 

5 6%      

  :'   "  =

-$7)@(('(((((7*B/  '57*B   @7(((45   "         4   " 



 < 9  '

 1 2

  @( $( & 



  ()($$( *           "     (A ($( &

D "        

 .

. 

        :'>    

     D " -C

/ 

    >             ((A(@$45    " $( &

 7(&7)*45

 "   ? > 

 

  

    :' @7((((45  (A ($( &

   

       

D  

  :' .

.> 



  :'     





  

         

:'

   "  

 2  "

   :'  

C

 

   

     

"  



 E>+ 2 

    

   

      

   



  

  A$&)B)$(45  

2

   



     

   $( &     2  "

  

  (2 > 





  

  

   

 .   .       

  

  

        

  

     ' +  !"

 3" 

  

  $( *-

7/, 7@* 

  



 !"

 

       

  $( )-&/ ,&@$ 

  , =B&$ $( )-9H/   

 " <  

      *7$( ) >  

   

 





             

D

!







      )&*))&*5             94:

, 4!,;

 %     *& %

  

        

 

 <

  "

    



     





 !  =    + 2  

  $( &  

   :'  4 =$7)@(('(((((7*B ;

7(&7)*((4



 C



 







E>+ 2   A$&)B)$(4

 D   



     

  "            :'  4  = $7)@(('(((((7*B       

  



   !=   + 2     

   

   (A ($( &



 "  

:'  "

  !    "

  :'        

 

 

   > 

   

  2

 C 

 :'.

 "

.

.     

      D

  



E>+ 2  

      

.

 

  A$&)B)$(4            





.  $( &   "

   

   

     " 

     >   !"



  

  





 

  

      

 

 "



  3    

 >   

  

    

    

   "# $ "%&# '()

*+  *